教育王國
標題: (急)香港華仁 vs 救恩，應該怎取捨 [打印本頁]
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 14:15 標題: (急)香港華仁 vs 救恩，應該怎取捨
各位友好，犬兒幸運地被華仁抽中，但救恩已交留位費，由於華仁註冊日期漸近，可否發表一下對兩間學校的意見，例如：
校風 (操行)
學業壓力 (功課量，考試測驗多少等)
學習模式
升中安排及往績
希望各位能鼎力幫忙，謝謝!
作者: kenfu 時間: 10-11-23 14:23
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: YuHangMum 時間: 10-11-23 14:44
香港華仁: 朋友兒子剛升了上中學部
校風 (操行): 純樸
學業壓力 (功課量，考試測驗多少等): 跟一般學校相約
學習模式: 不清楚, 好似還是大班
升中安排及往績: 跟華仁書院是有直屬關係應該有8成可以直升
救恩: 朋友的小孩在學
校風 (操行): 好, 著重生命教育
學業壓力 (功課量，考試測驗多少等): 小一及二沒有考試, 但以評估形式進行, 功課量都不是太少
學習模式: 較活動, 小班教學
升中安排及往績: 中西區中學網, 大部分都可以入到英中, 但沒有保證
and 華仁 free of charge, 救恩: 6年學費
作者: AthenaCheng 時間: 10-11-23 15:02
小兒正在KYS讀P1，感覺不是太好！
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 15:31
請問是哪方面不太好呢？原帖由 AthenaCheng 於 10-11-23 15:02 發表 
小兒正在KYS讀P1，感覺不是太好！
作者: babybear 時間: 10-11-23 15:47
個人比較喜歡華仁。
作者: brian61950 時間: 10-11-23 15:55
或者諗下放棄左邊間會可能會後悔及冇機會返轉頭,答案早在你心裏.
作者: babybear 時間: 10-11-23 15:57
Good point!
原帖由 brian61950 於 10-11-23 15:55 發表
或者諗下放棄左邊間會可能會後悔及冇機會返轉頭,答案早在你心裏.
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 16:17
如果答案早在我心裡，我便無需在這裡詢問各位意見，我既要打問題，又要看回覆，更佔用了其他BK家長的時間，相信我應該不會這樣浪費自己和其他人的時間吧。
說真的，選哪一間都可能後悔和不能回頭(例如救恩在我們接受自行後會轉為備取生，不接受自行就更不可回頭追回華仁)，現在只是希望有更多資料去作決定，因為我們想多從其他家長的親身體驗(或聽來別人的親身體驗)進一步了解兩校，就此而已。原帖由 brian61950 於 10-11-23 15:55 發表
或者諗下放棄左邊間會可能會後悔及冇機會返轉頭,答案早在你心裏.
作者: karen55407 時間: 10-11-23 16:23
緊係華仁啦！
原帖由 ykha 於 10-11-23 16:17 發表
如果答案早在我心裡，我便無需在這裡詢問各位意見，我既要打問題，又要看回覆，更佔用了其他BK家長的時間，相信我應該不會這樣浪費自己和其他人的時間吧。
說真的，選哪一間都可能後悔和不能回頭(例如救恩在我們接受自行後會轉 ...
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 16:27
可否解釋一下原因？是否你的小孩或朋友的小孩在這兩間學校讀書？原帖由 karen55407 於 10-11-23 16:23 發表
緊係華仁啦！
作者: traeh 時間: 10-11-23 16:27
你係咪華仁舊生？如果係，你應該識得而家讀緊嘅小朋友家長，不如直接問下佢地，而家華仁係點，升返中學比例如何。
華仁同救恩各有各好，但救恩無直屬中學，六年後再玩升中，要呈分撲學校，你係咪okay？如果唔想再煩，而華仁升中比率又高，咁揀華仁啦。
原帖由 ykha 於 10-11-23 16:17 發表
如果答案早在我心裡，我便無需在這裡詢問各位意見，我既要打問題，又要看回覆，更佔用了其他BK家長的時間，相信我應該不會這樣浪費自己和其他人的時間吧。
說真的，選哪一間都可能後悔和不能回頭(例如救恩在我們接受自行後會轉 ...
作者: carolchanym 時間: 10-11-23 16:29
原帖由 AthenaCheng 於 10-11-23 15:02 發表
小兒正在KYS讀P1，感覺不是太好！
請問你囝是哪一班呢? 我兒有可能是他的同學呢...
能否分享一下你對這校的感覺呢? 如不想公開, 請pm...
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 16:34
我雖然是舊生，但已是30多年前的事，現在學校變成怎樣，可能問最近入學或畢業的家長比較清楚，當年的同學不少已移民外國，回港的或留港的多為子女選國際學校，所以資料不多。原帖由 traeh 於 10-11-23 16:27 發表
你係咪華仁舊生？如果係，你應該識得而家讀緊嘅小朋友家長，不如直接問下佢地，而家華仁係點，升返中學比例如何。
華仁同救恩各有各好，但救恩無直屬中學，六年後再玩升中，要呈分撲學校，你係咪okay？如果唔想再煩，而華仁升中比率又高，咁 ...
作者: steve666 時間: 10-11-23 16:37
我都揀華仁，有中學。
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 16:40
請問津貼中學的收生制度是怎樣的？直屬中學可以自行決定取錄直屬小學的學生的百分比或最低成績嗎？原帖由 steve666 於 10-11-23 16:37 發表
我都揀華仁，有中學。
作者: 277177 時間: 10-11-23 16:41
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 6321 時間: 10-11-23 16:49
hihi,
how many points can get Wah Yan in the first lucky draw?
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 16:50
可否就我提到的那數點解釋一下？原帖由 277177 於 10-11-23 16:41 發表
緊係華仁啦 !!!
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 16:51
20 points here原帖由 6321 於 10-11-23 16:49 發表
hihi,
how many points can get Wah Yan in the first lucky draw?
作者: HuiTung 時間: 10-11-23 16:51
我有親戚也將入讀, 亦有朋友在救恩做, 但我也選港華.
作者: ahpei 時間: 10-11-23 16:52
概係華仁啦, 好多人點抽都抽唔到, 又 free of charge, 救恩學費都幾貴, 長遠黎講不如留返黎學野好過 ~
作者: ferrynferry 時間: 10-11-23 16:56
華仁有直上中學 300%揀華仁級數唔同六年學費 貼錢買差啲
作者: traeh 時間: 10-11-23 16:58
直屬中學可用最多百分之八十五學位，收返直屬小學學生（有錯請指正），但有唔少學校為保持中學水平，唔會用晒個QUOTA，據聞Maryknoll就只係收小學一半人，其他位用來收外邊學校叻人。
原帖由 ykha 於 10-11-23 16:40 發表
請問津貼中學的收生制度是怎樣的？直屬中學可以自行決定取錄直屬小學的學生的百分比或最低成績嗎？
作者: steve666 時間: 10-11-23 16:59
這個我就唔清楚，但佢應有一部份學位佢自已有選擇權，另一部份就交出供其他申請(用小五小六呈分計)。但你可以睇返佢過往，佢收左幾多%佢既直屬小學學生，就略知一二。
原帖由 ykha 於 10-11-23 16:40 發表
請問津貼中學的收生制度是怎樣的？直屬中學可以自行決定取錄直屬小學的學生的百分比或最低成績嗎？
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 17:01
請問是哪方面差d (名氣除外)？原帖由 ferrynferry 於 10-11-23 16:56 發表
華仁有直上中學 300%揀華仁級數唔同六年學費 貼錢買差啲
作者: ahpei 時間: 10-11-23 17:04
都有幾個朋友讀救恩, 救恩不是差, 不過兩者比較會揀華仁 !
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 17:04
請問在哪裡有這方面的資料？小學網站似乎沒有。原帖由 steve666 於 10-11-23 16:59 發表
這個我就唔清楚，但佢應有一部份學位佢自已有選擇權，另一部份就交出供其他申請(用小五小六呈分計)。但你可以睇返佢過往，佢收左幾多%佢既直屬小學學生，就略知一二。
...
作者: PoorParent 時間: 10-11-23 17:06
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: hauyya 時間: 10-11-23 17:06
其實兩間都唔同類型,一間是比較傳统有名氣的學校,一間是比較新派活動式有愛心的学校,真的事乎你想仔仔接受那一種教學方式。
但兩間也是好好的小學!
作者: traeh 時間: 10-11-23 17:08
梗係睇教育局網站啦:
http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManager/TC/Content_1579/faq_sspa0911(100901)chi(r).pdf
http://www.edb.gov.hk/FileManager/TC/Content_1579/leaflet-sspa%2009-11c(4paged).pdf
原帖由 ykha 於 10-11-23 17:04 發表
請問在哪裡有這方面的資料？小學網站似乎沒有。
作者: babybear 時間: 10-11-23 17:16
如果小朋友係谷得, 真係唔駛再三心兩意~
作者: babybear 時間: 10-11-23 17:17
好睇小朋友係邊種氣質而去選擇.
原帖由 hauyya 於 10-11-23 17:06 發表
其實兩間都唔同類型,一間是比較傳统有名氣的學校,一間是比較新派活動式有愛心的学校,真的事乎你想仔仔接受那一種教學方式。
但兩間也是好好的小學! ...
作者: ferrynferry 時間: 10-11-23 17:17
原帖由 ykha 於 10-11-23 17:01 發表
請問是哪方面差d (名氣除外)？
請問取左活動教學,有咩會俾華仁好~
作者: brian61950 時間: 10-11-23 17:21
我諗既然冇乜比較,又交左留位費,咪當抽唔到咯,救恩好了.
唔駛煩.
作者: celialawrence 時間: 10-11-23 17:47
我有兩三個朋友個仔讀緊KYK, 佢地都唔揀返KY, 因為佢地話學校成日要佢地捐呢樣捐果樣, 唔捐又驚俾人睇少, 好煩. 同埋階級觀念好犀利, 當然如果你地係高D階級既咁無所謂啦.
津小就少好多呢D情況, 大家都係公平入黎學校讀既, 叻既唔係靠背景而係靠成績.
作者: brian61950 時間: 10-11-23 17:55
4姨太咁有錢都偏偏送左何B仔入華仁,佢地德育呢方面真係強.
原帖由 celialawrence 於 10-11-23 17:47 發表
我有兩三個朋友個仔讀緊KYK, 佢地都唔揀返KY, 因為佢地話學校成日要佢地捐呢樣捐果樣, 唔捐又驚俾人睇少, 好煩. 同埋階級觀念好犀利, 當然如果你地係高D階級既咁無所謂啦.
津小就少好多呢D情況, 大家都係公平入黎學 ...
作者: qqzzma 時間: 10-11-23 18:06
小女在救恩幼稚園畢業, 完全沒有所述事情(捐呢樣捐果樣,階級觀念).
救恩在關愛,德育做得極為出色, 採用活動探究教學. 除了在原區沒有直屬中學外, 是一間很值得考慮的小學.
原帖由 celialawrence 於 10-11-23 17:47 發表
我有兩三個朋友個仔讀緊KYK, 佢地都唔揀返KY, 因為佢地話學校成日要佢地捐呢樣捐果樣, 唔捐又驚俾人睇少, 好煩. 同埋階級觀念好犀利, 當然如果你地係高D階級既咁無所謂啦.
津小就少好多呢D情況, 大家都係公平入黎學 ...
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 18:52
活動教學是不是比傳統功課和測考對小朋友的學習更好？如果是的話，就是一個很大的好處。
不過我比較想知多一點就讀兩間學校家長對學校的評價，特別是我提到的幾點，因為我覺得那些是比較重要的。原帖由 ferrynferry 於 10-11-23 17:17 發表
請問取左活動教學,有咩會俾華仁好~
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 18:54
它好像是沒有直屬中學的，只有一間聯繫中學，給救恩畢業生30個學位，過去數年這30個學位均沒有用完。原帖由 qqzzma 於 10-11-23 18:06 發表
小女在救恩幼稚園畢業, 完全沒有所述事情(捐呢樣捐果樣,階級觀念).
救恩在關愛,德育做得極為出色, 採用活動探究教學. 除了在原區沒有直屬中學外, 是一間很值得考慮的小學.
...
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 19:01
謝謝你的提點!
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-23 19:02
How? I am a new user...原帖由 PoorParent 於 10-11-23 17:06 發表
You may ask Thomasha in the other thread.
作者: PoorParent 時間: 10-11-23 20:26
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-24 00:46
Thanks I will contact him.
Getting nervous now...hope more parents will share...
作者: Gogojuly 時間: 10-11-24 01:10
原帖由 AthenaCheng 於 10-11-23 15:02 發表
小兒正在KYS讀P1，感覺不是太好！
請問可透露是邊方面唔好嗎?
我有打算讓細仔入讀KYS,若不方便的話,請你PM我.
謝謝
不好意思,佔用樓主版面
作者: Gogojuly 時間: 10-11-24 01:12
原帖由 ykha 於 10-11-23 17:01 發表
請問是哪方面差d (名氣除外)？
若比我揀,我亦會揀華仁.
1.名氣
2.接龍中學
作者: Gogojuly 時間: 10-11-24 01:31
原帖由 celialawrence 於 10-11-23 17:47 發表
我有兩三個朋友個仔讀緊KYK, 佢地都唔揀返KY, 因為佢地話學校成日要佢地捐呢樣捐果樣, 唔捐又驚俾人睇少, 好煩. 同埋階級觀念好犀利, 當然如果你地係高D階級既咁無所謂啦.
津小就少好多呢D情況, 大家都係公平入黎學 ...
KYS是基督教小學.
佢地會有些慈善活動希望小朋友及家長参與.如買奬券,耆老餅,現今進行的"善普施聖誔禮物行動"就會將籌集的禮物盒送往經歷過天災的四川及青海.
我不是教徒,但覺得這些活動好有教育意義.且全是自願参加的.其他很多幼稚園亦有同樣的慈善活動.
因為佢地話學校成日要佢地捐呢樣捐果樣, 唔捐又驚俾人睇少, 好煩. 同埋階級觀念好犀利, 當然如果你地係高D階級既咁無所謂啦.我沒有這種感覺,我覺得其幼稚園真係十分之好,老師有愛心.其幼稚園的小朋友都好有自信,樂觀,開朗.
我仍在找其小學的資料,希望有多些評語比我考参
[ 本帖最後由 Gogojuly 於 10-11-24 01:37 編輯 ]
作者: venuscc 時間: 10-11-24 01:36
如果是系我，一定華仁！
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-24 02:17
為甚麼呢？原帖由 venuscc 於 10-11-24 01:36 發表
如果是系我，一定華仁！
作者: mozartmom 時間: 10-11-24 04:56
I understand it is tough to make your decision as I have a similar problem.
I really like Kau Yan and prepare to let my daugther to study in Kau Yan before Monday. However, i am too lucky to get a seat from a traditional famous school. I have 20 marks but not living in the same district. After spending all my efforts of those P1 interviews and profile preparations, I feel that it's funny to pick a school which requires no effort but just by luck. Also, my own memory of those boring primary and secondary time make me feel that Kau Yan should be a dream school for my kid. Checking with friends, most of them recommend me to pick the traditional famous school. I am so afraid to make a wrong decision. Therefore, i let my kid to pick. She picks the school with more "beautiful" campus and uniform - the traditional famous school. Her good choice helps me save a few thousands a month and makes me feel better if i make a wrong choice for her by myself. See if my sharing of this experience will help. 
原帖由 ykha 於 10-11-24 02:17 發表
為甚麼呢？
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-24 09:22
Thank you for your understanding and sharing.
The case is a little more difficult for me because WY does not let us tour around any part of the campus. My son could only have my verbal description (may not be accurate as it was my vague impression 30+ years ago) as a reference.原帖由 mozartmom 於 10-11-24 04:56 發表
I understand it is tough to make your decision as I have a similar problem.
I really like Kau Yan and prepare to let my daugther to study in Kau Yan before Monday. However, i am too lucky to get a se ...
作者: carolchanym 時間: 10-11-24 11:23
原帖由 Gogojuly 於 10-11-24 01:31 發表
KYS是基督教小學.
佢地會有些慈善活動希望小朋友及家長参與.如買奬券,耆老餅,現今進行的"善普施聖誔禮物行動"就會將籌集的禮物盒送往經歷過天災的四川及青海.
我不是教徒,但覺得這些活動好有教育意義.且全是自願 ...
非常同意你的說法.
我囝現正就讀小一, 剛準備好一些禮物以響應"善普施聖誕禮物行動", 讓他能關愛別人, 明白"施比受有福"的道理及珍惜自己所有的...
亦有"食物銀行"可自由損出食物給有需要的小朋友, 今早他才帶了些"面食"回去呢...
昨天才完成了"赤腳行動", 讓他們親自感受冇鞋著的滋味, 我囝話個地下好硬同好凍喎...
這的確是一所非常有愛心的活動教學學校, 不能與傳統教學的比較, 因橙不同香蕉嘛...
但我對他們的校車服務就非常不滿...
作者: traeh 時間: 10-11-24 11:28
你試下帶小朋友去學校外圍行下，起碼有個idea。同埋你有無入舊生會？舊生會一般都會搞下同學校有關活動，話唔定有機會去睇下，同埋你會識多啲仔仔讀緊華仁嘅舊生，比多啲一手資訊你。不過好快要註冊，可能未必趕得切．．．
原帖由 ykha 於 10-11-24 09:22 發表
Thank you for your understanding and sharing.
The case is a little more difficult for me because WY does not let us tour around any part of the campus. My son could only have my verbal description ( ...
作者: artroboy 時間: 10-11-24 11:31
因為佢地既校車係外判的, 無辦法
原帖由 carolchanym 於 10-11-24 11:23 發表
非常同意你的說法.
我囝現正就讀小一, 剛準備好一些禮物以響應"善普施聖誕禮物行動", 讓他能關愛別人, 明白"施比受有福"的道理及珍惜自己所有的...
亦有"食物銀行"可自由損出食物給有需要的小朋友, 今早他才帶了些 ...
作者: artroboy 時間: 10-11-24 11:54
其實華仁己經不復當年勇.....睇返近年成績就明, 都係以名氣"答"救... (以前 d 人成日將皇仁, 華仁, 英皇並提) ..... ..特別係佢地既小學部成績並不是想像中咁強, 中學亦不是收返70%小學都......最好打電話去學校了解多 d 資料.
作者: 彤彤Mum 時間: 10-11-24 13:54
我會揀華仁，因為有中學
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-24 14:05
同意，如果仍如當年勇，我就無需這麼頭痛，左思右想。
經過各位的分享和再詢問不同的朋友，我們已有初步結果，今晚會再開會商討作確認，明天執行。當然，如果期間還有其他具份量的意見，我們還是會考慮的。
謝謝各位！原帖由 artroboy 於 10-11-24 11:54 發表
其實華仁己經不復當年勇.....睇返近年成績就明, 都係以名氣"答"救... (以前 d 人成日將皇仁, 華仁, 英皇並提) ..... ..特別係佢地既小學部成績並不是想像中咁強, 中學亦不是收返70%小學都......最好打電話去學校了解 ...
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 10-11-24 14:16
I have similar problem but I would choose a fee-paying school for my kid instead of a famous traditional school.
1. You are a discerning parent and your kids will succeed wherever they go. By accepting a fee-paying school, you are freeing up a valuable primary school place to someone else whose needs are greater than your kid. You are in fact creating more happiness in the world.
2. KYS is whole day, whereas WY is half-day. A big difference to me because I want my kids to enjoy a full-day experience.
3. KYS is co-educational, where WY is single sex. I think boys like girls, and at the age of 5, I'd choose a co-educational primary school for my son.
4. Teachers tend to be exhausted for teaching morning and afternoon classes in aided schools. Fee-paying schools tend to pay their teachers better, who in turn tend to have more energy to give more attention to your kids.
5. The fact that even as an old boy, you have hesitation about WY (and your friends all send their kids elsewhere) speaks for itself. Hong Kong's education is in a mess. You pay and you may have a greater say - because if you don't like the fee-paying school later on, you can always change or move or migrate.
6. I assume your son likes KYS, and his personalities fit into the philosophy of that school. Many people envy you. Take responsibility and make the right choice.
Good luck.
作者: shsm 時間: 10-11-24 15:18
WY's teachers in morning session will not teach in afternoon. Vice versa. Only principal and vice principal have to work whole day.
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-24 15:23
Thank you for sharing your views. Some additions or supplements to the points you shared:
1. You are a discerning parent and your kids will succeed wherever they go. By accepting a fee-paying school, you are freeing up a valuable primary school place to someone else whose needs are greater than your kid. You are in fact creating more happiness in the world.
I am not sure whether releasing an aided place will create more happiness than releasing a fee-paying place. I cannot measure the happiness of a middle-class family vs a modest family for fee-paying place and an aided place, respectively, released by me.
2. KYS is whole day, whereas WY is half-day. A big difference to me because I want my kids to enjoy a full-day experience.
Noted and understood.
3. KYS is co-educational, where WY is single sex. I think boys like girls, and at the age of 5, I'd choose a co-educational primary school for my son.
Noted and understood.
4. Teachers tend to be exhausted for teaching morning and afternoon classes in aided schools. Fee-paying schools tend to pay their teachers better, who in turn tend to have more energy to give more attention to your kids.
Based on my knowledge, WY's morning class teachers and afternoon class teachers are different , so the issue of tiredness for teaching all day does not exist. The principal and vice-principal do have to attend to both sessions.
5. The fact that even as an old boy, you have hesitation about WY (and your friends all send their kids elsewhere) speaks for itself. Hong Kong's education is in a mess. You pay and you may have a greater say - because if you don't like the fee-paying school later on, you can always change or move or migrate.
I should have mentioned that the brother of my friend (both are alumni of WY) sent his son to WY as well, though he had his son and himself baptised earlier to earn a secured place, meaning he was determined to go to WY. I have concerns for WY as much as for KY as well, though on different issues.
6. I assume your son likes KYS, and his personalities fit into the philosophy of that school.
He likes KY because of his personal experience on the interview day, and he also likes WY because of my description and the fact that I graduated there (i.e. he has a "finished product" to observe).
作者: DrBabyAlex 時間: 10-11-24 15:26
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 4eyesDad 時間: 10-11-24 15:42
To ykha:
I see you have your own thinking on all my points.
Point 1 is a difficult one to consider. You have no obligation to consider the happiness of the world at all in relation to your choice of a primary school for your son.
However, logically, it is not impossible to measure the happiness between two families.
The reason why I think freeing a place in an aided school will create more happiness in the world is that those who need (and hence have no other choice, due to financial constraint, ignorance, or location, etc.) to go to an aided school have only one hope. By comparison, those who can choose (or can afford to choose among different types of schools) have more than one hope.
So the former group will be happier if their one hope be fulfilled.
作者: mow-mow 時間: 10-11-24 15:53
ykha,
Why don't you bring your son to attend a church service in Wah Yan on a Sunday?
You might even be able to talk to some current students / parents as well.
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-24 15:54
Thank you for your feedback. I really cherish your sharing (and comments of all people who have responded to this topic in detail). I take all the comments seriously and try to consider them thoroughly.
It is a difficult comparison. That's why I invited parents who have children studying in those schools or know people whose children are studying there to share their experience. We are somewhat aware of the styles of the schools, but I want to get more information to ascertain the "details" so that I can put proper weights to my concerns and make a more sensible decision.原帖由 4eyesDad 於 10-11-24 15:42 發表
To ykha:
I see you have your own thinking on all my points.
Point 1 is a difficult one to consider. You have no obligation to consider the happiness of the world at all in relation to your choice of a ...
作者: ykha 時間: 10-11-24 15:58
I don't belong to any religion...I feel odd to attend a church service just to talk to others and extract info from them...原帖由 mow-mow 於 10-11-24 15:53 發表
ykha,
Why don't you bring your son to attend a church service in Wah Yan on a Sunday?
You might even be able to talk to some current students / parents as well.
作者: thomasha 時間: 10-11-24 16:24
我咁o岩都係要揀呢兩間，好彩你開個主題先，我就可以揩o下油水。
大部分BK外的朋友都建議我地揀華仁，因為佢有名氣，有直屬中學 (不過直升比率只有六成左右)，校風又唔錯，不過亦有幾位基督徒家長就極力推薦救恩，話佢校風好，教得活，不過升中
往績就只係一般。
我都係等到聽日先至最後決定，希望你決定後上黎講聲，等o個d等緊你放棄個位o既家長開心o下。
作者: markBB 時間: 10-11-24 18:43
Perhaps the world really changed, i never expect parents will compare WY with 救恩, honeslty Ieven don't know where is this school.
I agree that WY may not be able to produce the best students, but at least it has a good tradition and students there in general are more "pure" than its competitor schools nearby.
One disavantage I warned my wife and my friends about WY is its relatively weak English standard, lots of the graduates have difficulties in this area when they move up to WYCHK.
作者: diversity 時間: 10-11-25 00:31
原帖由 thomasha 於 10-11-24 16:24 發表
我咁o岩都係要揀呢兩間，好彩你開個主題先，我就可以揩o下油水。
大部分BK外的朋友都建議我地揀華仁，因為佢有名氣，有直屬中學 (不過直升比率只有六成左右)，校風又唔錯，不過亦有幾位基督徒家長就極力推薦救恩，話佢校風好，教得 ...
bet you will choose WY at last!!
作者: thomasha 時間: 10-11-25 00:35
Any opinion?原帖由 diversity 於 10-11-25 00:31 發表
bet you will choose WY at last!!
作者: milkonline2 時間: 10-11-25 00:40
duplicated
[ 本帖最後由 milkonline2 於 10-11-25 00:50 編輯 ]
作者: milkonline2 時間: 10-11-25 00:44
duplicated
[ 本帖最後由 milkonline2 於 10-11-25 00:50 編輯 ]
作者: milkonline2 時間: 10-11-25 00:46
duplicated
[ 本帖最後由 milkonline2 於 10-11-25 00:50 編輯 ]
作者: milkonline2 時間: 10-11-25 00:47
Thomas, you should choose WY in order to suit HK educational system. OTherwise, you will suffer again after 6 years. Just personal feeling!
作者: panbaby 時間: 10-11-25 00:55
救恩現在真的咁好? 以前真的好少見用港華同佢比較, 今天竟然可以一較高下? 我真的很有興趣知道.
我就會選港華了. 俗語說 : 瘦死的駱駝比馬大. 港華再不濟亦是男名校, 質素即使與以前不同只要你肯去讀, 軟件仍在, 想讀好書不難. 而且最最重要的是佢有名氣, 升中做人都有著數, 而且又有中學又免費...名校是細佬一生的cv 之一呀! 第時有人問你, 你讀邊間學校？ 答:港華 都大聲啲呀。
三思呀.
作者: milkonline2 時間: 10-11-25 01:00
有人問你, 你讀邊間學校？ 答:港"大" 都大聲啲呀........... 
原帖由 panbaby 於 10-11-25 12:55 AM 發表
救恩現在真的咁好? 以前真的好少見用港華同佢比較, 今天竟然可以一較高下? 我真的很有興趣知道.
我就會選港華了. 俗語說 : 瘦死的駱駝比馬大. 港華再不濟亦是男名校, 質素即使與以前不同只要你肯去讀, 軟件仍在 ...
作者: markBB 時間: 10-11-25 01:27
if 救恩 is your choice, why not just stay at Victoria primary school at Sham Wan.
作者: thomasha 時間: 10-11-25 08:15
I have no offer from Victoria. :(
Do you think the style of VSA and Kau Yan are similar? I believe character development is much better in Kau Yan than VSA.原帖由 markBB 於 10-11-25 01:27 發表
if 救恩 is your choice, why not just stay at Victoria primary school at Sham Wan.
[ 本帖最後由 thomasha 於 10-11-25 08:18 編輯 ]
作者: 輝輝的媽媽 時間: 10-11-25 08:36
I am a Wah Yan mum, my wahyanite is enjoying his school very much. The school though is consider to be a traditional school, uses a lot of encouragement methods to help the children to grow and work hard.
The school treat us parents as part of the school, we are free to visit our children and attend their assemblies, you can feel that you are growing hand in hand with your children.
The father, headmaster and teachers are all very caring to the children. The old father ( I think more than 70 years old) even come down to play football with the children during recess time.
Of course you can't compare the campus with a Y2k campus, but it is small and cosy, the children can't tell the difference, they enjoy and make good use of every space in the school.
作者: backtohome2005 時間: 10-11-25 08:50
原帖由 Gogojuly 於 10-11-24 01:31 發表
KYS是基督教小學.
佢地會有些慈善活動希望小朋友及家長参與.如買奬券,耆老餅,現今進行的"善普施聖誔禮物行動"就會將籌集的禮物盒送往經歷過天災的四川及青海.
我不是教徒,但覺得這些活動好有教育意義.且全是自願 ...
絕對同意ＫＹＳ是一間好學校。我個仔是Ｋ１插班生，佢本來是在一間出名幼稚園就讀ＰＮ，因搬家關係，Ｋ１轉到同幼稚園的分校，但兩間學校給我的感覺很不一樣｟可能是地區不同｠，校內由校長、部份家長、ＳＴＡＦＦ、、、、給我的印象是階級觀念重、提倡競爭、比較、，總括來說似辦公室政治那般，其後仔仔轉到ＫＹＳ讀，由面試那天我巳經感覺到他們的愛心、對小朋友的關愛、對教育的熱誠、，絕對沒有上述的辦公室政治ＦＥＥＬ。
至於小一選校，我只報了一間直資，其實是針對現實問題：一條龍，加上傳統或活動教學的取捨，在這兩開學校的ＯＦＦＥＲ中，我選擇了直資，坦白而言，一條龍給予的保障是很實在的；加上仔仔不是太適合活動教學，而我自問亦沒有太大信心可以引導他作活動教學【本人認為活動教學更需要家長的引導及監察】。所以華仁及救恩兩者的考慮是一條龍及教學方法。
作者: markBB 時間: 10-11-25 09:32
Oh sorry i thought most kids in Victoria got offer from VSA. my wife loves VSA since she is a fan of facilities. i agree that the campus of WY is ugly, but I do like old stuff and this is why i am against the development of the new hall at WYCHK. anyway dont go too far. I do feel the care and creativities from VSA, so it's one of our top pick outside traditional schools. but too bad I am too bias to WY so didnt really think about other alternatives.
原帖由 thomasha 於 10-11-25 08:15 發表
I have no offer from Victoria. :(
Do you think the style of VSA and Kau Yan are similar? I believe character development is much better in Kau Yan than VSA.
作者: Student123 時間: 10-11-25 10:11
How about
浸大附屬XX, 嶺大同學....,港大同學,皇仁舊生xx
英皇舊生...
:loveliness: :loveliness: :loveliness: ?
Misleading:( :( :(
原帖由 milkonline2 於 10-11-25 01:00 發表
有人問你, 你讀邊間學校？ 答:港"大" 都大聲啲呀...........
作者: Student123 時間: 10-11-25 10:17
I don't know much about KY, but I know that WY's students' moral/ ethical standard is high.:D :D
原帖由 輝輝的媽媽 於 10-11-25 08:36 發表
I am a Wah Yan mum, my wahyanite is enjoying his school very much. The school though is consider to be a traditional school, uses a lot of encouragement methods to help the children to grow and work h ...
作者: Gogojuly 時間: 10-11-25 13:45
原帖由 carolchanym 於 10-11-24 11:23 發表
非常同意你的說法.
我囝現正就讀小一, 剛準備好一些禮物以響應"善普施聖誕禮物行動", 讓他能關愛別人, 明白"施比受有福"的道理及珍惜自己所有的...
亦有"食物銀行"可自由損出食物給有需要的小朋友, 今早他才帶了些"面食"回去呢...
昨天才完成了"赤腳行動", 讓他們親自感受冇鞋著的滋味, 我囝話個地下好硬同好凍喎...
這的確是一所非常有愛心的活動教學學校, 不能與傳統教學的比較, 因橙不同香蕉嘛...
但我對他們的校車服務就非常不滿...
請問小學部和幼稚園部的校車是不一樣的嗎?
我個小朋友曾坐過幼稚園的校車,非常之好喎.司機叔叔及跟車保姆都好好.
今年就不知道校車的安排如何了
作者: motherotk 時間: 10-11-25 15:55
Wah Yan is good!!
Especially the secondary school, both on HK and Kowloon side are good schools!!
Not related to religion as Wah Yan, though a Catholic schools, very open and encourage independent thinking ... I have lots of friends from Wah Yan, really good schools!!
My boy aim at Kowloon Wah Yan...secondary school!
原帖由 thomasha 於 10-11-24 16:24 發表
我咁o岩都係要揀呢兩間，好彩你開個主題先，我就可以揩o下油水。
大部分BK外的朋友都建議我地揀華仁，因為佢有名氣，有直屬中學 (不過直升比率只有六成左右)，校風又唔錯，不過亦有幾位基督徒家長就極力推薦救恩，話佢校風好，教得 ...
作者: preciousstone 時間: 10-11-26 00:29
其實兩間都是好學校, 如果錢不是一個考慮, 還是選一間近屋企的吧. 小朋友會無O禁辛苦. 我相信你囝囝無論最後讀哪間學校, 都不會後悔的.
你最後選哪一間呢?
作者: 麟媽媽 時間: 10-11-26 00:42
由你口述都足夠架喇，
因為華小跟30年前環境無咩大變(我老公話)，
金魚缸仍叫金魚缸，你明我講邊度架喇？！
操場亦同以前一樣，有好多個龍門架，
而且小一旅行仍然係去灣仔峽公園，
40年不變，有無鈎起你既童年回憶？
我個仔係華小度過左六個年頭，
你問我華小如何，我好滿意！
好多人話華仁成績今非昔比，
呢樣我唔否認，但係咪真係好差呢？
又未必，當中好多成績好到過大塘架。
如果你讀一間無直屬中學既小學，
最終小六升中又一樣想考華中，
咁就當然入華小佔優，有直屬額嘛。
華仁仔既德行素質，依舊保持，
呢樣好緊要，我個人非常重視。
我仔剛升上中一，讀得非常開心，
仲成日同佢老豆係星期六返學校打波，
你係舊生，得閒返去行下，
同d 師弟傾下計，你自然心中有數，
好過係度問家長，不如去問下用家啦。
原帖由 ykha 於 10-11-24 09:22 發表
Thank you for your understanding and sharing.
The case is a little more difficult for me because WY does not let us tour around any part of the campus. My son could only have my verbal description ( ...
作者: thomasha 時間: 10-11-26 03:16
我都係舊生，當年o既回憶仲好清楚，金魚缸我都有幫手打理；操場，禮堂等等仍然好記得。諗唔到佢地小一旅行仍然堅持去灣仔峽公園(我地當年係1-3年級都係去o個度)，唔知四年級係唔係仲係去石澳呢？
華小好似唔開放俾其他人入去 (最近兩次去都係限去小食部隔離個活動室搞手續)，華中就開放好多，假期幾乎係自由出入。
各位看官，唔好意思，我o既童年回憶可能會悶親大家。原帖由 麟媽媽 於 10-11-26 00:42 發表
由你口述都足夠架喇，
因為華小跟30年前環境無咩大變(我老公話)，
金魚缸仍叫金魚缸，你明我講邊度架喇？！
操場亦同以前一樣，有好多個龍門架，
而且小一旅行仍然係去灣仔峽公園，
40年不變，有無鈎起你既童年回憶？
我個仔係 ...
作者: ferrynferry 時間: 10-11-26 12:08
YKHA 同 thomas
你地最後決定左邊間??
作者: thomasha 時間: 10-11-26 12:13
我揀左華仁，自行報華仁o既家長，對唔住喇，希望遲d有其他學校取錄小兒，先至有權放返個位出黎喇。
至於救恩備取生o既家長，希望你地其中一人受惠。原帖由 ferrynferry 於 10-11-26 12:08 發表
YKHA 同 thomas
你地最後決定左邊間??
作者: PoorParent 時間: 10-11-26 12:20
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: appleycma 時間: 10-11-26 12:56
100% Wah Yan.
作者: brian61950 時間: 10-11-26 13:01
差d就作出歷史性的創舉....
作者: megabee 時間: 10-11-26 19:08
Thomasha,
I really thought you wil opt for KY! Me too decided to go for a traditional school instead of a DSS with new teaching approach.
A very difficult choice indeed. Hope we all are right!
Megabee
原帖由 thomasha 於 10-11-26 03:16 發表
我都係舊生，當年o既回憶仲好清楚，金魚缸我都有幫手打理；操場，禮堂等等仍然好記得。諗唔到佢地小一旅行仍然堅持去灣仔峽公園(我地當年係1-3年級都係去o個度)，唔知四年級係唔係仲係去石澳呢？
華小好似唔開放俾其他人入去 ( ...
作者: wootaitai 時間: 10-11-27 00:01
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: ferrynferry 時間: 10-11-27 13:13
原帖由 thomasha 於 10-11-26 12:13 發表
我揀左華仁，自行報華仁o既家長，對唔住喇，希望遲d有其他學校取錄小兒，先至有權放返個位出黎喇。
至於救恩備取生o既家長，希望你地其中一人受惠。 ...
我係你都會去華仁~
我個囝無舊生老豆~
作者: thomasha 時間: 10-11-27 17:22
其實係一個幾難o既決定，我地呢代人，上承傳統教育，過去算是行得通的，不過漸被批抨為不合時宜，而華仁的確在學業方面o既表現不復當年勇，係不爭o既事實；下啟活動教學，可以令學習過程更開心，更能促進思維；夾在兩者中間，要在 "舊派" (有往績支持) 和 "新派" (好多專家話好) 之間去揀。
雖然我個仔叫做谷得，但我唔係好想谷佢，因為好容易破壞佢而家對學習o既興趣同渴求，而且佢比較文靜，我地想佢開朗d，呢樣對佢o既成長更重要。講真，如果救恩有一條龍中學，我地o既決定可能好唔同。
作者: wlmom 時間: 10-12-14 12:10
The world has really changed. I also never expect one would compare WY with 救恩 (honestly i haven't heard much of this school before).
I believe WY may not be the best school academically, but it's still amongst the top tier schools.
作者: thomasha 時間: 10-12-14 12:39
This topic is already out-dated. Even WY has been given up for another school already. :)原帖由 wlmom 於 10-12-14 12:10 發表
The world has really changed. I also never expect one would compare WY with 救恩 (honestly i haven't heard much of this school before).
I believe WY may not be the best school academically, but it's ...
作者: lugano 時間: 10-12-14 13:07
Go for Wah Yan for sure
I don't know much about Wah Yan primary but WYCHK and WYK are definitely top tier schools
作者: yatyatbb 時間: 11-7-16 21:51
原帖由 thomasha 於 10-12-14 12:39 發表
This topic is already out-dated. Even WY has been given up for another school already. :)
從無諗過救恩可以同華仁相提並論, 請問樓主同thomasha最終揀咗邊間?
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |