教育王國

標題: 喇沙小學vs新油天小學, 點揀好? [打印本頁]

作者: Chin-Chin 時間: 09-10-20 14:31 標題: 喇沙小學vs新油天小學, 點揀好?

喇沙小學

vs新油天小學, 點揀好? 囝囝冇分, 一定靠大抽獎, 咁點好?

作者: LS+MCS 時間: 09-10-20 14:34

原帖由 Chin-Chin 於 09-10-20 14:31 發表
喇沙小學vs新油天小學, 點揀好? 囝囝冇分, 一定靠大抽獎, 咁點好?

It's purely by luck ! I would aim high - La Salle.

作者: Chin-Chin 時間: 09-10-20 14:44

Thank you. The other concern for me is the secondary school. If I choose La Salle, it is no doubt to La Salle secondary. But if I choose 油天, I can choose the secondary school base on my child ability and 油天 is boy-girl school. No figure about the student in La Salle will go to which school if cannot go directly to La Salle secondary.

原帖由 LS+MCS 於 09-10-20 14:34 發表

It's purely by luck ! I would aim high - La Salle.

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-10-20 16:04

咁你已經有答案啦, 如果想讀男女校, 咁梗係新油天.

原帖由 Chin-Chin 於 09-10-20 14:44 發表
Thank you. The other concern for me is the secondary school. If I choose La Salle, it is no doubt to La Salle secondary. But if I choose 油天, I can choose the secondary school base on my child abilit ...

作者: ko06879 時間: 09-10-20 18:01

我朋友個仔今年油天小六, 之前一路頭痛會被派去邊間中學, 佢話如果當年搵間有中學既就唔駛煩。
不過各有所好啦!

作者: Chin-Chin 時間: 09-10-20 19:22

呢個亦係我嘅concern. 現在小一已經好煩, 6年後再煩多次. 爸爸話新油天的工課壓力可能會小d, 咁其實邊間程度較深?

原帖由 ko06879 於 09-10-20 18:01 發表
我朋友個仔今年油天小六, 之前一路頭痛會被派去邊間中學, 佢話如果當年搵間有中學既就唔駛煩。
不過各有所好啦!

作者: 必必 時間: 09-10-20 22:16

講程度一定係喇沙深. 喇沙中學唔係收晒所有小學部學生, 都要keep到好成績先得.

原帖由 Chin-Chin 於 09-10-20 19:22 發表
呢個亦係我嘅concern. 現在小一已經好煩, 6年後再煩多次. 爸爸話新油天的工課壓力可能會小d, 咁其實邊間程度較深?

作者: Chin-Chin 時間: 09-10-21 16:25

Yes, I know it. But I cannot find the information about the left behind students will go to which schools. Since I know 新油天 will have 60% students go to English Secondary School. Do any parents know how many % of LS students promote to English Secondary School? Thanks.

原帖由必必於 09-10-20 22:16 發表
講程度一定係喇沙深. 喇沙中學唔係收晒所有小學部學生, 都要keep到好成績先得.

作者: wunma 時間: 09-10-21 16:29

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-10-21 16:33

新油天近年只有5x%可以升入band 1 中學.

原帖由 Chin-Chin 於 09-10-21 16:25 發表
Yes, I know it. But I cannot find the information about the left behind students will go to which schools. Since I know 新油天 will have 60% students go to English Secondary School. Do any parents kno ...

作者: ko06879 時間: 09-10-21 18:55

原帖由 wunma 於 09-10-21 16:29 發表
喇小上喇中都唔止60%啦.

喇沙書院通常收80%喇沙小六畢業生。但喇沙小學每級都out人，可以由喇沙小一升到小六已經是難事。

作者: LS+MCS 時間: 09-10-21 20:05

原帖由 ko06879 於 09-10-21 18:55 發表

喇沙書院通常收80%喇沙小六畢業生。但喇沙小學每級都out人，可以由喇沙小一升到小六已經是難事。

LSPS didn't kick anyone out. Did they ??????

It's around 70% this year entering LSC.

作者: ko06879 時間: 09-10-21 21:05

原帖由 LS+MCS 於 09-10-21 20:05 發表

LSPS didn't kick anyone out. Did they ??????

It's around 70% this year entering LSC.

My friend said LSPS did ask some of their student to consider to choose another primary school. You can said they don't kick out but suggest you to leave. Then LSPS will accept some top students from other primary schools, i.e., 宣道小學, 油天...

作者: wunma 時間: 09-10-22 08:57

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: momochiu 時間: 09-10-22 20:15

我覺得名校當然每年都會勸人走, 因大部份學生係抽播來的, 走咗D差既, 先有位收自己想收既新血, 如果唔係點KEEP 住個名?
我知好多學校都有勸人走, 其中有MARYKNOLL。

作者: ko06879 時間: 09-10-22 21:28

The information is not from my friend's friend. Of course, the number of student who was being asked to leave is limited, but it is the truth. Apart from La Salle and MARYKNOLL, 番禺會所華仁小學 is also the same. My sister's son was requested to leave in P3 and he is now studying in international school.

作者: AlanShirley 時間: 09-10-22 21:33

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: wunma 時間: 09-10-23 09:57

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: HoHoMom 時間: 09-10-23 11:46

Oh, that's sad.

原帖由 ko06879 於 09-10-22 21:28 發表
The information is not from my friend's friend. Of course, the number of student who was being asked to leave is limited, but it is the truth. Apart from La Salle and MARYKNOLL, 番禺會所華仁小學 is a ...

作者: Odin 時間: 09-10-24 08:26

請問資料來源？

作者: kerkermui 時間: 09-10-25 16:22

我都聽過類似傳聞.. source係朋友個朋友個朋友.. 小朋友讀緊LS嘅家長..
佢仲話要好active咁做家長義工, 建立良好關係

我信傳聞架.. 如果唔係點會年年都有位俾其他小朋友插班

問心, 如果小朋友個個學期包尾嘅, 家長又明知課程比出面深, 咁點解唔俾佢做返個普通人呢? 唔怕佢怕咗讀書咩?

作者: Odin 時間: 09-10-26 15:14

身為喇沙家長，未聽過「喇沙小學每級都out人」，一直以來，只知道有數位學生因為家長去外國工作或想提早到外國升學原因而退學。

校方當然希望自己學生成績好，喇沙小學教學方針是「『教好』學生」，不是只『教』『好學生』，校方及老師都很關心學生，尤其會關愛有特別照顧需要的學生，亦會鼓勵學生多方面發展，例如運動及文化藝術方面，不會一見學生成績跟不上便勸其退學。

最近的一個例子就是有喇沙書院的學生被同學及老師揭發藏有毒品，學生受審期間不但能如常上課，被定罪後還得到校方給予機會，鼓勵做義工改過自新，可見到校方對問題學生是循循善誘，並沒有盲目維護校譽而莽顧學生的前路。

喇沙小學與喇沙書院是香港碩果僅存的兩所有直屬關係的男校，絕大部份的學生都能由小學升上直屬中學，其他的都能升上不錯的中學。

傳統名校都受到家長的追捧，學校是社會的縮影，因此不存在競爭是騙人，但說成「可以由喇沙小一升到小六已經是難事」未免太過誇張，起碼據我所知，有99%喇沙小學學生都能由小一升到小六。

每人對待「傳聞」的態度各有不同，尤其是網上的傳聞，大家自已分析一下孰耶非耶好了。

作者: diversity 時間: 09-10-26 16:06

喇沙小學與喇沙書院是香港碩果僅存的兩所有直屬關係的男校，絕大部份的學生都能由小學升上直屬中學，其他的都能升上不錯的中學。

版主,
The son of my friend who is in the range of 100 - 110. However, he fails to get to La salle Secondary this yr. So I have a bit of doubt of what you say 'the big majority' can go to LS secondary.

作者: AlanShirley 時間: 09-10-26 16:21

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: corliss_yu 時間: 09-10-26 17:00

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: diversity 時間: 09-10-26 18:13

原帖由 corliss_yu 於 09-10-26 17:00 發表
一直以來，我都覺得喇沙高班過油天、新油天好多好多。
不喜勿插，當無睇過。

agree, they are actually of different levels. Quite suprise indeed for comparing the 2....

作者: ryohga 時間: 09-10-27 10:16

我每次看見這類討論都會覺得很有趣. 'kick' or 'suggest out', it seems the same!

一位學生如果在一所學校每年都成績低落, 甚至乎考第尾, 那他還留在這裡幹嗎? 難道真的要等到6年級派位時被'亂'派先好嗎?? 那時恐怕派得差事少, 學生的自信心被摧毀了才事大!

所以如果是我, 唔理是否捨不得名校也好, 是校方'踢'或'提議'離校也好, 反正結果都一樣, 轉校便轉校吧! 最重要還是如何幫自己的小朋友改善現在的學習模式, 使他重拾自信. 我幫他轉校, 學校都是自己選的, 總好過俾政府'亂'派呢!!

原帖由 ko06879 於 09-10-21 21:05 發表

My friend said LSPS did ask some of their student to consider to choose another primary school. You can said they don't kick out but suggest you to leave. Then LSPS will accept some top students f ...

作者: Kendis1 時間: 09-10-27 13:28

好同意...如果在brand 1考包尾, 而係brand 2考前10名的話, 我諗我也會選擇後者, 至少可重拾"已失去的尊嚴&信心"....

原帖由 ryohga 於 09-10-27 10:16 發表
我每次看見這類討論都會覺得很有趣. 'kick' or 'suggest out', it seems the same!

一位學生如果在一所學校每年都成績低落, 甚至乎考第尾, 那他還留在這裡幹嗎? 難道真的要等到6年級派位時被'亂'派先好嗎?? 那時恐 ...

作者: Chin-Chin 時間: 09-10-27 13:56

Because I planned to move the living location. LS, no doublt is a good boy school. However, 新油天 is also good among the boy-girl school. For sure, if boy school must be LS.

If the location is not a concern in Kowloon side, which is the best of boy-girl school? I want good academic but I little bit more perfer to boy-girl school. Therefore I want to know more deeply about these 2 schools to make the decision.

So what do you think which boy-girl school is good and comparively to LS?

原帖由 diversity 於 09-10-26 18:13 發表

agree, they are actually of different levels. Quite suprise indeed for comparing the 2....

作者: ryohga 時間: 09-10-27 20:52

Of course St. Paul Co-ed.!!!!!!!!!!

原帖由 Chin-Chin 於 09-10-27 13:56 發表
Because I planned to move the living location. LS, no doublt is a good boy school. However, 新油天 is also good among the boy-girl school. For sure, if boy school must be LS.

If the location is not ...

作者: Chin-Chin 時間: 09-10-28 08:53

But I want government school. If private school, I think there will have many choices.

作者: 凍奶茶 時間: 09-11-29 18:09

樓主似乎很想選男女小學，又唔想太深，又想成績好，重最好有聯繫中學，我建議「馬頭涌官立小學」，既是男女小學，又有以下幾間聯繫中學：
伊利沙伯中學、何文田官立中學、賽馬會官立中學

作者: rookiemom 時間: 09-11-29 20:25

你都唔睇樓主點解要compare呢兩間學校，梗係surprise啦，唔係人人都只考慮名氣和課程艱深程度，揀學校仲有好多考慮因素，例如孩子的性格和能力，或家中有冇妹妹跟尾。

我的好朋友（唔係朋友個朋友）個仔在喇小成績差，從來冇人叫佢走，只不過每年學校都明示，佢個仔係冇機會上喇中而矣。

原帖由 diversity 於 09-10-26 18:13 發表

agree, they are actually of different levels. Quite suprise indeed for comparing the 2....

作者: nicolemummy 時間: 09-11-29 22:30

有人走是事實, 但不是因為趕走成績差. 我知道, 有小朋友從小在外國大, 唔識中文, 在小一時候, 看到中文心中驚到在班中咬丟了鉛筆皮, 同班同學也因他的行為嚇壞了. 為了小朋友的身心, 所以才勸他離開. 其他就算不合格, 也只是督促功課而已.

原帖由 momochiu 於 09-10-22 20:15 發表
我覺得名校當然每年都會勸人走, 因大部份學生係抽播來的, 走咗D差既, 先有位收自己想收既新血, 如果唔係點KEEP 住個名?
我知好多學校都有勸人走, 其中有MARYKNOLL。 ...

作者: CFaHB 時間: 09-11-30 12:21

如對囝囝的學習水平
有信心 - > LS
一般 - > 新油天

作者: moonychan 時間: 09-11-30 13:01

可唔可以咁諗呢, 我本身有諗過move去41網, 但個仔又只得15分, 如果我參加大抽獎, 入LS 既機會率都得低, 咁不如讀間好私小/直資, 到小二才考插班LS?? 插到就顧然好, 插唔到就繼續讀返原本間小學??

作者: wantai 時間: 09-11-30 13:50 標題: 回覆 1# moonychan 的文章

好多家長都會咁做。都係一個機會！

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)