教育王國

標題: 有無人收到九龍塘樂基入學通知信 [打印本頁]

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-3 13:56 標題: 有無人收到九龍塘樂基入學通知信

I have not yet received letter today (3/1/09)

作者: monkey05 時間: 09-1-3 15:57

我都係未收到. 今早打去學校問, 佢地話下MON OR TUE 會收到喎. 唉, 又要等多兩日, 心急死人.

作者: anthony010103 時間: 09-1-3 16:05

their admin procedure seems really so so wooow

[ 本帖最後由 anthony010103 於 09-1-3 16:08 編輯 ]

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-3 20:43

Dear all

my friend's daugther has received acceptance letter for pre-school AM class today, so I want to know any parents has received letter from HKPS for K1 class.

作者: BH_2 時間: 09-1-3 22:32

kowloon tong or ShaTin ?seems only Shatin hv result wow..

We "in" Kowloon Tong only, still waiting la.. I think they said 5 Jan, so should be next wk lo..

原帖由 mwccwtl 於 09-1-3 20:43 發表
Dear all

my friend's daugther has received acceptance letter for pre-school AM class today, so I want to know any parents has received letter from HKPS for K1 class.

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-3 23:05

my friend's daughter interview at Kowloon Tong, she is accepted by HKPS for pre-school AM class.

原帖由 BH_2 於 09-1-3 22:32 發表
kowloon tong or ShaTin ?seems only Shatin hv result wow..

We "in" Kowloon Tong only, still waiting la.. I think they said 5 Jan, so should be next wk lo..

作者: vivicicimimi 時間: 09-1-4 22:24

Really!

i have not yet recieve a acceptance letter!

作者: red888 時間: 09-1-5 00:46

Is your friend's daughter "big" girl or "small" girl?

原帖由 mwccwtl 於 09-1-3 23:05 發表
my friend's daughter interview at Kowloon Tong, she is accepted by HKPS for pre-school AM class.

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 09:17

Big girl....

作者: Barbie_jj 時間: 09-1-5 10:33

未收到的今日應該會收到結果的了! 剛剛打過電話去學校問, 他們說結果已全部寄出, 今天會收到了! 緊張....

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 11:14

可惜我要今晚放工返家才收到, very 緊張

作者: Barbie_jj 時間: 09-1-5 12:41

剛剛收到了, 又係waiting list呀... 想問HKPS係咪唔收的都是waiting? 如果係的話, 即是都冇機會了!

作者: Eh-oh 時間: 09-1-5 12:46

今晚放工返家CHECK CHECK, very 緊張緊張緊張緊張...

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 12:57

waiting list 要等大約6月才有機會知道有無位.

作者: Barbie_jj 時間: 09-1-5 13:02

原帖由 mwccwtl 於 09-1-5 12:57 發表
waiting list 要等大約6月才有機會知道有無位.

噢... 6月才有通知真的好"忟"呢... 因為都要決定囝囝讀甚麼學校! 不過如果HKPS收的話, 要等到6月都會等的!

作者: Eh-oh 時間: 09-1-5 13:19

They only send out the result today morning. You all receive the letter so quickly. I also hope I receive letter too after off today...
I really hope my son can study in HKPS...

作者: red888 時間: 09-1-5 15:57

好緊張....

作者: heidi0653 時間: 09-1-5 16:01

收到啦......細b又再一次failed.....囡囡果日表現得唔錯，但又係咁......激C

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 16:22

我個仔(small B)又肥佬咗, 好想哭.....

作者: Barbie_jj 時間: 09-1-5 16:25

係咪全部failed既小朋友, 都被學校放在waiting list? 我剛打過電話去, 但係乜都問唔到...

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 16:37

why? What HKPS say?

作者: monkey05 時間: 09-1-5 16:39

原帖由 Barbie_jj 於 09-1-5 16:25 發表
係咪全部failed既小朋友, 都被學校放在waiting list? 我剛打過電話去, 但係乜都問唔到...

唔好話細仔, 我呀仔係大仔又如何, 咪一樣係 waiting list.

作者: Barbie_jj 時間: 09-1-5 16:44

原帖由 mwccwtl 於 09-1-5 16:37 發表
why? What HKPS say?

今日打過電話去問學校, 我小朋友係waiting list, 想知大約幾時先會有通知有冇位, 職員把聲好似好忙, 可能今日收左好多呢類電話, 佢話比我知, 要等到有人話比佢地知, 唔會pick佢地既offer, 先有位release出來比waiting list小朋友, 所以話唔埋... 我又問個waiting list係咪好長, 佢只答我如果想知道小朋友係第幾個先排到, 佢冇呢張list, 有list既同事去左開會.

所以, 我係咩都問唔到, 亦都唔敢再打去攪住佢地做野啦! 而家都唔知點好.... 我諗機會可能好微, 可能個個唔收既都係叫做waiting?....

作者: ourbbchu 時間: 09-1-5 16:49

可能個個唔收既都係叫做waiting => no ar, one of my friends' son is rejected, no waiting wor

作者: monkey05 時間: 09-1-5 16:57

原帖由 Barbie_jj 於 09-1-5 16:44 發表

今日打過電話去問學校, 我小朋友係waiting list, 想知大約幾時先會有通知有冇位, 職員把聲好似好忙, 可能今日收左好多呢類電話, 佢話比我知, 要等到有人話比佢地知, 唔會pick佢地既offer, 先有位release出來比wait ...

我都係咁諗, 可以 wait 到既機會好微, 個個都想入到, 邊有咁多人放番個位出來. 算吧. 我都係同呀仔註冊駿景果間 hkps 算了.

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 16:58

Any parents has received acceptance letter from HKPS? So far I see all result of you are waiting list or failed (including my son).

作者: monkey05 時間: 09-1-5 16:59

原帖由 Barbie_jj 於 09-1-5 16:44 發表

今日打過電話去問學校, 我小朋友係waiting list, 想知大約幾時先會有通知有冇位, 職員把聲好似好忙, 可能今日收左好多呢類電話, 佢話比我知, 要等到有人話比佢地知, 唔會pick佢地既offer, 先有位release出來比wait ...

barbie_jj

你仔仔都係大仔來喎.
我呀仔當日interview 表現都好, 不過都唔收.

作者: Barbie_jj 時間: 09-1-5 17:04

原帖由 monkey05 於 09-1-5 16:59 發表

barbie_jj

你仔仔都係大仔來喎.
我呀仔當日interview 表現都好, 不過都唔收.

我囝囝都唔算係好大仔, 佢7月bb來的, 不過果日interview表現幾好, 全部外籍老師既問題都答對架! 所以我才會覺得今次應該機會幾大, 可惜又係waiting... 唯有等下啦....

作者: lyl 時間: 09-1-5 17:11

收到啦!!

將會讀Anglo-Chinese 下午班 (九龍塘)
我個女5月尾出世!
之前考st. cat waiting list咋, 好彩有而家學校收..
我個女無讀N1,幾驚佢出年無書讀

希望其他媽媽都收到好消息啦!!!

作者: flowermumy 時間: 09-1-5 17:15

hi all,

I have received the result letter but rejected!
I'm unhappy.

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 17:15

都唔知什麼入學標準, 表現幾好都無用啦, 唔收咪算囉..

作者: Barbie_jj 時間: 09-1-5 17:19

原帖由 lyl 於 09-1-5 17:11 發表
收到啦!!
將會讀Anglo-Chinese 下午班 (九龍塘)
我個女5月尾出世!
之前考st. cat waiting list咋, 好彩有而家學校收..
我個女無讀N1,幾驚佢出年無書讀

希望其他媽媽都收到好消息啦!!!: ...

congratulations! 我都好想收到好消息, 可惜係waiting...

作者: flowermumy 時間: 09-1-5 17:19

you are right "mwccwtl"......
my daughter is big girl, 佢表現好好都無用 they not accept.

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 17:21

lyl

Congra.. la

you are 1st good news

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 17:27

hi flowermumy

any other choice of KG of your kid?

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 17:32

As told by my friends, most Kids are referred by HKPS teacher in this year. So my son is rejected.......even he was good performace during interview.

作者: kinchani 時間: 09-1-5 18:09

我朋友都IN 左HKPS,不過REJECT左, 好彩佢有間重好既收左佢. YORK 重有名氣啦

作者: vivicicimimi 時間: 09-1-5 18:57

今天收到信，打開見到個passed個字，超開心以為收了我個仔，再望清楚唔係我個仔個名，係第２個小朋友個名，有冇攪錯呀！於是，2:35pm打电話去HKPS查問

，等到4pm都未覆，又再打电話去問

，個staff答只通知收嗰個小朋友個家長，而個家長答未放工回家收信，未知有冇收錯我個仔封信！

好了等到5:30pm，學校打來話

，佢哋話應該冇入錯信，仲問個地址是否係我屋企嗰地址，我心諗咁白痴個問題都問，唔係点寄俾我呀！
人哋話佢哋D行政亂，真係冇錯，咁樣都可以攪亂，真令人担心！

[ 本帖最後由 vivicicimimi 於 09-1-5 18:59 編輯 ]

作者: ourbbchu 時間: 09-1-5 19:05

sibling should have priority.. so actual seats for others won't be many lar..

作者: Eh-oh 時間: 09-1-5 20:00

Accepted Letter - PM International Class
Very happy ah...

作者: cnn328 時間: 09-1-5 20:01

Just received the letter, International Class PM.

My daughter performed quite good in the interview, but the competition is keen, I do not expect she can be admitted.

Very Happy!!!

作者: Eh-oh 時間: 09-1-5 20:08

作者: joyce1024 時間: 09-1-5 22:01

真係唔知佢點收生, 囡囡表現ok, 大部份指令都做到, 但都係唔收.

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 22:01

thank you
I know you write ....Steven

原帖由 kinchani 於 09-1-5 18:09 發表
我朋友都IN 左HKPS,不過REJECT左, 好彩佢有間重好既收左佢. YORK 重有名氣啦

作者: Jackdude 時間: 09-1-5 22:04

My daughter got accepted into the Anglo-Chinese PM class...
my daughter was born in late August...

Honestly, i am in doubt...
My daughter got accepted into Kentville, St. Cat, and HKPS...
After consideration, Kentville is out of the list... but here comes another consideration.. ST. Cat vs HKPS..

Can anyone share their experience with me?

I was told that St. Cat is more appropriate for GIRLS.. while HKPS is better for BOYS..
any comments?

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-5 22:52

you are right, St. Cat is suitable for girl and HKPS is suitable for boy, because the Principals are friend between Ying Wah Colleage (boy) and HKPS

原帖由 Jackdude 於 09-1-5 22:04 發表
My daughter got accepted into the Anglo-Chinese PM class...
my daughter was born in late August...

Honestly, i am in doubt...
My daughter got accepted into Kentville, St. Cat, and HKPS...
After cons ...

作者: Eh-oh 時間: 09-1-5 22:55

I was told that St. Cat is more appropriate for GIRLS.. while HKPS is better for BOYS..
any comments?

Yes! I also heard before. "St. Cat is more appropriate for GIRLS.. while HKPS is better for BOYS." Do St. Cat also accept you Anglo-Chinese Class?
My son only accepted by THINK. I'm sure I'll give up THINK now. But do i need to write the withdraw letter to the school for giving up the place...
Pls advise! Tks!

作者: pingbaby 時間: 09-1-5 23:37

almost the same with u, my "February" girl is admitted for international pm class, and she also has been accepted by St. cat anglo-Chinese am class. Actually, my girl is accepted by York and KV also but we have given them up. Now we're just struggling between HKPS and St. cat.

原帖由 Jackdude 於 09-1-5 22:04 發表
My daughter got accepted into the Anglo-Chinese PM class...
my daughter was born in late August...

Honestly, i am in doubt...
My daughter got accepted into Kentville, St. Cat, and HKPS...
After cons ...

作者: cwng3 時間: 09-1-6 00:09

my kid is rejected as well. my kid was able to complete the instruction during the interview and he was a big boy. but we are not even in waiting list. quite disappeared. I guessed the interview performance is not the only factor. may be any sibling studying, home location etc as well

作者: red888 時間: 09-1-6 01:54

Is your kid 大仔/女 ?

原帖由 Eh-oh 於 09-1-5 20:00 發表
Accepted Letter - PM International Class
Very happy ah...

作者: Jackdude 時間: 09-1-6 10:42

Seems everyone have the same concerns..

Given that St Cat is better for girls.. my favous goes to St Cat..
but many parents here said that since there is so many student in St. Cat.. sometimes, kids might not get attentions from teachers...

That's why i treasure the small class environment from HKPS.. struggling..

作者: joeyxlma 時間: 09-1-6 11:08

Jackdude,pingbaby

I got the same problem.  My baby girl also got accept from HKPS and St. Cat, both international classes.

Struggling...

I really like the language environment in HKPS as it as 2 class teachers, both native speakers (ie 1 in Eng & 1 in PTH) in HKPS for all 3 years.  In St. Cat. this only happens to K1.

I've heard that St. Cat is good for girls and HKPS is good for boys.

BTW, I alos heard that the adm is messy in HKPS and good in St. Cat....

difficult to chose and time is running out.

作者: chickenwing2006 時間: 09-1-6 11:14

我囡都係 in 得 ok ..... 不過都係 waiting,
可能都係位太少 !!

再睇下到時 7 , 8 月我估都會有 d 位
放出黎 .... 反正個個 mami 都報幾間係
手 , 有 c 死雞執掛 ??

原帖由 joyce1024 於 09-1-5 22:01 發表
真係唔知佢點收生, 囡囡表現ok, 大部份指令都做到, 但都係唔收.

作者: Jackdude 時間: 09-1-6 11:35

I want to give DGS a "TRY" when my daughter reach Primary School.. (at least a try)... however, from what parents said here, there is no girls from HKPS got into DGS...

Given that is the fact.. honestly, my preference still goes to St. Cat...

headache....

作者: bobbbby 時間: 09-1-6 11:35

比多少少資料你作考慮，今年HKPS K1係差唔多三十人一班，有三個老師（兩個普通話老師，一個英文老師）~~~

原帖由 joeyxlma 於 09-1-6 11:08 發表
Jackdude,pingbaby

I got the same problem. My baby girl also got accept from HKPS and St. Cat, both international classes.

Struggling...

I really like the language environment in HKPS as it as 2 cl ...

作者: carol716 時間: 09-1-6 13:37

chloe果日表現都好 good, 但都係waiting list, 唔緊要啦, 我已經揀左 KV 了

作者: Eh-oh 時間: 09-1-6 13:56

原帖由 red888 於 09-1-6 01:54 發表
Is your kid 大仔/女 ?

My son was born in April 06. He is ok in interview. I've heard the chance is high if you attend interview in morning session. I don't know it is true or not. But my son has interview in morning session too.

作者: Discover 時間: 09-1-6 16:35

囡囡二月出世，考入了中英班。當天她的表現真的是十分好的！

原帖由 Eh-oh 於 09-1-6 13:56 發表

My son was born in April 06. He is ok in interview. I've heard the chance is high if you attend interview in morning session. I don't know it is true or not. But my son has interview in morning sess ...

作者: anthony010103 時間: 09-1-6 19:48

原帖由 Jackdude 於 09-1-6 11:35 發表
I want to give DGS a "TRY" when my daughter reach Primary School.. (at least a try)... however, from what parents said here, there is no girls from HKPS got into DGS...

Given that is the fact.. ho ...

CCKG can give relatively high admission rate to DGS ..

作者: anthony010103 時間: 09-1-6 19:55

原帖由 mwccwtl 於 09-1-5 22:52 發表
you are right, St. Cat is suitable for girl and HKPS is suitable for boy, because the Principals are friend between Ying Wah Colleage (boy) and HKPS

A good teaching outcome is more important than a placement result by good relationship

. No offense ..........

作者: pingbaby 時間: 09-1-6 20:46

yes, agree with u....that's why i've rather preferred HKPS...
nevertheless, could anybody kindly provide some information about HKPS' allocation of primary schools?

原帖由 anthony010103 於 09-1-6 19:55 發表

A good teaching outcome is more important than a placement result by good relationship. No offense ..........

作者: Eh-oh 時間: 09-1-6 22:42

作者: w2b 時間: 09-1-7 09:51

你地好!收左我個仔讀International class.

想問下知唔知如果我第日幫妹妹報讀, 會唔會容易D?

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 09-1-7 11:05

有冇人知點解一定要星期六親身交留位費呢(而不可以郵寄方法辦理)？

請問有冇家長知09年9月上午及下午分別有多少個中英N班?

[ 本帖最後由 kyliema2006 於 09-1-7 11:51 編輯 ]

作者: BoBo1 時間: 09-1-7 11:59

我囡囡都讀緊HK Preshool Playgroup international class, 我覺得佢個admin係好唔掂，我明明開學第一日已交左Auto pay張form, 到現在都下學期仍未做到自動轉脹學費，攪到我每個月都要開cheque交學費，我都唔明有咩問題，問admin佢地又話銀行未覆，好彩我囡囡KV & St. Cat都收左上午班K1，我一定唔會留在HK Preshool, 不過我知道我個班有好多人考唔到St. Cat, 所以佢地個個都打算留在樂基，我返左１個學期，我唔覺得有咩好，不過３６００元有英普班就真係幾低讀，不過如果想入DGJS或傅統名校，樂基就派得唔係咁好．

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 09-1-7 12:26

BoBo1,

很少家長可以說得那麼坦坦蕩蕩的，很多身在其位的家長都會極力維護學校。

好與不好視乎每個家長的價值觀，若我希望孩子建立良好兩文三語，HKPS、LH、Victoria就會是考慮之一。我反觀SC的語境可能會比HKPS、LH、Victoria這些稍遜。

原帖由 BoBo1 於 09-1-7 11:59 發表
我囡囡都讀緊HK Preshool Playgroup international class, 我覺得佢個admin係好唔掂，我明明開學第一日已交左Auto pay張form, 到現在都下學期仍未做到自動轉脹學費，攪到我每個月都要開cheque交學費，我都唔明有咩問題，問ad ...

作者: FloliMom 時間: 09-1-7 12:27

你哋成日問想知收生標準，其實有冇諗過間學校嘅面試安排係好有問題。佢哋開成二十幾個interview panels，但係每個panel只係得一個老師int，仲唔同國籍唔同語言，分得太散亦流於過份主觀，當然我們不知校方是否已指引了老師不同班別﹝中英或國際﹞和不同年齡的小朋友有特定的一組問題。以我觀察同埋大家形容的佢哋「一貫」的行政表現，應該冇啦，有都唔嚴謹，咁樣我真係質疑校方如何確保每一位老師都拿著同一把尺去考咁多小朋友囉。所以，你們問呢個問題，應該沒有答案了。

原帖由 mwccwtl 於 09-1-5 17:15 發表
都唔知什麼入學標準, 表現幾好都無用啦, 唔收咪算囉..

作者: Eh-oh 時間: 09-1-7 12:41 標題: 回覆 # 的文章

"不過如果想入DGJS或傅統名校，樂基就派得唔係咁好．"

Is HKPS suit for BOYs more? I've heard many BOYs graduated in HKPS(Kln Tong) to DBS. Is it true? so, How many for last year?

作者: mrnosey 時間: 09-1-7 13:31

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Jackdude 時間: 09-1-7 14:38

大家唔好太激動
收唔收... 有好多因素..
衣D因素我地 outsider 好難會知道

見到有d家長, 話自已小朋友interview 當初天表現非常好.. 我絕對相信.. 因為我都講過同樣既說話

我小朋友好好彩, 入到心儀學校.. 但一樣有學校reject 左佢.. 等我share 下我既經歷/睇法:
我好早期同小女報左迦南.. interview 當日我夫婦兩人一齊入去, 見到小女表現非常好, 我覺得比平時更好得多... 心諗.. 迦南實收啦.... 點知衰左

我呀女知後 interview HKBU, KV, St. Cat, HKPS... 全部收晒... 老老實實.. 佢既表現都無interview 迦南咁好..

結論:
有機會經朋友問過迦南既老師
佢話可能我呀女回答問題.. D單字全部用英文回答,唱歌又唱英文歌.. 但迦南prefer中文多D... 因此唔收小女

所以.. 有時大家口中所講既"表現好好" 未必受到校方既應同... 所以唔需要太介意呀.. 學校唔收係唔開心, 但最緊要小朋友真係"有表現" 同健康快樂呀.

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-7 14:50

good point. I agree with your view. cheers

作者: FloliMom 時間: 09-1-7 15:13

我這個感覺係我當場見到佢個面試安排已經有，亦有同其他家長談及過，唔係而家出咗result 先講，更加唔係發洩，只係想解究吓點解有些家長話小朋友表現很好而仍不獲取錄的可能性，絕無意冒犯那些小朋友已被取錄的家長，我絕對相信一定有有真實力的小朋友成功被取錄，也相信學校實會有收到好學生，也真心替他們高興。

「主觀」是一個相對的概念，其實學校個面試安排可以加入一些較客觀的元素。本人都有留意/參與過多間幼兒園/幼稚園的面試，其他的學校有些會有較客觀的環節，例如一組小朋友一齊做幾項事情/指令──疊積木/配對/搖鈴/跳舞等等，而且過程很多時不只一個環節，小朋友在不同環節會由不同老師負責，一個小朋友不會只見得一位老師，就算對話環節只得一位老師見，也只會是集中由幾個老師﹝通常不會多過10個﹞負責面見全體考生。以上之舉例說明，希望可令我之前的發言有更深層的闡釋。

你這麼急於要給學校抱不平，並斷言我的發表不中肯、似是而非、以偏蓋全，難道你是學校的人/打手、小朋友在讀/被取錄的家長？都不打緊了。以上所言，謹屬小妹個人意見，如不合聽，大可聽完算了，無須動肝火，都是討論討論吧了。

原帖由 mrnosey 於 09-1-7 13:31 發表
你的發言都好唔不中肯wor.... 你係唔係被 reject or waiting 個批 ??? 想請問有邊d interview 是會不主觀 ga... 我會明白無 offer 的 frustation , 但發 sit 還發 sit ar.. 不要講 d 似是而非, 以偏蓋全的理論出 ...

作者: BoBo1 時間: 09-1-7 15:21

其實我只係講個事實出來，等大家去理解．

如果大家只係因為兩文三語個point就真係無得好講，除非小學都係target英普的學校或國際學校就更適合．

我覺得除左語言，其它方面都要平衡，其實學語言在家都好重要，唔係單係學校個３個小時就O.K.．

我知道今年好似有１０個男仔入到DBS second in．

作者: BH_2 時間: 09-1-7 16:48

我個仔都係waiting..

我覺得佢當日的表現是十分好, 答晒問題(比 st.cat 好得多), 而 in 的老師 (鬼婆) 亦說她十分喜歡我個仔 (I like you very much), 所以現 waiting 都有少少意外. 年

當然 HKPS 的收生人數好少, 亦可以理解. 不過我是 target 英普班的, 當時已對於不需再 in 普 (只 in 左英文) 幾意外, 因去 st. cat 是要 in 2 樣的.

anyway, 都好, 我們都不用煩, 順其自然去st.cat 讀英普吧.

作者: vivicicimimi 時間: 09-1-7 17:57

i support u! 佢哋d admin 真係好亂，佢哋將今次我個仔interview result 同另一個小朋友result 入錯信封，重要我打成2次電去追去result，佢哋重好意思話自己一定無入錯信封，問我個地址係咪我屋企個地址，都白痴嘅唔係點寄到俾我呀！

原帖由 BoBo1 於 09-1-7 11:59 發表
我囡囡都讀緊HK Preshool Playgroup international class, 我覺得佢個admin係好唔掂，我明明開學第一日已交左Auto pay張form, 到現在都下學期仍未做到自動轉脹學費，攪到我每個月都要開cheque交學費，我都唔明有咩問題，問ad ...

作者: mrnosey 時間: 09-1-7 18:04

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: cleverbb 時間: 09-1-7 22:52

Heard that 12 boys got 2nd in for DBS this year.

作者: Jackdude 時間: 09-1-8 10:08

just don't understand why HKPS seems to be welcomed by DBS... but not DGS... are the entry requirement so different between DBS & DGS?

again, is a question that is difficult to answer..

作者: mwccwtl 時間: 09-1-8 11:11

It is because the Principals are friends between HKPS and DBS.

原帖由 Jackdude 於 09-1-8 10:08 發表
just don't understand why HKPS seems to be welcomed by DBS... but not DGS... are the entry requirement so different between DBS & DGS?

again, is a question that is difficult to answer..

作者: FloliMom 時間: 09-1-8 15:45

你是新加入國民，又急急以武斷言詞批評人家的發表來替學校辯護，不能怪人對你的身份生疑。

我相信總有理智的家長是知道自己小朋友的斤兩，唔會盲目以為自己個小朋友係好醒。

誠然，涉及「人」的事都會不免帶點主觀，問題是「程度」，和有關方面有否/如何透過其他行政安排、機制將此等人為影響減低而已。當然不是每樣事都好似分「黑」同「白」咁簡單；是的，學校的做法無論怎樣，可能都有人非議，所以我所講的「主客觀」都是在「面試的安排」上「相對」地來說，也只代表本人所感。

其實總的來說，關鍵就是「貫徹-consistent」，所謂「公平」，也就是「貫徹-consistent」地以同一標準作決定，諸如你說：「有 d 學校是校長 will look at all comments and select student from her /him only.」，那就算主觀，起碼貫徹由一人全面評審所有考生，所以評審員多寡對「貫徹-consistency」有直接影響。雖然「貫徹-consistency」不等於客觀，至少兩者都是朝著「公平」邁進的，直接一點說，越「貫徹」、「客觀」，應該越「公平」。

本人對其他媽咪話有好多因素﹝影響學校決定﹞並無異議，如果學校有考慮小朋友面試表現以外的因素，那它們看重的是什麼、小朋友面試的表現與該等因素的比重又是多少，那可能是我們外人無法得知的，討論下去也不得要領，亦不是本人的討論點。我一直在談的是學校面試的安排而已，既非家長/老師如何評價小朋友表現，也非學校如何就它自己內部不為外人知的準則甄選學生。

作者: mrnosey 時間: 09-1-8 16:58

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: FloliMom 時間: 09-1-8 18:21

你都好「貫徹」地「主觀」，以尖酸的言詞批評人家的發表。我只是一個有親身參與過面試的一個普通家長，在談對學校面試的安排的感覺，並無需要「服眾」，反正這個「眾」有幾多人都無從稽考，亦無關痛癢。

噢，你是在說一個校長睇晒咁多位老師interview後的評語，而不是說校長一人負責面試嗎，我真的不知hkps是否校長一人審閱決定最後 offer list，我只知不是由她一人做晒所有interview 吧。我重申我並沒有一刀切地說間學校是主觀定客觀，面試後/以外校方會加入什麼其他考慮因素，都不是我的討論點，我只是說學校面試的安排於我來說是可以再客觀一點。

我一早已表明絕無意冒犯那些小朋友已被取錄的家長，我絕對相信一定有有真實力的小朋友成功被取錄，也相信學校實會有收到好學生，也真心替他們高興。

「難免人地會對你有 "吃不到的葡萄是酸的」──這個「人地」，你是講「你」吧，那你怎麼想我當然管不了。只是，人家都是平心靜氣議事論事，你卻總是好像在想挑啟爭端，人家說一些與你不同的個人意見就兇狠地抨擊，我覺得這些口舌之爭很無聊，也很浪費時間，你喜歡怎樣說隨你吧。

[ 本帖最後由 FloliMom 於 09-1-8 18:33 編輯 ]

作者: mrnosey 時間: 09-1-8 19:34

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)