教育王國

標題: 「升呢」「降呢」是怎樣計的？ [打印本頁]

作者: b-7 時間: 09-12-14 09:53 標題: 「升呢」「降呢」是怎樣計的？

看來不似與 Banding 有直接關聯！

求教有識者！

作者: nicholasmom 時間: 09-12-14 15:23

原帖由 b-7 於 09-12-14 09:53 發表
看來不似與 Banding 有直接關聯！

求教有識者！

It need over 85% of the student last year which is in the top 40% of Hong Kong. (Band 1 is 33%).

A class have 36 students, therefore, it need 36 X 85% = 30.6 students to open a English class. If a school said that it can have 2 English classes, that means it have 71 students in the top 40%. if an EMI school have 5 classes. it need at least 36X5X85%=153 students which is in the top 40% to maintain all English classes.

作者: b-7 時間: 09-12-14 17:08

又有疑問：

1. 據說 banding 是分區計算的，不是全港劃一的，例如中西區的 band I 學生就遠優於北區的。這點有計算在內嗎？

2. 以郭得勝為例，「降呢」是因為去年收了大量 band II 學生，以一間英中來說，以英中學位數量與 band I 學生數量來比較，這是難以置信的。真有這樣的可能嗎？

原帖由 nicholasmom 於 09-12-14 15:23 發表

It need over 85% of the student last year which is in the top 40% of Hong Kong. (Band 1 is 33%).

A class have 36 students, therefore, it need 36 X 85% = 30.6 students to open a English class. If a ...

作者: tictactoe 時間: 09-12-14 17:26

banding 分網內及全港2種。

「升呢」「降呢」是講全港最佳40%

沙田英中多，學生少，郭得勝是沙田英中尾，自然收不足5班x85% 全港最佳40%學生。

原帖由 b-7 於 09-12-14 17:08 發表
又有疑問：

1. 據說 banding 是分區計算的，不是全港劃一的，例如中西區的 band I 學生就遠優於北區的。這點有計算在內嗎？

2. 以郭得勝為例，「降呢」是因為去年收了大量 band II 學生，以一間英中來說，以英中學位數量與 b ...

作者: b-7 時間: 09-12-14 18:23

明白了。謝謝！

原帖由 tictactoe 於 09-12-14 17:26 發表
banding 分網內及全港2種。

「升呢」「降呢」是講全港最佳40%

沙田英中多，學生少，郭得勝是沙田英中尾，自然收不足5班x85% 全港最佳40%學生。

作者: peelychu 時間: 09-12-16 16:20

Thank you for your explanation. That means a school would like to accept as many band 1 students as possible in order to maintain their English classes. In such case, I'm afraid that most schools will not accept a student who is studying in a primary school that is not taking part in the SSPA system (they do not have a banding). Is that true?

[ 本帖最後由 peelychu 於 09-12-16 16:22 編輯 ]

作者: mattsmum 時間: 09-12-16 23:14

what sort of school are not in the SSPA system?

is DSS restricted by the % too?

原帖由 peelychu 於 09-12-16 16:20 發表
Thank you for your explanation. That means a school would like to accept as many band 1 students as possible in order to maintain their English classes. In such case, I'm afraid that most schools wi ...

作者: nicholasmom 時間: 09-12-16 23:19

原帖由 mattsmum 於 09-12-16 23:14 發表
what sort of school are not in the SSPA system?

is DSS restricted by the % too?

No, DSS have their own rights to choose teaching language. You can see some Band 3 DSS teaching in English.

作者: mattsmum 時間: 09-12-16 23:22

maybe governement wants more DSS school?

原帖由 nicholasmom 於 09-12-16 23:19 發表

No, DSS have their own rights to choose teaching language. You can see some Band 3 DSS teaching in English.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)