教育王國

標題: 細B被年齡歧視 [打印本頁]

作者: stevetso 時間: 10-7-6 14:02 標題: 細B被年齡歧視

有好多學校都唔收細B, 收..都係waiting list.

有D學校連細B form都唔收.

如果要追上K1, 好多幼稚園都會favour讀PN既學生....好慘.

作者: yinghung1234 時間: 10-7-6 14:18

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: fishballbaby 時間: 10-7-6 14:20

所以呢，就算並非心儀的PN，都要讀住先，如果唔係到升K1又少咗一個籌碼。

原帖由 stevetso 於 10-7-6 14:02 發表
有好多學校都唔收細B, 收..都係waiting list.

有D學校連細B form都唔收.

如果要追上K1, 好多幼稚園都會favour讀PN既學生....好慘.

作者: cycream 時間: 10-7-8 11:10

原帖由 yinghung1234 於 10-7-6 14:18 發表
我個女都係細b , 其實又唔可以話細B被年齡歧視咁嚴重 , 始終小朋友差幾個月能力差異好明顯 , 如果學校有得揀 , 正常都會揀能力高既學生. 2008 & 09出生率咁高 , 講緊報既學生分分鐘都過千 , 學校梗要用方法分類.

...

我覺得學校唔止係因為prefer能力高既學生,而且係細b要做插班,收少2,3個月學費. 我有個朋友既朋友係名kg教,佢話佢間學校話收細b係表面,其實係少到好緊要,佢話收少學費係其中一個原因:(

作者: chanwendy 時間: 10-7-8 11:36

原帖由 cycream 於 10-7-8 11:10 發表

我覺得學校唔止係因為prefer能力高既學生,而且係細b要做插班,收少2,3個月學費. 我有個朋友既朋友係名kg教,佢話佢間學校話收細b係表面,其實係少到好緊要,佢話收少學費係其中一個原因:( ...

好多學校 n1 都會分開開課的, 好似我女學校咁, 有啲班係十月, 十一月, 有啲甚至十二月先開學, 全班都係細仔細女.

作者: LPN 時間: 10-7-8 13:16

原帖由 chanwendy 於 10-7-8 11:36 發表

好多學校 n1 都會分開開課的, 好似我女學校咁, 有啲班係十月, 十一月, 有啲甚至十二月先開學, 全班都係細仔細女.

請問有邊間會有細 b 班?

作者: kkwu 時間: 10-7-8 13:17

咁又幾好喎...全班都係細仔細女...無咁大能力差異...
請問你個女讀邊間架?

原帖由 chanwendy 於 10-7-8 11:36 發表

好多學校 n1 都會分開開課的, 好似我女學校咁, 有啲班係十月, 十一月, 有啲甚至十二月先開學, 全班都係細仔細女.

作者: yaulinda 時間: 10-7-8 15:33

直頭對細b超唔公平啦,
好蘇浙nursery咁,
寫到明只接受1月至8月出生的小朋友呀!

作者: babyakambm 時間: 10-7-8 15:55

Same with HKPS Kln Tong !

作者: fishballbaby 時間: 10-7-8 18:20

我囝囝是0809，報了8間幼稚園，得方方、黃埔迦南和樂基有得IN，樂基FAIL咗，黃埔迦南是後補INTERVIEW，但係我無去到IN。

而方方，一早已OFFER INTERVIEW比我囝囝並取錄了，雖然方方並非名校，但是我有一種被專重被重視的感覺，囝囝有書讀，無需要做別人的後補。

原帖由 babyakambm 於 10-7-8 15:55 發表
Same with HKPS Kln Tong !

作者: happymamme 時間: 10-7-8 19:51

I totally agree. The system itself is badly planned. Children borned in end of year all have to face this problem. This is so unfair. I think the yearly intake and age requirement should be grouped by year to year. So all children born in the same year have the same chance. If school thinks children born in the yearend is less smarter, they can conduct tests and interviews, but at least the kids can have a chance first.

作者: charis_mama 時間: 10-7-9 10:47

如果向平基會投訴, 受唔受理呢?

不過如果學校表現話收哂 1- 12月出生的小朋友, 但實際只考慮8 月前出生, 而問到校方時, 佢地會話小朋友的面試表現比較好, 哩類就肯定無得搞。

但寫到明收 1- 8 月的學校, 就可能有機會投訴成功。

不過幼兒園始終只係私校, 是否不受任何政府部門規管? 如果係, 佢地咁唔公平都無佢地辦法。

作者: sammiyy 時間: 10-7-9 12:01

咁未生BB嘅時候就要諗, 要計埋每年嘅3,4月份先好dodo

作者: cycream 時間: 10-7-9 13:10

原帖由 sammiyy 於 10-7-9 12:01 發表
咁未生BB嘅時候就要諗, 要計埋每年嘅3,4月份先好dodo

我個大仔10月出世界(而加20個月大),而加陀緊細仔又係10月生,我1月份有bb時都未感受到細b既讀書問題,早知係咁,我都等多幾個月先由, 等細仔年頭生:(

作者: venus_mama08 時間: 10-7-9 13:52

my b is also 0809, we mailed 5 application. only 1 we not yet to have interview. At first, we got 1 offer and 3 waiting. Finally, we got 3 offer and 1 waiting.

So, no need to worry, u must have chance

原帖由 fishballbaby 於 8-7-2010 18:20 發表
我囝囝是0809，報了8間幼稚園，得方方、黃埔迦南和樂基有得IN，樂基FAIL咗，黃埔迦南是後補INTERVIEW，但係我無去到IN。

而方方，一早已OFFER INTERVIEW比我囝囝並取錄了，雖然方方並非名校，但是我有一種被專重被重視的感覺，囝囝有 ...

作者: babyakambm 時間: 10-7-9 14:03

The only solution is to have the baby born in Jan - July. I will try to plan to born my next baby in the first half of the year.

作者: tantanmama 時間: 10-7-9 14:15

原帖由 cycream 於 10-7-9 13:10 發表

我個大仔10月出世界(而加20個月大),而加陀緊細仔又係10月生,我1月份有bb時都未感受到細b既讀書問題,早知係咁,我都等多幾個月先由, 等細仔年頭生:(

我個女預產期係09年1月尾, 但早咗5W出世, 變成0812-->我即時反應就係揾學校會好難. 做大B定細B嘅問題令我非常困擾.

作者: yinghung1234 時間: 10-7-9 15:06

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: babyakambm 時間: 10-7-9 15:08

For me, I never wanted to have my baby to be borned in Dec, as I am a Dec girl too. And accidently, he was born in Dec ... !!! Struggling to be small B or extra big B now !

作者: brrbaby2007 時間: 10-7-9 15:27

如果父母係DBS、DGS、LS....等等，細B都實收..

作者: Makfung 時間: 10-7-10 00:13

我打去心儀的幼稚園到問,她們聽到係細B就已經話可能連IN都無機會,不過你都可send Fm try啦！唉！我都覺得好唔開心呀！好唔公平呀！我都好worry 啊仔無書讀。細B都可以好叻好出色！！！

作者: cincin_ko 時間: 10-7-10 09:43

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: tsobaba 時間: 10-7-12 17:56

TotallyAgree!其實都唔洗咁擔心, 我個女係07年細B, 報左7間九龍城區嘅KG, 1stRound, 得York收, 3間唔收, 3間Waiting, 我兩公婆最初都好擔心, 後來2ndRound, KLLC同MS都收左, 叫做放下心頭大石。所以唔應該介懷大細B, 大人同小朋友盡左力, 天父會給安排。

原帖由 yinghung1234 於 10-7-9 15:06 發表

投訴最終的目的是爭取權益 , 我覺得為呢樣投訴會好無謂 , 因為實際唔會幫你爭取到權益. 因為就算比你投訴寫明 "1 - 8月" 係有問題 , 你得值 , 到時所有學校都話會比你見 , 但實際你花左大量人力物力之後 , 學校都 ...

作者: OscarFanMaMa 時間: 10-7-21 22:40

o麥9月出世都算係細仔呀?我個B係0909,佢早咗4個幾禮拜出世,我仲諗住佢變成適齡添...重要09出生率創新高,點算呀

作者: godloveus 時間: 10-7-22 20:05

我亞囡係十月尾細b,初初報咗幾間,交報名表時已經講到明呢d係"插班生",有位先通知interview,初頭真係完全冇消息,啲朋友的大b已經有好多offer,都幾令人擔心!!

後來1月開始有得interview,想讀嗰幾間都收咗,所以父母應該都唔使太worry!!

作者: sugary 時間: 10-7-23 03:14

我果囡係8月B, 問過幾間都話優先收1-7月, 至於8-12月的會成為waiting list, 有人唔讀你才可以補上

我都好想告佢地囉.

作者: jelly-pudding 時間: 10-7-23 10:51

oh! 月出世都係waiting list? 我囝囝8/8 tim.

作者: 小幸子 時間: 10-7-23 11:47

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: sugary 時間: 10-7-23 16:42

馬鞍山合一堂同大水坑崇真會都話要等開學有N班學生唔讀, 才可以補上

原帖由 jelly-pudding 於 10-7-23 10:51 發表
oh! 月出世都係waiting list? 我囝囝8/8 tim.

作者: monkey05 時間: 10-7-23 23:03

原帖由 babyakambm 於 10-7-9 14:03 發表
The only solution is to have the baby born in Jan - July. I will try to plan to born my next baby in the first half of the year.

Me 2. This is the only solution.

作者: hoihoima 時間: 10-7-23 23:22 標題: 回覆 1# monkey05 的文章

The expected due date for my boy was mid-Jan. I was so happy to have a big boy when I knew that. Turned out he was borne in late Dec...人算不如天算...

作者: 5941 時間: 10-7-23 23:56

我個人認為是歧視, 係做過mama都知年紀越細, 差距越大; 每間學校都應有若干班數留給細b, 比賽都要在同一個ground先有得比啦, 何況現在連參賽資格都冇... 唔係話全港冇學校收細b, 將來細b一樣可以出類拔萃, 但現況係Kln Tong D kinder: "歡迎大仔; 我們優先處理"; 我明這是商業策略, 應該在學校背景寫明嘛, 以後個個識年頭生仔; 這個只是細b問題,變成社會問題; 我support樓主, 習慣o下不公平或看不下去的事要出聲, 要爭取, 要討論...無人知結果

作者: 5941 時間: 10-7-24 00:13

原帖由 tsobaba 於 10-7-12 17:56 發表
TotallyAgree!其實都唔洗咁擔心, 我個女係07年細B, 報左7間九龍城區嘅KG, 1stRound, 得York收, 3間唔收, 3間Waiting, 我兩公婆最初都好擔心, 後來2ndRound, KLLC同MS都收左, 叫做放下心頭大石。所以唔應該介懷大細B, ...

07年唔同08年, 09年更worse... 3間waiting即係standby 囉, 人o地揀完唔要... 比你囉

作者: Ericang 時間: 10-7-24 12:05

My second son will born in Dec 2010. I will let him to be a big B because he can learn better. Study is a long term planning and i think study 1 year eailier will not have many benefits.

作者: mb2 時間: 10-7-27 09:55

the problem is i checked some N, they stated that they only accept application of Jan - Aug BB! So for my Oct BB, even i want her to be a BIG b, she doesnt even have the chance!

So where should those Sep - Dec bb go??!

作者: brrbaby2007 時間: 10-7-27 11:21

原帖由 5941 於 10-7-24 00:13 發表

07年唔同08年, 09年更worse... 3間waiting即係standby 囉, 人o地揀完唔要... 比你囉

人地唔take個offer係有多種原因，如果成日諗住人地唔要先俾你呢種心態，我諗呢世人經常都有唔開心了

作者: 小曳人 時間: 10-7-27 11:26

原帖由 5941 於 10-7-24 00:13 發表

07年唔同08年, 09年更worse... 3間waiting即係standby 囉, 人o地揀完唔要... 比你囉

呢個世界唔係你揀人就係人揀你架啦~
到時你一樣可以攞住幾個offer, 然後唔要幾個架!

作者: 小曳人 時間: 10-7-27 11:30

原帖由 monkey05 於 10-7-23 23:03 發表

Me 2. This is the only solution.

要小心d計到好準
一個唔覺意 EDD 一月變12月出世呀!

hehe~ 我係幸運嘅人.. 兩個都係4月預產期架!

d朋友個個都話我識生, 唔熱又唔凍! 媽媽同bb都舒服!

作者: 5941 時間: 10-7-27 12:36

原帖由 mb2 於 10-7-27 09:55 發表
the problem is i checked some N, they stated that they only accept application of Jan - Aug BB! So for my Oct BB, even i want her to be a BIG b, she doesnt even have the chance!

So where should those ...

同意... 教育應是平等的...

作者: Sumyeema1 時間: 10-7-29 17:22

我有一女一仔（全部Dec B)，阿女預產期是一月中，豈料她早產，變成超細女。

當初我也有各位媽咪的想法，覺得細女能力不差，幫她報了K1做細女。當時的那間ＫＧ也算名校，班中很多年頭出生的大Ｂ，我女比別人矮一個頭，因為大小肌肉還沒有發展好，很多事情比大B 做的差，結果小女讀得不開心。

之后我讓她去另一間 KG repeat K1，做了大B, 理解能力/專注力好了，讀得很開心。

各位家長，如果出名的 KG 受了你的小朋友，但要和其他大B 競爭，你覺得對你的小朋友的發展是好事嗎？大女的經驗讓我決定弟弟做大 B.

作者: gyeung77 時間: 10-8-4 23:18

I agree. When you are small a few months does make a lot of difference, why force your baby to be such a difficult situation? One year does not make a lot of difference.

作者: MissMusic 時間: 10-8-5 07:40

咁十一月廿幾號出世生B女, 又應唔應該做大女?

十二月出世的做大仔大女好似理所當然D, 但十一月, 唔係最細, 遲一年先讀, 又驚學校唔接受申請~

作者: chowqv 時間: 10-8-15 19:59

大家都誤會左啦。其實學校就算收左你都無用，因為政府規定，小一入學要足5歲8個月。咁細b到時都係要讀到夠先可以升小學。咁不如俾佢做大b啦。

作者: pluto_yuen 時間: 10-8-15 20:17

the entrance age for P1 is 5yr 8 months old, so when your children born on dec of that year. He/she will be 5yr8 months old on sept of their P1 year.
I feel unfair to the SMALL B system too, i once applied a kinder at happy valley, the teacher would not even give my child a chance of interview. She just said small b will not be considered. I'm glad she rejected me coz i later got into a even better kinder at cental weeks ago. Her performance maybe a bit worst than Big B when she was 2yrs but as the child grew bigger, u'll see small b can improve a lot. And soon, u can't tell who is big b or small b in the class.

作者: sorman 時間: 10-8-16 11:55

我都宜家都唔明趕住做細B 入學真係有乜咁好?

先申報利益, 我個仔係大B, 不過我自己係超細B, 我係1月中出世, 但係早同年齡小朋友一年讀書, 當年未夠2歲就因為太想讀書 (阿媽送阿哥返學, 我係要入去霸埋一個位, 霸下霸下, 當全班返哂黎冇位坐先逼於無奈走人, 所以幼稚園校長見我咁俾我早讀, 上到小一, 當年EDB 冇咁嚴, 有間小學肯收我...第二年要返去阿哥O個間一齊讀, 本來要REPEAT 小一, 但校長見我成績好, 俾我直上小二.....就係咁, 我由小一到讀完大學, 都係細過同班同學一年. 我仲識一個朋友只係細我一日, 但遲我一年畢業. 所以我絕對係細B受惠者)

但到我做老豆, 我要揀的話都唔想個仔做細B...細個當佢覺得樣樣都追唔到同學, 可能令佢有挫敗感, 唔鍾意讀書返學就大鑊了....所以, 何必格硬想去做細B?

作者: BethMarc 時間: 10-8-25 00:09

Both of my kids are small b. One is 2007 Oct and the other is better 2009 Sep, I will keep my fingers cross.
My daughter was in a small Bs class last year (PN) and many of her classmates are born in Nov and Dec.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)