教育王國

標題: 根德園VS德望....邊間好? [打印本頁]

作者: bb.ma 時間: 09-12-7 20:47 標題: 根德園VS德望....邊間好?

我BB係女,兩間都收左,我唔知邊間好?

1)根德園:校風一向好好,教育小朋友品格正合我心,但無一條龍,三年後要再搏.頭痛! 2)德望: 有一條龍,小學&中學都OK,但年年都要比學費,都貴嫁

其實我仲想去試下"協恩",希望各位於MAMA比D意見!!

THANKS

作者: saiwai 時間: 09-12-7 21:44

假如3間都收我會先選根德或協恩

作者: bb.ma 時間: 09-12-7 21:58

假如3間都收我會先選根德或協恩 [/quote]

請問點解?

作者: princess_sumyin 時間: 09-12-7 22:24

你想唔想三年之後黎過先?如果唔想,當然是GH。如果你冇所謂,就KV 啦!For我自己,我好怕好怕呢d面試遊戲,所以我會選擇一條龍,因為考小學競爭更大,我有d朋友為左個女考小學成日訓唔著,小朋友同大人壓力都好大

作者: babe725 時間: 09-12-7 22:37

原帖由 bb.ma 於 09-12-7 20:47 發表
我BB係女,兩間都收左,我唔知邊間好?

1)根德園:校風一向好好,教育小朋友品格正合我心,但無一條龍,三年後要再搏.頭痛! 2)德望: 有一條龍,小學&中學都OK,但年年都要比學費, ...

的確好難決定。我同你都一樣，GH收咗，另SC同根德都收埋，（SC同KV，較喜歡SC），CONCERN同你一樣，另外重有個妹妹，好似GH比較穩陣D，第日妹妹入GH可能有PREFERENCE，但又唔知第一年辦幼稚園如何，真係好煩啊！

作者: BB0407 時間: 09-12-7 22:42

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Yorkie 時間: 09-12-7 22:51

Me too....I gave up the seat at St Cat (not an easy decision) and go for GH too but I am sure we will not regret in the future!

作者: BB0407 時間: 09-12-7 23:04

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: jl118 時間: 09-12-7 23:06

原帖由 Yorkie 於 09-12-7 22:51 發表
Me too....I gave up the seat at St Cat (not an easy decision) and go for GH too but I am sure we will not regret in the future!

me three

作者: Yorkie 時間: 09-12-7 23:11

BB0407 and jl118, Besides, we can always apply other school in primary with less pressure since we already got an offer on hand. I read some thread in BK who mentioned that some of the CCKG and St. Cat girls finally apply for GH in primary so what's the point of giving it up now????

作者: babe725 時間: 09-12-7 23:13

原帖由 jl118 於 09-12-7 23:06 發表

me three

I don't know whether I will be the "me four" or not!

作者: jl118 時間: 09-12-7 23:15

原帖由 Yorkie 於 09-12-7 23:11 發表
BB0407 and jl118, Besides, we can always apply other school in primary with less pressure since we already got an offer on hand. I read some thread in BK who mentioned that some of the CCKG and St. ...

I think I will give up GH only when I got the offer from SH or SPK

[ 本帖最後由 jl118 於 09-12-7 23:31 編輯 ]

作者: Yorkie 時間: 09-12-7 23:17

I will only give up GH if I got an offer from SPK too!

作者: smartmatt 時間: 09-12-7 23:18

原帖由 Yorkie 於 09-12-7 22:51 發表
Me too....I gave up the seat at St Cat (not an easy decision) and go for GH too but I am sure we will not regret in the future!

You will not regret in 3 yrs time. The odds of getting a school in 3 yrs time will be very small given the number of golden piggies...

作者: Yorkie 時間: 09-12-7 23:20

Yes, smartmatt, this is what I think too.....the competition is really keen for 07 babies!!!

原帖由 smartmatt 於 09-12-7 23:18 發表

You will not regret in 3 yrs time. The odds of getting a school in 3 yrs time will be very small given the number of golden piggies...

作者: bb.ma 時間: 09-12-7 23:48

我自己心大心細, 兩間都比$660先,但心中GH機會高D,因怕三年後個女唔夠人地FIGHT,三年後再無大B優勢!!!

作者: kl1234 時間: 09-12-7 23:51

德望可guarantee小學的學位
where you find this inf???

作者: smartmatt 時間: 09-12-7 23:54

原帖由 kl1234 於 09-12-7 23:51 發表
德望可guarantee小學的學位
where you find this inf???

I'm sure GH p kids will have the advantage, its in the interest of GH otherwise it will loose some of its appeal.

I think HY S give preference to its P kids when knocking on door.

作者: bb.ma 時間: 09-12-7 23:55

請問SH & SPK 係乜學校?

I think I will give up GH only when I got the offer from SH or SPK

[/quote]

作者: smartmatt 時間: 09-12-7 23:58

原帖由 Yorkie 於 09-12-7 23:20 發表
Yes, smartmatt, this is what I think too.....the competition is really keen for 07 babies!!!

My kid is boy otherwise I will choose GH without thinking twice. Competition for KG is so keen the odds are 10:1 for best KGs, think in 3 yr time the odds will be 30:1 for girls/ boy school as P schools usually only take on 120 kids.

作者: Yorkie 時間: 09-12-8 00:02

If I have boy, I wish he can study in KV!

作者: smartmatt 時間: 09-12-8 00:25

原帖由 Yorkie 於 09-12-8 00:02 發表
If I have boy, I wish he can study in KV!

Me too, luckily he got the offer from KV which we will definitely take up.

作者: Yorkie 時間: 09-12-8 09:49

Congratulations!

作者: share123 時間: 09-12-8 10:20

原帖由 kl1234 於 09-12-7 23:51 發表
德望可guarantee小學的學位
where you find this inf???

面試前既講座講,佢地係要辦一條龍學校.有家長打過電話,學校話自己學生不需參加面試,會內部評核.其實,小學的位有225個,比幼稚園180個多,不用擔心不收,除非個女有好大問題啦,否則,近水樓臺,唔會需要同出面d人一樣爭得甘慘

作者: Bert 時間: 09-12-8 10:36

原帖由 jl118 於 09-12-7 23:15 發表

I think I will give up GH only when I got the offer from SH or SPK

May I know your reason for choosing SH or SPK rather than GH ? Thanks

作者: ysnmama 時間: 09-12-8 10:38

兩者中一定選德望幼稚園. 因為等同已經步入了德望小學了.

作者: share123 時間: 09-12-8 11:01

SH學費平,因為可以用學券,小學私校可以留位,小學學費都平d. 不過德望個校舍好明顯好好多,又新又大. SH每日都要小朋友行好多樓梯先入到學校.

作者: yin725 時間: 09-12-8 13:14

Actually, I just know many people said SPK and SH are good school.

But how good are they? Why do you will to give up GH after you got the offer from them? Thanks.

原帖由 jl118 於 09-12-7 23:15 發表

I think I will give up GH only when I got the offer from SH or SPK

作者: jl118 時間: 09-12-8 13:48

原帖由 bb.ma 於 09-12-7 23:55 發表
請問SH & SPK 係乜學校?

I think I will give up GH only when I got the offer from SH or SPK

[/quote]
SH-聖心
SPK-聖保祿

作者: jl118 時間: 09-12-8 14:13

原帖由 yin725 於 09-12-8 13:14 發表
Actually, I just know many people said SPK and SH are good school.

But how good are they? Why do you will to give up GH after you got the offer from them? Thanks.

Hi yin725 & Bert,
我覺得三間學校係校風同成績方面都好好，有幸入到邊間都係好的開始

SPK & SH有學卷，中小學學費較GH平
SPK係英文小學
公開考試SPK 同 SH平均成績好似好GH少少 (pls correct me if I am wrong)
GH第一年幼稚園，師資(經驗)唔肯定
location我較喜歡SPK (我也不太喜歡SH的長樓梯,但我也很喜歡GH的校社)
認識的朋友中聖保祿出身較smart and presentable

作者: jeremyphlam 時間: 09-12-8 14:16

原帖由 bb.ma 於 09-12-7 20:47 發表
我BB係女,兩間都收左,我唔知邊間好?

1)根德園:校風一向好好,教育小朋友品格正合我心,但無一條龍,三年後要再搏.頭痛! 2)德望: 有一條龍,小學&中學都OK,但年年都要比學費, ...

如果妳經歷過小一搵學校的痛苦你唔會問呢個問題。

聽我講，一定係德望！

作者: princess_sumyin 時間: 09-12-8 15:03

超級同意，我見我d朋友好痛苦．．．．．我就係唔想咁！一定是一條龍學校好

原帖由 jeremyphlam 於 09-12-8 14:16 發表

如果妳經歷過小一搵學校的痛苦你唔會問呢個問題。

聽我講，一定係德望！

作者: kl1234 時間: 09-12-8 15:59 標題: 回覆 24# share123 的文章

thx

Indeed, I like GH' primary and secondary school, so, even its kinder has some uncertains, e.g. 第一年幼稚園. Provided that it is 一條龍, I don't mind the kinder' standard

Am I correct?? any other point of view??

[ 本帖最後由 kl1234 於 09-12-8 16:05 編輯 ]

作者: Bon_Bon_Pa_Pa 時間: 09-12-8 16:23

As I knew many St. Cat K1 and K2 girls will change to GH K2 and K3 next year just because of GH has primary school. All parents have the experience to help their kids to find a primary school will agree this is a terrible process. If there is a primary school backup and then apply for other elite DSS schools or lucky draw, there is not much pressure at all.

作者: share123 時間: 09-12-8 16:41

原帖由 jl118 於 09-12-8 14:13 發表

Hi yin725 & Bert,
我覺得三間學校係校風同成績方面都好好，有幸入到邊間都係好的開始
SPK & SH有學卷，中小學學費較GH平
SPK係英文小學
公開考試SPK 同 SH平均成績好似好GH少少 (pls correct me if I am wrong ...

SPK同SH比,好多人既1st choice應該係SPK,我見到好多friend係SPK既waiting,但SH都收左.

其實要看自己住邊區,雖然SH有好多保母車,但路途太遠,好多uncertainty,都係近自己好d.

作者: Elsat 時間: 09-12-8 16:55

難為天下父母親! 我為學校的問題十分頭痛! 試過寫信比升學專家, 幾星期都唔見佢登出答覆. 睇討論區, 各式各樣comments都有. 所以都係比$660留位GH先. Buy time 再做research.
GH & SH 邊間好D? Please help!

作者: share123 時間: 09-12-8 17:04

原帖由 Elsat 於 09-12-8 16:55 發表
難為天下父母親! 我為學校的問題十分頭痛! 試過寫信比升學專家, 幾星期都唔見佢登出答覆. 睇討論區, 各式各樣comments都有. 所以都係比$660留位GH先. Buy time 再做research.
GH & SH 邊間好D? Please help! ...

好多SH家長會說SH好,其實我覺得差不多.反而係SH學費平d,GH校園靓d.成績校風等應該差別不大.

作者: smartmatt 時間: 09-12-8 17:08

原帖由 Elsat 於 09-12-8 16:55 發表
難為天下父母親! 我為學校的問題十分頭痛! 試過寫信比升學專家, 幾星期都唔見佢登出答覆. 睇討論區, 各式各樣comments都有. 所以都係比$660留位GH先. Buy time 再做research.
GH & SH 邊間好D? Please help! ...

All the KGs mention in BK are very good. You need find out what is important to you and for kid and match as much possible.

Another consideration is entry to P1 is a even more of horrible process then getting into K school as the odds even small as P schools usually on take on around 120 kids. In 3 yrs time it will be a very severe nightmare as there will so many more kids compare to other years and school places will the same. I not looking forward to this and hoping my girl will get a place a mix government school next yr so that my boy can have safe passage and a backup.

[ 本帖最後由 smartmatt 於 09-12-8 17:14 編輯 ]

作者: eggmama 時間: 09-12-8 17:36

agree to a large extent. One more thing is SPK and GH's kinder-primary-secondary sections are located in the same area while SH different sections are in different area, right?

One more silly point is, I like the SPK uniform

原帖由 jl118 於 09-12-8 14:13 發表

Hi yin725 & Bert,
我覺得三間學校係校風同成績方面都好好，有幸入到邊間都係好的開始
SPK & SH有學卷，中小學學費較GH平
SPK係英文小學
公開考試SPK 同 SH平均成績好似好GH少少 (pls correct me if I am wrong ...

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)