教育王國
標題: 皇仁 / 喇沙 / 男拔 / 聖保羅男女, 你哋點排呀? [打印本頁]
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-2-18 19:11 標題: 皇仁 / 喇沙 / 男拔 / 聖保羅男女, 你哋點排呀?
如果咁好彩，以上四間學校都收，請問你們會點排呀?
作者: Lmum 時間: 10-2-18 21:08
純個人觀感,我會咁排....
聖保羅男女
皇仁
男拔
喇沙
如從要交學費角度來看,我會咁排....
皇仁
男拔
聖保羅男女
喇沙
其實只可能發生,係聖保羅男女+男拔都獲錄取而己.
原帖由 ABC-DAD 於 10-2-18 19:11 發表 
如果咁好彩，以上四間學校都收，請問你們會點排呀?
作者: kuenkuenmum 時間: 10-2-18 21:49
Just my personal opinion:
1. DBS
2. SPCC
3. QC
4. LSC
作者: Leica-user 時間: 10-2-18 23:39
my personal view:
1.QC
2.DBS
3.SPCC
4.LS
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-2-19 00:13
各位朋友, 在回應時, 可否講埋点解呀! Thanks!
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-2-19 03:07
Hi,
各位都擺LSC最尾噃，有無特别原因呢﹖
原帖由 ABC-DAD 於 10-2-19 00:13 發表
各位朋友, 在回應時, 可否講埋点解呀! Thanks!
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-3-9 16:14 標題: 回覆 1# ABC-DAD 的文章
早前 LSC 暗示會收,週一收SPCC信2ND IN 過左關（第一輪唔得跌落ＧＥＮＥＲＡＬ ADMIT 唔係2ND IN SORRY),本來SPCC好無信心,
另外DBS 1ST IN左之後未有消息,阿仔自己話有信心,....
ＱＣ 又係要等有無得
ＩＮ 等好定唔等好, 請大家俾Ｄ意見，
ＭＡＮＹ ＴＨＡＮＫＳ 係咪ＴＡＫＥ 左
ＳＰＣＣ先好Ｄ呢？
[ 本帖最後由 ABC-DAD 於 10-3-9 19:12 編輯 ]
作者: tangko 時間: 10-3-9 18:02
交得起學費，往返交通又無問題的話，會揀spcc。
男女校始終比純男校好! 況且spcc假假地都是個人擇A率最高的學校。
但如令郎較活潑好動的話，可能dbs或ls較適合。
所以不應純以學校的質數作決定，還應結合小朋友的志趣一併考慮。
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-3-9 19:19
TANGKO,
謝謝你的意見, 我亦屬意男女校,只不過DBS /LSC D HARDWARE 好吸引D 仔....
選DBS／ＬＳＣ的話各路英雄雲集， 活潑好動唔一定有發展機會呢,可能係SPCC重會有機會池中無魚虾自大噃？（好 ＡＨ Ｑ）
quote]原帖由 tangko 於 10-3-9 18:02 發表
交得起學費，往返交通又無問題的話，會揀spcc。
男女校始終比純男校好! 況且spcc假假地都是個人擇A率最高的學校。
但如令郎較活潑好動的話，可能dbs或ls較適合。
... [/quote]
[ 本帖最後由 ABC-DAD 於 10-3-9 19:30 編輯 ]
作者: MountainView 時間: 10-3-10 11:27
I think it should depend on your son's personality.
If he is good at academic only, QC or SPCC would be a good choice. Diff is 男女校 or 男校. I personally prefer 男校 as they are not mature enough to deal with 男女 relationship yet and nowadays, it can't be avoided.
If he is active, initiative, very confidence type, good at sports/music, DBS or LSC would be good. People often have different opinion on them. I just guess most DBS kids are from high income family, do you have concern on this kind of peer influence?
Just my personal opinion.
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-3-10 12:29
Mountain view,
You did raised a good point. I might LOOK FURHTER INTO the personality developement of my son. He'd studied in a co-ed P-school for 6yrs already,shifting to a boy's school is a CHANGE,A BIG MOVE FOR A BOY.
The fact is ,rather he can manage both sides as before.
Many thanks
原帖由 MountainView 於 10-3-10 11:27 發表
I think it should depend on your son's personality.
If he is good at academic only, QC or SPCC would be a good choice. Diff is 男女校 or 男校. I personally prefer 男校 as they are not mature enough to ...
作者: MountainView 時間: 10-3-10 12:41
My son was in co-ed primary also, it is really not big a deal to study at boy's school now at secondary. Actually, he sometimes jokes that he likes the current environment as girls are troublesome and noisy sometimes 
原帖由 ABC-DAD 於 10-3-10 12:29 發表
Mountain view,
You did raised a good point. I might LOOK FURHTER INTO the personality developement of my son. He'd studied in a co-ed P-school for 6yrs already,shifting to a boy's school is a CHANGE, ...
作者: citizen 時間: 10-3-11 18:17
My personal opinion:
1. LSC
2. DBS
3. QC
4. SPCC
作者: wunma 時間: 10-3-12 10:04
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: DKmum 時間: 10-3-12 16:24
好奇問一問明示會明成點呢?
原帖由 wunma 於 10-3-12 10:04 發表
暗示? 有危險! 因為必收的話會明示的.
作者: mow-mow 時間: 10-3-12 16:25
One bird in hand is worth two in the bush!
I would take SPCC if I were you.
In terms of academic results, SPCC is arguably the best out of the 4.
In terms of music, SPCC is as good as DBS and better than QC & LS.
In terms of sports, DBS & LS are definitely better.
So unless your son is a very keen sportsman, SPCC would be a good choice.
作者: wunma 時間: 10-3-12 16:55
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: Johnny@Klnbay 時間: 10-3-12 17:14 標題: 回覆 1# wunma 的文章
我仔中學同學第二次面試喇沙時，會問他有無報直資，叫他不用簽紙直資，意思就是收他了！
作者: sandyaloha 時間: 10-3-12 21:31
原帖由 DKmum 於 10-3-12 16:24 發表
好奇問一問明示會明成點呢?
大家阿仔有機會做同學,
想交流下,
please check PM,
Thanks!
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-3-13 03:04
睇完 [email=Johny@Klnbay]Johny@Klnbay[/email] 的話，完來我攪錯,係明明明示云至真 but finally I will take SPCC thks everyone
原帖由 wunma 於 10-3-12 10:04 發表
暗示? 有危險! 因為必收的話會明示的.
作者: CFaHB 時間: 10-3-16 09:37
真犀利, SPCC & LC.
你仔仔是不是讀得體育又得 ? interview 問什麼呢 ? 請賜教 (pm 也ok) !
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-3-17 04:20
Not that good as you think, thank you for your comment anyway.
Do you mean the interview of SPCC OR LC?
原帖由 CFaHB 於 10-3-16 09:37 發表
真犀利, SPCC & LC.
你仔仔是不是讀得體育又得 ? interview 問什麼呢 ? 請賜教 (pm 也ok) !
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-3-21 03:13 標題: 回覆 1# ABC-DAD 的文章
收到QC 28/3 面試信
作者: MountainView 時間: 10-3-22 11:33
Good luck, if he is accepted by SPCC, QC interview will be very easy to him.
原帖由 ABC-DAD 於 10-3-21 03:13 發表
收到QC 28/3 面試信
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-3-22 12:05 標題: 回覆 1# MountainView 的文章
Thank You ! MountainView, you are a very supporting n helpful bk member
Your son is in S2?
I'd seen your articals for a while, la!
Have to said Hi and Thank you for all the bk mums and dads
升中選校原來真係要大家支持呀
: :
有壓力。。有壓力。。
呀！
歡迎ＰＭ呀 不過我未試過
作者: MountainView 時間: 10-3-22 12:28
Ha ha, thanks for reading. I did have more time before but now I am back to work, I come here less often, only if I am less busy at work, like today.
BK is good site to get information, but now money related (like which course is good, which centre, etc) topics are getting more "adv-like" type of conversation. But I like this thread as I did get a lot of information when my son did F1 application before, really thanks other parents at that time. I will visit here for latest info again as my younger son would apply F1 at the end of year!
Yeah, my son is now S2.
BTW, PM by clicking on second button at the bottom (private message). I PM you too.
Good luck again!
原帖由 ABC-DAD 於 10-3-22 12:05 發表
Thank You ! MountainView, you are a very supporting n helpful bk member
Your son is in S2?
I'd seen your articals for a while, la!
Have to said Hi and Thank you for all the bk mums and dads: ...
[ 本帖最後由 MountainView 於 10-3-22 12:35 編輯 ]
作者: BB822 時間: 10-3-22 16:08 標題: 怎樣預備升中
Hello, MountainView, ABC-DAD & all friends
看見你們的孩子升上很好的中學, 真是很羨慕;
相信孩子和你們都付出很大的努力, 恭喜你們!
小兒現正就讀四年級(沒有直屬中學), 我知道升中成績很重要, 但除成績外, 是否要預備很多東西, 例如各樣的比賽等, 請問可否指教什麼証書或比賽成績, 學校較著重.
我現在才開始搜集資料, 什麼都不懂, 請多多指教!
萬分感謝!
bb822
[ 本帖最後由 BB822 於 10-3-22 16:10 編輯 ]
作者: MountainView 時間: 10-3-22 17:20
I personally think academic goes before everything. Then, picking activities that go with your kid's interest. If they have talent on that (music,sport, speaking, dancing, etc), of course, try to get the best result from inter-school competition. Otherwise, getting certificates from different type will show the balance between academic and activities. This will not guarantee you.
I actually think training his presentation skills, thinking process, etc is more important and takes time, that will help him during interview, and later in school.
In most school's selection process, I believe they count academic + activities + interview performance.
Finding a right/good school according to your kid's capability and interest. If they enjoy school life, build confidence there, no matter what banding school they go to, they all have good future!
Just my own thoughts.
原帖由 BB822 於 10-3-22 16:08 發表
Hello, MountainView, ABC-DAD & all friends
看見你們的孩子升上很好的中學, 真是很羨慕;
相信孩子和你們都付出很大的努力, 恭喜你們!
小兒現正就讀四年級(沒有直屬中學), 我知道升中成績很重要, 但除成績外, 是 ...
作者: crystal2009 時間: 10-3-29 11:36
Mountain View, ABC-DAD
很羨慕你們的仔仔入讀了QC /獲得面試的機會, 可否透露一下他們的學業成績 (全級名次)及活動強項 (校外賽獎項)? 我想幫小兒報考QC , 但又恐怕因差距太遠而浪費一個跨區名額, 所以冒昧地請你們賜教 !!
另外, 通常人們只會提及運動及音樂方面有優異成績的會有優勢, 但小兒的強項只是奧數, 不知道奧數獎項會有幫助嗎?
作者: MountainView 時間: 10-3-29 17:16
My son was 1st in grade, he has swimming, table tennis and piano, never got 校外賽獎項 but he was in school teams, but enough to show balance I guess.
Olympic Maths does count but I heard it is even better if you can get some prizes in those related exams as this can show how good he is.
I never know what criteria they used to select students for interview, but I do heard that most are top 5 in primary, or may be only those who will apply...
原帖由 crystal2009 於 10-3-29 11:36 發表
Mountain View, ABC-DAD
很羨慕你們的仔仔入讀了QC /獲得面試的機會, 可否透露一下他們的學業成績 (全級名次)及活動強項 (校外賽獎項)? 我想幫小兒報考QC , 但又恐怕因差距太遠而浪費一個跨區名額, 所以冒昧地請你 ...
作者: ABC-DAD 時間: 10-3-29 17:46
我同意MT.VIEW的睇法,
了解囝囝嘅興趣/強項係首要，奧數好多名校有興趣但語文成績一定行先，而且有奧數成績嘅人年年都好多，spcc行普教中，你自己度一度啦。名中學好出名的其他比賽你可在網上捜一搜尋..辯論..創意解難,能代表學校比賽表演，同通識方面嘅都hit。純個人，有怪莫怪。
另阿仔有事無in到QC。多謝你讃佢
[ 本帖最後由 ABC-DAD 於 10-3-29 17:55 編輯 ]
作者: crystal2009 時間: 10-3-29 23:12
Mountain View, ABC-DAD
多謝你們的寶貴意見!
作者: alilu 時間: 10-4-1 16:51
Hello ABC-DAD and MT. VIEW, 想請教QC, SPCC等的interview criteria 多是什麼? 是否都是以academic result行先? 另小五的校內成績及程分試是否最重要? 萬一失手, 還有得追嗎? Thanks.
作者: MountainView 時間: 10-4-9 15:04
For QC interview (2 years ago)
- English passage reading, picture description
- Conversation in various topics regarding yourself, school, family,etc in Cantonese and English
Fairly easier comparing to DBS, SPCC ,etc interviews (personal feel)
For QC req (public info in their web):
學業成績(佔評分50%)
操行(佔評分5%)
課外活動(佔評分15%)
面試時之表現(佔評分30%)
~200 students will be interviewed for 54 seats this year.
<小五的校內成績及程分試是否最重要? 萬一失手, 還有得追嗎?>
Well, the 程分試 affect the 教育局學生次第名單. It will include P5 final, P6 first and second term result. So, I believe the rank list QC got should include result from P5 final and P6 first term, not sure how worse you meant from P5, try the best in P6 first term to make up I guess.
According to QC "校方參考教育局提供之「申請學生次第名單」及評估申請人填報之資料考慮須否約見申請人。"
Too many applicants, getting an interview opportunity is already a very good start!
原帖由 alilu 於 10-4-1 16:51 發表
Hello ABC-DAD and MT. VIEW, 想請教QC, SPCC等的interview criteria 多是什麼? 是否都是以academic result行先? 另小五的校內成績及程分試是否最重要? 萬一失手, 還有得追嗎? Thanks. ...
作者: DKmum 時間: 10-4-9 23:49
原帖由 alilu 於 10-4-1 16:51 發表
Hello ABC-DAD and MT. VIEW, 想請教QC, SPCC等的interview criteria 多是什麼? 是否都是以academic result行先? 另小五的校內成績及程分試是否最重要? 萬一失手, 還有得追嗎? Thanks. ...
I think they rank highly on the academic result. We need to fill in the ranking in class & whole form in the application form. Only very little space for filling activities & achievement in the form, unlike other top school like DBS, LSC & SPCC.
My friend's son (2 years ago) got fair result in P.5 2nd term & good result in P.6 1st term. He did not have interview from QC in the 1st round. Since his son ranks very good in P.6 2nd term, he was finally admitted through knocking door.
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |