教育王國

標題: 青衣地利亞閩僑 [打印本頁]

作者: larchai 時間: 09-11-28 22:42 標題: 青衣地利亞閩僑

此校是新直資, 半數以上外籍 so 全外語環境, 加上法語及普通話, 活動式教學, 且有一條龍中學. 點解無人討論?

[ 本帖最後由 larchai 於 09-11-29 03:56 編輯 ]

作者: larchai 時間: 09-11-29 12:02

原帖由 larchai 於 09-11-28 22:42 發表
此校是新直資, 半數以上外籍 so 全外語環境, 加上法語及普通話, 活動式教學, 學費便宜, 且有一條龍中學. 點解無人討論過?

no one knows about this school?

作者: Quentin0227 時間: 09-11-29 23:35

I want to know too, anyone can share?

作者: janetysy 時間: 09-11-29 23:54

are u sure you want your child to go to delia secondary school???

原帖由 Quentin0227 於 09-11-29 23:35 發表
I want to know too, anyone can share?

作者: cheque 時間: 09-11-30 12:33 標題: Any mothers knew more

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 2king 時間: 09-12-1 00:03

我有個朋友由加拿大返來住珀麗灣, 住我屋苑(青衣一線屋苑)也見過有兩至三人讀地小.

不過我都好想知多d, 有沒有家長的子女現讀此校.可否分享?

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-12-1 10:34

hello 2king,
nice to meet you, pls check PM

原帖由 2king 於 1/12/2009 00:03 發表
我有個朋友由加拿大返來住珀麗灣, 住我屋苑(青衣一線屋苑)也見過有兩至三人讀地小.

不過我都好想知多d, 有沒有家長的子女現讀此校.可否分享?

作者: YLau 時間: 09-12-1 11:15

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: larchai 時間: 09-12-1 20:15

frostangraphy, 你有這個學校的comment? pls share wz us.

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-12-2 09:41

hello larchai,
其實我對這學校也曾有興趣.
as we really want our child go into a english primary school and we live on Park island. so Delia is quite convenient for the location actually. and there is the only english primary school in the area.
however, as you have mentioned, no one take about this school here...

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/vie ... &extra=page%3D1

for my own impression. school is small. around 30 pupils per class. we know people (french) put their child there and seems satisfy. the school fee is low compare to other DSS.

hope this help.

原帖由 larchai 於 1/12/2009 20:15 發表
frostangraphy, 你有這個學校的comment? pls share wz us.

作者: janetysy 時間: 09-12-2 10:55

What i know is that this school's students are quite naughty.. there are in fact very few chinese student go there because of the quality of students.....of coz if it is near you may consider it..but there are actually i lot of choices....so.. you may use it as back up choice...as there are a lot of places there...

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-12-2 09:41 發表
hello larchai,
其實我對這學校也曾有興趣.
as we really want our child go into a english primary school and we live on Park island. so Delia is quite convenient for the location actually. and there is ...

作者: easonkinki 時間: 09-12-3 01:16

之前上網有人話呢間學校好似得P.1~p.3所以一直都無升中派位,聽聞話做埋今年,我都想了解多d呢間學校,我上網搵唔到人講呢間學校,有無家長小朋友讀緊?

作者: 竹葉青 時間: 09-12-3 01:42

我好想了解多一點E間學校,這校係英文小學又有較多唔同國籍小朋友應該可以做到一個好好既英語環境,學費又唔貴,真係好吸引,但我係網上只揾到好少資料,仲要係好極端既評語.有冇家長可以討論下呀!其實美孚果間私校同E間除學費外,分別大唔大呢?

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-12-3 10:09

dear janetysy,
noted with thanks, however, our son has been accepted by another school.
so we are not considering delia anymore.

原帖由 janetysy 於 2/12/2009 10:55 發表
What i know is that this school's students are quite naughty.. there are in fact very few chinese student go there because of the quality of students.....of coz if it is near you may consider it..but ...

作者: 2king 時間: 09-12-4 00:30

我仔仔是在delia kg 讀k1, 之前都見很多負面的message, 但較多是非正就讀的家長發表, 後來自己親自到學校參觀, 同校長傾下, 又等放學問下d本地媽媽, 發覺很不錯. 同時又因好奇心推動下, 去了美孚地小參觀, 當日主任帶我去參觀學校, 又給小4上試卷給我看, 發覺英文試卷很深, 用政府網頁做閱讀理解,還用F.1 地理書分三年(P.4,5,6)讀. 感覺很接近陳守仁. 主任直言中文可能會無傳統學校好, 同校舍細D.
而青衣個間我沒有去參觀, 故很想聽下D正有小孩讀地小的媽媽分享.

[ 本帖最後由 2king 於 09-12-4 00:51 編輯 ]

作者: easonkinki 時間: 09-12-8 15:46

咁呢間小學有無小六架?

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-12-8 18:55

原帖由 easonkinki 於 8/12/2009 15:46 發表
咁呢間小學有無小六架?

創校年份:2006, 06年小朋友今年只上到小三.

作者: kermitan 時間: 09-12-8 21:57 標題: Some Facts Concerning 地利亞閔橋小學

此校乃源自閔橋小學當年收生不足而殺校，2006年起由地利亞教育機構接管開辦直資小學，現時已開到四年級（現時是指2009-2010學年）。校長方面仍由陳鉅培博士擔任，他並同時是此校的一條龍中學地利亞修女紀念學校（百老匯）的校長。

此校學生暫以南亞（Indians, Pakistani, Nepalese）及東亞（Pilipino, Indonesian）居多，亦有一群東歐同學（Ukrainian, Russian）及極少數的加拿大及西歐裔學生，本地華裔學生則不到1/4。

為何沒有人提此校？我估計最大問題有三個：

1. 此校的一條龍中學地利亞修女紀念學校（百老匯）致今的會考成績雖在逐年進步中，但仍然合格率低於一半、六科14分者或以上亦不足兩成（這是他們的內部資料 à 不要問我怎麼會知道）

2. 該校的一條龍中學亦不同於其他國際學校，他們主要是行本地學制，另有部份GCESE科目，但並無IB

3. 地利亞教育機構在港歷史雖長，但未見其能建立起一個優秀的教學傳統

原帖由 larchai 於 09-11-28 22:42 發表
此校是新直資, 半數以上外籍 so 全外語環境, 加上法語及普通話, 活動式教學, 且有一條龍中學. 點解無人討論?

作者: easonkinki 時間: 09-12-9 02:55

thx

作者: larchai 時間: 09-12-9 17:00

simply speaking, is it that DELIA brand name is not good at all in HKG, so even if it is DSS, cheap, English speaking environment and close to the MTR, it is still not interested by most of the HK parents?

作者: kermitan 時間: 09-12-9 18:35

Dear Larchai,

Education is a years-long commitment, and in case of primary school, you are talking about at least 6 years of commitment (and 12 years if you really go to their "through-train" secondary school as well).

There are many criteria in choosing schools, such as method of teaching, medium of instructions, public examination results, students' conducts, courses offered, traveling convenience, etc.

But among all those factors, I would think that "traveling convenience" should not be such a big deal in Hong Kong, especially among families with average income or above. For example, I would seriously doubt that anybody would turn down an offer from DGJS or St. Paul's Co-ed preparatory primary schools simply because they are far away.

In case of medium of instructions, there are a host of DSS or privately-run primary schools thats has more renowned traditions, better public examination results, use English as the medium of instruction, and are not that much expensive than Delia (Man Kiu) English Primary School, such as St. Clare's Primary School, Po Leung Kuk Camões Tan Siu Lin Primary School, and the like. Of course, it would required your kids to compete with others to get into these ones, as all renowned schools probably are.

I think those are probably the reasons why not that much people would talk about Delia (Man Kiu). It does not meant that it might never become a renowned school someday, just that it is not there yet.

Of course, if you would like to put your faith in Delia (Man Kiu), do so and involve passionately as parents to make sure your kids receive the best possible education as provide by this school. As "early adopters", you have the advantage of having a less-than-keen competition when applying for it.

But for the many of of us, we might be taking a more prudent, maybe even "conservative" route in choosing schools. Hence, the relative lack of discussion about this particular Delia school.

原帖由 larchai 於 09-12-9 17:00 發表
simply speaking, is it that DELIA brand name is not good at all in HKG, so even if it is DSS, cheap, English speaking environment and close to the MTR, it is still not interested by most of the HK par ...

[ 本帖最後由 kermitan 於 09-12-9 18:37 編輯 ]

作者: larchai 時間: 09-12-9 23:47

Tks Kermitan, I understand what you mean.

But what I doubt is, among these "new" DSS schools, e.g. WKF, Pui Kiu, PLK CKY, PLK LMC, Evangel, SMC, Delia(Man Kiu)...all they have had not yet thru-educating students step on secondary school, how can people judge from the public exam results?

In fact Delia(Man Kiu)did offer me a seat but surely I didn't go for it as I decided another one already. My personal feeling is not very bad wz this school but I really do not dare to study further, you know why? Because I could not find enough information/comments regarding this school and I won't take the risk.

My only explanation is, brand name.

If it is PLK Man Kiu, I believe there will be many people interested in understanding more about this school. You think so?

作者: funnycat 時間: 09-12-10 00:49

原帖由 larchai 於 09-12-9 23:47 發表
If it is PLK Man Kiu, I believe there will be many people interested in understanding more about this school. You think so?

作者: kermitan 時間: 09-12-10 01:31 標題: CKY and Evangel have their own unique strengths

Well, For me I would not consider WKF, Pui Kiu, PLK LMC, Evangel and SMC, too. Because they have not got any track record yet, and because I have been attending parents talks of most of them (except PLK LMC --> the application form design already scared me away), the principals' performance during which were also just so-so. But some people would surely go for it, especially in WKF (because of "boss" being Baptist University), Pui Kiu (Tsang Yuk Shing as their Boss), and of course all those PLK schools.

Evangel was a bit different though, for the way the principal presented it, they really welcome all those kids who are normal in their IQ but behavioural speaking in need of improvements, and he actually spend more than 2 hours (!!!) in the parent talk demonstrating how he would tackle them in a nearly role-playing manner!!!

But PLK CKY is a bit different. First of all, it was established since 2002, and has already had the first cohort of students passing the P.6 grade twice with flying colours (nearly all of them decided to go to their through-train school, again PLK CKY, and a very small minority of them would went to excellent EMI schools). Secondly, the curriculum design is very well planned, with IB firmly grounded in its secondary senior years. So, in my humble opinion this one is really different, and should not treated just as another no-record-brand-name-only school.

So, even only among those schools you have mentioned, people were choosing them owing to varying reasons, and not necessarily only the "brand name" thing.

原帖由 larchai 於 09-12-9 23:47 發表
Tks Kermitan, I understand what you mean.

But what I doubt is, among these "new" DSS schools, e.g. WKF, Pui Kiu, PLK CKY, PLK LMC, Evangel, SMC, Delia(Man Kiu)...all they have had not yet thru-educa ...

[ 本帖最後由 kermitan 於 09-12-10 01:32 編輯 ]

作者: beemaggie221 時間: 10-1-6 15:58 標題: 青衣地利亞

你好, 我是住青衣的, 對地利亞這小學也有興趣, 可以給我多些資料嗎 ? 謝

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-12-1 10:34 發表
hello 2king,
nice to meet you, pls check PM

作者: kermitan 時間: 10-1-6 19:49 標題: 閔橋小學 Facts

Dear beemaggie221:

此校乃源自閔橋小學

當年收生不足而殺校，2006年起由地利亞教育機構接管開辦直資小學

，現時已開到四年級（現時是指2009-2010學年）。校長方面仍由陳鉅培博士擔任，他並同時是此校的一條龍中學地利亞修女紀念學校（百老匯）的校長。

此校學生暫以南亞（Indians, Pakistani, Nepalese）及東亞（Pilipino, Indonesian）居多，亦有一群東歐同學（Ukrainian, Russian）及極少數的加拿大及西歐裔學生，本地華裔學生則不到1/4。

為何沒有人提此校？我估計最大問題有三個：

1. 此校的一條龍中學地利亞修女紀念學校（百老匯）致今的會考成績雖在逐年進步中，但仍然合格率低於一半、六科14分者或以上亦不足兩成（這是他們的內部資料 à 不要問我怎麼會知道）

2. 該校的一條龍中學亦不同於其他國際學校，他們主要是行本地學制，另有部份GCESE科目，但並無IB

3. 地利亞教育機構在港歷史雖長，但未見其能建立起一個優秀的教學傳統

原帖由 beemaggie221 於 10-1-6 15:58 發表
你好, 我是住青衣的, 對地利亞這小學也有興趣, 可以給我多些資料嗎 ? 謝

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)