教育王國

標題: st. joseph's 定spcc? [打印本頁]

作者: cutekiddy 時間: 10-11-16 13:43 標題: st. joseph's 定spcc?

朋友個仔有25分入梗st. joseph's,但係佢spcc有2nd in,當時校長不經意同小朋友講咗句"開學見!",應該都入梗!

佢問我意見点簡,大家点睇?

作者: CaCaDad 時間: 10-11-16 13:44

I vote for St. Joe!

作者: artroboy 時間: 10-11-16 13:46

SPCC

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 10-11-16 13:43 發表
朋友個仔有25分入梗st. joseph's,但係佢spcc有2nd in,當時校長不經意同小朋友講咗句"開學見!",應該都入梗!

佢問我意見点簡,大家点睇?

作者: diversity 時間: 10-11-16 13:50

I will choose SPCC

作者: brian61950 時間: 10-11-16 13:54

如是公務員或好有錢我都會揀SPCC,如都不是St. Joe好了,幾千銀唔係比唔起,但儲起比佢將來出國讀書仲好.

作者: nicolemummy 時間: 10-11-16 14:00

spcc校長鐘意佢, 當然係spcc. 點知第二時st joe校長鐘唔鐘意佢.

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 10-11-16 13:43 發表
朋友個仔有25分入梗st. joseph's,但係佢spcc有2nd in,當時校長不經意同小朋友講咗句"開學見!",應該都入梗!

佢問我意見点簡,大家点睇?

作者: hui916 時間: 10-11-16 14:03

St. Jopseph勝在津校, 唔駛交學費. 但中學及小學並非一條龍, 應該只能數番7成左右的St. Joseph小學學生.

SPCC基本上可以收番全部直屬小學學生.

如果經濟條件許可, 當然揀SPCC啦, 始終學生有揀過及未揀過分別相當大. 同輩影響相當大, 起碼可以避開一些有問題的家庭及學生.

作者: jellycheng 時間: 10-11-16 14:07

SPCC - no doubt.

作者: cutekiddy 時間: 10-11-16 14:09

$$應該唔係問題.我朋友幾年前原本住3千幾呎豪宅,當時市值都4,5千萬,但係為咗唔想個仔大大吓覺得mud嘢都好似係理所當然有,竟然搬去8佰幾呎嘅單位.

佢個仔依家都好謙遜,幾歲人仔都唔會浪費,有時同佢行街想買份gift比佢 e.g.一支筆仔,佢都會話屋企有啦,唔好浪費!

原帖由 brian61950 於 10-11-16 13:54 發表
如是公務員或好有錢我都會揀SPCC,如都不是St. Joe好了,幾千銀唔係比唔起,但儲起比佢將來出國讀書仲好.

作者: Charlotte_mom 時間: 10-11-16 14:18

李校長最鐘意呢D謙謙有禮既小朋友
我都會揀SPCC, 教出黎D學生又叻又謙虛, 一流

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 10-11-16 02:09 PM 發表
$$應該唔係問題.我朋友幾年前原本住3千幾呎豪宅,當時市值都4,5千萬,但係為咗唔想個仔大大吓覺得mud嘢都好似係理所當然有,竟然搬去8佰幾呎嘅單位.

佢個仔依家都好謙遜,幾歲人仔都唔會浪費,有時同佢行街想買份gift比 ...

作者: uarecheap 時間: 10-11-16 14:20

同你朋友講25分唔係入硬，大把人有這個分數。

作者: uarecheap 時間: 10-11-16 14:21

同你朋友講25分唔係入硬，大把人有這個分數。

作者: hophopbunny 時間: 10-11-16 14:22

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: uarecheap 時間: 10-11-16 14:28

我識STJOS幼稚園家長全部都25分。

作者: bbAvalon 時間: 10-11-16 14:43

Do you mean that they also failed to get into st. Joseph in 1st round despite they have 25 pts?

原帖由 uarecheap 於 10-11-16 14:28 發表
我識STJOS幼稚園家長全部都25分。

作者: 仔仔錫錫你 時間: 10-11-16 14:46

SPCC 個名享d, 環境好d; 但單講成績, St joe 好d. 我問過老公, dbs / spcc / st joe / yw, 佢首選 st joe.

作者: artroboy 時間: 10-11-16 14:51

你個甲由仔搞到我成日以為個 mon 上面有蟲....

原帖由 uarecheap 於 10-11-16 14:20 發表
同你朋友講25分唔係入硬，大把人有這個分數。

作者: ahpaahmi 時間: 10-11-16 14:55

SPCC

SPCC男女校
st. joe 男校

為了個人日後成長發展，緊係揀男女校啦！

BTW, 你朋友個仔是否 st. joe kinder 學生？大/細仔？

好叻仔呀！真係恨死人啦！

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 10-11-16 13:43 發表
朋友個仔有25分入梗st. joseph's,但係佢spcc有2nd in,當時校長不經意同小朋友講咗句"開學見!",應該都入梗!

佢問我意見点簡,大家点睇?

作者: eatcookies 時間: 10-11-16 15:04

樓主朋友呢個選擇真係“恨死隔離”，謎埋眼是但要一個都唔會錯得去邊架啦。。恭喜！

PS: 如果比我揀，我揀SJC

作者: hui916 時間: 10-11-16 15:09 標題: 回覆 3# 仔仔錫錫你的文章

但以成績平均水平而言. St. Josph絕對不會比SPCC好. 無錯St. Joe今年出咗4個10A. 但不要只看10A, 要看整体平均水平.

以2010會考成績參考: 總共157個考生, SPCC 平均每個學生考取2.4個A , 6A以上的人數33人, 考獲14分以上佔92%.

不知你是否有St. Joe的統計數據作比較.

作者: uarecheap 時間: 10-11-16 15:12

她們是今年STJOS幼稚園家長，自行得3O個位，如她們25分都唔中，都可比叩門但只限STJOS幼生。

作者: uarecheap 時間: 10-11-16 15:39

25分家長是今年等22号，真的很多25分得30個位。如她們失敗都可以叩門，因只限SJ幼稚園生。街外人勉問。

作者: ysnmama 時間: 10-11-16 16:13

25分是舊生加宗教. 你認識的大慨有多少是25分? 我有朋友20分, 她已打了輸數.

原帖由 uarecheap 於 10-11-16 15:39 發表
25分家長是今年等22号，真的很多25分得30個位。如她們失敗都可以叩門，因只限SJ幼稚園生。街外人勉問。

作者: uarecheap 時間: 10-11-16 16:22

在學校應最少3x個，全級K3有78個，1x個哥哥細路関係，3x個天主教。25分校內都吾夠分,都未計校外人。

作者: ysnmama 時間: 10-11-16 16:27

有哥哥正讀是必收. 不計在自行的30個位. 另若3X個是天主教. 如單是天主教而不是舊生是20分. 25分是天主教加爸爸是舊生. 不知我有否理解錯?

我朋友兒子是天主教徙. 而兒子爸爸不是舊生. 所以20分.

原帖由 uarecheap 於 10-11-16 16:22 發表
在學校應最少3x個，全級K3有78個，1x個哥哥細路関係，3x個天主教。25分校內都吾夠分,都未計校外人。

[ 本帖最後由 ysnmama 於 10-11-16 16:28 編輯 ]

作者: bbAvalon 時間: 10-11-16 16:29

3x天主教 <=== all parents also old boy?

原帖由 uarecheap 於 10-11-16 16:22 發表
在學校應最少3x個，全級K3有78個，1x個哥哥細路関係，3x個天主教。25分校內都吾夠分,都未計校外人。

作者: hophopbunny 時間: 10-11-16 16:31

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ysnmama 時間: 10-11-16 16:31

兩校要選. 除卻學費. 聖保羅男女由校舍開始. 也比聖若瑟優.

作者: hophopbunny 時間: 10-11-16 16:35

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: cutekiddy 時間: 10-11-16 17:04

你講得啱!只有爸爸係old boy + 天主教先可以有25分.小朋友就算讀緊st. jo kinder 係無分加嘅.

所以之前uarecheap所講嗰3x個小朋友,要睇埋爸爸係唔係old boy 先至知有無25分.

根據之前record,25分基本上係間間都係必入,仲未聽過有人衰咗.

原帖由 ysnmama 於 10-11-16 16:27 發表
有哥哥正讀是必收. 不計在自行的30個位. 另若3X個是天主教. 如單是天主教而不是舊生是20分. 25分是天主教加爸爸是舊生. 不知我有否理解錯? 我朋友兒子是天主教徙. 而兒子爸爸不是舊生. 所以20分.

...

作者: traeh 時間: 10-11-16 17:06

你自己有乜想法？

原帖由 hophopbunny 於 10-11-16 16:35 發表
借個位-有冇人可以比d意見我講重讀嘅case?

作者: cutekiddy 時間: 10-11-16 17:08

開個新topic,會多啲人aware同答你!

原帖由 hophopbunny 於 10-11-16 16:35 發表
借個位-有冇人可以比d意見我講重讀嘅case?

作者: phpyma 時間: 10-11-16 17:10

想請問各位, 在大抽獎一環節裏, 理論上是不計分的, 但會否有暗盤而學校把學位留給高分的人抽呢? 若果我只有 15分, 是不不應浪費 quota 填報呢? 還是在大抽獎一環節中, 25 分與 15分被抽中的機會均等, 只靠彩數? Thanks.

作者: cutekiddy 時間: 10-11-16 17:18

機會應該係一樣.我個仔上年都係15分,係大抽獎先入到.

原帖由 phpyma 於 10-11-16 17:10 發表
想請問各位, 在大抽獎一環節裏, 理論上是不計分的, 但會否有暗盤而學校把學位留給高分的人抽呢? 若果我只有 15分, 是不不應浪費 quota 填報呢? 還是在大抽獎一環節中, 25 分與 15分被抽中的機會均等, 只靠彩數? Than ...

作者: ysnmama 時間: 10-11-16 17:34

是. 很多人有20分(因為宗教關係)就不足為奇.

如果爸爸是舊生再加天主教也不夠分第一輪. 真的比較少有. 因為就是最受歡迎的學校, 年年20分的也有人中.只差多與少. 那麼25分便全收才可到20分. 你朋友兒子有25分. 真的非常穩當. 我朋友兒子20分, 只可等運到.

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 10-11-16 17:04 發表
你講得啱!只有爸爸係old boy + 天主教先可以有25分.小朋友就算讀緊st. jo kinder 係無分加嘅.

所以之前uarecheap所講嗰3x個小朋友,要睇埋爸爸係唔係old boy 先至知有無25分.

根據之前record,25分基本上係間間都係 ...

作者: bbAvalon 時間: 10-11-16 17:40

uarecheap, can you advise?

原帖由 hophopbunny 於 10-11-16 16:31 發表
哥哥細佬嗰d係必收生,唔計在30個內

另外3x 天主教有幾多舊生先

作者: hophopbunny 時間: 10-11-16 17:50

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: ysnmama 時間: 10-11-16 17:54

是呀. 不少第一輪填了聖若瑟的也想你確實. 因為如果你所說的25分跟正常的計分是有出入. 並不是爸爸是舊生加天主教. 而只是宗教20分. 那麼其他以20分抽的家長, 仍有希望的. 以免人心惶惶.

原帖由 bbAvalon 於 10-11-16 17:40 發表
uarecheap, can you advise?

作者: YoungKY 時間: 10-11-16 22:10

I won't let my kids repeat 1 more year..time is the most valuable thing. If your kid is good, s/he could doing well anywhere. Too risky to let your kid repeat!!!!

原帖由 hophopbunny 於 10-11-16 17:50 發表

當初當然佷心儀spccps，舊年又入唔到才再去報。但而家讀了小一又跟得上, 有些懷疑係唔係值得多花一年時間

作者: hophopbunny 時間: 10-11-16 23:12

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Loso 時間: 10-11-17 08:44

St. Joe 啦! 唔駛錢，又係好學校!

作者: tszfungmama 時間: 10-11-17 09:12

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: arcadia 時間: 10-11-17 09:13 標題: 回覆 2# hophopbunny 的文章

都係一年啫，咁無論將來有冇細佬妹，或將來佢生嘅仔或女，都係related, 比其他人多機會讀這學校，更不用說他所接受的優質一條龍教學，做大仔所訓練到的領導才能，如果收嘅話，唔使唸啦！

作者: Loso 時間: 10-11-17 10:56

我都係覺得揀St. Joe 化算D，一嚟都係好學校，二嚟慳返學費，可以更加善用資源，簡單計由小一至中六慳返72萬！三嚟直覺覺得St. Joe環境單純D，Spcc 家長群背景咁勁，對我呢D平民百姓嚟講太複雜囉，況且近幾年St. Joe 出唔少狀元，成績好好呢！

作者: fundfund 時間: 10-11-17 14:23

一定SPCC, 以收番全部直屬小學

學生, 中學唔駛煩多次

作者: fundfund 時間: 10-11-17 14:32

St. Joe環境, 家長背景比較複雜, 始終派入去, 乜人都有。 SPCC 無論家長背景, 小朋友程度, 升中派位比較有保証, 至於學校環境, St. Joe 真係無得比, 因為St. Joe 真係太細

作者: hsbmama 時間: 10-11-17 15:13

St Jo has 75 places for discretionary allocation which is 50% of 150 places, the other 50% (75 places) is for central allocation.

First round discretionary allocation: (a) 30% of 150 (=45) is for kids with sibling or parents working at the school. If they have more than 30% than they will take places from central allocation to provide places for these kids (then there will be less than 50% for the central allocation). If they have less than 30% then they will give these places for counting points. (b) 20% of the places (= 30) are for point system, most first born will have 15pts, +5 for old boys/girls, +5 for church members.

SO...
1) Can they fill up all the 45 places for siblings & parents at the same school?? I would think so, but that's my guess.
2) How many are old boys and same church = 25pts (not counting siblings and parents at the school)??
3) If there are less than 30 applicants with 25 pts, then the 20 pts ones will have a chance... if there are more than 30 applicants with 25pts (then there won't be room for 20 pts applicants) and they have to do a lucky draw within the 25pts applicants.

ps. I have heard that someone with 25 pts cannot get into DPS... so, 25 pts is not a sure win. But of course for DPS, there are less places for allocation and it is a coed school now, therefore it's situation might not reflect the other bigger schools.

原帖由 uarecheap 於 10-11-16 16:22 發表
在學校應最少3x個，全級K3有78個，1x個哥哥細路関係，3x個天主教。25分校內都吾夠分,都未計校外人。

[ 本帖最後由 hsbmama 於 10-11-17 15:33 編輯 ]

作者: kochiman2004 時間: 10-11-17 15:52

... surely 100% SPCC ... just like Rolex c.f. Sekio ... different classes and levels wor ... don't give up SPCC ... (although I also want you to give up SPCC to free up one more SPCC seat to us) ... really ... don't give up SPCC ..

作者: oknsca 時間: 10-11-17 19:54

SPCC for sure!

作者: 好一個爸爸 時間: 10-11-17 20:15

你朋友個仔好叻。

我個仔都 1st int 咗成個幾鐘, 校長仲問佢喜唔喜歡間學校, 點知 2nd int o既機會都無

作者: sheep30 時間: 10-11-17 22:14

I will choose St. Joe. I don't think everyone should wear or like Rolex when Seiko is already good enough.

I really like St. Joe！

原帖由 kochiman2004 於 10-11-17 15:52 發表
... surely 100% SPCC ... just like Rolex c.f. Sekio ... different classes and levels wor ... don't give up SPCC ... (although I also want you to give up SPCC to free up one more SPCC seat to us) ... r ...

作者: ChuLuLu 時間: 10-11-17 22:20

原帖由 sheep30 於 10-11-17 22:14 發表
I will choose St. Joe. I don't think everyone should wear or like Rolex when Seiko is already good enough.

I really like St. Joe！

Chanel vs. LV may be a more appropriate comparison!!

. Anyway, beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

作者: ANChan59 時間: 10-11-18 01:32

Average academic results must be SPCC.

Great school and also through-train. nearly 100% promote to secondary school.

Add up 12 years school fee may only afford to send our kids to study overseas university for one year in the future. Also, SPCC has the most generous remission scheme, many students get remission and scholarship.

作者: PMma 時間: 10-11-19 01:22

I think if this boy got 25 points in SJPS, his father must be a St. Joe old boy and this family is catholic. There is no doubt that the boy and his family fit better with SJPS.

Meanwhile, St. Joe's old boys are very loyal to their alma mater. If the father can decide the choice, there is almost no doubt that he will choose SJPS for his son. But of course, the mother may have different preferences.

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 10-11-16 13:43 發表
朋友個仔有25分入梗st. joseph's,但係佢spcc有2nd in,當時校長不經意同小朋友講咗句"開學見!",應該都入梗!

佢問我意見点簡,大家点睇?

作者: cutekiddy 時間: 10-11-19 13:29

You are right! That's why the kid's mother asked for my opinion about this.

原帖由 PMma 於 10-11-19 01:22 發表
I think if this boy got 25 points in SJPS, his father must be a St. Joe old boy and this family is catholic. There is no doubt that the boy and his family fit better with SJPS.

Meanwhile, St. Joe' ...

作者: PMma 時間: 10-11-19 15:37

It's because I was once that kind of mom....... Now, my son is another St. Joe boy following his father, uncles and grandfather.

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 10-11-19 13:29 發表
You are right! That's why the kid's mother asked for my opinion about this.

作者: cutekiddy 時間: 10-11-19 16:09

wow... you gave up SPCC before and I believe it was really a difficult decision.

作者: PMma 時間: 10-11-19 17:58

No!! My son didn't even have the chance to have second interview with SPCC. We had the pleasure of having headmistress Lee interviewing my son in the first interview. But according to my son, he strictly said "NO" to Headmistress Lee when he was asked whether he likes this school (SPCC) and wants to study here .......

In my previous messages written, I was just saying that I was also once being a mom with catholic background, whose husband is an SJ old boy, and having a son applying P1.

I personally have no preference towards either of these two schools. I myself (and my sibilings too) didn't graduate from any prestigious primary schools; but we could achieve very high education and master in our own professions. On the contrary, I can see many of the graduates of these prestigious schools are just ordinary people in the society after grown up.

Being admitted to any prestigious famous schools or not means little in the long path of life!

原帖由 cutekiddy 於 10-11-19 16:09 發表
wow... you gave up SPCC before and I believe it was really a difficult decision.

作者: childrenfirst 時間: 10-11-19 18:15

Not a good metaphor at all, I know some people they simply don't like Rolex at all although they can afford to have one or several. Who cares LV or Rolex..

quote]原帖由 kochiman2004 於 10-11-17 15:52 發表

... surely 100% SPCC ... just like Rolex c.f. Sekio ... different classes and levels wor ... don't give up SPCC ... (although I also want you to give up SPCC to free up one more SPCC seat to us) ... r ... [/quote]

作者: sheep30 時間: 10-11-19 23:40

It's true. My husband is an old boy from SJC. He 100% wants his son to be graduated from St Joe too.

原帖由 PMma 於 10-11-19 01:22 發表
I think if this boy got 25 points in SJPS, his father must be a St. Joe old boy and this family is catholic. There is no doubt that the boy and his family fit better with SJPS.

Meanwhile, St. Joe' ...

作者: SCKnight 時間: 10-11-20 01:05

I like St Joe too.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)