教育王國

標題: 有冇讀過Learning Habitat + St Cat 可以share 嗎 ? [打印本頁]

作者: babyjoshua 時間: 10-12-1 23:24 標題: 有冇讀過Learning Habitat + St Cat 可以share 嗎 ?

有冇讀過Learning Habitat + St Cat 的parents 可以share what is good / bad about each school? We are not sure whether we should change from LH to St Cat for K1.
My son 係Learning Habitat 讀緊PN , St Cat有 offer, should we 轉定唔轉? Both are AM & we decided to choose Cantonese + English for him because (佢而家似鬼佬講中文，平時講英文為主, he needs to improve his Cantonese for P.1 interview.)

但我發現阿仔讀LH 嘅PN 讀得超級開心，學倒好多嘢, teachers are super nice and would call us to discuss about my son's progress regularly. And there are many parents-school gatherings & discussions. 我最大爭扎點就係佢好怕轉環境，thus we don't know whether we should change to SC.

但是SC是名校, P1應該派好D.

有冇人可以share SC 升 P1 的結果or statistics?

作者: Toffeenut 時間: 10-12-2 00:05

我都好想知!!!

我個case係兩間都eng+pth的下午, 但我囝現讀LH的上午, 似乎轉到e/p上午的機會都係有的.

我主要想知SC對小朋友的行為問題/品德教育方針, 會否因為小朋友不合作/唔夠乖而忽略了個別小朋友? 會否罰小朋友/用咩方法?

作者: icbb1230 時間: 10-12-2 00:18

SC超好因大女讀過K1, 老師好，功課適中，但K2開始發力，小朋友要在校assessment.

LH近年口碑勁好，考私校/直資成績都好好。

所以兩間都好，但名氣就一定係SC贏。

至於派位學校，全靠運氣，讀邊間都一樣。

作者: icbb1230 時間: 10-12-2 00:24

Toffeenut,

你講嘅情況，我阿女在SC時冇發生過，我阿女都係有"主見"個堆，班主任打俾我傾，告訴我她在學校用什麼方法教番好佢。最後，阿女好好，學期尾評估仲好好成績tim。

作者: Toffeenut 時間: 10-12-2 00:25

原帖由 icbb1230 於 10-12-2 00:18 發表
SC超好因大女讀過K1, 老師好，功課適中，但K2開始發力，小朋友要在校assessment.

LH近年口碑勁好，考私校/直資成績都好好。

所以兩間都好，但名氣就一定係SC贏。

至於派位學校，全靠運氣，讀邊間都一樣。 ...

多謝你的意見, 你囡己無讀SC嗎? LH因為自己囝讀緊, 好唔好真係自己知, 不過我主要擔心因小兒行為還不成熟,

有時會搗蛋, 唔知SC會否包容得到?
我想問派位的意思是指DSS/私小, 我都想知啊.

作者: myfatgal 時間: 10-12-2 00:26

I tried to search in SC's website but there is no P.1 placement results... I want to compare LH & SC's results too.

作者: mewmew2 時間: 10-12-2 00:41

我都係,兩間都係PM E/P的offer,阿仔讀開LH的下午班,我都好懊惱揀邊間好. 我阿仔都係較有性格,會容易發皮4,擔心SC對佢會唔會太嚴格呢? D老師唔知有冇愛心? 當初報SC只係因為佢名氣大,其實對佢唔係咁了解,有冇人可以分享下?

作者: icbb1230 時間: 10-12-2 00:47

Hi Toffeenut,

yes, she quit SC.  She is now in GH K2 coz I don't want to play this exciting game for her P1 anymore.  This year, my younger one K1 application already given me a serious headache....

派位學校是指要經政府統一派位的學校, e.g. Maryknoll, La Salle, Heep Yun, St Mary, all these school are government or aided school, so you can't apply by yourself, you must go thru the central allocation.  But 1st round allocation can have advantage by if you are old boy or girls, or with same religion, or 1 of the parent are shcool staff, etc.  2nd round is like lucky draw.  Details you can check in the educational department website.

If private or DSS school, e.g. St Paul Co-ed, DGS, DBS, GH, St Joseph, Ying Wa, etc.  You can apply, but the competition is keen and you have to pay for monthly school fee.

Hope the above can help you a bit.

cheers
icbb

P.S.  pls make up your mind asap because SC and LH are very popular school, my younger one is on SC waitlist now.  Don't keep the placement too long if you don't choose it finally.

原帖由 Toffeenut 於 10-12-2 00:25 發表

多謝你的意見, 你囡己無讀SC嗎? LH因為自己囝讀緊, 好唔好真係自己知, 不過我主要擔心因小兒行為還不成熟, 有時會搗蛋, 唔知SC會否包容得到?
我想問派位的意思是指DSS/私小, 我都想知啊. ...

作者: Toffeenut 時間: 10-12-2 01:12

原帖由 icbb1230 於 10-12-2 00:47 發表
Hi Toffeenut,

yes, she quit SC. She is now in GH K2 coz I don't want to play this exciting game for her P1 anymore. This year, my younger one K1 application already given me a serious headache.... ...

啊... 聽到考P1真係好嚴峻... 好得人驚... 你囡本來SC都... 但我囝係無你所講政府學校的派位優勢, 無論父母/兄姊/宗教/地區, 全部無, 一係就襯呢2年要安排下, 一係就靠考直資私校. 咁你個囝有無考PC?
PS: 收到的!!

作者: ganen 時間: 10-12-2 09:25

我地的情況差唔多, 現正在LH讀上午pn, 來年編了下午普英(但應有機會轉番上午), SC是下午普英, 而家亞女十分享受LH學校生活, 英文講多左, 老師也有方法"整治"到佢, 我也想知道SC對小朋友的行為問題點樣處理, 我認為老師對學生嚴格一點沒有問題, 小時唔"禁"住大些仲難管教。

作者: bb@wonderland 時間: 10-12-2 09:30

原帖由 babyjoshua 於 10-12-1 23:24 發表
有冇讀過Learning Habitat + St Cat 的parents 可以share what is good / bad about each school? We are not sure whether we should change from LH to St Cat for K1.
My son 係Learning Habitat 讀緊PN , St ...

SC does not publish P1 application results, as there are too many students in one year (~600). Of course there are students who have good offers, and on the other hands, some may not.

Both schools are good. But SC is a big school, unlike LH with small class size; teachers of SC will not call you initially, unless your kid has problem in the class (but if you call the teacher, the teachers do reply you call and discuss with you)

My kid is studying in SC, I have friends' kids studying in LH. All kids are studying happily in their own school. So it is difficult to compare.

[ 本帖最後由 bb@wonderland 於 10-12-2 09:32 編輯 ]

作者: 日日見住你 時間: 10-12-2 09:36

俾我就鐘意小班教學,老師會consider d.關心d.

作者: sadsam 時間: 10-12-2 09:47

我覺得兩間學校好相似。有讀過SC，冇讀過LH。

有以下COMMENT:
SC就老牌子，LH新。

老師: LH感覺上親切(因沒有親身經歷)，關愛學生；SC不是沒有愛心，可更加好的。
校長：LH沒有架子(Interview 看她介紹學校)有和家長交流；SC 3年來在學校見過她不到十次，我沒有跟她接觸過。但有同學仔家長跟她接觸過，沒有架子，仲請家長去9龍塘會吃飯。

教學經驗：SC好D，有紅鬚綠眼外國人多d；LH-Interview當日係中國人講英文故事的，感覺上好似少左d外國人老師。

環境：SC有outdoor playground，課室細/舊，低密度；LH(青衣)看不到有室外，但室內都好大活動空間，校舍在屋苑內。

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-2 10:49

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-2 11:02

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: icbb1230 時間: 10-12-2 11:15

Hi Toffeenut,
I have 2 daughters, no son, haha. My elder daughter was fail in PC interview in 2005, and I didn't apply for my younger one as she is very small B. Actually, PC is not suitable for my kid as both of them are too active. PC requires kids to behave in good discipline.
cheers

原帖由 Toffeenut 於 10-12-2 01:12 發表

啊... 聽到考P1真係好嚴峻... 好得人驚... 你囡本來SC都... 但我囝係無你所講政府學校的派位優勢, 無論父母/兄姊/宗教/地區, 全部無, 一係就襯呢2年要安排下, 一係就靠考直資私校. 咁你個囝有無考PC?
PS: 收到的!! ...

作者: mewmew2 時間: 10-12-2 11:21

講開小班,有冇人知SC K1等係幾多小朋友一班? LH都唔少人,我仔PN都有28人一班.

作者: onec 時間: 10-12-2 11:40

SC大概都係24-28人一班, 班班唔同, 一個中文, 一個net, 一個助教. 有些大班的會分兩個classroom上堂.
囡囡係英普, 有部份接觸過的普通話老師不是非常native的, 當然有不錯的, 囡囡k1 k2的也ok....k3就一般.
SC咁大間學校, 老師的standard比較參差.
net 就一定係鬼(好似冇聽過有abc...我囡囡k1係英國人, k2係美國人, 口音係會唔同, 不過小朋友唔會覺得有乜問題, net是有 share的, K3其實係半個net, 因為1個net兩班分, 3個中內, net只會於1.5中內出現

細仔考過LH但唔收PN, 唔知LH點

作者: lovelyaudrey 時間: 10-12-2 12:04

原帖由 sadsam 於 10-12-2 09:47 發表
我覺得兩間學校好相似。有讀過SC，冇讀過LH。

有以下COMMENT:
SC就老牌子，LH新。

老師: LH感覺上親切(因沒有親身經歷)，關愛學生；SC不是沒有愛心，可更加好的。
校長：LH沒有架子(Interview 看她介紹學校)有和家長交流；SC 3年 ...

正讀緊LH, 分析中肯, 全對~
真係喜歡LH, 校長好"down to the earth", 每次茶敍, 同老師傾完, 就會同校長傾, 佢亦好尊重我地意見, 係好坦誠的溝通, 好欣賞校長, 課程內容安排都很好, 感覺好close, 好warm~
但我無懷疑NET 的數量, 因每日早會時間都看到, 每班都有NET班主任的, 真有點奇怪反而interview當日要安排ABC講story.
SC 同 LH 真係好難compare!! 隨了"名氣"SC係好過LH之外, 其他真係不相伯仲~
如果有多點 SC升小的資料就好!!

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-2 12:09

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: carcar418 時間: 10-12-2 12:10

原帖由 lovelyaudrey 於 10-12-2 12:04 發表

正讀緊LH, 分析中肯, 全對~
真係喜歡LH, 校長好"down to the earth", 每次茶敍, 同老師傾完, 就會同校長傾, 佢亦好尊重我地意見, 係好坦誠的溝通, 好欣賞校長, 課程內容安排都很好, 感覺好close, 好warm~
但我無懷 ...

想請問LH青衣分校係咪都一樣咁好呀?!?! 我見考直資私校既成績都唔錯呢!

作者: brrbaby2007 時間: 10-12-2 12:14

原帖由 lovelyaudrey 於 10-12-2 12:04 發表

正讀緊LH, 分析中肯, 全對~
真係喜歡LH, 校長好"down to the earth", 每次茶敍, 同老師傾完, 就會同校長傾, 佢亦好尊重我地意見, 係好坦誠的溝通, 好欣賞校長, 課程內容安排都很好, 感覺好close, 好warm~
但我無懷 ...

有LH k2、k3家長提過LH除2文3語presentation外，亦特別著重培育邏輯思考等等，唔知SC呢方面係點？

作者: giant_japan 時間: 10-12-2 12:19

原帖由 carcar418 於 10-12-2 12:10 發表

想請問LH青衣分校係咪都一樣咁好呀?!?! 我見考直資私校既成績都唔錯呢!

基本上全部分校都係一樣的

作者: sadsam 時間: 10-12-2 12:21

去得SC既，9龍塘區......D家長來來去去都係想入果幾間架啦，佢地學生人數又多，相對都幾多人入倒架。我小朋友同同學仔都有好多人入到，數數下MCS都有60-70個，LS識既都有廿幾個囉。不過呢D唔係考入去既，係主要派入去。另識有D係P2插入去 OR P1 KNOCK DOOR入。

原帖由 lovelyaudrey 於 10-12-2 12:04 發表

正讀緊LH, 分析中肯, 全對~
真係喜歡LH, 校長好"down to the earth", 每次茶敍, 同老師傾完, 就會同校長傾, 佢亦好尊重我地意見, 係好坦誠的溝通, 好欣賞校長, 課程內容安排都很好, 感覺好close, 好warm~
但我無懷 ...

作者: kitmantsoi 時間: 10-12-2 12:35

分享小小經驗, 仔仔以前返Victoria playgroup, NET係ABC, 而家返LH PN NET 係外籍老師唔覺適應有問題. 而家d 小朋友好叻會自己轉台, 你同佢講英文就答英文, 你同佢講PTH就答PTH. 不用擔心!

原帖由 Pertra 於 10-12-2 11:02 發表
St. Cat
我想問SC出名是因為英普班學生嗎?但我看了BK forum 話英普班只是近幾年才有，以前無，我吾知有無看錯。如是，SC 自7X年，都只有中英班，建立學校的名譽及名氣。所以中英班學生都已好出色，有無SC mami 知??
學之園
想 ...

作者: nataliepsc 時間: 10-12-2 14:01

SC名氣大, 但LH呢幾年上得好快, 兩間都強調語言能力, 所以真係不相伯仲
小朋友適應能力強, 應該唔駛太擔心, 但如果小朋友係如你所講o係LH超開心, 點解要 take risk 去轉呢? 轉左除非係超級勁開心, 否則就有d"捉蟲"...你第日諗落可能會覺得後悔&自責, 不如同c6傾清楚啦, 有時男人會比較step back俾到d我地諗唔到stuck住左既points...

作者: Toffeenut 時間: 10-12-2 14:19

我囝係海帆軒的LH pn上午班, 就係好欣賞校長, 每日我接送個囝都見到佢企起門口同d小朋友講早晨byebye(真係每一日), 我囝好多時唔睬佢, 佢照日日同我囝打招呼, 上次同校長傾有關派k1班, 佢真係可以由我的角度出發, 去分析點做. 我囝班都係 1中文老師+1 NET, 雙班主任, 再加1 assistant都係老師來的(佢應該係下午班的班主任), 另外每星期都有普通話2定3堂, 呢個係native pth老師(應該係share其他中英班的. 以我所見, 除了1位好似係課程顧問的ABC英文老師, 其他都係NET.

作者: brrbaby2007 時間: 10-12-2 14:20

另外，我覺得都要考慮吓小朋友在LH讀左幾個月有乜得著先？如果得著好小，轉去SC呢個未知得著既地方值博率好高。而如果得著好大，就應好好同老師傾吓LH K1-K3未來課程如何發展，老師點睇你地小朋友等等。

[ 本帖最後由 brrbaby2007 於 10-12-2 14:23 編輯 ]

作者: Toffeenut 時間: 10-12-2 14:25

原帖由 nataliepsc 於 10-12-2 14:01 發表
SC名氣大, 但LH呢幾年上得好快, 兩間都強調語言能力, 所以真係不相伯仲
小朋友適應能力強, 應該唔駛太擔心, 但如果小朋友係如你所講o係LH超開心, 點解要 take risk 去轉呢? 轉左除非係超級勁開心, 否則就有d"捉蟲".. ...

我相信好多媽咪"stuck住左"果個point, 最主要就係名氣, 大學校vs細學校(指全級人數). 我有時諗, 係咪小朋友去邊度讀個分別都唔大? (provided 2間都是適合的教學類型), 咁去考小學的分別會否在於名氣? 但又會擔心個囝去左咁大間學校, 稍為中平都會被人忽略左, 無响LH呢度會發展得咁好?

作者: kitmantsoi 時間: 10-12-2 14:39

same thing happen in LV campus, 班主任亦有好open咁商討K1升班問題. 我仔仔so far 中英文聽講理解力ok, 但適應力低, 老師就advise我唔好轉換太多環境.
加上我係working mom, LH's e-circular 確實減輕左我小小.

原帖由 Toffeenut 於 10-12-2 14:19 發表
我囝係海帆軒的LH pn上午班, 就係好欣賞校長, 每日我接送個囝都見到佢企起門口同d小朋友講早晨byebye(真係每一日), 我囝好多時唔睬佢, 佢照日日同我囝打招呼, 上次同校長傾有關派k1班, 佢真係可以由我的角度出發, 去 ...

作者: babyjoshua 時間: 10-12-2 15:18

Nataliepsc,
係呀，我個仔讀LH真係超開心，而我亦非常欣賞老師同校長嗰份熱誠及主動同家長溝通。
好似昨天為例，我只係喺阿仔書包放咗張字條同班主任分享阿仔話佢同學喊，跟住班主任下午就打電話俾我，話我聽發生乜事，跟住再傾咗起碼15分鐘其他阿仔喺學校各種趣事。有時我心諗，老師真係要好有heart先會咁主動及frequent同家長接觸，這正是唔知轉唔轉去st cat嘅原因。
另一個原因就係見阿仔每次返維記都劏晒豬，喊住話要返LH,我就真係唔知佢轉去st cat會唔會又係噉喊喊喊。 (佢返維記係因為要幫妹妹舖路，我女係細b,大家都知細好難入倒好嘅pn la,但維記話明哥哥喺度，妹妹就入硬，所以阿仔走兩邊)
所以我真係好想知st cat 係咪真係派得好好多,請分享

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-2 15:27

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: babyjoshua 時間: 10-12-2 18:55

Toffeenut,

My son is also an AM student (PNA) at Olympic LH. How about your son? I am a working mum so I don't go to school often. However, every time I go, I see the principal... very impressive. She is so 親力親為.

I feel the same way too....擔心個囝去左咁大間學校, 稍為中平都會被人忽略左, 無响LH呢度會發展得咁好?

作者: Toffeenut 時間: 10-12-2 19:12

原帖由 babyjoshua 於 10-12-2 18:55 發表
Toffeenut,

My son is also an AM student (PNA) at Olympic LH. How about your son? I am a working mum so I don't go to school often. However, every time I go, I see the principal... very impressive ...

我囝PNB的. 我囝又係好鍾意返學, 好鍾意老師, 鍾意到連我帶佢去interview其他學校, 佢都好喜歡同老師"玩遊戲"(即interview考果d野).

你可否pm我?

作者: Toffeenut 時間: 10-12-2 20:09

原帖由 Pertra 於 10-12-2 15:27 發表
" 除了1位好似係課程顧問的ABC英文老師http://adex.baby-kingdom.com/www/delivery/avw.php?bannerid=591&cb=2115, 其他都係NET."
Toffeenut,
即是海帆有多少個NET ? 多少個普通話老師在校?
Thanks.
Pertra ...

咁呢個我真係唔清楚喎...

作者: Connieleo 時間: 10-12-2 20:11

My friend has the same situation as you last year and she chose LH and she found that she did a right decision.

原帖由 Toffeenut 於 10-12-2 14:19 發表
我囝係海帆軒的LH pn上午班, 就係好欣賞校長, 每日我接送個囝都見到佢企起門口同d小朋友講早晨byebye(真係每一日), 我囝好多時唔睬佢, 佢照日日同我囝打招呼, 上次同校長傾有關派k1班, 佢真係可以由我的角度出發, 去 ...

作者: babyjoshua 時間: 10-12-2 20:15

Toffeenute - I have pm-ed you. Please check!

作者: Toffeenut 時間: 10-12-2 20:15

原帖由 Connieleo 於 10-12-2 20:11 發表
My friend has the same situation as you last year and she chose LH and she found that she did a right decision.

請問你朋友係點found out呢?

作者: babyjoshua 時間: 10-12-2 21:52

Connieleo, I want to know why your friend thinks she has made the right decision.

By the way, does anyone know how many hours of Mandarin lessons are conducted each week at SC (we have chosen Eng-Cant for my boy).

Thanks

作者: 薯仔1607 時間: 10-12-2 22:19

我小朋友最近才上 LH 康城新校讀PN，我們在玫瑰崗讀而轉過來的，因他在玫瑰崗喊足兩個月，所以停學轉到LH，非常認同媽咪所說，他勁開心，每日放學還唱英文歌，而且還主動說要返學。
SC聽聞每班40人，因為以前教育處批下。舊校一個大課室中間拉簾的，因學生大多，但新校好好多的。

作者: babyjoshua 時間: 10-12-2 22:39

So ... from your observation, what made your kid cried and cried b4? Is the teaching approach very different from Learning Habitat?

原帖由 薯仔1607 於 10-12-2 22:19 發表
我小朋友最近才上 LH 康城新校讀PN，我們在玫瑰崗讀而轉過來的，因他在玫瑰崗喊足兩個月，所以停學轉到LH，非常認同媽咪所說，他勁開心，每日放學還唱英文歌，而且還主動說要返學。
SC聽聞每班40人，因為以前教育處批下。舊校一個大 ...

作者: zooooman 時間: 10-12-2 23:04

薯仔1607
My girl also got an offer from LH (LohasPark) Eng/Pth class, so I wanna know more about this new school....
your girl is in E/P or E/C class?

原帖由 薯仔1607 於 10-12-2 22:19 發表
我小朋友最近才上 LH 康城新校讀PN，我們在玫瑰崗讀而轉過來的，因他在玫瑰崗喊足兩個月，所以停學轉到LH，非常認同媽咪所說，他勁開心，每日放學還唱英文歌，而且還主動說要返學。
SC聽聞每班40人，因為以前教育處批下。舊校一個大 ...

作者: Connieleo 時間: 10-12-2 23:14

Because his son also attended both LH & SC for month but finally she found that her son was very happy when returning back from LH and said to her that he did not like SC. My friend also very like the principal and teacher in LH and she said the teachers in SC not so kind because they really need to take care so many students and the buildings is so old, so she dropped SC and only go to LH now.

原帖由 babyjoshua 於 10-12-2 21:52 發表
Connieleo, I want to know why your friend thinks she has made the right decision.

By the way, does anyone know how many hours of Mandarin lessons are conducted each week at SC (we have chosen Eng-C ...

作者: chafamama 時間: 10-12-2 23:20

hihi, 同大家一樣都係煩惱中。
有SC (pm eng/can) & KV (am) offer。會放KV出黎，唔會交留位費，因覺得不太適合小兒性格。
讀緊LH (LV am)有K1 eng/put am offer。so far好滿意LH，仔仔讀得好開心。但亦主要因為升學問題，target左傳統名校，係咪揀SC會保險D？如讀SC，eng/can班，需要出外讀putonghua嗎？因一定會不及LH 英普班效果。謝謝！

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-3 10:21

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: giant_japan 時間: 10-12-3 10:30

原帖由 chafamama 於 10-12-2 23:20 發表
hihi, 同大家一樣都係煩惱中。
有SC (pm eng/can) & KV (am) offer。會放KV出黎，唔會交留位費，因覺得不太適合小兒性格。
讀緊LH (LV am)有K1 eng/put am offer。so far好滿意LH，仔仔讀得好開心。但亦主要因為升學問題，ta ...

其實想問下putonghua係咪真係咁緊要對於將來或升小一?

作者: hinhinboy 時間: 10-12-3 12:44

我係st. cat的媽咪, 囝囝讀緊k2英普班. 我覺得st. cat都好ok. 因為本身我都唔係好識普通話, 家裹都係講d好簡單的對話. 但小朋友返學後, 講多了不同的詞彙, 又會糾正我的讀音. 而英文方面, 亦講多了不同的詞彙, 仲嘗試用拼音去串字.
不過, 我覺得如果讀緊LH的, 就唔好轉校. 因為學術上, 兩間應該都唔差的. 但st cat始終係大校. 老師關懷方面, 就真係好唔同. 我讀咁耐, 老師真係冇主動打電話比我, 講吓小朋友的情況. 但係, 你找佢, 佢都好樂意解答的. 我覺得呢個係st car的傳統吧

作者: Connieleo 時間: 10-12-4 00:16

Yes, my son is studying SC K3 Eng/Can and I found that he could not talk PTH after K1 and the PTH teacher also told me that he did not want to talk at class. So I let him to join PTH course immediately at K2. My other friend is that his son is studying in SC K2 Eng/Can, his Eng teacher also told him that his son is not willing to talk in class, then she immediately let his son to join some Eng class. Actually, I found so many parents in SC should pay extra money to let the children to join so many courses. So if I am in your case, I will let your son to study in LH.

原帖由 chafamama 於 10-12-2 23:20 發表
hihi, 同大家一樣都係煩惱中。
有SC (pm eng/can) & KV (am) offer。會放KV出黎，唔會交留位費，因覺得不太適合小兒性格。
讀緊LH (LV am)有K1 eng/put am offer。so far好滿意LH，仔仔讀得好開心。但亦主要因為升學問題，ta ...

作者: Connieleo 時間: 10-12-4 00:19

If I am you, I will choose LH co's SC's PTH class in Eng/Can stream is so limited. My son is studying K3 SC now, I should let him to study PTH outside starting in K2 co's I found him cannot talk a word in PTH after K1.

原帖由 chafamama 於 10-12-2 23:20 發表
hihi, 同大家一樣都係煩惱中。
有SC (pm eng/can) & KV (am) offer。會放KV出黎，唔會交留位費，因覺得不太適合小兒性格。
讀緊LH (LV am)有K1 eng/put am offer。so far好滿意LH，仔仔讀得好開心。但亦主要因為升學問題，ta ...

作者: Toffeenut 時間: 10-12-4 00:29

我諗若果家長是想小朋友學好pth, 但派的是英粵班, 還是可以考慮的, 只要家長可以安排在外補pth便可. 睇下要sacrifice邊樣了.

作者: huba 時間: 10-12-4 00:38

What traditional elite schools are your targeting?

原帖由 chafamama 於 2/12/2010 23:20 發表
...讀緊LH (LV am)有K1 eng/put am offer。so far好滿意LH，仔仔讀得好開心。但亦主要因為升學問題，target左傳統名校，係咪揀SC會保險D？ ...

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-4 11:43

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Connieleo 時間: 10-12-4 12:49

I don't think my son does not like PTH co's he can speak a lots after I let him to learn outside. It's only SC has so little time to teach PTH if you study in E/C class.

原帖由 Pertra 於 10-12-4 11:43 發表
Connieleo,
Did you talk to the PTH teacher about your son's situation ?
He didn't like PTH or didn't like the teacher ??

作者: babyjoshua 時間: 10-12-5 00:47

Went to LH's school picnic today and I think I have a stronger motivation to stay at LH (rather than going to SC). There are a few reasons behind it:

a) I spoke to my son's NET and she confirmed that the weighting between Chinese and English will be 50/50 throughtout K1-K3.  Wheresa from what I understand from my SC friend, the NET will not be there the whole time in K2/3.

b) I actually told this NET we are struggling between LH and SC.  She then mentioned a few interesting things (well it's up to us to digest and decide whether to believe or not la):

   i) There have been students who left LH, went to SC but wanted to return to LH.  However, LH would not have the extra seats to re-take these kids .....
   ii) She re-assured me that typical K3 students at LH would really be able to think in English and switch between English / Chinese easily.  She gave me an example that K3 kids will talk to other classmates in English when the English teacher was there.  On the other hand, when the Chinese teacher is there, kids would talk in Chinese amongst themselves. She also said that she has met some ex-LH students who have gone to SC and she felt that their English communication skill seemed to have deteriorated a bit.

c) She mentioned that SC P.1 placement results in the recent years seem to be not as good as before. (This is consistent with other comments I saw in BK forum)

d) I told her that I am concerned about my boy's ability in adjusting to a new environment.  She agreed with my view and she felt that my boy will probably take a long time to adapt to new school.

Two other things to share....

1.  I spoke to a friend who knows a LH K3 student.  That girl has applied for 10 good schools and got offers from 9 of them.  Only failed DGS.  I think that's very impressive!

2.  At the picnic today, I could really observe how my boy interacts with his teachers and how teachers interact with my boy. I was just so so so so surprised to see my boy loves the teachers so much.  No matter where teachers went today, my boy will run after them and follow and just stood very close to the teachers and smile with them.  (You can imagine it's like a kid going to Disneyland and wants to always follow Mickey Mouse & Minnie. Just like a 追星族 ). All his teachers are really so nice and I can feel they have passion and love the children. I will go to Victoria school picnic next week.... I can compare further afterwards.

Also, LH will continue to have about 28-29 students in K1-3.  I think it would make the learning environment more effective vs big classes at SC.

作者: d-ma 時間: 10-12-5 01:37

babyjoshua, thanks for your sharing. I have more preference to choose LH for my active kids.

作者: babyjoshua 時間: 10-12-5 01:43

d-ma,

Are you kids currently at LH too?

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-5 09:24

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: y3y 時間: 10-12-5 16:27

Hi babyjoshua, what you described below is very impressive! I'm also thinking to let my boy going to LH, may I know which campus is your boy studying?
[
quote]原帖由 babyjoshua 於 10-12-5 00:47 發表

Went to LH's school picnic today and I think I have a stronger motivation to stay at LH (rather than going to SC). There are a few reasons behind it:

a) I spoke to my son's NET and she confirmed th ... [/quote]

作者: babyjoshua 時間: 10-12-5 19:13

he goes to HL (olympic) campus

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-5 22:22

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: mylee6 時間: 10-12-5 22:25

Hi Babyjoshua,
I also got LH (HL P/E) PM offer.
Do you know if LH parents arrange a lot of "after-class" (academic)for kids? Is it very common?
E.g. The girl got 9 out of 10 offers.
My concern is how much extra $$ I have to pay in order to let my son get "some" offers for P1.

作者: kelvincheng 時間: 10-12-5 22:43

Hi Pertra,

Every class has 1 NET + 1 Chinese teacher. If it is P/E class, then the Chinese teacher is a PTH native speaker.

So, the number of net teachers really depends on the number of classes. For details, you may check with the school directly.

原帖由 Pertra 於 10-12-5 22:22 發表
babyjoshua,
1) How many net teachers in this campus ?
Some K1 class will be taught by the chinese (native
speaker), right ?
It seems that nobody could answer this questions before.
...

作者: d-ma 時間: 10-12-5 23:37 標題: 回覆 56# babyjoshua 的文章

Not current. My son got an pm offer of PE class from HL branch. I like the language environment and curriculum of LH very much as I think it takes a balance between active and traditional teaching. But still have some concern on the pm class and location.

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-8 14:43

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: huba 時間: 10-12-8 19:13 標題: 回復 1# Pertra 的帖子

Would suggest you to post the below questions under LHK's forum for more responses.

[ 本帖最後由 huba 於 10-12-8 19:17 編輯 ]

作者: HTY2003 時間: 10-12-9 00:18

1) 幾時要學寫字？K2
2) 普通話科K1內容？有無CD support 家長 ? 有
有無漢語拼音學？K2才有
3) 參觀或活動每月多少次？兩三月一次
4) 英文 phonics 有無 CD support 家長?

主要靠唱歌學發音，可訂購CD
5) 有無reading schedule ? 學校借書給家長回家
有，每星期中英文各一本
6) Oxford Tree Reading Book 幾時要學?K1
7) 功課量如何？一至兩項

其實選擇LH，都是為了它的語言環境，如果語言根基好，考什麼學校也容易。

HTY2003

作者: joannesm 時間: 10-12-9 08:25

聽到你哋講LH真係好吸引！我個仔有凱帆英普下午班同TT國際班，請問大家有咩意見?聽人講LH普通話唔教拼音，只係唱下歌，係咪咁？

作者: brrbaby2007 時間: 10-12-9 10:11

原帖由 Pertra 於 10-12-8 14:43 發表
學之園 - Please help !
FOR K1 : - :)
1) 幾時要學寫字？
2) 普通話科K1內容？有無CD support 家長 ?
有無漢語拼音學？
3) 參觀或活動每月多少次？
4) 英文 phonics 有無 CD support 家長?
5) 有無readin ...

Pertra唔需要顧累o甘多，有人話某名校的優點係返左K1講多左英文成日唱英文歌，我個case係小朋友返左N班幾個月，除左自動轉台外英文句子愈講愈長及連續講幾句。尋日同佢唱"The wheel on the bus"唱到最后果句我唔小心唱左all dayS long，佢即刻話唔係o甘唱係all day long！我其實唔知LH點教但我就好有驚喜！當然每人不一樣但我就好滿意LH。

如果諗住考名校，SC既名氣是吸引的，不過如果target St Paul Coed果d，KV可能更合

[ 本帖最後由 brrbaby2007 於 10-12-9 10:48 編輯 ]

作者: busy_penny 時間: 10-12-9 10:20

我覺得 St cat 值的，因為教英文是外籍人士（不是印度人），而且學費便宜些（交十個月），但LH則要交12個月；另外St Cat校舍很大，相對租金應該很昂貴，但學費較便宜，那就表示不太商業味道了。

作者: HTY2003 時間: 10-12-9 11:20

LH普通話方面，不會只唱歌，是教詞語、簡單句子，拼音有聲母及簡單韻母，你很難期望三、四歲人仔會拼音，能對答已可以。
英文方面，我只見到Net教，從未見過ABC/印度人，反而有的是澳洲口音，我不大喜歡。
LH的學費不便宜，家長要認真考慮，而且LH只有十年歷史，名氣比不上KV、SC是事實。我見大部份家長目標都是不大傳統的小學，所以想想什麼是你們的要求才下決定吧！
HTY2003

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-10 11:31 標題: 回復 2# busy_penny 的帖子

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: elizatyy 時間: 10-12-11 11:17

原帖由 Pertra 於 10-12-8 14:43 發表
學之園 - Please help !
FOR K1 : - :)
1) 幾時要學寫字？
2) 普通話科K1內容？有無CD support 家長 ?
有無漢語拼音學？
3) 參觀或活動每月多少次？
4) 英文 phonics 有無 CD support 家長?
5) 有無readin ...

ｋ２開始会教得較快，但学生一般可以應付到

作者: mylee6 時間: 10-12-11 12:55

Hi Pertra,
Can you explain more about the summer class?
Does LH student need to go to school during summer time?
Thx!

作者: elizatyy 時間: 10-12-11 18:29

LHK has around 3 weeks of summer holiday. Students do not go to school.

作者: sp3014 時間: 10-12-12 00:08

其實我囡囡PN係讀LH PM，現在讀SC E/C PM。想當初我地都矛盾左好耐，因為我囡囡同我自己都好認同其他人所講的優點咁鍾意LH，同我都好擔心囡囡會唔適應。最後把心一橫去SC係因為係送囡囡返學時識一個LH K2的家長，同佢傾計，佢話佢同個囝囝in小學時，深深體會到如果想去讀私立同直資，幼稚園的名氣都好重要，因為其實一間小學一年見幾千人，一般的正常的小朋友都會表現好好，除非個別特別outstanding impress 到佢地啦，所以學校就會參考佢讀邊間幼稚園同佢地D progress report。我從來沒懷疑LH的好，雖然近年口碑都升得好快,只係佢比較新，我相信幾年後佢再發展下去絶對可以同SC齊名，但係我囡囡兩年後就要考小學，所以我都係決定去SC。
其實兩間的教學都好相似，所以囡囡好快就適應到，SC E/C一星期都有兩日有PH上，不過無可否認LH係大D新D，老師會耐唔耐打比你同你講下小朋友的情況，SC就唔會。但係SC的課程就比較systematic 同organised,尤其佢地的4 weeks plan for English,我終於有D明白如果家長同學校一起配合，小朋友讀完K3之後,英文應該會係幾好。

作者: 星歷仔ccsclh 時間: 10-12-12 01:06

Deleled...............................................................................

[ 本帖最後由星歷仔ccsclh 於 11-1-4 23:59 編輯 ]

作者: fatma2222 時間: 10-12-12 03:15

i also feel when the school building is older, it is a real place for studying.. i don't want my kid to enjoy just hotel like places all the time.. a real place to study should not have toys everywhere..
happiness should gain from interaction between student themselves and with teacher
i think both school are good, just depends on what the parent want mostly

作者: Christi 時間: 10-12-12 09:42

LH普通話教成點,我要觀察多一段時間.但小女現讀PN,有一次用普通話對我講:你真捧.又能分別普通話[捧]和[笨],說不是[笨],是[捧],是bang...真的令我很錯愕呢!

作者: brrbaby2007 時間: 10-12-13 09:28

原帖由 星歷仔ccsclh 於 10-12-12 01:06 發表
 http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/vie ... &extra=page%3D1

LH-->SC-->CCKG-->DBSPD

如果佢考到CCKG，我諗係LH既功勞之一，畢竟spend左1年響LH操好d Eng，而在SC只是短短開學3個月就去in。不過SC名氣有冇幫助入到CCKG就不知道了，等我出年試吓！

作者: huba 時間: 10-12-13 19:12

Good point. Though, the kid should have received very good support from the parents/family in parallel as well.

原帖由 brrbaby2007 於 13/12/2010 09:28 發表

如果佢考到CCKG，我諗係LH既功勞之一，畢竟spend左1年響LH操好d Eng，而在SC只是短短開學3個月就去in。...

作者: 星歷仔ccsclh 時間: 10-12-14 00:40 標題: 回復 81# huba 的帖子

deleted..........................................................................

[ 本帖最後由星歷仔ccsclh 於 11-1-5 00:01 編輯 ]

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-14 11:33

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: huba 時間: 10-12-15 01:12

Deleted...

[ 本帖最後由 huba 於 11-1-5 02:34 編輯 ]

作者: lovelyaudrey 時間: 10-12-17 11:26

原帖由 brrbaby2007 於 10-12-13 09:28 發表

如果佢考到CCKG，我諗係LH既功勞之一，畢竟spend左1年響LH操好d Eng，而在SC只是短短開學3個月就去in。不過SC名氣有冇幫助入到CCKG就不知道了，等我出年試吓！ ...

brrbaby2007, so that means you will stay in LH to test its "名氣" in CCKG next year?

作者: Pertra 時間: 10-12-29 14:21

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: PoorParent 時間: 11-1-4 23:56

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)