教育王國

標題: Unfair of DGJS interview [打印本頁]

作者: PhdJessiema 時間: 09-10-10 18:21 標題: Unfair of DGJS interview

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: overview 時間: 09-10-10 18:25

what do you mean by "the game rule has changed" ?

Doesn't matter la...even the school accept all CCKG girls, there still many seats available for other genius girls.

原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 09-10-10 18:21 發表
Heard that most of the CCKG girls were in school uniform when attending the interview. They knew that the game rule has changed. Thus they want to show their school uniforms to get some sort of benefi ...

[ 本帖最後由 overview 於 09-10-10 18:28 編輯 ]

作者: luiluimama 時間: 09-10-10 18:29

我就唔覺得有咩所謂, 佢地著住校服去面試可能係想面試完即刻去番學, 講真, 就算佢地唔著校服, 睇申請表都知佢係基督堂學生啦, 無咩話公平唔公平呀

唔通著住基督堂校服既小朋友會嚇窒其他小朋友?

"I understand they have the rights but it seems that is too obvious to do so" 你依句野都好自相矛盾囉, 知道人地有權但又去投訴人, 你出街會唔會見到一個靚女化行哂妝(你明知人地有權化妝)靚得滯(太明顯)而投訴人咖?

[ 本帖最後由 luiluimama 於 09-10-10 18:34 編輯 ]

作者: PhdJessiema 時間: 09-10-10 18:42

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: luiluimama 時間: 09-10-10 18:56

我個pt係dgjs個申請表都有問小朋友係讀邊間學校, 如果dgjs係偏好要收cckg既學生, 就算個小朋友唔著cckg校服, 個老師睇申請表果時都會知咖啦, 唔通課室面試緊既老師唔會睇下學生既申請表? 我唔信囉

我小朋友係讀kv既, 如果家長覺得咁樣係唔公平既, 咪著番自己學校既校服去面試囉

或者咁講, 如果你覺得果件所謂"cckg校服"咁有影響力, 早知我就買定一件叫我個女去dgjs面試果時著住搏大霧啦

原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 09-10-10 18:42 發表
I understand this year the interview style has been completely changed because the headmistress would like to ensure the process is fair. Therefore we are sure that the teachers inside the meeting roo ...

[ 本帖最後由 luiluimama 於 09-10-10 18:59 編輯 ]

作者: Sindy 時間: 09-10-10 18:59

原帖由 luiluimama 於 09-10-10 18:56 發表
我個pt係dgjs個申請表都有問小朋友係讀邊間學校, 如果dgjs係偏好要收cckg既學生, 就算個小朋友唔著cckg校服, 個老師睇申請表果時都會知咖啦, 唔通課室面試緊既老師唔會睇下學生既申請表? 我唔信囉

我小朋友係讀kv既 ...

有個媽咪話,讀基督堂又唔係收硬.......駛乜咁介意人地係點啫,做好自己盡左力咪得囉.....

作者: Gooddaddy 時間: 09-10-10 19:44

PhdJessiema,

Why do you want to stir things up by putting up this negative post? Why can't you just think it is quite normal for students to wear uniform to atttend interviews for the sake of convenience. This is particularly noticeable when the interview takes place during regular school hours.

原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 09-10-10 18:21 發表
Heard that most of the CCKG girls were in school uniform when attending the interview. They knew that the game rule has changed. Thus they want to show their school uniforms to get some sort of benefi ...

作者: magiccandy 時間: 09-10-10 21:00

I don't think teachers don't know students' profile before or during the interview. They changed the game rule just to pretend they're doing it more fairly but who knows what fairness is. If they think having educated parents is good, then they choose their children. If they think money is important, they choose the rich ones. These are their own critieria, can't be defined as fair or not.

作者: Yanamami 時間: 09-10-10 21:08

Disagreed. My elder daughter attended DGJS interview 5-6 yrs ago, and we met some CCKG girls wearing school uniform to the interview. I don't think there's any unfairness but it seems like a "tradition" for yhodr girls to wear their uniform to DGJS interview.

原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 09-10-10 18:21 發表
Heard that most of the CCKG girls were in school uniform when attending the interview. They knew that the game rule has changed. Thus they want to show their school uniforms to get some sort of benefi ...

作者: chanmeow 時間: 09-10-10 21:28

不如去教育局投訴!!!

叫cckg結束，咁就公平。

作者: tvnotallow 時間: 09-10-10 21:57 標題: 回覆 1# PhdJessiema 的文章

Phdjessiema,

is your girl now in K3, why you have so many complaint on DGJS???????

作者: crismo 時間: 09-10-10 22:46

I also feel unfair. All the CCKG arrange their inteview on Fri. They have special arrangement.

作者: crismo 時間: 09-10-10 22:51

DGJS can offer to cckg all the seat and not required any interview for them. Then we are not cckg can save the time for waiting for the interview.

作者: Chumeiying 時間: 09-10-10 23:05

Instead, I feel the format of the interview this year would be fairer than the previous years.
At least they entertained us for 45mins to 1hr, allowing the kids to perform, comparing the individual interview at 5mins before.

原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 09-10-10 18:21 發表
Heard that most of the CCKG girls were in school uniform when attending the interview. They knew that the game rule has changed. Thus they want to show their school uniforms to get some sort of benefi ...

作者: circleda 時間: 09-10-10 23:13

會o架, 投訴佢畫皮

我最有興趣知如果呢間咁unfair既dgjs收佢個女, 佢仲去唔去讀, 會唔會猛讚dgjs好fair

原帖由 luiluimama 於 09-10-10 18:29 發表
"I understand they have the rights but it seems that is too obvious todo so" 你依句野都好自相矛盾囉, 知道人地有權但又去投訴人,你出街會唔會見到一個靚女化行哂妝(你明知人地有權化妝)靚得滯(太明顯)而投訴人咖?

作者: JST 時間: 09-10-10 23:27

為什麼你咁緊張?

你的女兒"in" 9 號還是10號?
Good luck!

作者: jojo_c 時間: 09-10-11 00:03

crismo,

I would like to tell you Eason's girl is arranged on Sat. and she doesn't wear CCKG uniform. I do know some CCKG students were on Sat too.

原帖由 crismo 於 09-10-10 22:46 發表
I also feel unfair. All the CCKG arrange their inteview on Fri. They have special arrangement.

作者: 可敏 時間: 09-10-11 00:04 標題: 還有很多不公平

我好明白你的心情，但有咩辦法呢?佢係私校，校長有絕對權力? 事實上，佢地總要好多位留俾的達官貴人添?無計拉?

反過來說，女小拔唔收個女可能是件好事。因為我今日係個HALL 度等阿女面試時，佢地播的學校活動花絮俾家長睇，全部都係攞獎及表演，的表演係嚴彇的，我發現片中的小朋友全部神情認真及嚴謹，無晒童真及不懂開懷大笑。雖然大部分女仔將來必要成就，但係生活不開心，無謂啦。　

原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 09-10-10 18:21 發表
Heard that most of the CCKG girls were in school uniform when attending the interview. They knew that the game rule has changed. Thus they want to show their school uniforms to get some sort of benefi ...

作者: luiluimama 時間: 09-10-11 00:08

哈哈, 承你貴言dgjs收我個女, 到時我一定比個女讀

如果dgjs收我個女, 就證明佢一定係fair, 自問我個女無咩特別, 我唔係讚dgjs公平, 只係覺得單憑申請人著校服面試就話人地學校唔公平, 實在搞笑左d啫

希望你出街唔好遇到咩咩大美人, 免得去投訴人畫皮, 第日喺報紙見到你投訴靚女依單趣聞啦

原帖由 circleda 於 09-10-10 23:13 發表
會o架, 投訴佢畫皮

我最有興趣知如果呢間咁unfair既dgjs收佢個女, 佢仲去唔去讀, 會唔會猛讚dgjs好fair

[ 本帖最後由 luiluimama 於 09-10-11 00:23 編輯 ]

作者: jojo_c 時間: 09-10-11 00:08

When you are performing on the stage, i think you will serious too. I know some DGJS students and they are very cheerful and happy in their school life. Honestly speaking, compared to other famous school, such as Mary Knoll, I think their work load (homework and test) is not so heavy.

原帖由可敏於 09-10-11 00:04 發表
我好明白你的心情，但有咩辦法呢?佢係私校，校長有絕對權力? 事實上，佢地總要好多位留俾的達官貴人添?無計拉?

反過來說，女小拔唔收個女可能是件好事。因為我今日係個HALL 度等阿女面試時，佢地播的學校活動花絮俾家長睇，全部 ...

作者: 可敏 時間: 09-10-11 00:12 標題: good point

My point is DGJS can give all CCKG girls offer, then we can save the time for waiting interview.

作者: jojo_c 時間: 09-10-11 00:23

From past record, not all CCKG students can be admitted to DGJS, although the acceptance rate is high when compared to other kinder.

I have to point out that most CCKG students are very smart as they (only 42 girls) all are selected from several thousand candidates.

原帖由可敏於 09-10-11 00:12 發表
My point is DGJS can give all CCKG girls offer, then we can save the time for waiting interview.

作者: catw88 時間: 09-10-11 00:40

我無報小女拔..路過入來一睇..
我女不是讀cckg..不過呢2日我都有同佢去第2樹interview..前2日我都諗唔到女著咩衫..真係有諗過叫女著校服去架..hahah~因為我覺得女校服好令..著出街人地都唔知係uniform..hehehe..

作者: panbaby 時間: 09-10-11 00:40

讀基督堂梗是貪佢大機會入dgjs 啦, k2 轉校不是一件好玩的事兒.

如果真是絶對公平公正基督堂便不會那麼搶手啦, 對不?

星期五穿校服我不知是否正在上堂, 有關家長可以報料. 星期六穿也無可厚非.

養兵千日, 用在一朝, 等了二年, 就等今天, 香港人咁醒目, 梗係用盡機闗. (可惜小女不是基督堂學生)

妳將基督堂看作dgjs 幼稚園如st. paul 幼稚園便不會太礙眼了...st. paul convent 收大大大部分自己的幼稚園又是這支故事.

香港好的小學多的是...

[ 本帖最後由 panbaby 於 09-10-11 00:57 編輯 ]

作者: Sindy 時間: 09-10-11 00:59

原帖由可敏於 09-10-11 00:04 發表
我好明白你的心情，但有咩辦法呢?佢係私校，校長有絕對權力? 事實上，佢地總要好多位留俾的達官貴人添?無計拉?

反過來說，女小拔唔收個女可能是件好事。因為我今日係個HALL 度等阿女面試時，佢地播的學校活動花絮俾家長睇，全部 ...

有幸兩年去面試,撞啱轉堂,小朋友係音樂室/操場上課室,個個都係happy face架...又有自信......雖然佢都唔收我個女,但都唔會踩佢

作者: Sindy 時間: 09-10-11 01:01

原帖由 panbaby 於 09-10-11 00:40 發表
讀基督堂梗是貪佢大機會入dgjs 啦, k2 轉校不是一件好玩的事兒.

如果真是絶對公平公正基督堂便不會那麼搶手啦, 對不?

星期五穿校服我不知是否正在上堂, 有關家長可以報料. 星期六穿也無可厚非.

養兵千日, 用 ...

有時細路咁細個,真係乜都係考慮因素....我仔in spk時,我都有叫女著校服一齊去.....呢個時候,唔理有無用,乜法寶都要出啦

作者: Ben2003 時間: 09-10-11 01:13

原帖由 Sindy 於 09-10-11 00:59 發表

有幸兩年去面試,撞啱轉堂,小朋友係音樂室/操場上課室,個個都係happy face架...又有自信......雖然佢都唔收我個女,但都唔會踩佢

作者: cmchang0927 時間: 09-10-11 01:21

One of the reasons why a school changed to a private school was because they wanted to have rights to choose their students. So once I decided to hand in the form of a private school, I just followed the rules of school. My girl is not outstanding and I still let her try. If u don't try, u just have 0% opportunity. So just take it easy and there would be a school for her her finally since HK has 9 yrs free education. I m already proud of my girl since she has grown up from a dependent new born baby to a kid that could go with strangers for an interview with me waiting outside.........

作者: panbaby 時間: 09-10-11 01:21

佩服

原帖由 Sindy 於 09-10-11 01:01 發表

有時細路咁細個,真係乜都係考慮因素....我仔in spk時,我都有叫女著校服一齊去.....呢個時候,唔理有無用,乜法寶都要出啦

[ 本帖最後由 panbaby 於 09-10-11 01:44 編輯 ]

作者: Sindy 時間: 09-10-11 01:52

原帖由 panbaby 於 09-10-11 01:21 發表
佩服

不過都係無註冊spk.....辦法用盡,收左先有權諗,又唔係傍門左道...

[ 本帖最後由 Sindy 於 09-10-11 01:54 編輯 ]

作者: Astoria 時間: 09-10-11 08:04

There is another CCKG girl interviewed on Sat morning and put on uniform as well. I think no all CCKG girls interview on Friday.

原帖由 jojo_c 於 09-10-11 00:03 發表
crismo,

I would like to tell you Eason's girl is arranged on Sat. and she doesn't wear CCKG uniform. I do know some CCKG students were on Sat too.

作者: chingmon 時間: 09-10-11 10:01

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: JST 時間: 09-10-11 10:18 標題: 回覆 1# chingmon 的文章

我看見有女仔著聖保祿幼兒園校服

作者: magiccandy 時間: 09-10-11 11:36

luilui8mama,

you are very humorous. I agree with you

原帖由 luiluimama 於 09-10-10 18:29 發表
我就唔覺得有咩所謂, 佢地著住校服去面試可能係想面試完即刻去番學, 講真, 就算佢地唔著校服, 睇申請表都知佢係基督堂學生啦, 無咩話公平唔公平呀

唔通著住基督堂校服既小朋友會嚇窒其他小朋友?

"I understand the ...

作者: CFaHB 時間: 09-10-11 12:30

有風度

原帖由 Sindy 於 09-10-11 00:59 發表

有幸兩年去面試,撞啱轉堂,小朋友係音樂室/操場上課室,個個都係happy face架...又有自信......雖然佢都唔收我個女,但都唔會踩佢

作者: childrenfirst 時間: 09-10-11 13:25

I think all of us should admit the fact that it's no real fairness in this world and as a private or DSS school, the head of the school will has the sole power to select the student that she/he or the school may prefer. I think it's part of the game rule. Not only their preference on CCKG's student but also many other preferences behind.
Do you think these kinds of interviews will achieve any fairness? Come on, from day one, i don't dream that these interviews can make a 100% fair judgement on my kid! Like the interview of SPCC, the questions were so general, how can they select the right ones out of 2000 applications? 10 mins interview and they would know the kid? It's a joke. Therefore, they must have their preferences.
If parents can admit this cruel fact, both the child and the parent can enjoy the process more and feel happier ...The fact is - We can never beat with the ones with connection or related. But what's the matters? I think the whole process is a kind of life exposure and after all there must be a school who will appreciate our children's potential. It's not the end of the world to be rejected by these top schools. Of course, I would be extremely excited if those schools accept my application, that means our kids are much out perform than those who are related/connected!

My feeling is - I don't feel offended by the CCKG uniform issue (my kid is not at CCKG) as it's normal for the parents to do what they can for their kids!

作者: mango22 時間: 09-10-11 15:44

原帖由 childrenfirst 於 09-10-11 13:25 發表
I think all of us should admit the fact that it's no real fairness in this world and as a private or DSS school, the head of the school will has the sole power to select the student that she/he or the ...

Totally agree...!

作者: ShinTeresa 時間: 09-10-11 17:40

照計著咩對個ｉｎｔ　ｒｅｓｕｌｔ既影響應該不大　你一報時佢都知你讀邊間　始終都係睇個小朋友既林埸表演　

原帖由 PhdJessiema 於 09-10-10 18:21 發表
Heard that most of the CCKG girls were in school uniform when attending the interview. They knew that the game rule has changed. Thus they want to show their school uniforms to get some sort of benefi ...

作者: charwes 時間: 09-10-11 18:25

冇錯，我覺得入得 CCKG 個目的都係想入 DBSPD or DGJS，父母想顯示呢點少少優勢真係無可厚非喎。

原帖由 mango22 於 09-10-11 15:44 發表

Totally agree...!

作者: JKTL 時間: 09-10-11 21:04

我覺得你講的對

原帖由 Sindy 於 09-10-10 18:59 發表

有個媽咪話,讀基督堂又唔係收硬.......駛乜咁介意人地係點啫,做好自己盡左力咪得囉.....

作者: nicolemummy 時間: 09-10-11 22:08

我不是這年的考生. 但我知道, 前年面試的安排, 是按幼稚園的名稱作次序. 例如: 浸大附幼(BUkinder), 基督堂幼(CCKG), 培正(Pui Ching) 等, 就是以B,C,P等去排. 所以, CCKG的小朋友擠在某1,2天面試不為奇.

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-10-11 22:34

如果學校本身鍾意收某間幼稚園既學生, 佢著唔著校服結果都係一樣, 平常心啦, 無謂太介懷.

作者: chuyuencheung 時間: 09-10-11 22:49

近年越來越多香港人奉行投訴文化，相信在投訴後便會獲得特別處理，相信任職服務業的站友一定有所感受，而近其中大少女因投訴而在 youtube 及高登討論區聲名大燥，更是此種文化的最佳實例。

作者: charwes 時間: 09-10-11 23:15

據理力爭其實冇問題，最怕係輸打贏要。

原帖由 chuyuencheung 於 09-10-11 22:49 發表
近年越來越多香港人奉行投訴文化，相信在投訴後便會獲得特別處理，相信任職服務業的站友一定有所感受，而近其中大少女因投訴而在 youtube 及高登討論區聲名大燥，更是此種文化的最佳實例。 ...

作者: ahtan 時間: 09-10-13 22:19

原帖由 childrenfirst 於 09-10-11 13:25 發表
I think all of us should admit the fact that it's no real fairness in this world and as a private or DSS school, the head of the school will has the sole power to select the student that she/he or the ...

My kids are not in CCKG but I feel that if your kid is smart enough to get into CCKG, parents should be proud to show it. Besides, I have seen many other kids wearing other kindergarten's uniforms ( like St. Paul's Convent Nursery, Kai See etc) going for interviews last year. I don't see why people just point out about CCKG. Don't get jealous just because kids in CCKG are generally smart and well prepared! Even so, there are many smart kids who can't get into their desired schools every year. There is really NO guarantee. Therefore I don't think it's a big deal that kids are wearing school uniforms to interviews.

作者: shwamy 時間: 09-10-15 14:29

穿校服較穿全身名牌好!

作者: heison 時間: 09-10-17 00:09 標題: 回覆 26# Sindy 的文章

我個係仔，所以無留意DGJS 既收生情況，但我好同意Sindy 所講，係呢個時候，Mud野法寶都要出架LA

作者: candietweety 時間: 09-10-17 09:40

i agree with shwamy

原帖由 shwamy 於 09-10-15 14:29 發表
穿校服較穿全身名牌好!

作者: circleda 時間: 09-10-17 10:49

唔係化, DGJS有無唔咁蠢, 驚人唔知interview係點要group埋同校o既一齊前後腳咁去in?

原帖由 nicolemummy 於 09-10-11 22:08 發表
我不是這年的考生. 但我知道, 前年面試的安排, 是按幼稚園的名稱作次序. 例如: 浸大附幼(BUkinder), 基督堂幼(CCKG), 培正(Pui Ching) 等, 就是以B,C,P等去排. 所以, CCKG的小朋友擠在某1,2天面試不為奇. ...

作者: KK07 時間: 09-10-17 14:57

想起幾年前參加一直資一條龍學校中一收生briefing, 該校講明會預留大部分學位給自己小學,只招收40-60外來生, 當中竟有家長向校長發問, 投訴這是否對非其小學的考生不公平!

聽後不禁覺得'公平'兩字被濫用!

作者: nicolemummy 時間: 09-10-17 15:15

其實, interview係點, 間間學校大同小異, 不外乎, 問下小朋友一些問題(叫咩名, 喜歡D咩), 讀下書, 問下感想. 學校根本不會在乎家長知唔知面試程序.

大家都明白, 收唔收小朋友, 面試係一項分數, 但不是全部.

GROUP埋一齊係係學校內部行政容易D.......行政容易D....

原帖由 circleda 於 09-10-17 10:49 發表
唔係化, DGJS有無唔咁蠢, 驚人唔知interview係點要group埋同校o既一齊前後腳咁去in?

作者: Ben2003 時間: 09-10-17 15:49

>投訴這是否對非其小學的考生不公平!

真係咁都有....

原帖由 KK07 於 09-10-17 14:57 發表
想起幾年前參加一直資一條龍學校中一收生briefing, 該校講明會預留大部分學位給自己小學,只招收40-60外來生, 當中竟有家長向校長發問, 投訴這是否對非其小學的考生不公平! 聽後不禁覺得'公平'兩字被濫用! ...

作者: PhdJessiema 時間: 09-10-19 18:32

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)