教育王國

標題: 家長已經取消了學費自動轉賬嗎？ [打印本頁]

作者: bebegirl 時間: 09-6-25 13:27 標題: 家長已經取消了學費自動轉賬嗎？

其實，都希望七月可以照常上課，無奈…政府已經決定了！一方面希望小朋友都做個有始有終的人，而且這次停課又真的與學校無關，但就是因為小朋友停課期間沒事做，反而，我們又要額外花錢安排一些課外活動讓他們參與，所以開支更大！
我的小朋友只讀Pre-nursery，學費每月三千多元，下學年又不會再在此校就讀，所以好惆悵呢！不知是否真的有很多家長已經截了autopay呢？

作者: ioi 時間: 09-6-25 13:50

如果卑鄙些的做法, 當然是停了autopay, 到學校追收再算, 反正也不在此校升學. 但當然不建議使用.

較好的做法是, 你盡快, 最好今天, 即刻寫封退學信給學校, 一般退學是一個月通知, 那麼你的學費也只需交至7月24日, 不用交足七月份, 甚至八月份(如有)的學費. 如自動轉賬在月初已扣全數, 學校在最後應該要退還部份學費給你.

作者: siusung 時間: 09-6-25 15:14

我同你的case相同,我都唔知交唔交好!!

原帖由 bebegirl 於 09-6-25 13:27 發表
其實，都希望七月可以照常上課，無奈…政府已經決定了！一方面希望小朋友都做個有始有終的人，而且這次停課又真的與學校無關，但就是因為小朋友停課期間沒事做，反而，我們又要額外花錢安排一些課外活動讓他們參與，所以開支更大！
我 ...

作者: KarenKwan 時間: 09-6-25 16:09

same case as mine, but school will have function for my son, from 7/2 - 7/16, 1 hour per day, so i will pay July school fee - $4380.

作者: Kendis1 時間: 09-6-25 16:27 標題: 回覆 1# KarenKwan 的文章

我已經cut咗喇! 因為下年我已經唔喺度讀, 無計啦! 如果係喺度讀既話, 焗住都要俾...

1)學校: 其實學校最緊張就係收到錢啫! 既然可以收到錢,係8月頭會開始俾d細路上playgroup又點話, 反正d老師係咪都要返架喇! (妳估佢哋真係可以放暑假咩!)

2)政府:話停校啫, 不過無話停playgroup. 所以學校呢招真係高明, 真係"上有政策,下有對策"喇! 今次我哋又要睇我哋既政府點"拆招"喇!

3)家長: 坦白講, 出面上playgroup洗麥 (咁貴)用到HK$4xxx啊!既然學校諗到解決辦法, 咁咪算囉 (好黎好去)!唔通真係唔交咩(企硬)?!話晒(無計啦!)個細路仲要喺度學落去,好好醜醜,焗住都要俾...

作者: jm1874 時間: 09-6-26 00:25

真係可以續日計？我都驚我果間學校會收足我七月學費呀陰功!

原帖由 ioi 於 09-6-25 13:50 發表
如果卑鄙些的做法, 當然是停了autopay, 到學校追收再算, 反正也不在此校升學. 但當然不建議使用.

較好的做法是, 你盡快, 最好今天, 即刻寫封退學信給學校, 一般退學是一個月通知, 那麼你的學費也只需交至7月24日, ...

作者: FiMaMa 時間: 09-6-26 01:18

My situation is the same. My daugther is attending N class and will promote to K1 in another kindergarten in Sep 09.

The existing school called and informed that the class (something liked a play group mode) will resume in early Jul 09 to mid-Jul.

Quite a dilemma! On one hand, I'm very concern about the Swine Flu that I may put my girl exposed to the illness if I let her go to school. On the other hand, it seems not very appropriate to just cut the autopay and the resumption of class seems to be an alternative to justify my continued paying the school fee for Jul (around $3,200) and let her spend her time in a more meaningful way.

Would you share your views?

作者: ioi 時間: 09-6-26 07:56

原帖由 jm1874 於 09-6-26 00:25 發表
真係可以續日計？我都驚我果間學校會收足我七月學費呀陰功!

oh... 那我又不知幼稚園是否可以計得那麼準確, 但指明是一個月通知, 應該計得清清楚楚才是. 不過現在都月尾了, 就算佢計清楚都只是慳少少錢.

作者: 七點半 時間: 09-6-26 17:00

我都係....雖然有人叫我cut自動轉賬...但係囡囡都曾經好開心咁係學校讀過...所以我都係跟返正常程序預早一個月通知退學....七月份學費要照交....

原帖由 bebegirl 於 09-6-25 13:27 發表
其實，都希望七月可以照常上課，無奈…政府已經決定了！一方面希望小朋友都做個有始有終的人，而且這次停課又真的與學校無關，但就是因為小朋友停課期間沒事做，反而，我們又要額外花錢安排一些課外活動讓他們參與，所以開支更大！
我 ...

作者: wlmom 時間: 09-6-26 17:22

i really couldn't believe there are moms who will cease to pay the school fees for July. This is an irresponsible act. they just make themselves so cheap in saving the little money.

i will continue to pay even the fee is $4xxx and my son will graduate this year. the school still needs to operate and teachers still need salaries. besides, u never know what you will need from the school in the future. "good start good end"

作者: 靚太太 時間: 09-6-26 21:07

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: cheng713 時間: 09-6-26 23:18

原帖由 wlmom 於 09-6-26 17:22 發表
i really couldn't believe there are moms who will cease to pay the school fees for July. This is an irresponsible act. they just make themselves so cheap in saving the little money.

i will continue ...

Sorry wlmom but I don’t agree with you. Many private KGs like the one my son goes to put money ahead of education. The did not offer any help during school closure and even discouraged parents from taking their kids back to school, even on some days we were so busy that no one could watch him. Now they urge us to pay July fee ($4,xxx) but only offer exercise books in return (it’s true. They offer nothing else)

I agree with you that we should give everything a good start and a good end. But why should the parents be the only side to commit to this, and to suffer? Why can’t the KGs and teachers share our difficulties? Why can’t the gov. offer help, since they are the ones to order school closure. The schools have normal expenses during closure, and so do the parents. Perhaps you are financially affluent. But to many families the school fee is a big part of their expenses. Now we even have to spend extra money to hire someone to watch our son, or send him to other play groups. Why will help us? I don’t believe if parents not pay for one month, the schools and teachers will be broke. (If so, the headmaster must have problems in dealing with finances.)

If I tell my employer that I won’t do anything
(or do 10% of work) for him for 2 months but he has to keep paying me, do you think he, or anyone that is not crazy, would do that? Many private schools are being run like a business, like the one my son attends. Education to them is just a way of making money. I don’t see they will share our difficulties and offer help when we need.

So I cut my autopay and don’t plan to pay for the July school fees.

作者: bebegirl 時間: 09-6-27 00:28

For those parents who have already cut the autopay, will you attend the parents' day or just ignore everything from school?
Though I strongly agreed that no pay for no services received, but it's not the schools who intentionally closed that make us headache. I think that's a case which really requires the government to intervene and compensate for parents but not in terms of salaries from teachers. Sigh...

作者: Kendis1 時間: 09-6-27 10:19

親愛的家長們,

這一刻我們的政府是不會再為停課而出來講野. Why? 因為再講就會牽涉金錢(學費). 所以, 佢哋依家仲唔係做"縮頭動物", 有几遠就"閃"几遠喇!

至於學校, 一定要諗下d新(好)"計仔". 否則就係對d家長們好不公平, 條氣難順, 又點自願俾錢啊!

原帖由 bebegirl 於 09-6-27 00:28 發表
For those parents who have already cut the autopay, will you attend the parents' day or just ignore everything from school?
Though I strongly agreed that no pay for no services received, but it's not ...

作者: siusung 時間: 09-6-27 15:29

其實我都好同意你"口既"說法,其實我囝囝現時謮近n1,個班主任對我囝囝好好,坦白講我情願將學費比哂班主任,我都唔想交比學校,因學校完全無幫我地家長唸過,所以我都決定唔會交的,我相信如果只係一個月的學費,唔會另到學校有困難的!!

原帖由 cheng713 於 09-6-26 23:18 發表

Sorry wlmom but I don’t agree with you. Many private KGs like the one my son goes to put money ahead of education. The did not offer any help during school closure and even discouraged parents from ...

作者: 靚太太 時間: 09-6-27 15:59

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: cheng713 時間: 09-6-27 16:19

原帖由 靚太太 於 09-6-27 15:59 發表
點解唔諗下都最後一個月,好來好去!
況且如果9月開學都仲有H1N1,唔通大家又會cut左自動轉脹,會唔會其實係因為大家來年都唔讀反正見唔到所以索性cut左去呢？？？ ...

Why can't school be "好來好去" by offering discounts or simply resume classes in small groups like some schools do? Again, the point is, why this whole H1N1 thing the parents seem to be the only side to sacrifice and suffer? Why the gov. not doing anything? Why can't the schools and teachers share our difficulties? Why?

作者: bloodleee 時間: 09-6-29 03:24

To cheng713 & siusung

OkOk, 拿，以後逢係紅黑暴雨，3 號8 號風球幼稚園需要停課時，你班師奶就出黎遊行叫政府或學校Pro-rata退返一日兩日學費備你地咯，哦，仲有吾好吾記得退埋個十蚊八蚊校車錢喔。
如果你地真係覺得要備幾千蚊係好肉赤，點解當初你地吾備你地細路讀D平D既幼稚園？？所以人地教育局米串你話其實幼稚園都吾係必須要讀黎升小學咯，因爲吾讀米完全吾駛錢咯，你話呢？哦，索性當初吾好鬼生仔米乜錢都吾駛用咯。。。。

作者: twinsstar 時間: 09-6-29 09:55

Ha .. the goverment didn't intentionally make you suffer ... .....hahaha

原帖由 cheng713 於 09-6-27 16:19 發表

Why can't school be "好來好去" by offering discounts or simply resume classes in small groups like some schools do? Again, the point is, why this whole H1N1 thing the parents seem to be the only sid ...

作者: twinsstar 時間: 09-6-29 10:06

Guess your kid would not study in this school next year ?!... if you hate this sch sooooo much and you really think that the sch / teachers / other staff has nth to be appreciated of ... gd that you've cut the autopay.. or else you will be furious all the time...

原帖由 cheng713 於 09-6-26 23:18 發表

Sorry wlmom but I don’t agree with you. Many private KGs like the one my son goes to put money ahead of education. The did not offer any help during school closure and even discouraged parents from ...

作者: Kendis1 時間: 09-6-29 10:37

打手,

依家係講僅一個月(停課)嘅問題, 而唔係一.兩日(暴雨&病假)問題, right????

呢一刻,忽然停課真係對好多家長做成好大負擔的, 而家長們只是在這平台訴訴苦而已, 何必要處處"將軍揪車"呢?!

最後, 是否會支付學費只家長們自己才知曉, 為何不抱著平常心聽聽她們的說法呢???

原帖由 bloodleee 於 09-6-29 03:24 發表
To cheng713 & siusung

OkOk, 拿，以後逢係紅黑暴雨，3 號8 號風球幼稚園需要停課時，你班師奶就出黎遊行叫政府或學校Pro-rata退返一日兩日學費備你地咯，哦，仲有吾好吾記得退埋個十蚊八蚊校車錢喔。
如果你地真係覺得要備 ...

作者: 熱血媽媽 時間: 09-6-30 13:20

"打手出沒注意"

作者: ioi 時間: 09-6-30 21:07

原帖由 靚太太 於 09-6-27 15:59 發表
點解唔諗下都最後一個月,好來好去!
況且如果9月開學都仲有H1N1,唔通大家又會cut左自動轉脹,會唔會其實係因為大家來年都唔讀反正見唔到所以索性cut左去呢？？？ ...

我是有照交學費的, 我都想好來好去, 可是現在似乎是家長願意盡責, 但學校不想盡責... 學校只是在第一次宣佈停課時派了一叠平日的功課, 原定覆課時交. 第二次宣佈停課再派了一叠餘下的功課, 但沒有收回第一次的功課, 亦沒有說明是否要交, 何時要交. 我認為, 沒有老師批改的習作, 是沒有意義的, 學生得不到回饋, 不知道做得好不好, 亦不知道做對或做錯. 而不用呈交的習作亦會令學生失去做功課的動力. 原本沒有停課的話, 老師也要批改這叠功課的, 但停了課, 老師就甚麼也不做了, 那老師豈不是更"著數". 說老師要備課, 做教具等... 沒錯, 她們正準備下年度的事, 就算沒有停課, 她們在暑期也是要做的!

如果你子女的幼稚園是這樣甚麼也不做的話, 連最基本的批改功課也不做, 你認為交學費還合理嗎?

作者: 靚太太 時間: 09-7-1 14:49

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: junjun609 時間: 09-7-1 22:38

My daughter was studying N1 , and she will go to another school in K1 . The school fee was very expensive , $5XXX / month.
I had talked to the teacher by phone, will they have any policy on the swine flu and the school fee in July. Will there any discount on school fee...... She said they will have meeting and discuss on this issue with the principal , and reply me later. But they never call me . So I want to quit the class .
I think the teachers will have lots of time in school during this period. Good communication and relationship between us is important. But my impression is that they did nothing to keep our relationship.

It is good that some schools change the format of teaching . Have some activities/ playgroup ....At least they do something. Even some parents will not let their child to attend because of swine flu pandemic, but i think most of us are willing to pay for the school fee.

作者: lingling06 時間: 09-7-1 22:58

$5xxx school fee? Is your daughter studying at YC?

My boy's case is similar to yours. No phone calls from the school but the school still charges us the July tuition fee.

原帖由 junjun609 於 09-7-1 22:38 發表
My daughter was studying N1 , and she will go to another school in K1 . The school fee was very expensive , $5XXX / month.
I had talked to the teacher by phone, will they have any policy on the ...

作者: gyeung77 時間: 09-7-1 23:26

Although my girl is going to a different school next year (K1) and I already inform the school that she is not attending the school in May, I will still pay the July school fee. Becasue I feel that although we told the school my girl is not going to stay in the school in K1, they still take care of my girl so I think that I should pay the fee.

作者: support2008 時間: 09-7-1 23:27 標題: july school fee

I really couldn't believe some moms will cease the school fee, especailly, for those are studing in K3. Making them so cheap and they have responsibility to pay for the fee.

Even worst that a mom fired a complaint to the education department asking the school to stop all the activities including graduation ceremony and mid term exam, just because her son/daugther will not come back. She think it is not fair to her child, if other kids can join the graduation ceremony. But she already told the school that she will not pay for the fee.

The school has done so much during this period and I think we should do as what we agree to pay for 12 months school fee.

This parent is so selffish and childish

作者: twinsstar 時間: 09-7-4 14:36

yes ... we parents want the sch / govt to consider our needs / difficulties but I think we have to think of their difficulties too ...

原帖由 support2008 於 09-7-1 23:27 發表
I really couldn't believe some moms will cease the school fee, especailly, for those are studing in K3. Making them so cheap and they have responsibility to pay for the fee.

Even worst that a mom ...

作者: leemeifung 時間: 09-7-4 22:44

幫幫忙,想找日計幼兒(稚)園,因7月份只返得十幾日, 唔想比足一個月,有無好來好去既幼兒(稚)園?
"問下唔好打頭"

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)