教育王國

標題: 德望 , ST Clare's , 聖心你地會點揀呢？ [打印本頁]

作者: sin_928 時間: 10-7-16 09:31 標題: 德望 , ST Clare's , 聖心你地會點揀呢？

德望 , ST Clare's , 聖心你地會點揀呢？

st clare's am~ guarantee P1 seat, english primary, KG has 學卷, campus 一般

scarted heart am~ guarantee P1 seat in their am primary, KG has 學卷 and primary is the cheapest between these three schools and gd result in their P6 and have gd secondary as a backup, campus 可以

GH am~ finally got a message at this moment telling that not guarantee P1 seat, new re-open KG, no 學卷 and expensive school fees in the future
, campus 超靚

請問大家會點排點揀？

作者: wootaitai 時間: 10-7-16 09:58

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: spmok1999 時間: 10-7-16 10:22

同意

作者: easybring 時間: 10-7-16 10:31

I vote for SH> GH> St Clare <-- same

原帖由 wootaitai 於 10-7-16 09:58 發表
I vote for SH> GH> St Clare

I think its not difficult to get a seat in St Clare even if you dont attend its kindergarten

作者: sin_928 時間: 10-7-16 11:03

may i know why SH is over GH, please?

作者: jezzyuen 時間: 10-7-16 12:56

請問你地住邊區？3間都好，而且係咪都收哂上午？如果近近地，放學返黎仲可以學興趣班添，已7月中喇，媽媽決定啦！其實出呢個post，媽媽係咪已經排左名？德望＞聖嘉勒＞聖心？

原帖由 sin_928 於 10-7-16 11:03 發表
may i know why SH is over GH, please?

作者: wootaitai 時間: 10-7-16 13:41

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: princess_sumyin 時間: 10-7-16 15:07 標題: 回覆 1# sin_928 的文章

May I know how you got a message that GH kinder not guarantee P1 seat

作者: sin_928 時間: 10-7-17 11:41

~we live in kln side at the moment, but we are going to move to Hk Island if we pick SH,

~yes, luckily all am class

~no, i wrote it randomly ^^

原帖由 jezzyuen 於 10-7-16 12:56 發表
請問你地住邊區？3間都好，而且係咪都收哂上午？如果近近地，放學返黎仲可以學興趣班添，已7月中喇，媽媽決定啦！其實出呢個post，媽媽係咪已經排左名？德望＞聖嘉勒＞聖心？ ...

[ 本帖最後由 sin_928 於 10-7-17 11:46 編輯 ]

作者: sin_928 時間: 10-7-17 11:48

hi, u may read this link:

[http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=2175539&extra=page%3D1&page=9

quote]原帖由 princess_sumyin 於 10-7-16 15:07 發表

May I know how you got a message that GH kinder not guarantee P1 seat [/quote]

作者: iantsang 時間: 10-7-17 12:07

Just can't help it but need to leave a message.  You still cannot decide?  haha, omg!  Better do it soon as the whole family need to know which kindergarten to attend and make adjustment soon (e.g. re-location)

According to what I have heard from you, and as you still cannot make a decision.  I will have to say may be you should choose GH.  I agree with the other parents preference but apparently you care about something else which GH should be able to offer.

Here's my reasoning to share to you.  SHCK is a kindergarten not stressing on curriculum alone.  The main key in their kindergarten is moral education.  So, if the parents really concern moral education, it should take no time and can quickly decide this is the right kindergarten.  I am serious about it.  Moreover, it is not a DSS/Private school system where school management control the admission policy internally.  So, if you really concern the importance of being able to stay in same school system for 15 years, the ranking should be GH then St. Clare's then SH.

For GH, they make their own decision to admit for primary and secondary so as long as you can follow their requirement and expectation, then you are good to stay, without the need to bother with EDB policy changes.

For St. Clare's, there will be enough seats for certain to reach their secondary schools as long as the students keep band 2 level.  For example in this year''s placement, there are not even enough band 1 & 2 students to fill all their reserved seats for own primary students (reserved 70 but only 65 return, and with other going to other band2/3 schools, that means the other must be band 3 and allocate elsewhere).

For SH, yes, there are way more band 1 & 2 students than SHCC can take.  So, if it is so important to go to same secondary school, then no one can guarantee you unless your daughter can maintain band 1.  But it is not a harsh requirement if you know majority of SHCSPS girls are band 1 anyway.  As I explained to you earlier, if the students really are band 3, let them stay in a band 1 school will not be a pleasant experience.

Finally, hope you can decide soon and release the other seats soon.

Anyway, I wish you and your daughter all the best!

Ian

原帖由 sin_928 於 10-7-17 11:41 發表
~we live in kln side at the moment, but we are going to move to Hk Island if we pick SH,

~yes, luckily all am class

~no, i wrote it randomly ^^

作者: ck07hk 時間: 10-7-17 13:55

i would like to know the percentage for the students that can be promoted to P1 in Sacred Heart?? thanks a lot.

作者: elmolly 時間: 10-7-17 16:25

原帖由 iantsang 於 10-7-17 12:07 發表
Just can't help it but need to leave a message. You still cannot decide? haha, omg! Better do it soon as the whole family need to know which kindergarten to attend and make adjustment soon (e.g. re ...

Hi Ian,

in terms of academic, SH or GH is better?

作者: iantsang 時間: 10-7-17 18:16

100%

原帖由 ck07hk 於 10-7-17 13:55 發表
i would like to know the percentage for the students that can be promoted to P1 in Sacred Heart?? thanks a lot.

作者: iantsang 時間: 10-7-17 18:19

Hi Emily,

In terms of academic? It is going to raise a debate if I choose to say either one is better since there are no objective measures to determine which one is indeed better.

Moreover, are you referring to kindergarten, primary or secondary?

On a personal level, I chose one that fits my daughter. Don't you know which one that is already?

Ian

原帖由 elmolly 於 10-7-17 16:25 發表

Hi Ian,

in terms of academic, SH or GH is better?

作者: jezzyuen 時間: 10-7-17 20:38

德望我都好鍾意，可惜我住香港區。哈哈，不過你囡囡好勁呀，間間都am。

原帖由 sin_928 於 10-7-17 11:41 發表
~we live in kln side at the moment, but we are going to move to Hk Island if we pick SH,

~yes, luckily all am class

~no, i wrote it randomly ^^

作者: elmolly 時間: 10-7-17 23:42

原帖由 iantsang 於 10-7-17 18:19 發表
Hi Emily,

In terms of academic? It is going to raise a debate if I choose to say either one is better since there are no objective measures to determine which one is indeed better.

Moreover, are yo ...

GH's kinder is brand new, I think can't compare with SH. secondary level is really depends on the ability of my girl, probably don't need to bother now, so I only want to find out at primary level

well, I don't know which suits my girl more, I only know that she did well at pn and she loves reading. as my in laws live in net 11, so just start to brain storm which school I should target for the lucky draw.

作者: iantsang 時間: 10-7-18 00:33

I agree with your comments that only primary section is the level to be compared!

You mentioned net 11..... so you are referring to SHCS (pm gov't aided)? Their pm section is going through lots of improvement in recent years. Whether at the end they will all become good results, I guess no one can guarantee but certainly are all being done in good intention.

Honestly, as GH's kinder just resumed this year, I never had went thru the distance to research so detail on its primary section. To be frank again, my personal position is a Catholic school shouldn't operate under DSS model..... so

At the end, the only way to find out is to establish personal "feelings" with these schools to find out which is suitable for your daughter.

Ian

原帖由 elmolly 於 10-7-17 23:42 發表

GH's kinder is brand new, I think can't compare with SH. secondary level is really depends on the ability of my girl, probably don't need to bother now, so I only want to find out at primary level:w ...

作者: sin_928 時間: 10-7-18 14:24

hi iantsang,

thank you very much for showing your care and advise, made the choice already, so dont worry, place of the other two already released ^^

i just raise up the question and see what other's think only ^^ .........so dont worry!!!! and i always love to hearing from u, u always have good point of view, thank you very much!!!

原帖由 iantsang 於 10-7-17 12:07 發表
Just can't help it but need to leave a message. You still cannot decide? haha, omg! Better do it soon as the whole family need to know which kindergarten to attend and make adjustment soon (e.g. re ...

[ 本帖最後由 sin_928 於 10-7-18 14:30 編輯 ]

作者: sin_928 時間: 10-7-18 14:25

多謝！because she is lucky!!!

原帖由 jezzyuen 於 10-7-17 20:38 發表
德望我都好鍾意，可惜我住香港區。哈哈，不過你囡囡好勁呀，間間都am。

作者: jezzyuen 時間: 10-7-18 16:03

介吾介意講我知，你會揀邊間？

原帖由 sin_928 於 10-7-18 14:25 發表
多謝！because she is lucky!!!

作者: Sum107 時間: 10-7-18 16:52

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: jezzyuen 時間: 10-7-18 18:26

可以PM我嗎.....我想知係德望定聖心...

原帖由 Sum107 於 10-7-18 16:52 發表
我都有興趣知道你最終點揀。一來三間都咁好，二來有朋友等緊上午班個位…

作者: jezzyuen 時間: 10-7-18 18:31

感恩...我仲有個仔要玩多次呢D遊戲....煩呀!

原帖由 sin_928 於 10-7-18 14:25 發表
多謝！because she is lucky!!!

作者: iantsang 時間: 10-7-18 20:15

Hi sin_928,

great that it is finally settle!

Ian

原帖由 sin_928 於 10-7-18 14:24 發表
hi iantsang,

thank you very much for showing your care and advise, made the choice already, so dont worry, place of the other two already released ^^

i just raise up the question and see what other' ...

作者: elmolly 時間: 10-7-18 22:17

原帖由 iantsang 於 10-7-18 00:33 發表
I agree with your comments that only primary section is the level to be compared!

You mentioned net 11..... so you are referring to SHCS (pm gov't aided)? Their pm section is going through lots of ...

yes, I'm referring to SHCS's pm session. actually SHCS was my 1st choice of primary before I learnt that am is a private school and only pm statys gov't aided. I heard that the chance is not bad for lucky draw to get into SHCS, but I need to overcome the problem of pm first as the workload at primary will be very heavy.

作者: Little_cy 時間: 10-7-19 00:06

for me , i will choose SH

作者: sin_928 時間: 10-8-26 03:42

唔好意思，要大家久等，亦多謝大家關心，因為我不停收到pm問我揀邊間。開估之前又向大家請教，既然三間都好，作為父母既，應該揀間自已prefer既，定小朋友鐘意既呢？

意思係 : 你會揀一間小朋友經過門口都已經好興奮地拉住你入去，入到去會周圍同人介紹佢自已既新學校 or
你會揀一間你自己覺得好好，唔讀覺得超可惜！但小朋友未去到門口已經表現唔鐘意，入到去唔夠十五分鐘就話要走呢？！

你係我應該點揀 ><

作者: MoJoJoJo 時間: 10-8-26 07:21

> 應該揀間自已prefer既，定小朋友鐘意既呢？
i had a similar decision to make a few weeks ago, i chose the one i prefer, which i think is a better path for my girl.

> 你係我應該點揀
this experience is observed during the interivew / registration day?
if so, i think small children's mood & preference changes - easily & from day to day. once s/he made new friends in one place, s/he'd start feeling belonged to the school and happy about going to school as well.

i'm very interested to know which one u have chosen in the end too! :)

原帖由 sin_928 於 10-8-26 03:42 發表
唔好意思，要大家久等，亦多謝大家關心，因為我不停收到pm問我揀邊間。開估之前又向大家請教，既然三間都好，作為父母既，應該揀間自已prefer既，定小朋友鐘意既呢？

意思係 : 你會揀一間小朋友經過門口都已經好興奮地拉住你入去， ...

[ 本帖最後由 MoJoJoJo 於 10-8-26 07:22 編輯 ]

作者: mimimomo6 時間: 10-8-26 07:54

原帖由 sin_928 於 10-8-26 03:42 發表
唔好意思，要大家久等，亦多謝大家關心，因為我不停收到pm問我揀邊間。開估之前又向大家請教，既然三間都好，作為父母既，應該揀間自已prefer既，定小朋友鐘意既呢？

意思係 : 你會揀一間小朋友經過門口都已經好興奮地拉住你入去， ...

就係我的小朋友經過門口都已經好興奮地拉住入去,

同 N 班全校人講 3 歲會轉去讀, 我揀左GH 了

作者: elmolly 時間: 10-8-26 09:53

原帖由 sin_928 於 10-8-26 03:42 發表
唔好意思，要大家久等，亦多謝大家關心，因為我不停收到pm問我揀邊間。開估之前又向大家請教，既然三間都好，作為父母既，應該揀間自已prefer既，定小朋友鐘意既呢？

意思係 : 你會揀一間小朋友經過門口都已經好興奮地拉住你入去， ...

take a balance, 小朋友好興奮果間, 對你黎講係咪完全唔可以接受?

你囡囡適應能力強唔強? 有d小朋友, 就算初初唔鍾意, 好快都融入到新環境, 有d, 我知由開學一路喊, 由3個月至一年都有, 最後喊左成年個位小朋友既媽媽頂唔住, 學期未完已經退學, 所以要睇下你小朋友既性格.

作者: 仔仔錫錫你 時間: 10-8-26 17:43

將心比己!!  有兩份工,
a. 經過公司門口都已經好興奮地想入去做, even 人工一般, 但感覺係可以做到終老;
b. 份工係父母介紹, 佢地覺得好好, 人工多d, 有進升機會, 唔做覺得超可惜, 但未去已經覺得唔會做得耐.

我自己幫小朋友揾學校會先以佢地意願作首.  eg. 細女今年3月in 某kg n1, 之前從未經過該地點, interview 後6月去該區玩才第2次經過kg 門口時, 佢已經認得該校重話係自己間學校; 相反, 另一間kg 在家附近, 1星期經過2-3次連望都無望.

我覺得讀書唔係下下睇學校會教幾多, 小朋友可以學幾多.  如果小朋友從小有一個自己鍾意環境下開始讀書, 就會愛上上學, even 去到"鮮魚行小學"一樣可以升band 1 中學再入大校.  eg. LS小學係仔都想入, dj 鄧藹霖大仔當年入到可惜変左惡夢要轉校, 但係米等於失敗?  好彩佢當時醒覺得早, 最後個仔重入埋港大攞埋文學獎, 名副其實條條大路通羅馬.

作者: POLLYTO 時間: 10-8-26 18:42 標題: 德望 , ST Clare's , 聖心你地會點揀呢？

三間都有各優點,

德望校舍新,兩文三語有d似國際學校課程(無學劵課程深d)
st.clare's 老師好似好好,校舍舊d
聖心名氣最好,我妹讀過其小學,她說她英文好,都是小學打的根基好
怎樣都好,恭喜你有三間禁好的選擇.

polly

作者: chunlaifat 時間: 10-8-27 14:40

very imaginative example.....I think it is right to respect the feelings of our kids. They are the one who study in KG, not the parents. More, they are all good kg. Whichever your choose, it won't be a bad decision.

將心比己!! 有兩份工,
a. 經過公司門口都已經好興奮地想入去做, even 人工一般, 但感覺係可以做到終老;
b. 份工係父母介紹, 佢地覺得好好, 人工多d, 有進升機會, 唔做覺得超可惜, 但未去已經覺得唔會做得耐.

作者: icbb1230 時間: 10-8-27 15:33

hi Ian,

Just want to know why you don't agree GH secondary is a DSS school, but there are many Christian DSS schools, such as DGS, DBS, SPCC, Ying Wa, etc. Also, HY will change to DSS secondary school as well later.

cheers
icbb1230

原帖由 iantsang 於 10-7-18 00:33 發表
I agree with your comments that only primary section is the level to be compared!

You mentioned net 11..... so you are referring to SHCS (pm gov't aided)? Their pm section is going through lots of ...

作者: iantsang 時間: 10-8-27 16:52

Hi icbb1230,

But Good Hope is a Catholic school..... not Christian school..... I don't agree with a Catholic (secondary) school taking the DSS approach only.

Ian

原帖由 icbb1230 於 10-8-27 15:33 發表
hi Ian,

Just want to know why you don't agree GH secondary is a DSS school, but there are many Christian DSS schools, such as DGS, DBS, SPCC, Ying Wa, etc. Also, HY will change to DSS secondary sch ...

[ 本帖最後由 iantsang 於 10-8-27 23:14 編輯 ]

作者: icbb1230 時間: 10-8-27 17:18

Of course, I know GH is a Catholic School. But just wonder why you think Catholic School can't be a DSS school, but on the other hand, Christian school can be. Is it meant you think it's against the Catholic principle and belief, do you?

No offense here, but just my curiosity.

cheers
icbb1230

原帖由 iantsang 於 10-8-27 16:52 發表
Hi icbb1230,

But Good Hope is a Catholic school..... not Christain school..... I don't agree with a Catholic (secondary) school taking the DSS approach only.

Ian

[ 本帖最後由 icbb1230 於 10-8-27 17:22 編輯 ]

作者: iantsang 時間: 10-8-27 23:22

No problem. It's an open discussion so everyone can have their own interpretation.

Similarly, my own interpretation of DSS shouldn't match the Catholic belief for education. Just that.

Ian

原帖由 icbb1230 於 10-8-27 17:18 發表
Of course, I know GH is a Catholic School. But just wonder why you think Catholic School can't be a DSS school, but on the other hand, Christian school can be. Is it meant you think it's against the ...

作者: chunlaifat 時間: 10-8-29 01:25

What do you think about St Paul's Convent? You did apply it for your daughter last year.

作者: stinkyrabbit111 時間: 10-8-29 07:59 標題: 回覆 39# chunlaifat 的文章

sorry, i am just a by-passer, I like to comment on spk & shck mainly, as I don't have much info on the other 2 school... good hope is yet too new to be commented (except the 校舍, very impressive indeed), , may be you can judge if by it primary and secondary section!

I am sure most parent with daughter aiming for traditional school will apply for spk first, and also shck and others..

those who are lucky enough to have the "honour" to choose between the 2 , have a very very tough decision to make..most will pick spk because of its fame, and % of admitted / applied..

my girl is a small small girl, she was not being accepted into any of the major traditionals last year.....and I had been doing a lot of researches, my conclusion is shck really has its 優勢..curriculum wise, it is more balanced, structured, parents will not have to worry about their children 程度唔夠and has to 出去補習at a young age, PTA is well organised, parents voices will be heard; my only dislike about shck is the staircase!!

[ 本帖最後由 stinkyrabbit111 於 10-8-29 08:00 編輯 ]

作者: iantsang 時間: 10-8-29 11:56

I assume the question is for me (as I did apply for SPK for my daughter last year).

As this topic is not related to SPK so let me make it brief and quick. I guess just like other parents, I am not that educated about education system in HK when I look for kindergartens for my elder one two years ago. So, I just pick the popular choices just like everyone. But when it comes to the point that I need to make a choice, then I started to research really hard to understand the real meanings......

Anyway, my young one will apply for K1 this year and SPK will not be in my list this time.

原帖由 chunlaifat 於 10-8-29 01:25 發表
What do you think about St Paul's Convent? You did apply it for your daughter last year.

作者: wootaitai 時間: 10-8-29 23:18

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: icbb1230 時間: 10-8-30 13:00

Hi Ian,

can you elaborate more your point of view? If GH is a private school, will u also have the same comment? Why Chrisitan school can be DSS?

Sorry, I don't quite understand, you may PM me as the topic isn't related to here.

cheers
icbb1230

原帖由 iantsang 於 10-8-27 23:22 發表
No problem. It's an open discussion so everyone can have their own interpretation.

Similarly, my own interpretation of DSS shouldn't match the Catholic belief for education. Just that.

Ian

...

作者: iantsang 時間: 10-8-30 17:53

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=1703585

here's one of my previous posts concerning these two.

原帖由 wootaitai 於 10-8-29 23:18 發表
Can you elaborate on curriculum comparison between SHCK and SPK? or just on SHCK?

Perhaps a link to your previous relevant discussions would be most helpful. thanks!

作者: iantsang 時間: 10-8-30 18:06

Please note that I am NOT comparing Catholic and Christian schools. There are many schools with management organizations from any religions! Anyone can run a DSS, but with my personal knowledge of Catholic school organizations, I just feel it is inappropriate to do so only. I don't have any further elaboration.

May be you can refer to formal information about DSS from EDB:
http://www.edb.gov.hk/index.aspx?nodeid=1475&langno=2

Sorry but I really have nothing more to add concerning DSS and SPK vs. SHCK here since it is not sin_928's questions.

原帖由 icbb1230 於 10-8-30 13:00 發表
Hi Ian,

can you elaborate more your point of view? If GH is a private school, will u also have the same comment? Why Chrisitan school can be DSS?

Sorry, I don't quite understand, you may PM me as ...

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)