教育王國

標題: 請問20分入Maryknoll 的機會有幾多呀? [打印本頁]

作者: tt2009 時間: 09-5-23 22:23 標題: 請問20分入Maryknoll 的機會有幾多呀?

請問20分入Maryknoll 的機會有幾多呀? 因為我個女K2啦, 要選學校, 好煩呀, 請幫吓手啦!!謝謝!!

作者: 277177 時間: 09-5-26 15:48

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 小元 時間: 09-5-28 13:11

侄女是準小一學生,她是20分,她媽咪話如果有多人同時20分會在那班人再自己抽籤,她的朋友也是20分也落選,但她到了聖方濟各。
祝大家　good　luck!

作者: mmak 時間: 09-5-30 23:08

20分有人抽到, 但都有好多人抽唔到, 睇你膽量... ??

原帖由 277177 於 09-5-26 15:48 發表
我都好想知呀

作者: hawflake0496 時間: 09-7-13 00:07

原帖由 tt2009 於 09-5-23 22:23 發表
請問20分入Maryknoll 的機會有幾多呀? 因為我個女K2啦, 要選學校, 好煩呀, 請幫吓手啦!!謝謝!!

20 credits for Maryknoll is not safe at all. 25 credits should be secure, but 20 credits is just by luck! I am a Maryknoll graduate, but since my daughter is not a Catholic, I also got 20 credits only, and I didnt make it as well in 2nd round. But since i am an old gal, I do have referral to principal, so finally made it thru the 3rd round interview. But its not easy to be success too, since all the list of candidates in 3rd round are either daughters of old gals (like my case), or have referral from school management/sisters.
But up to this stage, the principal is fair, the performance of the girls will be most essential.

[ 本帖最後由 hawflake0496 於 09-7-13 00:08 編輯 ]

作者: vivi111 時間: 09-7-20 23:17

how do you know it's fair

作者: youma 時間: 09-7-23 00:07

You get an interview only if you have internal references or are an old girl. What sort of “fairness” it is?

Maryknoll is a subsidized school. 這根本就是將政府資源私相授受 !

作者: bigfoothk 時間: 09-7-23 08:55

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: baekdoosan 時間: 09-7-23 09:53

i guess about 1/5 to 1/10 chance with 20 pts.

作者: littlekid 時間: 09-7-24 13:58

20分的機位都有 2:8, 即 2 為 20分, 8 為 25分 (第一 round)

作者: mmak 時間: 09-7-24 17:53

舊年 2008.11 我在MCS看到1st round 的收生結果是76個位

聽講第一輪76個位之中60%留給有姊姊讀緊的細女(必收), 宜家出生率低應有剩位... 再留俾25-20分的.

所以第一輪餘下的40%，就是約有30個位是給 25-20分抽韱的。

應該派晒25分>> 再到20分就抽籤決定, 機會好微.. 但都會有人抽中的.

其實大家都係估估吓 ???
都唔知每年有幾多細女 ???
又唔知有幾多25分 ???... 20分???

作者: minniez 時間: 09-7-25 11:10

原帖由 mmak 於 09-7-24 17:53 發表
舊年 2008.11 我在MCS看到1st round 的收生結果是76個位

聽講第一輪76個位之中60%留給有姊姊讀緊的細女(必收), 宜家出生率低應有剩位... 再留俾25-20分的.

所以第一輪餘下的40%，就是約有30個位是給 25-20分抽韱 ...

請問邊度可以睇到間學校第一輪同第二輪分別收左幾多學生?

作者: mmak 時間: 09-7-25 18:05

minniez,

依度有資料, 但唔update...
http://psp.proj.hkedcity.net/chi/parser.php?file=chi/detail_sch_class_stru.htm&school_id=401

我估今年 2009/2010 應有150個P.1 位??
我自己親身去MCS 睇1st round 結果時, 自己親手逐個人名數架(希望無數錯..)

我唔知我有無搞錯???
抽獎方式好似係將所有學額分一半,
1st & 2nd round 各有76個位.... (75+75 =150)

希望我無搞錯,

原帖由 minniez 於 09-7-25 11:10 發表

請問邊度可以睇到間學校第一輪同第二輪分別收左幾多學生?

[ 本帖最後由 mmak 於 09-8-3 14:45 編輯 ]

作者: ziyi 時間: 09-8-3 14:33

怎算才公平?
我覺得現在已經是不公平中的公平,
先聲明我囡囡只有15分,亦只有一個小朋友
試想想,如果計考試,K3可以考什麼,基本上那個年齡只會谷Vocab,5-6歲人仔
如果論面試表現,你也可以說自己的那個表現佳,是學校偏私
而且,突然小朋友面試出了狀況,那又怎計
現在round 1, 不面試,只計分,雖然不是最公平,但最小心中有數啊
而且,收回有哥倫比亞,姐姐的先,你可以不公平,但同時要體諒,叫父母每天送完一個又一個?
我希望入的一間也不夠分,但只能說規則就是這樣!
到叩門,大家都是這樣的情況下,認識有優勢是無可口非,像一個是你朋友,一個不是,你會信誰?
多些找尋,研究策略好過

作者: 小曳人 時間: 09-8-3 15:29

原帖由 youma 於 09-7-23 00:07 發表
You get an interview only if you have internal references or are an old girl. What sort of “fairness” it is?

Maryknoll is a subsidized school. 這根本就是將政府資源私相授受 !

有幾公平?
hmm... 早幾日先同個老友傾開, 佢老婆响maryknoll教, 佢話唔駛諗, 全部校長決定, 以前佢地同LS有非明文習慣, 老師d仔就講LS, 女就讀maryknoll, 不過近d真係無位, 無呢支歌仔唱喇! 所以佢話要生就一定要生女!

作者: ziyi 時間: 09-8-3 15:54

有幾公平?
hmm... 早幾日先同個老友傾開, 佢老婆响maryknoll教, 佢話唔駛諗, 全部校長決定, 以前佢地同LS有非明文習慣, 老師d仔就講LS, 女就讀maryknoll, 不過近d真係無位, 無呢支歌仔唱喇! 所以佢話要生就一定要生女!

為什麼"無呢支歌仔唱喇"
就是因為所有官津學敕要跟政府規定
我沒有說這是最好的,但我想也不至私相授授
你估我不希望囡囡可以入協恩或Maryknoll,但只有15分
為什麼我可以問心無愧說這些,我得一個,亦只有15分,亦不認識任何有關聯人士
這世界沒有絕對公平,每一個人也有各自想法,但在各人利益不同下,最少你可以去計算,

作者: brian61950 時間: 09-8-3 21:10

各有前因莫羨人............
用了特別channel 的人又怎會周圍唱呢?

另一事例...........
頭輪自選只計分,同分學校"自行"抽....

la x 小學會派老師到排隊交表的家長中"傾談",因頭輪自選不能interview, 故只能"傾談", 然後他們在申請表mark上不同的記號.

個啲記號有乜用呢?

作者: ziyi 時間: 09-8-3 23:33

像我的囡囡只有15分
怎樣下記號也不會輪到我家的
但那又怎樣
最少我對得起自己的良心
"人在做,天在看",我也不去羨慕別人,努力去多了解什麼學校不太差的,計劃將來

作者: brian61950 時間: 09-8-4 00:08

原帖由 ziyi 於 09-8-3 23:33 發表
像我的囡囡只有15分
怎樣下記號也不會輪到我家的
但那又怎樣
最少我對得起自己的良心
"人在做,天在看",我也不去羨慕別人,努力去多了解什麼學校不太差的,計劃將來 ...

咁又唔係完全無機既,投其所好曪.........
名幼稚園
高薪厚職
揸靓車
攞名牌袋
帶名表
有錢地址...........

或絕招............
自己係右上角打粒星

作者: ziyi 時間: 09-8-4 12:13

haha
做唔出,無能力做,亦過唔到自己
所以放棄這些學校

作者: Reximom 時間: 09-8-4 12:34

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: 2ling 時間: 09-8-4 21:57

It's weird. I handed a form at La X School last November. I was there for more than an hour but didn't see a single teacher came inside the waiting hall --- only a "sum sum" greeted us.

I live at Net 41, my son is a Catholic and studied in a famous kinder in Kln Tong and he awarded the "first place in the class" .... no La X teacher approached us at all!!!! I guess my son was not their target?????? Hmmm.... this rumour is... interesting!!!

原帖由 brian61950 於 09-8-3 21:10 發表
各有前因莫羨人............
用了特別channel 的人又怎會周圍唱呢?

另一事例...........
頭輪自選只計分,同分學校"自行"抽....

la x 小學會派老師到排隊交表的家長中"傾談",因頭輪自選不能interview, 故只能"傾談" ...

作者: nicolemummy 時間: 09-8-4 22:10

2ling,

my situation was completely different to you. I had no good wearings or clothings. I was on a HK$33 T-shirt and a HK$160 jean with a pair of HK$40 cloth shoes. I had no make-up on my face. Let's alone any good handhand - I was with my HK$100 backpack only. I was working in Macau at that time!

During the first round application, I queued in MCS. My daughter was neither from SC nor KV. We had only 15 marks - must fail in Round 1. But we finally make it in Round 2 (lucky draw).

原帖由 2ling 於 09-8-4 21:57 發表
It's weird. I handed a form at La X School last November. I was there for more than an hour but didn't see a single teacher came inside the waiting hall --- only a "sum sum" greeted us.

I live at ...

[ 本帖最後由 nicolemummy 於 09-8-4 22:15 編輯 ]

作者: 2ling 時間: 09-8-4 22:43

nicolemummy,
Do you remember me? You pm me almost 5 years ago about a pn?

What I wanted to say in my last message was that I don't believe the teachers of La X school would approach the queued applicants! Honestly, my boy failed in the 1st round and did not join the lucky draw. He will study in a DSS next month though La X is still my dream school.

作者: parentslove 時間: 09-8-4 23:48

Anyway, 20 marks for Maryknoll is not secure.
If you don't try, means "total lost".
If you try, means "chance".
Before you take this risk, please secure your daughter has a good private school behind.
If I were you, I will try.
I did try St. Mary for my eldest daughter, now waiting for a seat in private school.

作者: nicolemummy 時間: 09-8-5 06:47

2ling,

Already 5 years! Time flies....my daughter left the pn school and joint a government aided kindergarten afterwards.

I get your points. That's why I replied you. I agree your view. And congratulation to your son. I understand why you don't try the 2nd round.

BTW, I have a son. Wish he can follow your son's suit.

原帖由 2ling 於 09-8-4 22:43 發表
nicolemummy,
Do you remember me? You pm me almost 5 years ago about a pn?

What I wanted to say in my last message was that I don't believe the teachers of La X school would approach the queued app ...

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)