教育王國
標題: Sacred Heart accepted my girl's p1 app admission [打印本頁]
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-14 15:36 標題: Sacred Heart accepted my girl's p1 app admission
Dear parent,
I will write a letter to True Light n St. Clare's for giving up the seats of P1 admission.
I m more than happy, n I m so proud of her. Now, it's the time to choose now. SSCPS or Sacred Heart? Any advice?
作者: fsforth 時間: 09-12-14 16:11
論學費, SSCPS 貴好多!
論workload, Sacred Heart 大很多, 但如果挨得住, 成績有保證.
女仔我會選聖心, 因為 Value for money, 上中學唔會太早拍拖!
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-14 16:19
Dear fsforth, I agree with you. However, Sacred Heart is only half day school which mean I have to arrange the afternoon activities for her. This may turn out spending more thanSSCPS. These two schools have their own characteristic. For kids, I believe she loves more SSCPS than Sacred Heart. For me, I love Sacred Heart more, and the only disadvantage is Half day school.
原帖由 fsforth 於 09-12-14 16:11 發表 
論學費, SSCPS 貴好多!
論workload, Sacred Heart 大很多, 但如果挨得住, 成績有保證.
女仔我會選聖心, 因為 Value for money, 上中學唔會太早拍拖!
作者: fsforth 時間: 09-12-14 16:37
原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-14 16:19 發表
Dear fsforth, I agree with you. However, Sacred Heart is only half day school which mean I have to arrange the afternoon activities for her. This may turn out spending more thanSSCPS. These two sc ...
聖心功課夠你做半日, 我表妹以前都係呢度小學畢業, 成績好, 中學考入聖保羅男女, 聽佢講老師比較惡, 壓力都幾大
我係小朋友都會喜歡SSCPS, international school feeling, 老師好人又多野玩, 有時會去室外上課, 親親大自然, 不過, $5,500+樂器費+lunch+車費, P.4-P.6
一年一次oversea trip, 一個月要八千
仲有可能年年加學費...P.6強制性留宿, 到時月花一萬以上!
學術上因為SSCPS唔會"谷"學生, 只要你個女肯自律, 入SSCPS都可以有好成績, 分別是入聖心是考父母的耐力, 而入SSC就是考你的財力!
作者: traeh 時間: 09-12-14 16:54
非常認同，聖心好考父母耐力，因為聞說得返一半學生可直升自己中學，平均分少過某個分數（大概88.X之類都頗高的分數），肯定升唔返；同一時間，私立部每班人數甚多，而學校課程又教得好快，好多時都要靠父母跟返足．如果錢同distance唔係問題，做聖士提反的家長可能會無咁辛苦．
原帖由 fsforth 於 09-12-14 16:37 發表
聖心功課夠你做半日, 我表妹以前都係呢度小學畢業, 成績好, 中學考入聖保羅男女, 聽佢講老師比較惡, 壓力都幾大 ......
學術上因為SSCPS唔會"谷"學生, 只要你個女肯自律, 入SSCPS都可以有好成績, 分別是入聖心是考父母的耐力, 而入SSC就是考你的財力!
作者: Piaget 時間: 09-12-14 16:54
Hi shusiusiu,
May I know when you receive the acceptance letter?
原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-14 16:19 發表
Dear fsforth, I agree with you. However, Sacred Heart is only half day school which mean I have to arrange the afternoon activities for her. This may turn out spending more thanSSCPS. These two sc ...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-14 17:02
Really thks fsforth. I specially like you said "入聖心是考父母的耐力, 而入SSC就是考你的財力!"原帖由 fsforth 於 09-12-14 16:37 發表
聖心功課夠你做半日, 我表妹以前都係呢度小學畢業, 成績好, 中學考入聖保羅男女, 聽佢講老師比較惡, 壓力都幾大
我係小朋友都會喜歡SSCPS, international school feeling, 老師好人又多野玩, 有時會去室外上課, ...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-14 17:04
I just received it today. The stamp chop is 12/12/2009.原帖由 Piaget 於 09-12-14 16:54 發表
Hi shusiusiu,
May I know when you receive the acceptance letter?
作者: Piaget 時間: 09-12-14 17:11
Congratulations and thank you for your reply.
By the way, both SSCPS and SH are good schools. But I'll prefer SH as I like traditional schools.
原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-14 17:04 發表
I just received it today. The stamp chop is 12/12/2009.
作者: reneeleung 時間: 09-12-14 17:39
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: CFaHB 時間: 09-12-14 18:54
好中肯
原帖由 fsforth 於 09-12-14 16:37 發表
聖心功課夠你做半日, 我表妹以前都係呢度小學畢業, 成績好, 中學考入聖保羅男女, 聽佢講老師比較惡, 壓力都幾大
我係小朋友都會喜歡SSCPS, international school feeling, 老師好人又多野玩, 有時會去室外上課, ...
作者: ellylau 時間: 09-12-14 19:21
Hi shusiusiu,
Headache..headache headache...
I have more or less same situation w. you..
I have already given up some choices..
now, SSCPS vs SHCS..... (we'll soon get the DGJS result too)
My gal likes SSCPS so much.... she tells everyone she chooses St. Stephen already...
作者: Sunglasses 時間: 09-12-14 21:50
My daughter is accepted too. Very headache to choose between Good Hope School and Sacred Heart. We live in West Kowloon so both schools are more or less the same in terms of distance. Both are traditional Catholics school with similar branding. Can anyone advise how many students are there in each a.m. class?
作者: fsforth 時間: 09-12-14 22:58
原帖由 ellylau 於 09-12-14 19:21 發表
Hi shusiusiu,
Headache..headache headache...
I have more or less same situation w. you..
I have already given up some choices..
now, SSCPS vs SHCS..... (we'll soon get the DGJS result too)
My gal ...
小朋友睇過 SSCPS 既 VCD 就多數會好喜歡間學校, 只計校園生活, 同聖心比真是一間渡假生活, 一間要做朝8晚11忙過不停, 家長角度一定想value for money and result oriented, 如果你真係選聖心, 最好同個女講清楚, at least, 要有心理準備.
作者: kcPooh 時間: 09-12-14 23:17
Hi Ellylau
If DGJS offers your daughter a place, would you have different selection?
原帖由 ellylau 於 09-12-14 19:21 發表
Hi shusiusiu,
Headache..headache headache...
I have more or less same situation w. you..
I have already given up some choices..
now, SSCPS vs SHCS..... (we'll soon get the DGJS result too)
My gal ...
作者: bkychan 時間: 09-12-14 23:31
My daughter is now studying P6 in SHCSPS. I keep on hearing people saying that SHCSPS has much homework and heavy workload.
I would like to say that this is not the case from my experience. On average, my daughter has only two or three assignments per day so she can finish them within an hour.
Regarding the half-day school matter, my daughter has her extracurricular activities in weekday afternoon so that we can have our family time on Saturday and Sunday.
I can see my daughter and her schoolmates having smiling faces.
原帖由 fsforth 於 09-12-14 22:58 發表
小朋友睇過 SSCPS 既 VCD 就多數會好喜歡間學校, 只計校園生活, 同聖心比真是一間渡假生活, 一間要做朝8晚11忙過不停, 家長角度一定想value for money and result oriented, 如果你真係選聖心, 最好同個女講清楚, ...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-15 00:19
Dear ellylau,
Honestly, I dare to let my girl to watch the VCD of SSCPS since I m afraid she insists to go to SSCPS if she watch the VCD.
For DGJS, I have given up already since I believe the chance is really too small for me to have a hope.
Actually, I was graduated from SHCS, n I was so scare to do homework too when I was at that age. From my memory, every schoolmate are very smart and clever, but not very nice. We were proud of to be "ST Sim Mui", but we were afraid of teachers (maybe respect) We had so many awards, yet we practice n practice n practice.
I do not know whether SHCS has changed or not since it was long time ago. I believe SHCS definitely is a good school, but I like the characteristic n culture of SSCPS. The most impt of all, my girl is really not that hardworking type.......
原帖由 ellylau 於 09-12-14 19:21 發表
Hi shusiusiu,
Headache..headache headache...
I have more or less same situation w. you..
I have already given up some choices..
now, SSCPS vs SHCS..... (we'll soon get the DGJS result too)
My gal ...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-15 00:26
Dear Sunglasses,
Both ar definitely good schools. However, I learned that SHCS seems like having a higher branding than Good Hope. Friend of mine have two daughters studing in Good Hope n she said the grading in Good Hope is declining n it's not as good as previous. (Don't know whether is ture or not). If the travel distance ar same, I may prefer SHCS. PPls said it's really hard to get in if your girl is not a kinder from SHCS.
原帖由 Sunglasses 於 09-12-14 21:50 發表
My daughter is accepted too. Very headache to choose between Good Hope School and Sacred Heart. We live in West Kowloon so both schools are more or less the same in terms of distance. Both are trad ...
作者: Sindy 時間: 09-12-15 01:52
唔通呢兩年小得咁西利,之前都同我朋友交流下,我聽到佢由小一開始到三四年班....都有五六樣一日..跟住呢兩年都唔得閒同佢傾呢d..而家咁輕鬆?原帖由 bkychan 於 09-12-14 23:31 發表
My daughter is now studying P6 in SHCSPS. I keep on hearing people saying that SHCSPS has much homework and heavy workload.
I would like to say that this is not the case from my experience. On aver ...
作者: Sindy 時間: 09-12-15 01:56
原帖由 reneeleung 於 09-12-14 17:39 發表
SH係非常傳統的修女學校.
AM SCH 頭100名入SHCC, PM SCH 頭80名入SHCC.
你呢個數字係穩入...仲有band2果堆好彩未計...下午班去好既學校(包括sh中學),約有百二人
作者: Sindy 時間: 09-12-15 01:58
早幾年,有個朋友個女由gh插到sh下午班五年班,入到黎成績一般,上唔返聖心中學添.....我諗佢唔叻又插唔到班,但叻入到黎成績又一般,好難解釋
作者: reneeleung 時間: 09-12-15 10:28
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: fsforth 時間: 09-12-15 11:30 標題: 回覆 22# reneeleung 的文章
其實好多名校課程程度都會高, 分別在教學方法, 和interview時老師選學生眼光如何.
我唔mind 學校比reject letter 我, 因為大家一早在interview之中已經知道係mismatch, 好過入到來先知頂唔住...
作者: justforfunmama 時間: 09-12-15 13:12
anyone recieved letter today? any waiting list?
作者: lui 時間: 09-12-15 13:38 標題: 回覆 1# shusiusiu 的文章
My girl studied at SHam last year. We changed to another private school this year. She isn't the type that getting outstanding result by "feeding" and "pushing". Though her result was not bad, but I can really see there will be no great improvement in the days after. The experience of mine and my friend tell is some kids can be pushed and some can't. Those couldnt be pushed is not identified to be "less smart", but they need another kind of interaction and education. If your kid is the latter, putting her in an traditional school will kill her fond of learning. That's really true. If you can afford, choose the one you believe your kid will enjoy rather than the one you believe their adcademic is guaranteed.
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-15 17:49
Dear Lui, Your reply is really why I m still struggling which school I should let her in. To me, I m also the one who experienced "feeding" n "pushing" learning environment. I know that the academic result will be fine anyway, but I (MAY) turn out stopping my girl's right brain development. May I know which private school your girl is currently studing?
原帖由 lui 於 09-12-15 13:38 發表
My girl studied at SHam last year. We changed to another private school this year. She isn't the type that getting outstanding result by "feeding" and "pushing". Though her result was not bad, but I ...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-15 17:51
Dear reneeleung,
May I know what is GS? Thank you very much.
原帖由 reneeleung 於 09-12-15 10:28 發表
我妹妹都是插班入shcs am, 當時是2百幾收2個, 結果要留班, 佢初初入到聖心真係做功課做到喊. 而且聖心讀書係讀高一級, 加上又轉英文GS. ANYWAY, 佢都聖心畢業了.
...
作者: ellylau 時間: 09-12-15 18:00
Hi shusiusiu,
Again, we have 1 more similarity.. 
I was graduated from one of the Canossian Schools in Kln. side. I do have special feelings and passion abt the Canossian schools, for sure. By the time we applied SHCS, we didn't enclose any portfolios or information abt I was once in the Canossian family. I just leave everything to God and believe he will take care of the rest.
I would say, after 1 night's thought and some friends' advice, I tend to buy SHCS more... I guess each family has its own concern and it seems like studying in SHCS is more feasible at this moment. I do really enjoy spending much time with my daughter and my hubby likes the idea of half day school a lot.
SSCPS is a kind of every kid's dream school...fresh air..close to the nature..good environment/atmosphere..
But we still can't figure out all the logistic arrangements. Moving or not..transportation...
Price of the properties these days has been rising a...lot..... Renting a place in HK South/HK East is so expensive too. I guess it's not wise to spend a year's tution fee per month (incl. housing, transportation, school fees. ECA fees) just to accomodate everything fit for her studying in SSCPS.... Well.. I hope we will make up our mind soon and we can release the seat to others asap.
作者: kidsmother 時間: 09-12-15 18:00
I am also considering to change to another school. Tests and dictations every week are really too much. My girl is really obedient, so she doesn't protest but only cries when her heart tells her there are still so many exercises she needs to do to get good marks. And I am like crazy buying exercises for her to practice and practice.
And I can't understang why our kids under local curricumlum need to do Chinese listening tests. We didn't learn to listen our mother tongue when we were kids, did we? As we grow up and interact normally with friends, we can learn to listen, right? Why need to put listening Cantonese in the formal curriculum? But in order for my girl to get good marks, I even need to buy those exercises on the market to let her practice. How sad!
原帖由 lui 於 09-12-15 13:38 發表
My girl studied at SHam last year. We changed to another private school this year. She isn't the type that getting outstanding result by "feeding" and "pushing". Though her result was not bad, but I ...
作者: ellylau 時間: 09-12-15 18:19
Hi kcPooh,
Well...chances of obtaining an offer fm DGJS is kind of low..
The competition is extrememly keen, I mean when studying inside...
I bet it's a really tiresome journey for striving an excellence at all time with your kid..... competing with the topguns in town at all time.. WOW)))) it's a BIG thing...
I am more than happy to be an ordinary, less pressured human being...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-15 19:00
For all similarity, what a conincident! I didn't inform the school that I was one of the old girl too!
I think I will have the same decision as yours. Let me tell you one more thing: I m living in Bonham Road which is very close to Caine Road. Regarding to my research n friends' advice, SHCS seems to be the best decisions for me. Maybe I should let my girl to sleep one hour more. Haha.
原帖由 ellylau 於 09-12-15 18:00 發表
Hi shusiusiu,
Again, we have 1 more similarity.. I was graduated from one of the Canossian Schools in Kln. side. I do have special feelings and passion abt the Canossian schools, for sure. ...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-15 19:01
Dear kidsmother,
Is your girl currently studing in SHCS? Do you give her plenty of ECA?
thank you very much!
原帖由 kidsmother 於 09-12-15 18:00 發表
I am also considering to change to another school. Tests and dictations every week are really too much. My girl is really obedient, so she doesn't protest but only cries when her heart tells her there ...
作者: ellylau 時間: 09-12-15 19:43
Hi Shusiusiu,
For your reference, (copy from other post)
2006年全港各區會考資料. 最近的資料暫時拿不到:
地區 學校 會考最佳六科平均分數
東區 張祝珊英文中學 22.8
庇理羅士女子中學 19.4
金文泰中學 18.4
香港中國婦女會中學 17
聖馬可中學 16.9
寶血女子中學 15.3
嘉諾撒書院 13.4
筲箕灣官立中學 11.5
灣仔 聖保祿中學 18.3
皇仁書院 17.4
聖保祿學校 17.1
嘉諾撒聖方濟各書院 16.7
瑪利曼中學 16
香港真光中學 15.4
何東中學 14.4
香港華仁書院 14.1
玫瑰崗學校 7
中西區 聖保羅男女中學 22.5
聖士提反女子中學 20.1
英皇書院 19.1
聖若瑟英文書院 18.8
英華女學校 16.8
聖類斯中學 16.6
聖嘉勒女書院 15.7
高主教書院 15.3
聖保羅書院 15
南區 嘉諾撒聖心書院 19.5
聖公會呂明才中學 18
香港真光書院 14.5
嘉諾撒培德書院 13.7
聖士提反書院 11.6
油尖旺 保良局莊啟程預科書院 21.4
拔萃女書院 20.3
嘉諾撒聖瑪利書院 19
循道中學 18.8
中華基督教會銘基書院 16.9
伊利沙伯中學 16.8
華仁書院（九龍） 16.7
真光女書院 15.2
深水土步 寶血會上智英文書院 20.1
長沙灣天主教英文中學 19.3
英華書院 18
中華基督教會銘賢書院 17.8
香島中學 17.3
瑪利諾神父教會學校 15.7
德雅中學 15
佛教大雄中學 13.6
聖母玫瑰書院 11.7
德貞女子中學 11.6
觀塘 聖言中學 21.5
觀塘官立中學 17.2
藍田聖保祿中學 16.7
聖傑靈女子中學 16
順利天主教中學 15
聖安當女書院 14.1
梁式芝書院 10.2
九龍城 拔萃男書院 22.2
喇沙書院 21.7
瑪利諾修院學校（中學部） 20.7
基督教女青年會丘佐榮中學 19.6
協恩中學 18.7
何文田官立中學 18.4
香港培正中學 17.9
旅港開平商會中學 17.3
民生書院 15.9
華英中學 15.7
九龍真光中學 15.6
東華三院黃笏南中學 14.9
香港培道中學 13.1
何明華會督銀禧中學 12.9
嘉諾撒聖家書院 12.2
迦密中學 12.1
黃大仙 保良局第一張永慶中學 22.5
可立中學（嗇色園主辦） 19.5
德望學校 17.4
中華基督教會協和書院 16.2
聖母書院 11.9
屯門 順德聯誼總會梁銶琚中學 21
保良局百周年李兆忠紀念中學 20.8
保良局董玉娣中學 17.9
南屯門官立中學 16.6
仁愛堂田家炳中學 16.6
屯門天主教中學 15.9
宣道中學 15.8
香港九龍塘基督教中華宣道會陳瑞芝紀念中學 14.1
作者: ellylau 時間: 09-12-15 19:46
Hi shusiusiu,
keep in touch and hope our daughters can be friends (good sisters)
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-15 19:55
Dear ellylau,
o yes, our girls may become schoolmate next year. let's keep in touch. May I know what kindergarten your girl is currently attend? Mine is St. Paul Church.
原帖由 ellylau 於 09-12-15 19:46 發表
Hi shusiusiu,
keep in touch and hope our daughters can be friends (good sisters)
作者: tweetyho 時間: 09-12-15 20:35
原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-15 00:26 發表
Dear Sunglasses,
Both ar definitely good schools. However, I learned that SHCS seems like having a higher branding than Good Hope. Friend of mine have two daughters studing in Good Hope n she said ...
the academic performance of SHCC (sec sch) is dropping rapidly these years..........
嘉諾撒聖心書院，升大學比率下跌
嘉諾撒聖心書院過往屬一線名校，升大學率超過九成，但近年成績不斷下滑，家長選校要小心選擇。
根據該校官方資料，中七畢業生升讀本地大學學位課程連年下跌，由高峰期九成大跌至五六成，整體已跌至Brand 2水平。而升讀IVE或副學士的中七畢業生，則不斷上升。
嘉諾撒聖心書院中七畢業生升讀本地大學學位課程：
2006年：90.82%
2007年：81.73%
2008年：56.48%
2009年：64.20%
嘉諾撒聖心書院中七畢業生升讀IVE / 副學士 / 其他非學位課程：
2006年：0%
2007年：13.43%
2008年：34.26%
2009年：22.10%
官方Report：
2006-2008 成績 - http://www.shcc.edu.hk/info/report0809/2.pdf (Page 20)
2009 成績 - http://www.shcc.edu.hk/info/report0809/2.pdf (Page 14)
[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 09-12-15 20:37 編輯 ]
作者: kidsmother 時間: 09-12-15 21:40 標題: 回覆 5# shusiusiu 的文章
normal activities - piano, ballet, swimming, kumon.
作者: fsforth 時間: 09-12-15 22:15
原帖由 tweetyho 於 09-12-15 20:35 發表
the academic performance of SHCC (sec sch) is dropping rapidly these years..........
嘉諾撒聖心書院，升大學比率下跌
嘉諾撒聖心書院過往屬一線名校，升大學率超過九成，但近年成績不斷下滑，家長選校要小心選擇。 ...
"谷" 得太盡...小學生仲會怕呀媽怕老師, 大個左就"hea"哂!
作者: Sunglasses 時間: 09-12-15 22:24 標題: 回覆 18# shusiusiu 的文章
Dear Shusiusiu,
Thanks for sharing. Even though my daughter is now studying in a traditional kindergarten, I'm still scared about the workload and pressure of Sacred Heart. Just wonder if a working mom (I personally am one) could be capable to cope with the workload, demand and expectation of the school.
Really need to deliberate, for choosing a suitable school for my daughter.
作者: bkychan 時間: 09-12-15 22:27
Sindy,
Not that heavy workload than I expect.
原帖由 Sindy 於 09-12-15 01:52 發表
唔通呢兩年小得咁西利,之前都同我朋友交流下,我聽到佢由小一開始到三四年班....都有五六樣一日..跟住呢兩年都唔得閒同佢傾呢d..而家咁輕鬆?
作者: tweetyho 時間: 09-12-15 23:08
原帖由 fsforth 於 09-12-15 22:15 發表
"谷" 得太盡...小學生仲會怕呀媽怕老師, 大個左就"hea"哂!
i think the reason is that top students are leaving SH for better schools such as St Paul co-ed, belilios, dgs etc......when they are promoting to sec sch
作者: rachaeltam 時間: 09-12-15 23:09
原帖由 reneeleung 於 09-12-15 10:28 發表
我妹妹都是插班入shcs am, 當時是2百幾收2個, 結果要留班, 佢初初入到聖心真係做功課做到喊. 而且聖心讀書係讀高一級, 加上又轉英文GS. ANYWAY, 佢都聖心畢業了.
...
I have a relative previously in SHCS am (not long ago). She seldom took long time to complete homework. Have not heard of 做功課做到喊, not to mention 朝8晚11忙過不停.
作者: bkychan 時間: 09-12-15 23:52
Tweetyho,
I agree with your comment. In last Satursday's Secondary School Places Allocation (SSPA) System briefing meeting, SHCSPS urged the parents of P6 students to choose SHCC as their first choice. It is sad to see the P6 students leaving the family.
原帖由 tweetyho 於 09-12-15 23:08 發表
i think the reason is that top students are leaving SH for better schools such as St Paul co-ed, belilios, dgs etc......when they are promoting to sec sch
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-16 00:05
a, so do I, my girl is learning piano, ballet, swimming n Kumon. All same. Haha
原帖由 kidsmother 於 09-12-15 21:40 發表
normal activities - piano, ballet, swimming, kumon.
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-16 00:17
Dear Sunglasses,
I m also a working mammy, n I think I will let her to go to tutorial class if I really can't take care of her homework.
原帖由 Sunglasses 於 09-12-15 22:24 發表
Dear Shusiusiu,
Thanks for sharing. Even though my daughter is now studying in a traditional kindergarten, I'm still scared about the workload and pressure of Sacred Heart. Just wonder if a working ...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-16 00:20
May I know why the P6 pupils are leaving ?
原帖由 bkychan 於 09-12-15 23:52 發表
Tweetyho,
I agree with your comment. In last Satursday's Secondary School Places Allocation (SSPA) System briefing meeting, SHCSPS urged the parents of P6 students to choose SHCC as their first choi ...
作者: tweetyho 時間: 09-12-16 01:37
原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-16 00:20 發表
May I know why the P6 pupils are leaving ?
coz it's obvious that SH 's academic performance is dropping tremendously these years......
top students of course leaving la..........for better schools .....
作者: kidsmother 時間: 09-12-16 10:06
Do you have any idea why their academic performance (HKCEE results) is getting worse?
原帖由 tweetyho 於 09-12-16 01:37 發表
coz it's obvious that SH 's academic performance is dropping tremendously these years......
top students of course leaving la..........for better schools .....
作者: tweetyho 時間: 09-12-16 10:47
原帖由 kidsmother 於 09-12-16 10:06 發表
Do you have any idea why their academic performance (HKCEE results) is getting worse?
i think that's a vicious cycle:
top students leave --> results getting worse
--> more students leave
may be schools of southern districts are less popular .... coz it's a bit far away, unless u are living there .... top students in hk island have a few more better choices like St paul co-ed, belilios and ying wa... rather than SH
and most of the schools in southern districts are of band 2 or 3... (as many parents are working parents .... they dont have time to care much about there children w.r.t. their academic work)
... i think the overall standard of SH is lowered by some of these students ......
[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 09-12-16 10:58 編輯 ]
作者: Elsat 時間: 09-12-16 13:56
My kid is just in PN. Now, I'm going to select appropirate K1 for her.
I'm a SH (primary) old girl and I entered BPS (secondary) then evetually HKUST. My path sounds great but my career achievement is just so so (neither lawyer, doctor nor CPA).
I always repeatedly remind myself that school education is just one of the tools to equip my girl but I can't stop worrying 
since I'm a mother, a very sacred title.
Is SH still a top school? Do I need to let her join GH instead? BIG HEADACHE..
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-16 14:54
Dear Tweetyho,
Do you like the academic result is getting worse because of the Sec Sch is not DSS? What I mean is she is still a subsidized sec sch n have no right to select P6 pupils?
What we ar going to face is 12 years later. There is no more HKCEE. No one will know how's the schools result in the future. If that so, should I choose SSCPS rather than SHCS?
原帖由 tweetyho 於 09-12-16 10:47 發表
i think that's a vicious cycle:
top students leave --> results getting worse
--> more students leave
may be schools of southern districts are less popular .... coz it's a bit far away, unless u are ...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-16 14:55
May I know what is GH?
原帖由 Elsat 於 09-12-16 13:56 發表
My kid is just in PN. Now, I'm going to select appropirate K1 for her.
I'm a SH (primary) old girl and I entered BPS (secondary) then evetually HKUST. My path sounds great but my career achievement ...
作者: tweetyho 時間: 09-12-16 22:47
原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-16 14:54 發表
Dear Tweetyho,
Do you like the academic result is getting worse because of the Sec Sch is not DSS? What I mean is she is still a subsidized sec sch n have no right to select P6 pupils?
What we ar ...
I dont think so ..... coz BPS, QC, SJC and some traditional famous sch on kln side are not DSS... but still they can sustain their academic level ...
i think i would choose SH ... coz it's in central (save travelling time)
and she can change to St Paul co-ed, BPS or Ying Wing etc later if she is capable of
作者: bkychan 時間: 09-12-17 00:04
Below are the HKCEE 2009 examination results of the named schools:
| School | 2009 |
| 英文 5* % | 中文 5* % | 人均A | 人均優良率 | 今年6科14分佔 |
| 嘉諾撒聖心書院 | 11.4% | 10.4% | | | 85.1% |
| 庇理羅士女子中學 | 19.7% | 8.6% | 1.20 | 5.20 | 82.3% |
| 英華女學校 | | | | | 80.4% |
| 聖保羅男女書院 | 30.0% | 22.0% | 2.22 | 6.80 | |
原帖由 tweetyho 於 09-12-16 22:47 發表
I dont think so ..... coz BPS, QC, SJC and some traditional famous sch on kln side are not DSS... but still they can sustain their academic level ...
i think i would choose SH ... coz it's in cent ...
作者: tweetyho 時間: 09-12-17 00:54
原帖由 bkychan 於 09-12-17 00:04 發表
Below are the HKCEE 2009 examination results of the named schools:
School 2009英文 5* %中文 5* %人均A人均優良率今年6科14分佔嘉諾撒聖心書院 11.4%10.4% 85.1%庇理羅士女子中學 19. ...
so ur conclusion is ? ..........
i know this year SPCC has about 88% of students getting 14 pts or above ......
and that last year SH only got 70% of students with 14 pts or above
seems that there is not sufficient data for comparing ying wa
i think SPCC is the best among all ........
BPS has better results than SH and YW .... esp for science stream
% in 6科14分資料(2008)
%
79.50 寶血會上智英文書院
85.90 庇理羅士女子中學
88.40 張祝珊英文中學
71.08 嘉諾撒聖心書院
79.10 聖士提反女子中學
75.90 聖若瑟英文書院
82.50 皇仁書院
81.00 瑪利曼中學
75.80 嘉諾撒聖方濟各書院
71.00 喇沙書院
74.00 保良局第一張永慶中學
79.20 聖公會林護紀念中學
87.70 道教聯合會鄧顯紀念中學
85.40 聖公會曾肇添中學
78.70 沙田崇真中學
78.60 浸信會呂明才中學
75.00 沙田培英中學
93.60 聖保羅男女中學
74.00 拔萃男書院
85.50 英華女學校
86.60 嘉諾撒聖瑪利書院
75.00 伊利沙伯中學
[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 09-12-17 01:04 編輯 ]
作者: wootaitai 時間: 09-12-17 09:15
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: tweetyho 時間: 09-12-17 10:37
原帖由 wootaitai 於 09-12-17 09:15 發表
Can you share what is the source of the information?
in other posts ......
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-17 15:42
Apart from travel time, money is also a big concern.($55000 Vs 22000)
Regarding to the trend, does anyone think that SH may possibly change from half day to full day school in futures?
If my girl studing in a half day school, I may need to arrange ECA or tutorial class for my girl since I m a working mammy. Can anyone tell me how much will the tutorial class be?
Really thanks for your help!
原帖由 tweetyho 於 09-12-16 22:47 發表
I dont think so ..... coz BPS, QC, SJC and some traditional famous sch on kln side are not DSS... but still they can sustain their academic level ...
i think i would choose SH ... coz it's in cent ...
作者: manling33 時間: 09-12-17 16:00
$22000 half day in fact imply $44,000 for a whole day.
原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-17 15:42 發表
Apart from travel time, money is also a big concern.($55000 Vs 22000)
Regarding to the trend, does anyone think that SH may possibly change from half day to full day school in futures?
If my girl ...
作者: vienpa 時間: 09-12-17 18:06
原帖由 wootaitai 於 09-12-17 09:15 發表
Can you share what is the source of the information?
The source is consolidated by me after viewing the school webs and here.. BK 升中派位
http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=2141081&extra=page%3D1&page=1
If you spend hours to review all the posts, you will know more about the current status of Secondary School...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-17 18:33
Dear manling,
Yes, u ar right. Do you think that the ECA if studing in SH will cost more than SSCPS?
原帖由 manling33 於 09-12-17 16:00 發表
$22000 half day in fact imply $44,000 for a whole day.
作者: brendaliu 時間: 09-12-17 19:18
Do anyone know how many outsiders would be accepted by SH (private section ) in the past year?
What is the chance for waiting list candidates?
Many thx
[ 本帖最後由 brendaliu 於 09-12-17 19:24 編輯 ]
作者: bkychan 時間: 09-12-17 20:40
Tweetyho,
The table that I've posted regarding the HKCEE 2009 Examination Results for the named school is to echo your statement saying that "it's obvious that SH's academic performance is dropping tremendously these years."
Below information is obtained from SHCC's Annual Report:
| 6科14分佔 |
| Year 2006 | 79% |
| Year 2007 | 81% |
| Year 2008 | 71% |
| Year 2009 | 85% |
If most of the top SHCS P6 students can go to SHCC, SHCC can perform even better.
Some of my information can be found in
《明報 10/11升中選校全攻略》
原帖由 tweetyho 於 09-12-17 00:54 發表
so ur conclusion is ? ..........
i know this year SPCC has about 88% of students getting 14 pts or above ......
and that last year SH only got 70% of students with 14 pts or above
seems that th ...
作者: panbaby 時間: 09-12-17 21:46
應該這樣想, 聖心是津校, 一方面受政府派位, 一方面又特別照顧自己的幼稚園, 小學的學生, 其中當然會有好有不好, 不似其他沒有小學的名校, 可以左選右選......
另外, 聖心是女校, 我想文科是較多人讀, 文科的成積當較理科難取A, B, C...
從我的觀察, 以前聖心 (現在都做了阿媽, 不過本人不是) 和現在聖心的差別不是很大, 以前在家長的心目中是排在那幾間之下 (如女拔, Marymount, Maryknoll, 聖保祿等), 現在的ranking 也差不多, 小六走也都是走去那幾間, 對不對?
今天我見到的聖心學生, 給我的印象仍是乖乖女, 多數是斯文的, 和以前分別不大, 這足以証明聖心的硬件不錯, 入這學校就會有這類型的學生.
事實上, 我在親子王國, 很少見人批評聖心, 身邊讀聖心的小女孩, 讀聖心都很開心的, 半途離開聖心私小的都是頂不住學業壓力, 但即使如此, 她們也不會罵聖心, 因為我想這學校是又嚴但又有愛心...
原帖由 bkychan 於 09-12-17 20:40 發表
Tweetyho,
The table that I've posted regarding the HKCEE 2009 Examination Results for the named school is to echo your statement saying that "it's obvious that SH's academic performance is dropping t ...
作者: tweetyho 時間: 09-12-17 22:42
原帖由 panbaby 於 09-12-17 21:46 發表
應該這樣想, 聖心是津校, 一方面受政府派位, 一方面又特別照顧自己的幼稚園, 小學的學生, 其中當然會有好有不好, 不似其他沒有小學的名校, 可以左選右選......
另外, 聖心是女校, 我想文科是較多人讀, 文科的成積當 ...
some ppl said that SH's performance is declining ...
that's true .... and i've seen a few such posts b4 ...
it's not as top as st paul co-ed , bps etc....
but u may say that SH is a gd school ... regarding to the sense of belonging SH gals have ... to their sch ...
though some ppl leave every year for st paul co-ed, bps, dgs and ywgs ....
many students remaining there love their school and enjoying going to school
according to previous analysis, the top ten traditional famous schools are (w.r.t to HKCEE results of recent years):
1. st paul co-ed
2. La salle, DBS, QC, St Joseph
3. Maryknoll, BPS, St Mary's, DGS, St Paul convent
[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 09-12-17 23:24 編輯 ]
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-17 23:40
Dear bkychan
May I ask how much Extra Cirrucular activities the girls normally have after their schools? Do most of the girls have tutorial classes after school?
原帖由 bkychan 於 09-12-17 20:40 發表
Tweetyho,
The table that I've posted regarding the HKCEE 2009 Examination Results for the named school is to echo your statement saying that "it's obvious that SH's academic performance is dropping t ...
作者: panbaby 時間: 09-12-17 23:59
聖心是女校, 只能以女校與之比較, 在我的年代是這幾間較前, 在今天亦是, 而與皇仁聖Joseph, co-ed 比較是沒有意思的, 因它們是男校且理科強...
會考成績的高低年年不同, 不必太介意, 品格修為才重要, 我雖不是讀聖心, 但亦可看出tweetyho 對聖心的投入及愛護...
我亦相信樓主會有自己的好選擇, 畢竟這不是討論聖心成績的題目...
原帖由 tweetyho 於 09-12-17 22:42 發表
some ppl said that SH's performance is declining ...
that's true .... and i've seen a few such posts b4 ...
it's not as top as st paul co-ed , bps etc....
but u may say that SH is a gd school ... ...
作者: bkychan 時間: 09-12-18 00:16
Shusiusiu,
My daughter doesn't join the ECA provided by SHCSPS. Since this is a half-day school, my girl's after-school activities are in week-day afternoon.
I have no statistics on how much Extra Cirrucular activities the girls normally have after their schools. But like other children in Hong Kong, it is common in SHCSPS to have after-school activities. My daughter has four. SHCSPS is not pushy on either ECA or getting inter-school competition awards.
原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-17 23:40 發表
Dear bkychan
May I ask how much Extra Cirrucular activities the girls normally have after their schools? Do most of the girls have tutorial classes after school?
作者: panbaby 時間: 09-12-18 00:35
半日有一個好的地方是她有很多時間做功課讀書....
原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-14 16:19 發表
Dear fsforth, I agree with you. However, Sacred Heart is only half day school which mean I have to arrange the afternoon activities for her. This may turn out spending more thanSSCPS. These two sc ...
作者: shusiusiu 時間: 09-12-18 00:40
Thank you for all of your information. It really help me to choose.
作者: Bon_Bon_Pa_Pa 時間: 09-12-19 21:22
Can someone advise when is the registration date of P1?
作者: rachaeltam 時間: 09-12-20 00:03
原帖由 panbaby 於 09-12-17 21:46 發表
...從我的觀察, ..., 以前在家長的心目中是排在那幾間之下 (如.,Marymount, Maryknoll, 聖保祿等), 現在的ranking 也差不多, 小六走也都是走去那幾間, 對不對?...
相信這是你的想法，其他家長是否如你所說，個人就覺得是見仁見智。你可以翻閱 http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=2141081&extra=page%3D1 的數據分析再作比較，聖心是在Band 1頭學校的前列，並不遜於這些學校。事實上，聖心的透明度是值得欣賞，可以從學校的網站找到幾年來的資料。我不是想引起爭辯，祗是覺得這說法對聖心的學生有點不公。
[ 本帖最後由 rachaeltam 於 09-12-20 00:05 編輯 ]
作者: tweetyho 時間: 09-12-20 00:52
w.r.t to university admission rate and the number of students eligible for early admission (hkcee > 6As), SH really can't compared with those top girl schools .....
and it's very true that some top students leave every year....
http://www.shcsps.edu.hk/download/2008-09p6-f1.pdf
for BPS, St Paul co-ed, DGS and YWGS
[ 本帖最後由 tweetyho 於 09-12-20 00:53 編輯 ]
作者: panbaby 時間: 09-12-20 02:01
是, 對不起, 完全是個人意見.
作者: Sunglasses 時間: 09-12-20 11:25
16 Jan 2010 a.m.
原帖由 Bon_Bon_Pa_Pa 於 09-12-19 21:22 發表
Can someone advise when is the registration date of P1?
作者: Sindy 時間: 09-12-21 01:10
原帖由 panbaby 於 09-12-17 21:46 發表
應該這樣想, 聖心是津校, 一方面受政府派位, 一方面又特別照顧自己的幼稚園, 小學的學生, 其中當然會有好有不好, 不似其他沒有小學的名校, 可以左選右選......
另外, 聖心是女校, 我想文科是較多人讀, 文科的成積當 ...
半途離開的我想大部份不是頂不住學業壓力,我聽到的都是考到另一所程度差唔多但唔駛比錢既學校,一係就程度差唔多但全日制既學校,咁耐以黎,我只聽到一至兩個係個女讀唔掂的,十幾人都係因為唔駛比錢同全日制而走
作者: lui 時間: 09-12-23 15:59
Dear Shusiusiu,
Sorry that I didn't online for weeks.
And I have read some of your recent posts.
My girl changes to CKY this year. I can REALLY tell the difference between two schools cos I had come across with these two. My girl is proceeding quite well here. Of course, she still need to work harder in her English even though SH English is one year advanced. What I am saying is that it really bothers which kind of kid your daughter is. The recent change (last year) in the assessment form really bothers. That's why some mum here complains and almost can't afford being pushed days after days. Be frank, I didn't send my girl to have ECA other than Maths when she was with SH. She simply did not have enough time to do so. Maybe it was because she was P1 at that time and taking quite much time to do homework (she writes slowly and sometimes got distract from other things). Then we have to revise with her everyday to get her prepared for the quizzes every week. But of course, there are still a lot of brilliant students who can play hard and study hard getting very good result. But my girl isn't the one among them. So being parent, we should choose the best for our kid and NOT choose the BEST school.
I have a friend who have two kids, the daughter is so smart that being accepted by almost all the top schools in P1. She finally choose SPXX because she has a younger son. Having silbling will enchance the chance of being admitted when the little brother admit to P1. The little brother finally failed and even failed in ALL the school applications. Actually they do predict the result as they know well about their son, of course, they are worried and sad of the result but they have to face it. Now they are checking with the international school. They know even the son is lucky enough to be admitted, he may not able to do well under the traditional education system. SInce you still have time to choose and think, doing it seriously (don't too rely on the secondary school result as it is too remote in this stage!)
原帖由 shusiusiu 於 09-12-15 17:49 發表
Dear Lui, Your reply is really why I m still struggling which school I should let her in. To me, I m also the one who experienced "feeding" n "pushing" learning environment. I know that the academic ...
作者: lui 時間: 09-12-23 16:10
Hi Kidsmother,
Really understand how you feel. Personally i would see the listening in Chi is fair as it tests their listening skills (if you can hear the main points) rather than the listening proficiency/ability in cantonese.
I understand some of the girls are studying happily but some are not (like the girls I know, some is 1 form higher than my girl). If you want to change, prepare it for now as most of the schools starts the insert student application during may to june each year. Add oil!
原帖由 kidsmother 於 09-12-15 18:00 發表
I am also considering to change to another school. Tests and dictations every week are really too much. My girl is really obedient, so she doesn't protest but only cries when her heart tells her there ...
作者: kidsmother 時間: 09-12-23 22:02
I already have plan to change my daughter's school.
Actually, I think it's really waste of time to have the listening section. Since Cantonese is already our mother tongue, will spending time on "training" our kids to listen to machine help them be a good listener? Shouldn't our kids' education be more inspiring?
I have been requested by the teacher to buy exercises on the market and give her more training on skills in doing the listening tests.
If time is used on the listening tests, why don't we use the time on letting her interact with real people and friends?
I just wonder if other countries include listening to mother tongue "twisted" conversation on machine in their curriculum for their kids.
原帖由 lui 於 09-12-23 16:10 發表
Hi Kidsmother,
Really understand how you feel. Personally i would see the listening in Chi is fair as it tests their listening skills (if you can hear the main points) rather than the listening prof ...
作者: 加油站 時間: 09-12-29 16:35
sorry, del
[ 本帖最後由 加油站 於 09-12-29 17:33 編輯 ]
作者: AhiruNoPekk 時間: 09-12-29 17:00
Hi Sindy,
Have something to seek for your valuable advice.
Could you please check PM? Many Thanks
原帖由 Sindy 於 09-12-21 01:10 發表
半途離開的我想大部份不是頂不住學業壓力,我聽到的都是考到另一所程度差唔多但唔駛比錢既學校,一係就程度差唔多但全日制既學校,咁耐以黎,我只聽到一至兩個係個女讀唔掂的,十幾人都係因為唔駛比錢同全日制而走 ...
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |