教育王國

標題: 民生 vs St Catherine [打印本頁]

作者: red888 時間: 09-12-13 02:54 標題: 民生 vs St Catherine

小女係 07年12月細女, 有幸收到民生同 St Catherine 嘅 am offer

宜家煩緊點揀...

有冇 mami 可以比下意見 ?

many thanks

作者: kmingc 時間: 09-12-13 08:51

me too. mu son also accepted by 民生and st catherine. i don't know how to choose. my target is la salle primary school becasue i have 25 maarks. as i know 民生 hte academia is easy and easy adapt for primary school. the school fee is reasonable. on the other hand st catherine is expensive and is eacy for adapt for primary school?

作者: NICOLE123 時間: 09-12-13 19:47

原帖由 kmingc 於 09-12-13 08:51 發表
me too. mu son also accepted by 民生and st catherine. i don't know how to choose. my target is la salle primary school becasue i have 25 maarks. as i know 民生 hte academia is easy and easy adapt for ...

如果你有25分入LA SALLE 你要打聽下係唔係一定入到
如果係緊係讀SC 啦打好個底
入左MS 好唔SURE有無得玩計分.大抽獎就一定無得玩

作者: mandor 時間: 09-12-13 20:04

Is it 入 LA SALLE by 大抽獎? the location of address is more important than which kindergarten your kid is studying?

作者: NICOLE123 時間: 09-12-13 20:28

原帖由 mandor 於 09-12-13 20:04 發表
Is it 入 LA SALLE by 大抽獎? the location of address is more important than which kindergarten your kid is studying?

佢有25分就唔係大抽獎啦

作者: joanne1231 時間: 09-12-14 00:04

原帖由 red888 於 09-12-13 02:54 發表
小女係 07年12月細女, 有幸收到民生同 St Catherine 嘅 am offer

宜家煩緊點揀...

有冇 mami 可以比下意見 ?

many thanks

我都好想知ar!
我同老公唔係名校出身，又唔係住九龍塘，又無宗教分，讀SC好似只係打好基礎，等報真資小学，值得嗎？

作者: WillBmama 時間: 09-12-14 00:53

原帖由 joanne1231 於 09-12-14 00:04 發表

我都好想知ar!
我同老公唔係名校出身，又唔係住九龍塘，又無宗教分，讀SC好似只係打好基礎，等報真資小学，值得嗎？

我同你情況一樣, 諗緊三年後又如何呢??

作者: fatma2222 時間: 09-12-14 10:32

many say those direct school are easy as they don't want their kindergarten kids go anywhere else
so if you want La Salle best go for St Cat to have good foundation otherwise wasted your kid at easy school and even you can get in La Salle and will have difficult time adapting and end up can't catch up with primary cirruculum ..

作者: gigi1020 時間: 09-12-14 11:34

原帖由 kmingc 於 09-12-13 08:51 發表
me too. mu son also accepted by 民生and st catherine. i don't know how to choose. my target is la salle primary school becasue i have 25 maarks. as i know 民生 hte academia is easy and easy adapt for ...

sorry, 請問係點計分架? 因我不懂大抽獎 / in 直資係點? 係咪有d學校, 例如munsang, puiching係咪無得大抽獎? thanks...

作者: KennyDaddy 時間: 09-12-14 11:46

I think only the parents can tell whether it's worthwhile, considering the distance, school fee, etc...

However, there must be reasons why there are thousands of parents making their choices to send their child to those kg ever year.

原帖由 joanne1231 於 09-12-14 00:04 發表

我都好想知ar!
我同老公唔係名校出身，又唔係住九龍塘，又無宗教分，讀SC好似只係打好基礎，等報真資小学，值得嗎？

作者: red888 時間: 09-12-14 16:47

sorry, mine is girl, is SC a better chance to go to DGS??

Can anyone tell me the P.1 school distribution from SC ?

作者: conniew117 時間: 09-12-14 16:56

The better chance KG to DGS should be CCKG.

原帖由 red888 於 09-12-14 16:47 發表
sorry, mine is girl, is SC a better chance to go to DGS??

Can anyone tell me the P.1 school distribution from SC ?

作者: mow-mow 時間: 09-12-14 17:12

Since kmingc has 25 points for La Salle (25 points is practically a sure win situation as I have never heard of anyone failing to win a place with 25 points in any school!), it makes sense for him to choose SC as he doesn't have to worry about primary 1 application.
But if you don't have a sure win place in a good primary school, it is worth thinking about MS ahead of SC as you can have a decent school in hand & can still try your luck applying to a top school like St Paul Co-ed or DGS.
SC may be able to prepare your kid a little bit better academically so that they may be able to do a little bit better at interviews when it comes to primary school application, but there really is no guarantee.
With >600 kids in SC's K3 classes each year, they can't possibly all get into top schools.
So it is up to you to play safe going to MS or take a gamble going to SC.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)