教育王國
標題: 報讀直資須知(New) [打印本頁]
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-2 16:52 標題: 報讀直資須知(New)
I pay deep salute to those DSS schools that provide quality education to children, especially those newly founded ones. My daughter benefitted from it very much. For some regional subsidized schools, they provide quality education to their pupils. However, they do not have enough able pupils to get outstandling results in the public competitions. It is because around half of their pupils are allocated by the government. They may even have special education needs.e.g. Autism, dylexia.Family and financial problems are also serious. However, the teachers are skilful to tackle these problems very well. Also, for the first round of some schools, it is no different to central allocation because they have to enrol whoever he/she is. They do not have enough intake. Owing to demographic reasons, they may be suffering from stringent classes. They have no source to attract pupils from other districts either. One school in Tseung Kwan O took up the solemn duty by enrolling these pupils. However, other parents did not accept this very much. Finally the school wound up. Next school year, as reported by the Government Department, 100 classes of P 1 wil be cut because of the lagacy of SARS. In conclusion, many schools provide quality education but they may have inadequate pupils for P.1. Some schools have the situation on the other way round.
[[i] 本帖最後由 funnyguy 於 09-9-11 02:23 編輯 [/i]]
作者: hkcindy 時間: 09-9-2 17:07
睇完都唔係好明妳想講咩添~
可唔可以直接d講埋school name?
作者: ShinTeresa 時間: 09-9-2 17:14
照你甘講 即係好定唔好 ??原帖由 hkcindy 於 09-9-2 17:07 發表 
mouth:" />
睇完都唔係好明妳想講咩添~
可唔可以直接d講埋school name?
作者: smartcar 時間: 09-9-2 17:16
Which school your daughter is stuying?
I agree school is only the platform and school takes all the credits from parent' private tutoring.
Don't upset...it is parent job to bring up the kid.
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 09-9-2 17:17
我想問有邊間學校, 老師教完之後, 父母o係屋企真係唔駛理架
唔止直資學校, 基本上每一間學校都話自己可以教好學生英文架啦...........
作者: hkcindy 時間: 09-9-2 17:22
原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 09-9-2 17:17 發表
我想問有邊間學校, 老師教完之後, 父母o係屋企真係唔駛理架
唔止直資學校, 基本上每一間學校都話自己可以教好學生英文架啦...........
作者: 猴子爸 時間: 09-9-2 17:22
I believe the most preferred schools you are talking about are SPCC, DBSPD, and DGJS (isn't it a private school? still, I can't think of a DS girls school that is comparable to these 2.). Are you saying that apart from these 3 schools, all other DSSs are just mediocre? By that you mean a lot of parental tutorial is required for those studying at these mediocre DSSs while those top 3 can train the students well without requiring much assistance from the parents? Well, based on hearsay, DBSPD requires the full time moms to provide a lot of assistance to their kid.
作者: myrchan 時間: 09-9-2 18:22
非常同意。
我都聽過一位過氣直資校長講過,既然有大把學生比我選擇,我無理由唔選擇果d有父母(即屋企)支援既學生。呢個係好現實既...
所有學校都一樣,成日將學生攞獎或考到咩好學校等成績貼晒出黎,其實好混淆視聽,究竟歸功父母定學校至真呢?
反而,我都有聽到一d直資校長/老師講佢地係好有心教好小朋友,而唔係一味講學術方面點叻,亦係我比較鍾意既。講真,我唔知我個小朋友係叻唔叻,就算唔叻,起碼學校教到佢唔好放棄,慢慢進步,都好過無啦。
原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 09-9-2 17:17 發表
我想問有邊間學校, 老師教完之後, 父母o係屋企真係唔駛理架
唔止直資學校, 基本上每一間學校都話自己可以教好學生英文架啦...........
作者: smartcar 時間: 09-9-2 19:11
agreed
我都聽過一位過氣直資校長講過,既然有大把學生比我選擇,我無理由唔選擇果d有父母(即屋企)支援既學生。呢個係好現實既...
school pick responsible parents.
作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-2 22:12
直資有收生權梗係會收好質素d既學生, 都係正常既.
作者: 召藥師 時間: 09-9-3 00:10
原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 09-9-2 05:17 PM 發表
我想問有邊間學校, 老師教完之後, 父母o係屋企真係唔駛理架
唔止直資學校, 基本上每一間學校都話自己可以教好學生英文架啦...........
其實間間學校都係咁，可能部份家長覺得交左學費都仲要出面再學會覺得唔抵。
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-4 15:05
Choose the right school!
[ 本帖最後由 funnyguy 於 09-9-11 02:07 編輯 ]
作者: bowling68 時間: 09-9-5 23:53
agree. if you want your kids to be successful,
parental teaching and full time mom is a MUST !
The kid will be more concentrated and easier to take up the knowledge.
作者: Unclejt 時間: 09-9-6 03:25
原帖由 bowling68 於 09-9-5 23:53 發表
agree. if you want your kids to be successful,
parental teaching and full time mom is a MUST !
The kid will be more concentrated and easier to take up the knowledge.
作者: myrchan 時間: 09-9-6 12:20
好現實架:;pppp:
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-7 00:43
My time on this message is not wasted. So many positive and encouraging replies.
[ 本帖最後由 funnyguy 於 09-9-7 00:52 編輯 ]
作者: mattsmum 時間: 09-9-7 13:24
1.agree that parantal guidance are always needed, especially on reading, what to read, how to read, when to read,
2. are our teachers too spoiled that they believe parents should take up the teaching, not teachers?
3. there are teachers in hk who said this: ( but they are not hk teachers but IS teachers): 别給孩子答案，如果他不明白，請孩子來找我們，我們會教他.
4. if an average child's abilility is 70% out of 100% and parents want 95%, parents would have to do the teaching.
作者: mattsmum 時間: 09-9-7 13:28
I don't think that applys to every DSS,
作者: Kanba 時間: 09-9-7 22:29
The higher the parents expect, the larger is the expectation gap, the more they need to do to narrow the gap. Who else will do it for you?
作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-7 23:32
唔係間間直資都係咁, 我囡囡學校基本上唔需要再出外補習都可以自行應付到.
原帖由 funnyguy 於 09-9-4 15:05 發表
My daughter has just been promoted to S1. I am writing this message to share my feelings after my daughter has completed her primary school life in a DSS school this year.
I believe many parents are ...
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-8 00:53
If parents have no expectation on their children, they will not pay for a place in a DSS school. Like me , I want my daughter to attain the great achievements as those in the famous schools.
If we ask for 95% from our children, does it mean they will get 95% in reality after we all have tried hard?
If we ask for 75% of our children, it does not mean we can let them learn themselves without our guidance and monitoring.
The reason is we always expect higher but the outcome is lower.
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-8 00:59
If parents have no expectation on their children, they will not pay for a place in a DSS school. Like me , I want my daughter to attain the great achievements as those in the famous schools.
If we ask for 95% from our children, does it mean they will get 95% in reality after we all have tried hard?
If we ask for 75% of our children, it does not mean we can let them learn themselves without our guidance and monitoring.
The reason is we always expect higher but the outcome is lower.
作者: fongyuen 時間: 09-9-8 06:46
funnyguy,
其實，學校唔係靈丹妙藥，無論直資、津校定官校，家長係唔可以諗住小朋友入咗學校，家長就可以唔使操心，小朋友會自然地好似工廠嘅優質產品咁出返嚟。除非小朋友絕頂聰明/自律性強，否則家長都係要响課後幫小朋友補習/搵人幫小朋友補習。
可唔可以PM話我知係邊間直資？
作者: maisyraymond 時間: 09-9-8 09:29
but the cruel reality is most parents always have high, and sometimes unreasonable, expectations on their children without fully understanding and assessing at what level their children are.
I have once heard one teacher teaching in a top band 1 primary school said whenever teachers give out test and exam papers, the next day they will receive numerous parents callings, urging for a few more marks because their little princes and princesses are unhappy about the results and they refuse to take meals. I guess it is NOT the children who has lost the appetite just because of a few marks on the papers. It is the parents who can't face the reality!
原帖由 fongyuen 於 09-9-8 06:46 發表
funnyguy,
其實，學校唔係靈丹妙藥，無論直資、津校定官校，家長係唔可以諗住小朋友入咗學校，家長就可以唔使操心，小朋友會自然地好似工廠嘅優質產品咁出返嚟。除非小朋友絕頂聰明/自律性強，否則家長都係要响課後幫小朋友補習 ...
作者: TomatoCat 時間: 09-9-8 09:39
Does it mean that the schools will prefer those kids with mother as housewife rather than go out to work?
原帖由 smartcar 於 09-9-2 19:11 發表
agreed
我都聽過一位過氣直資校長講過,既然有大把學生比我選擇,我無理由唔選擇果d有父母(即屋企)支援既學生。呢個係好現實既...
school pick responsible parents. ...
作者: 猴子爸 時間: 09-9-8 11:15 標題: 回覆 25# TomatoCat 的文章
Sure! I've heard that a lot of 1st tier schools prefer admitting students with a full time mom who can provide full assistance on the studies and moral education. DBSPD is one of them. But of course, this is not the only determining factor. At the end of the day, it's about the child himself. If he is super smart, no school would have any reason to reject him.
作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-8 11:16
我相信唔係所有家長都為分數去揀直資, 直資既出現的確比家長多左選擇去揀合適既學校, 而唔係只靠抽獎. 我自己揀直資主要係因為學校提供到好好既語文環境, 愉快教學, 有中學直上壓力唔大, 至於囡囡可唔可以攞到高分數, 呢樣野真係要睇佢自己既資質同父母可以付出幾多時間, 無可能靠哂學校就可以有個出類拔萃既小朋友.
原帖由 funnyguy 於 09-9-8 00:53 發表
If parents have no expectation on their children, they will not pay for a place in a DSS school. Like me , I want my daughter to attain the great achievements as those in the famous schools.
If we as ...
作者: 已刪除用戶 時間: 09-9-8 11:35
直資有好多種, 有d傳統轉直資, 從來focus都係strike for academic excellence
亦有部分直資, focus不嬲都唔係以學術行先, 而係講生命教育, 講發展小朋友各方面balance, 例如team building, presentation skills, 敢試敢錯, 培養自信心, critical thinking............如果你小朋友真係讀左呢類直資6年, 無理由感受唔到
覺得讀完, 而得唔到你想要既great achievements, 我只可以講句: 根本係錯配!
原帖由 funnyguy 於 09-9-8 12:53 AM 發表
If parents have no expectation on their children, they will not pay for a place in a DSS school. Like me , I want my daughter to attain the great achievements as those in the famous schools.
作者: myrchan 時間: 09-9-8 14:46
付了錢的總會覺得自己是客人，得不到心水貨品的總會覺得貨不對辦，一肚子難受。
DSS尚算新，唔似傳統學校可追溯多年公開試成績，究竟一個孩子由小一開始讀DSS至中學畢業再上大學，係會點既呢？我真係好想搵個實例睇下。既然兩者教學方向不同，若在學術上，要求DSS同學仔＝傳統學生，好似唔多公平，因為DSS可給予學生的發揮空間，又非傳統學校所能給予。
純粹就教育概念來說，我還是喜歡DSS讓孩子創意和學習興趣更高。因我見阿哥和家姐的女兒，讀傳統名校，成績ok，但全無學習興趣和動力，令父母担心。
但願大家為孩子「買」教育時，做個精明消費者，免得受人誤導，到時去消委會投訴都枉然
作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-8 16:59
選擇學校真係應該要親身多參觀, 多了解, 信自己雙眼好過只係聽人地講.
[ 本帖最後由 G-Ma 於 09-9-8 17:18 編輯 ]
作者: fongyuen 時間: 09-9-8 17:12
原帖由 myrchan 於 09-9-8 14:46 發表
付了錢的總會覺得自己是客人，得不到心水貨品的總會覺得貨不對辦，一肚子難受。
DSS尚算新，唔似傳統學校可追溯多年公開試成績，究竟一個孩子由小一開始讀DSS至中學畢業再上大學，係會點既呢？我真係好想搵個實例睇下。既然兩者 ...
我本身教傳統中學多年，猶記得上次SARS停課學生歡喜若狂的樣子，反觀活動教學的學校，學生一遇停課會非常失落，分別就在於此。前者視返學是苦差，後者視返學是樂事。孰優？敦劣？只有家長自己判斷。
作者: sweetyboy 時間: 09-9-9 00:36 標題: 回覆 2# G-Ma 的文章
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-9 09:25
some good responses again
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-9 12:41
I don't mean we can shift our duty to look after our children. However, it sounds funny if we have to teach them many subjects again at home instead of learning at school themselves
作者: fongyuen 時間: 09-9-9 15:09
原帖由 funnyguy 於 09-9-9 12:41 發表
I don't mean we can shift our duty to look after our children. However, it sounds funny if we have to teach them many subjects again at home instead of learning at school themselves
That's why I want to know which DSS your daugther was in.
As far as I know, not many DSSs like this. It is strange to say the DSS students experience ineffective learning at school.
Certainly, if "learning" to you means reciting, drilling and repetitively doing similar homework (in order to cope with TSA, etc.), DSS (with activity-based learning) is not the right choice for you.
[ 本帖最後由 fongyuen 於 09-9-9 15:10 編輯 ]
作者: jamhappybobo 時間: 09-9-9 15:46
原帖由 Charlotte_mom 於 09-9-8 11:35 發表
亦有部分直資, focus不嬲都唔係以學術行先, 而係講生命教育, 講發展小朋友各方面balance, 例如team building, presentation skills, 敢 ...
would you please tell me which school it is?
作者: ziyi 時間: 09-9-9 15:47
港同
原帖由 jamhappybobo 於 09-9-9 15:46 發表
would you please tell me which school it is?
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-9 20:17
You are lucky. I have difficulty in finding this message
作者: shala 時間: 09-9-9 22:35
我想問係咪準備去外國升學先揀直資謮?
如果唔係,咁小學上中學,係咪所有直資都會有中學比所有自己嘅小學生直上
直資係咪同傳統中學都係謮咁多年?咁大學呢,如果唔出國
前景會如何?
其實我都想同阿囝報直資,但對直資和傳統學校嘅瞭解不太深,
希望大家不要見笑
作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-9 22:54
讀直資最終唔一定要出外國讀, 好多直資課程都同官津一樣, 可以上本地中學及大學.
直資既好處係佢地既有政府資助, 亦會向家長收取學費, 所以資源上會比官津好d, 再加上直資學校可以自由收生, 自行編制課程, 相對學生程度會較相若, 學習起上黎會事半功倍.
原帖由 shala 於 09-9-9 22:35 發表
我想問係咪準備去外國升學先揀直資謮?
如果唔係,咁小學上中學,係咪所有直資都會有中學比所有自己嘅小學生直上
直資係咪同傳統中學都係謮咁多年?咁大學呢,如果唔出國
前景會如何?
其實我都想同阿囝報直資,但對直資和 ...
[ 本帖最後由 G-Ma 於 09-9-10 12:53 編輯 ]
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-10 00:35
we want positive answers
[ 本帖最後由 funnyguy 於 09-9-11 00:28 編輯 ]
作者: shala 時間: 09-9-10 10:56
我現階段只報了港同,請問香港同九龍共有邊幾間直資辦得不錯的?
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-10 17:27
waiting for your views
作者: myrchan 時間: 09-9-10 18:16
我都好想知,尤其九龍區。
funnyguy,你是否已為孩子轉回傳統學校?
[ 本帖最後由 myrchan 於 09-9-10 18:18 編輯 ]
作者: G-Ma 時間: 09-9-10 20:50
九龍區有陳守仁, 聖瑪加利, 蔡繼有等等
原帖由 myrchan 於 09-9-10 18:16 發表
我都好想知,尤其九龍區。
funnyguy,你是否已為孩子轉回傳統學校?
作者: shala 時間: 09-9-10 22:11
咁香港區呢?
作者: Hayley04 時間: 09-9-10 22:19
I fully agree with you.
Parents are like the high jump player. They always want to jump higher and higher even the world record is made.
Parents pay school fee in DSS (vs. not paying parents in most gov. school) would have higher expectation. In fact, outcomes might not link to your financial investment.
原帖由 funnyguy 於 09-9-8 00:59 發表
If parents have no expectation on their children, they will not pay for a place in a DSS school. Like me , I want my daughter to attain the great achievements as those in the famous schools.
If we as ...
作者: yeesumyin 時間: 09-9-11 00:11
St. Paul Boys also is a DSS school in Hong Kong side. Any comments on this school?
原帖由 shala 於 09-9-10 22:11 發表
咁香港區呢?
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-11 02:25
I am an honest mum. My passage is meaningful
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-11 12:49
Do you agree with my new views?
作者: funnyguy 時間: 09-9-11 23:47
Wait for your responses
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |