教育王國
標題: stafford, york, SC, KV 你地會點選? [打印本頁]
作者: midcofung 時間: 09-11-5 21:25 標題: stafford, york, SC, KV 你地會點選?
Stafford, York , SC 同 KV 你地會點選? 四間又有d咩分別? 有冇mami 知道 ???
作者: Karen2009 時間: 09-11-5 22:06
我個人會考慮係上午定下午班先, 因為 4 間都有好有唔好既地方, 假設全部係上午班, 我會甘選:
1)KV, 中, 數好, 但英文較差, 要係出面狂補, 但多出名小學收, 加上唔多學校活動, 啱晒我這些懶人..哈哈
2)YORK, 英, 數都好, 而且學校有劍橋英文試讀但可能中文會較差
3) SC, 多出名小學收, 不過我唔係好清楚 SC係邊個科目特好
但想入出名既或較好的小學, SC 絕對係必選
4)STOFFORD 好貴, 加上好似唔係好接得到傳統小學, 唔會諗
作者: BB豬MUMMY 時間: 09-11-6 13:55
both 4 i applied, but i knew that york & stafford are sister's kg, so i think their curriculum were same (difference stafford have small class size & have net teacher as class teacher; use english to teach maths, but york have more campus & big class size but no net teacher as class teacher, only 30 minutes). personally, i like sc & kv much more.
but still waiting their offer (only have stafford's offer now). so can't make decision.
原帖由 midcofung 於 09-11-5 21:25 發表 
Stafford, York , SC 同 KV 你地會點選? 四間又有d咩分別? 有冇mami 知道 ???
作者: 小曳人 時間: 09-11-6 14:59
SC/KV 都有一年全級pm, 一年全級am, 所以返學時間唔係考慮嘅都方
分別係
KV無乜活動, 學費平, 多功課, 如果target傳統小學, 包保小朋友適應上無乜太大問題, 中數強而英文無NET
SC就活d, 多d活動, 透明度好高, 語言係強項, 小朋友都幾醒架, 不過做功課就一定少d, 適應傳統小學就無KV咁易
其他嗰兩間我唔多清楚~
作者: Bilobi 時間: 09-11-6 15:07
Very accurate descriptions!
Generally, children in SC are presentable and independent. English proficieny is high.
KV quite stresses on academic development and discipline. Children can easily adapt to P1 curriculim.
Both are well received by good primary schools.
-------------------------------------------------
"KV無乜活動, 學費平, 多功課, 如果target傳統小學, 包保小朋友適應上無乜太大問題, 中數強而英文無NET
SC就活d, 多d活動, 透明度好高, 語言係強項, 小朋友都幾醒架, 不過做功課就一定少d, 適應傳統小學就無KV咁易"
作者: helloting 時間: 09-11-6 15:34
咩叫NET TEACHER!!!
作者: bvei 時間: 09-11-6 16:16
我有朋友的女女在kv讀, 我唔覺得佢英文差喎, 至於話要狂補, 我諗未免誇大左, 講開補習, 我自己個仔係某國際學校學英文, 佢地都有好多sc既學生嚟補, 所以我認為你只可以話kv係輸在冇NET, 但唔至於差囉..
原帖由 Karen2009 於 09-11-5 22:06 發表
我個人會考慮係上午定下午班先, 因為 4 間都有好有唔好既地方, 假設全部係上午班, 我會甘選:
1)KV, 中, 數好, 但英文較差, 要係出面狂補, 但多出名小學收, 加上唔多學校活動, 啱晒我這些懶人..哈哈
2)YORK, 英, 數 ...
作者: HebeMama630 時間: 09-11-6 16:53
agree with you...我囡囡係KV讀K1,本來預要"惡補"英文,但返咗兩個多月學,發覺KV都有教d英語對答,e.g. can you walk/sing/dance...佢會答yes, i can walk/sing...真係有d意外!
唔係話好好,只不過呢處forum太多人講KV冇英文,令到好多家長先入為主,其實KV只係冇net teacher啫...
叧外樓主的問題...其實每個家長要既野唔同...以我為例,我就揀咗KV,因我太多同事既小朋友學咗英文而唔鍾意中文,我本人亦認同英文比中文易學...所以揀KV再同佢响外面學phonics...原帖由 bvei 於 09-11-6 16:16 發表
我有朋友的女女在kv讀, 我唔覺得佢英文差喎, 至於話要狂補, 我諗未免誇大左, 講開補習, 我自己個仔係某國際學校學英文, 佢地都有好多sc既學生嚟補, 所以我認為你只可以話kv係輸在冇NET, 但唔至於差囉..
...
[ 本帖最後由 HebeMama630 於 09-11-6 21:44 編輯 ]
作者: HebeMama630 時間: 09-11-6 16:54
native speaking teacher原帖由 helloting 於 09-11-6 15:34 發表
咩叫NET TEACHER!!!
作者: kin1181015 時間: 09-11-6 18:49
I got the offer from York, but I prefer KV frankly.
York: English very good! But the school fee + Misc + School bus is bloody high..even higher than Master study in University
KV: School fee more reasonable, but need extra learning outside while you want to apply good primary school at KLN side.
SC: I didn't apply this school
All description and thinking in my own stance only
作者: nc2000 時間: 09-11-6 21:36
Lagreed! KV 中英數各科LEVEL 都好好, 只係無NET, 但又未需要狂補咁誇!
原帖由 bvei 於 09-11-6 16:16 發表
我有朋友的女女在kv讀, 我唔覺得佢英文差喎, 至於話要狂補, 我諗未免誇大左, 講開補習, 我自己個仔係某國際學校學英文, 佢地都有好多sc既學生嚟補, 所以我認為你只可以話kv係輸在冇NET, 但唔至於差囉..
...
作者: siumanmama 時間: 09-11-7 00:07
其實現時好多幼稚園的小朋友都出去上堂學野架啦!
我的小朋友讀KV架, 佢好多FRIENDS讀SC, 所以都幾清楚.
同意KV只係冇NET教英文, 只係本地老師教返, 但絕對唔駛狂補咁誇張!
以我小朋友為例, 佢都係一星期上一次英文班, 但好多人(包括我地的外籍鄰居)聽完佢講英文, 會問佢係咪讀國際學校架~ 唔多信佢讀KV架!
佢仲識自己睇/讀好多英文書, 老師都話佢唔係一般幼稚園學生程度了. 不過, 佢讀的是KV, ORAL都唔多計分, 唔同SC, 哈哈!
希望各位為你們的子女找到理想學校啦!
原帖由 Karen2009 於 09-11-5 22:06 發表
我個人會考慮係上午定下午班先, 因為 4 間都有好有唔好既地方, 假設全部係上午班, 我會甘選:
1)KV, 中, 數好, 但英文較差, 要係出面狂補, 但多出名小學收, 加上唔多學校活動, 啱晒我這些懶人..哈哈
2)YORK, 英, 數 ...
[ 本帖最後由 siumanmama 於 09-11-7 00:13 編輯 ]
作者: salai 時間: 09-11-7 00:45
原帖由 siumanmama 於 09-11-7 00:07 發表
其實現時好多幼稚園的小朋友都出去上堂學野架啦!
我的小朋友讀KV架, 佢好多FRIENDS讀SC, 所以都幾清楚.
同意KV只係冇NET教英文, 只係本地老師教返, 但絕對唔駛狂補咁誇張!
以我小朋友為例, 佢都係一星期上一次英 ...
Hi Siumanmama,
Could you give information about the English Class?
My email [email protected]
Thx
作者: greg 時間: 09-11-24 15:20
原帖由 siumanmama 於 09-11-7 00:07 發表
其實現時好多幼稚園的小朋友都出去上堂學野架啦!
我的小朋友讀KV架, 佢好多FRIENDS讀SC, 所以都幾清楚.
同意KV只係冇NET教英文, 只係本地老師教返, 但絕對唔駛狂補咁誇張!
以我小朋友為例, 佢都係一星期上一次英 ...
甘講法KV收既話一定係首選啦...平靚正..我家姐個同事個女都係KV畢業,讀緊小一,英文真係好好喎... 真係估唔到
作者: ElingLuk206 時間: 09-11-24 16:05
I also want to know the english course !
原帖由 siumanmama 於 09-11-7 00:07 發表
其實現時好多幼稚園的小朋友都出去上堂學野架啦!
我的小朋友讀KV架, 佢好多FRIENDS讀SC, 所以都幾清楚.
同意KV只係冇NET教英文, 只係本地老師教返, 但絕對唔駛狂補咁誇張!
以我小朋友為例, 佢都係一星期上一次英 ...
作者: lilian926 時間: 09-11-24 16:34
Do you know that Stafford and York are sister's schools? Their lessons are just the same. The difference is Stafford has NET as the head class teacher and has smaller class size.
原帖由 Karen2009 於 09-11-5 22:06 發表
我個人會考慮係上午定下午班先, 因為 4 間都有好有唔好既地方, 假設全部係上午班, 我會甘選:
1)KV, 中, 數好, 但英文較差, 要係出面狂補, 但多出名小學收, 加上唔多學校活動, 啱晒我這些懶人..哈哈
2)YORK, 英, 數 ...
作者: Jw291120 時間: 09-11-24 16:44
I also want the course information, pls send to me.
[email protected]
Tks
原帖由 siumanmama 於 09-11-7 00:07 發表
其實現時好多幼稚園的小朋友都出去上堂學野架啦!
我的小朋友讀KV架, 佢好多FRIENDS讀SC, 所以都幾清楚.
同意KV只係冇NET教英文, 只係本地老師教返, 但絕對唔駛狂補咁誇張!
以我小朋友為例, 佢都係一星期上一次英 ...
作者: ChingChingChoy 時間: 09-11-24 16:50
kv = 教出好孩子,自動自覺, 各方面平均.
sc = 聽講英文好, 其他我唔知有什麼好, 尢
其校舍細, 九曲十三彎 :;pppp:
作者: ysnmama 時間: 09-11-24 17:09
根德園雖注重中文, 但數學科題目是英文解題. 如果一定要以外藉老師來衡量. 便要選Stafford及SC. 應該好點.
作者: 6321 時間: 09-11-24 17:38
Stafford - I don't think it cannot classify as small-scale class anymore coz they mentioned they will have 28 to 30 kids per K1 class next yr, quite similar as other schools. Definitely, english is very good there.
With the high birth rate in 2007 & 2008, I believe all schools will change from small scale class to big scale class as long as they don't receive complaint from EBD.
作者: lilian926 時間: 09-11-24 17:47
My friend just called to Stafford. There will be 4 classes in 2010. Three am classes and 1 pm class... one am class size is 24... others usually are 28 to 30....
原帖由 6321 於 09-11-24 17:38 發表
Stafford - I don't think it cannot classify as small-scale class anymore coz they mentioned they will have 28 to 30 kids per K1 class next yr, quite similar as other schools. Definitely, english is ve ...
作者: 點算好 時間: 09-11-24 17:49
原帖由 ysnmama 於 09-11-24 17:09 發表
根德園雖注重中文, 但數學科題目是英文解題. 如果一定要以外藉老師來衡量. 便要選Stafford及SC. 應該好點.
想問問, 點解一定要NET?
作者: 小曳人 時間: 09-11-24 18:04
原帖由 點算好 於 09-11-24 17:49 發表
想問問, 點解一定要NET?
如果想小朋友學口語日常溝通嘅, 一定要NET先做到
HK人自己教~一來唔地道.. 二來~ 我個人對幼師嘅英語水平好有保留!
你叫佢地跟課程教應該無問題嘅..
作者: meimei05 時間: 09-11-24 18:27
原帖由 6321 於 09-11-24 17:38 發表
Stafford - I don't think it cannot classify as small-scale class anymore coz they mentioned they will have 28 to 30 kids per K1 class next yr, quite similar as other schools. Definitely, english is ve ...
I agree with you - dont think it's classified as small scale class however i think having NET as head teachers has its advantage! In light of the high birth rate in these years I guess it's hard to keep "small scale" class as running a kindie is also a business!
I think for every school, there's so called weakness and strength so it's hard to judge from the face of it.
作者: ysnmama 時間: 09-11-25 09:13
我沒有一定要net. 只是有其他家長特別喜歡net. 我自己選時, 以學校為主.
坦白說, 現在非牟利及各地區的私立幼稚園. 很多已有net. 只是時間上會分配多少. 如果真的要選有net同注重有net. 不如選間有net時間最多的學校. 例如國際班或英普班.
我自己認為家裡有個英語工人比學校有net更好. 我身邊例子告訴我. 入所謂有net的學校. 如果家裡不能配合. 不見得會英語流利. 但如果家長可配合, 有沒有net其實已不重要.
原帖由 點算好 於 09-11-24 17:49 發表
想問問, 點解一定要NET?
作者: MALTESE2000 時間: 09-11-25 15:16
AGREED...
原帖由 ysnmama 於 09-11-25 09:13 發表
我沒有一定要net. 只是有其他家長特別喜歡net. 我自己選時, 以學校為主.
坦白說, 現在非牟利及各地區的私立幼稚園. 很多已有net. 只是時間上會分配多少. 如果真的要選有net同注重有net. 不如選間有net時間最多的學 ...
作者: 點算好 時間: 09-11-25 15:29
原帖由 小曳人 於 09-11-24 18:04 發表
如果想小朋友學口語日常溝通嘅, 一定要NET先做到
HK人自己教~一來唔地道.. 二來~ 我個人對幼師嘅英語水平好有保留!
你叫佢地跟課程教應該無問題嘅.. ...
哦.....呀........
我諗有少少要搞清楚. NET 系指母語本身系英文(不是指外國人). 而我所見, 好多唔系NET(講東話正到不得了)教英文(但都唔算系幼師)都好好, 見過幾個講故事, 比起個d NET..嘩..唔巧講笑....
作者: 6321 時間: 09-11-25 15:33
Lilian - is it confirmed 24kids per class next year? I heard it is 28 to 30 when I asked last time?
Btw, I agree with many parents NET is important coz as local ppl, we don't have their accent & the way they express. And that's why I prefer Stafford more than York.
My daughter interviewed by Mr Nick & he is very young & nice, I am confident kids will love to talk with him. (my gal is very shy speaking to male, somehow, he can still encourage her to finish the interview).
作者: lilian926 時間: 09-11-25 16:09
My friend told me that only 1 am class will be 24 kids...others will be from 28 to 30 kids...
原帖由 6321 於 09-11-25 15:33 發表
Lilian - is it confirmed 24kids per class next year? I heard it is 28 to 30 when I asked last time?
Btw, I agree with many parents NET is important coz as local ppl, we don't have their accent & the ...
作者: jm1874 時間: 09-11-25 23:55
YORK AND STAFFORD: 你揀佢！
SC AND KV：佢揀你!
作者: ysnmama 時間: 09-11-26 08:59
簡單而清楚
原帖由 jm1874 於 09-11-25 23:55 發表
YORK AND STAFFORD: 你揀佢！
SC AND KV：佢揀你!
作者: jaycee_mami 時間: 09-11-26 09:07
原帖由 lilian926 於 09-11-24 17:47 發表
My friend just called to Stafford. There will be 4 classes in 2010. Three am classes and 1 pm class... one am class size is 24... others usually are 28 to 30....
stafford 28-30人一班, 邊算係小班教學呀?
金巴倫每班唔超過20人!
作者: p_hsy 時間: 09-11-28 02:27
heard that SN only has 20 kids in K1 only, but not in K2 and K3
原帖由 jaycee_mami 於 09-11-26 09:07 發表
stafford 28-30人一班, 邊算係小班教學呀?
金巴倫每班唔超過20人!
作者: helenli 時間: 09-11-28 13:26
yes, because the K1 class needs more attention. there will be less classes and more children in one class for K2 and K3.
原帖由 p_hsy 於 09-11-28 02:27 發表
heard that SN only has 20 kids in K1 only, but not in K2 and K3
作者: jeremyphlam 時間: 09-11-28 13:38
原帖由 小曳人 於 09-11-6 14:59 發表
SC/KV 都有一年全級pm, 一年全級am, 所以返學時間唔係考慮嘅都方
分別係
KV無乜活動, 學費平, 多功課, 如果target傳統小學, 包保小朋友適應上無乜太大問題, 中數強而英文無NET
SC就活d, 多d活動, 透明度好高, 語言 ...
聽朋友講今年SC暫時考直資、私小的結果好似麻麻，係唔係呀？
作者: beansan 時間: 09-11-28 18:24
dear siumanmama . could you please send me the english course details by email also. thanks
[email protected]
原帖由 siumanmama 於 7-11-2009 00:07 發表
其實現時好多幼稚園的小朋友都出去上堂學野架啦!
我的小朋友讀KV架, 佢好多FRIENDS讀SC, 所以都幾清楚.
同意KV只係冇NET教英文, 只係本地老師教返, 但絕對唔駛狂補咁誇張!
以我小朋友為例, 佢都係一星期上一次英 ...
作者: beansan 時間: 09-11-28 18:28
您女女係大定細B. INTERVIEW時是否非常好?
因為真的好難入..多謝您SHARING
原帖由 HebeMama630 於 6-11-2009 16:53 發表
agree with you...我囡囡係KV讀K1,本來預要"惡補"英文,但返咗兩個多月學,發覺KV都有教d英語對答,e.g. can you walk/sing/dance...佢會答yes, i can walk/sing...真係有d意外!
唔係話好好,只不過呢處forum太多人講KV ...
作者: nozomu-kun 時間: 09-11-28 19:50 標題: 回覆 26# siumanmama 的文章
如果只比較sc & kv, 大家有咩comment呀, 兩者今年的小學派位又如何呀 ?
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |