教育王國

標題: St. Margret / 陳守仁 / 優才 /黃錦輝 / 培僑 [打印本頁]

作者: hcsoma 時間: 09-9-9 00:19 標題: St. Margret / 陳守仁 / 優才 /黃錦輝 / 培僑

小女慢熱，自我要求高，面皮薄，記憶力强。老師說她不可選太傳統的學校，活動的較適合她。

請幫忙，以上的學校你會怎排次序呢???

作者: YAPPLE 時間: 09-9-9 06:53

學校收咗你女女才諗次序吧!

原帖由 hcsoma 於 09-9-9 00:19 發表
小女慢熱，自我要求高，面皮薄，記憶力强。老師說她不可選太傳統的學校，活動的較適合她。

請幫忙，以上的學校你會怎排次序呢???

作者: chuyuencheung 時間: 09-9-9 08:58

如果妳囡囡今年是 k3 的話，可以不考慮黃錦輝了，因為已經截止。

作者: rachncurtsmom 時間: 09-9-9 15:35

原帖由 hcsoma 於 09-9-9 00:19 發表
小女慢熱，自我要求高，面皮薄，記憶力强。老師說她不可選太傳統的學校，活動的較適合她。

請幫忙，以上的學校你會怎排次序呢???

呢幾間都係我有考慮的，黃錦輝已經截止左，無嘢好講啦。

培僑：

我原本睇學校校網都覺得唔錯，不過我老公唔鍾意左派學校，所以已被叮走。

St Margaret：

9月27日有簡介會，你有興趣可以去登記，到時自己睇睇。當然，佢有中學又係英文教學，呢D都係我考慮嘅因素，不過我一定要去完簡介會先會決定。

陳守仁：

我原本十分喜歡陳守仁，不過去完簡介會有少少失望。

第一、所有老師及校長講說話都是中英夾集，可能佢地英文好得啦，不過中文就...
第二、簡介會主要講學校對語文同課外活動嘅重視，不過呢個本身就係學校嘅賣點。
第三、全校十幾班，NET只有3個，好似少左D。
第四、有個家長問，如果小朋友面見時緊張，校方會點做；學校話家長應該俾小朋友心理準備，什麼什麼的，俾我嘅感覺係如果小朋友當日表現咁啱唔好，咁你就唔好彩囉。

不過我識得人個女之前喺陳守仁讀，個媽咪都覺得係一間好學校，不過聽講轉左而家個校長就無以前咁好，但係佢話都藉得入嘅。

優才：

我原本睇完學校校網就覺得十分硬銷，特別係張申請表，好似我去見工咁，不過簡介會又唔係咁差。

第一、學校特點係專科專教，而且，老師學歷都較高。
第二、小班教學，我個女間幼稚園本身好小人，所以識應應該會比較好。
第三、好似有10個定11個NET。
第四、相對陳守仁，優才對小朋友面見時緊張，話可以安排另一時段回來。

不過最唔好就係小一至小三要喺旺角校舍上堂。

所以，目前來講，我會選優才，跟住陳守仁。St Margaret要去完簡介會先知。不過，以上都係我個人嘅意見，同埋以識合我個女來計。

另外，我仲會報啟基同蔡繼有。

作者: HKQQbaby 時間: 09-9-9 17:51

rachncurtsmom

St Margaret's Co-edu:
已開始1st & 2nd interview, 共收80人 (1/4 收 non-chinese) so chinese students will be accepted about 60 persons 位吾多有興趣要快報名.

原帖由 rachncurtsmom 於 09-9-9 15:35 發表

呢幾間都係我有考慮的，黃錦輝已經截止左，無嘢好講啦。

培僑：

我原本睇學校校網都覺得唔錯，不過我老公唔鍾意左派學校，所以已被叮走。

St Margaret：

9月27日有簡介會，你有興趣可以去登記，到時自己睇睇。當然，佢有中學又 ...

作者: rachncurtsmom 時間: 09-9-9 20:40

原帖由 HKQQbaby 於 09-9-9 17:51 發表
rachncurtsmom

St Margaret's Co-edu:
已開始1st & 2nd interview, 共收80人 (1/4 收 non-chinese) so chinese students will be accepted about 60 persons 位吾多有興趣要快報名.

HKQQbaby,

唔該哂，我呢個星期內會報埋架啦﹗

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-9 23:07

interesting, interesting.
thanks for sharing!

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-9 23:22

me and my wife have been to the 1st briefing session on 23rd aug.
we think it's an ok school. they emphasis on the language learning program. we had actually almost an hour of phonics and phonetic lesson....

other than that, as many other dss school does, we had feeling that they are very hard sell too...

but well, if you want to know, we will still apply for our kid....

原帖由 rachncurtsmom 於 9/9/2009 15:35 發表

呢幾間都係我有考慮的，黃錦輝已經截止左，無嘢好講啦。

培僑：

我原本睇學校校網都覺得唔錯，不過我老公唔鍾意左派學校，所以已被叮走。

St Margaret：

9月27日有簡介會，你有興趣可以去登記，到時自己睇睇。當然，佢有中學又 ...

[ 本帖最後由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-11 15:13 編輯 ]

作者: rachncurtsmom 時間: 09-9-10 11:30

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-9 23:22 發表
me and my wife have been to the 1st briefing session on 5th.
we think it's an ok school. they emphasis on the language learning program. we had actually almost an hour of phonics and phonetic lesson. ...

Are you referring to St Margaret or TSL? So, which schools have you applied for for your son?

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-10 12:49

學校簡介會唔多唔少都一定係硬銷既.

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-9 23:22 發表
me and my wife have been to the 1st briefing session on 5th.
we think it's an ok school. they emphasis on the language learning program. we had actually almost an hour of phonics and phonetic lesson. ...

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-10 18:07

TSL only open day, talked to the teachers, pupils and met some pupils' parents. much more comfortable feel.
smc only briefing session, we missed the open day... so after the briefing session we only able to talk with 1 or 2 teachers but no pupils' parents, only parents who want to apply the school were there.
after a long discussion with my wife, we actually only select very few schools for our son.
as my wife doesn't read chinese, we only take EMI schools for application .
:funny:

原帖由 rachncurtsmom 於 10/9/2009 11:30 發表

Are you referring to St Margaret or TSL? So, which schools have you applied for for your son?

作者: rachncurtsmom 時間: 09-9-11 01:52

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-10 18:07 發表
TSL only open day, talked to the teachers, pupils and met some pupils' parents. much more comfortable feel.
smc only briefing session, we missed the open day... so after the briefing session we only ...

A lot of parents apply for EMI schools because they want their kids to have better English. I want my children's English to be good too. When my daughter was still a baby, I started talking to her in English as soon as she's comfortable with it.

Now my daughter is 5 and her preferred dialect is English. But I want her to learn Chinese as well because it's very difficult to learn. So I'm somewhat debating whether I should choose EMI or CMI school in the end.

If your wife doesn't read Chinese, do you still want your son to learn Chinese?

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-11 10:04

my wife wants to follow my son's education so all the school notices and flyers in english is a must for her. other than EMI school, i'm still looking if there is other school doing that...
of cause, my son needs to learn chinese, as this is one of his mother tongue (father tongue actually...

, his mother tongue is french).
however, we are both quite relax with the languages. we don't need them to be excellent, they are already comfortable with 3 is good enough.
the EMI choice is somehow because i'm lazy to translate all the notices, year report, lesson... as i'm doing now for another 6 years...

原帖由 rachncurtsmom 於 11/9/2009 01:52 發表

A lot of parents apply for EMI schools because they want their kids to have better English. I want my children's English to be good too. When my daughter was still a baby, I started talking to her ...

[ 本帖最後由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-11 10:19 編輯 ]

作者: rachncurtsmom 時間: 09-9-11 15:03

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-11 10:04 發表
my wife wants to follow my son's education so all the school notices and flyers in english is a must for her. other than EMI school, i'm still looking if there is other school doing that...
of cause, ...

Thank you for sharing. I just want to know someone else's point of view. And I'm still struggling.

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-11 15:31

i have learnt a lot via this forum and am happy to share the info with others as well.

原帖由 rachncurtsmom 於 11/9/2009 15:03 發表

Thank you for sharing. I just want to know someone else's point of view. And I'm still struggling.

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-11 15:41

have you been to any school open day?!
i do think that the school open day is a much better way to know more about the school than the briefing session!
i would rather prefer to meet the pupils and teachers in the school and able to talk with the parents actually, rather than listening the selling points of the school or the best way to pass the interview...

原帖由 rachncurtsmom 於 11/9/2009 01:52 發表

A lot of parents apply for EMI schools because they want their kids to have better English. I want my children's English to be good too. When my daughter was still a baby, I started talking to her ...

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-11 15:46

just for references:

All notices in SMC are written in both Chinese and English.

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-10 18:07 發表
TSL only open day, talked to the teachers, pupils and met some pupils' parents. much more comfortable feel.
smc only briefing session, we missed the open day... so after the briefing session we only ...

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-11 16:48

the flyer for 29th aug briefing session flyer was only in chinese....

however, i believe it's a rare case.

thanks g-ma for your info!

原帖由 G-Ma 於 11/9/2009 15:46 發表
just for references:

All notices in SMC are written in both Chinese and English.

[ 本帖最後由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-11 16:49 編輯 ]

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-11 23:37

Oops! really?!

They have 2 briefing sessions, one is in Chinese and one is in English. Which one you've attended?

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-11 16:48 發表
the flyer for 29th aug briefing session flyer was only in chinese....
however, i believe it's a rare case.
thanks g-ma for your info!

[ 本帖最後由 G-Ma 於 09-9-11 23:39 編輯 ]

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-12 09:53

the morning session, english one. and we have had one hour of phonic and phonetic lesson during the first hour.

:
funny that i discovered that the flyer of the briefing seesion on 27 sept is only in english.

原帖由 G-Ma 於 11/9/2009 23:37 發表
Oops! really?! They have 2 briefing sessions, one is in Chinese and one is in English. Which one you've attended?

作者: rachncurtsmom 時間: 09-9-12 14:05

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-11 15:41 發表
have you been to any school open day?!
i do think that the school open day is a much better way to know more about the school than the briefing session!
i would rather prefer to meet the pupils and ...

As a matter of fact, I have only been to two school open days. One of them, I probably won't apply because of the class size, even though there are a lot of good comments on the forum.

You are right, it's good to talk to the students and the parents. But then, I'm sure you can always find both happy and unhappy students and parents.

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-14 15:01

ha ha ha! not always right, since the parents and pupils who are willing to attend the open days are generally happy with the school.

原帖由 rachncurtsmom 於 12/9/2009 14:05 發表

As a matter of fact, I have only been to two school open days. One of them, I probably won't apply because of the class size, even though there are a lot of good comments on the forum.

You are rig ...

作者: fentanylbaby 時間: 09-9-15 11:31

各視學報告中,優才之學術表現很好,而且師資好像是全港最佳。

作者: jojolam_ma 時間: 09-9-15 12:24

以下是我去年的分析:

St Margaret: 較易考入, 很多南亞YUI的學生, 學校包裝是新派學校, 但教法仍很傳統

陳守仁: 很難考入, 英文好, 但教法也很傳統

優才: 沒去了解過

黃錦輝:不太難考入, 人事變動大, 學校還未穩定, 很多負面消息, 但新校長不錯, 選此校要搏一搏

培僑: 很難考入, 口碑不錯, 中英語文水平高, 多不同國藉學生, 教學水平不俗, 老師有愛心, 但有些家長因其背景而卻步

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-15 13:31

St Margaret 舊年差不多10幾個選1個, 我認為並唔係較易考入.

原帖由 jojolam_ma 於 09-9-15 12:24 發表
以下是我去年的分析:

St Margaret: 較易考入, 很多南亞YUI的學生, 學校包裝是新派學校, 但教法仍很傳統

陳守仁: 很難考入, 英文好, 但教法也很傳統

優才: 沒去了解過

黃錦輝:不太難考入, 人事變動大, 學校還未穩 ...

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-15 14:20

五間都是傳統教學?

原帖由 jojolam_ma 於 15/9/2009 12:24 發表
以下是我去年的分析:

St Margaret: 較易考入, 很多南亞YUI的學生, 學校包裝是新派學校, 但教法仍很傳統

陳守仁: 很難考入, 英文好, 但教法也很傳統

優才: 沒去了解過

黃錦輝:不太難考入, 人事變動大, 學校還未穩 ...

作者: jojolam_ma 時間: 09-9-15 16:53

去年亞仔班上有個小朋友，考了好多間直資都無功而還，但係　St M 就收左，所以印象中是較易考。

原帖由 G-Ma 於 09-9-15 13:31 發表
St Margaret 舊年差不多10幾個選1個, 我認為並唔係較易考入.

作者: jojolam_ma 時間: 09-9-15 16:55

直資一般都係claim自己開放式教學，不過就唔係間間都做得到。

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-15 14:20 發表
五間都是傳統教學?

作者: mamimummy 時間: 09-9-15 21:00

其實, 家長唔會因為學校有幾多位而考慮試不試考那學校的, 所以總報考人數可反映學校的普遍受歡迎程度.

如果一所學校只有30個位, 那麼很容易10+幾個選1個或更甚的假象.

但這亦不代表學校的好壞.

作者: mamimummy 時間: 09-9-15 21:03

其實我不認為陳守仁教法很傳統, 只是部份家長很傳統, 他們才教得自己的子女傳統. ^^

作者: Mimi_Ma 時間: 09-9-15 23:31

原帖由 jojolam_ma 於 09-9-15 16:53 發表
去年亞仔班上有個小朋友，考了好多間直資都無功而還，但係　St M 就收左，所以印象中是較易考。

我侄仔舊年都考好多間唔收, 但係男拔收佢, 佢媽咪的結論係個仔初期未識應面試, 到考男拔可能已識應及知道遊戲玩法.

作者: idy926 時間: 09-9-16 00:22

我女都考左浸小,優才,遲下都會考陳守仁.

考浸小個曰,我覺得氣氛幾凝重,遂個叫名小朋友出黎排隊,8個一組每人派一張紙(好似for畫畫),跟住老師去左面試室,家長就全部group埋留係hall度填校方比嘅問卷,亞女in完返來個樣都仲係好緊張,見倒我地先識笑...

而優才校長就親自同小朋友玩,一開始就先講個故事,再話:想玩遊戲既出黎排隊,玩完,熱身後就叫小朋友扮開火車,咁就吾覺吾覺跟左老師去面試,到接番女女時佢係操塲玩運動遊戲,真係未見過佢面試後咁開心,彈下彈下跳過黎,見牙吾見眼,最後臨走出大門口仲有禮物放枱面,十款八款比小朋友自己揀,我女吾like就有鬼....我覺得校長好有心思..

其實我都like優才,but遠,如果無校車,即使收都吾洗諗...

都係個句,收左先算...

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-16 00:41

多人報讀始終代表學校係有吸引人之處, 當然未必係最好, 但係供求定律, 提供既貨如果質量有問題, 亦唔會有客戶既需求, 更何況直資要交學費, 家長會更小心挑選.

原帖由 mamimummy 於 09-9-15 21:00 發表
其實, 家長唔會因為學校有幾多位而考慮試不試考那學校的, 所以總報考人數可反映學校的普遍受歡迎程度.

如果一所學校只有30個位, 那麼很容易10+幾個選1個或更甚的假象.

但這亦不代表學校的好壞. ...

[ 本帖最後由 G-Ma 於 09-9-16 10:13 編輯 ]

作者: mamimummy 時間: 09-9-16 05:35

我覺得而家唔同以前, 我女那時, 想讀邊間先考邊間, 而家好多讀唔讀都考, 辛苦自己又辛苦小朋友, 亦令到學校好亂. 有d離譜到係直資交留位, 最後去津校knock 門, 再去直資最回之前的錢. 太無責任心了, 如何教下一代.

原帖由 G-Ma 於 09-9-16 00:41 發表
多人報讀始終代表學校係有吸引人之處, 當然未必係最好, 但係供求定律, 提供既貨如果質量有問題, 亦唔會有客戶既需求, 更何況直資要交學費, 家長會更小挑選.

...

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-16 10:16

呢個真係怪現象, 我都識人考10間8間, 有d仲距離佢屋企好遠, 考到都唔會讀, 朋友話主要係比小朋友warm up下, 攞多d interview既經驗.

原帖由 mamimummy 於 09-9-16 05:35 發表
我覺得而家唔同以前, 我女那時, 想讀邊間先考邊間, 而家好多讀唔讀都考, 辛苦自己又辛苦小朋友, 亦令到學校好亂. 有d離譜到係直資交留位, 最後去津校knock 門, 再去直資最回之前的錢. 太無責任心了, 如何教下一代.

...

作者: ggoo 時間: 09-9-16 10:25

優才我舊年有去聽簡介會,兩個校長比我既感覺都好好,我覺得陳校長好有抱負同POWER,可以將間學校搞得好好,是我心水之一.

原帖由 idy926 於 09-9-16 00:22 發表
我女都考左浸小,優才,遲下都會考陳守仁.

考浸小個曰,我覺得氣氛幾凝重,遂個叫名小朋友出黎排隊,8個一組每人派一張紙(好似for畫畫),跟住老師去左面試室,家長就全部group埋留係hall度填校方比嘅問卷,亞女in完返來個樣 ...

作者: NeoMom 時間: 09-9-16 10:49

原帖由 G-Ma 於 09-9-16 00:41 發表
多人報讀始終代表學校係有吸引人之處, 當然未必係最好, 但係供求定律, 提供既貨如果質量有問題, 亦唔會有客戶既需求, 更何況直資要交學費, 家長會更小心挑選.

...

所以最好係睇幾多人放棄學位, 聽到有d學校要搵番reject左既candidate就要睇多兩眼

作者: idy926 時間: 09-9-16 11:20

咁都得？我吾信有得退吧？有mug理據攞得番？

原帖由 mamimummy 於 09-9-16 05:35 發表
我覺得而家唔同以前, 我女那時, 想讀邊間先考邊間, 而家好多讀唔讀都考, 辛苦自己又辛苦小朋友, 亦令到學校好亂. 有d離譜到係直資交留位, 最後去津校knock 門, 再去直資最回之前的錢. 太無責任心了, 如何教下一代.

...

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-16 12:33

咁當初揀得去in既, 間學校一定有可取之處, 如果唔係都唔side d咁既時間啦, 不過到最後係人都會揀最好最啱心水果間je.

要搵番reject左既candidate就係間學校行政問題, 聰明既就唔會話reject, 一定放佢係waiting list, 咁到時call返都唔洗瘀.

原帖由 NeoMom 於 09-9-16 10:49 發表

所以最好係睇幾多人放棄學位, 聽到有d學校要搵番reject左既candidate就要睇多兩眼

[ 本帖最後由 G-Ma 於 09-9-16 12:58 編輯 ]

作者: Hinbabyma 時間: 09-9-16 12:52

參加過培僑小一簡介會, 又唔見有其他國籍學生, local多, 校長有簡短presentation, 唔太hard sell, 仲有很多老師在場, 好nice。俾我感覺唔錯。

原帖由 jojolam_ma 於 09-9-15 12:24 發表
以下是我去年的分析:

St Margaret: 較易考入, 很多南亞YUI的學生, 學校包裝是新派學校, 但教法仍很傳統

陳守仁: 很難考入, 英文好, 但教法也很傳統

優才: 沒去了解過

黃錦輝:不太難考入, 人事變動大, 學校還未穩 ...

作者: mamimummy 時間: 09-9-17 04:02

他們的"理據"是"我並沒有開始用你們的服務

", 成功與否不是關鍵, 而心態好有問題

!!!!

原帖由 idy926 於 09-9-16 11:20 發表
咁都得？我吾信有得退吧？有mug理據攞得番？

作者: fongyuen 時間: 09-9-17 09:16

原帖由 mamimummy 於 09-9-17 04:02 發表
他們的"理據"是"我並沒有開始用你們的服務 ", 成功與否不是關鍵, 而心態好有問題 !!!!

呢個根本唔係理據，而係「奀理」﹗

打從開始報名申請，根本學校已經服務緊你，咩叫「我並沒有開始用你們的服務」？

買樓前都要俾訂啦，躂訂你可以攞返啲訂嘅咩？咁落訂嚟做乜？呢啲家長眼裡只有一個 $$$，真係不知所謂﹗

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-17 11:57

呢個世界好多人都唔講道理架啦!

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-17 12:33

我地只係幫個仔報得幾間學校...
但係都比人話, 做乜報咁少呀!! 咁少點得架!

家下都有d驚係唔係報得少得濟...

原帖由 G-Ma 於 17/9/2009 11:57 發表
呢個世界好多人都唔講道理架啦!

作者: littlefaith 時間: 09-9-17 12:42

原帖由 flostangraphy 於 09-9-17 12:33 發表
我地只係幫個仔報得幾間學校...
但係都比人話, 做乜報咁少呀!! 咁少點得架!

家下都有d驚係唔係報得少得濟...

我都係報咗兩間，仲少過你啦﹗

報學校最緊要match，唔應該用報學校嚟做工具 (如當保險、訓練面試)，所以我同太太都唔主張報咁多。

作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-17 12:55

我當年都係報左3間, 有一間收左之後, 其他果d連面試都無去, 免得阻左人地個位啦.

呢果世界永遠無話最好既, 最緊要覺得適合自己同小朋友就ok

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-17 13:49

totally agree!!!

it's always good to know that we are not alone!!!

原帖由 littlefaith 於 17/9/2009 12:42 發表

我都係報咗兩間，仲少過你啦﹗

報學校最緊要match，唔應該用報學校嚟做工具 (如當保險、訓練面試)，所以我同太太都唔主張報咁多。

作者: flostangraphy 時間: 09-9-17 13:49

support!!

原帖由 G-Ma 於 17/9/2009 12:55 發表
我當年都係報左3間, 有一間收左之後, 其他果d連面試都無去, 免得阻左人地個位啦.

呢果世界永遠無話最好既, 最緊要覺得適合自己同小朋友就ok

作者: rachncurtsmom 時間: 09-9-17 14:45

雖然我都覺得我個女唔錯，但係我真係唔夠膽只係報兩間，萬一無間收點算

不過我都只係報左四間，應該會報埋最後同最貴嗰一間，一共試五間，都係求個保險啫

作者: tinkerbell2004 時間: 09-9-17 16:12

I apply for different schools only for security reason. I also think that both the child and I will be fatigue if we need to attend many interviews.

作者: mamimummy 時間: 09-9-17 20:09

原帖由 G-Ma 於 09-9-17 12:55 發表
我當年都係報左3間, 有一間收左之後, 其他果d連面試都無去, 免得阻左人地個位啦.

呢果世界永遠無話最好既, 最緊要覺得適合自己同小朋友就ok

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)