教育王國

標題: DBS vs 英華, 你哋會點揀? [打印本頁]

作者: MumTang 時間: 08-12-8 17:57 標題: DBS vs 英華, 你哋會點揀?

請大家俾d意見,謝!

作者: loy211 時間: 08-12-8 18:13

論名氣應是DBS,不過家長背景非富則貴,如果家庭背景不俗,我會選DBS.

作者: laichuilai 時間: 08-12-8 20:24

如果以學校環境及名氣，當然DBS高一線。但我相信讀YW可能小明友會開心D。

作者: rookiemom 時間: 08-12-8 20:38

Of course is DBS la, Ying Wah is no comparison, ask those Ying Wah supporters, any of their sons are accepted by DBS but it happened that they have declined the offer and let their son go to Ying Wah instead, sure the Next's Magazine want to interview them!

原帖由 MumTang 於 08-12-8 17:57 發表
請大家俾d意見,謝!

作者: ma90a31 時間: 08-12-8 20:57

英華現在不輸dbs
他在今年及去年~搶走很多dbs的獎唷
再過幾年~應該可以勝過dbs了

但dbs~名氣真的很大
不可否認啦

想想
dbs~今年差不多1900多人考
英華都有1800以上~
兩家差不多差不到100人

而~paul boy今年才900多人報考

作者: rookiemom 時間: 08-12-8 21:20

see, that's what I am talking about, the point is not how many applicants they have, is how many people will choose Ying Wah if their son is accepted by DBS.

Come on, Ying Wah's standard is not even close to DBS, who are you fooling?

原帖由 ma90a31 於 08-12-8 20:57 發表
英華現在不輸dbs
他在今年及去年~搶走很多dbs的獎唷
再過幾年~應該可以勝過dbs了

但dbs~名氣真的很大
不可否認啦

想想
dbs~今年差不多1900多人考
英華都有1800以上~
兩家差不多差不到100人

而~paul boy今年才900 ...

作者: rookiemom 時間: 08-12-8 21:24

Just to declare interest here, my son applied both to DBS and Ying Wah last year, and he didn't get 2nd interview from both schools.

原帖由 rookiemom 於 08-12-8 21:20 發表
see, that's what I am talking about, the point is not how many applicants they have, is how many people will choose Ying Wah if their son is accepted by DBS.

Come on, Ying Wah's standard is not even ...

作者: chun12 時間: 08-12-8 21:50

of course if you have both offers, will choose DBS, unless $ matter. Quite surprise to see this topic. After DBS announce results, there will be lots of seats withdrawn from Ying Wa for sure.

作者: eileenycm 時間: 08-12-8 22:26

Yes, surprise!!

作者: Mamahui 時間: 08-12-8 23:35

毫無疑問，一定係男拔！

作者: matthewdad 時間: 08-12-9 09:27

everyone know the answer..... DBS of course.

原帖由 Mamahui 於 08-12-8 23:35 發表
毫無疑問，一定係男拔！

作者: gracechung 時間: 08-12-9 11:21

我講緊小學咋。為滿足家長虛榮心，絕對應該揀dbs，想小朋友扎扎實實讀好書，應該揀yw。

唔岩聽既家長唔洗勞嘈，亦唔需要鬧我，只要搵個在學的小朋友拼對下，就知道學校做左幾多，教過乜。

我好坦白咁講啦，yw現階段可能最輸蝕係傳聞過去一段時間內中學成績倒退左。

所以，yw除左苦心經營小學部之外，更根本的做法係應該苦心經營中學部。如果yw中學的outcome夠亮麗，各位睇法又如何？

作者: catcatmom 時間: 08-12-9 11:22

雖然我很BUY 林校長, 但我會選DBS, 因佢全英文學校. 我老板係DBS舊生(NN年前), 佢既英文好勁!(只讀完中學.)

作者: stjoboldboy 時間: 08-12-9 11:35

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Geni 時間: 08-12-9 11:47

喜歡dbs係因為佢o既傳統, 入到學校好容易感受到佢地團結o既氣氛, 特別係中學~~

喜歡yw係因為佢地o既衝勁, 覺得d小朋友好活潑可愛, 特別係小學~~

作者: fratelli 時間: 08-12-9 11:52

轉左直資應該會好好多.....可以自己揀top的學生。

原帖由 gracechung 於 08-12-9 11:21 發表
我講緊小學咋。為滿足家長虛榮心，絕對應該揀dbs，想小朋友扎扎實實讀好書，應該揀yw。

唔岩聽既家長唔洗勞嘈，亦唔需要鬧我，只要搵個在學的小朋友拼對下，就知道學校做左幾多，教過乜。

我好坦白咁講啦，yw現階段可能最輸蝕係傳 ...

作者: fratelli 時間: 08-12-9 11:54

同意......但仲要考慮埋家庭背境，冇返咁上下家底入讀DBS，小朋友唔自卑都幾難

原帖由 Geni 於 08-12-9 11:47 發表
喜歡dbs係因為佢o既傳統, 入到學校好容易感受到佢地團結o既氣氛, 特別係中學~~

喜歡yw係因為佢地o既衝勁, 覺得d小朋友好活潑可愛, 特別係小學~~

作者: jennytms 時間: 08-12-9 12:15

我都好同意你的講法. 因DBSPD太過有名氣, 太過有種貴族學校的感覺,所以D教職員可能都會看看家長的家境,另小朋友與小朋友之間都會互相比較. 但相反, 在YW可能會有不同的感覺, 林校長給家長或小朋友的印像都很好, 小朋友在這裡應該會讀得開心D.

原帖由 gracechung 於 08-12-9 11:21 發表
我講緊小學咋。為滿足家長虛榮心，絕對應該揀dbs，想小朋友扎扎實實讀好書，應該揀yw。

唔岩聽既家長唔洗勞嘈，亦唔需要鬧我，只要搵個在學的小朋友拼對下，就知道學校做左幾多，教過乜。

我好坦白咁講啦，yw現階段可能最輸蝕係傳 ...

作者: Geni 時間: 08-12-9 12:52

其實我覺得自唔自卑(仲有自大)好睇個家長點教, 其實小朋友自己係冇呢d concept, 好多時都係父母有意無意之間灌輸俾佢地.

我仲記得我小學o既時候有2個好有錢o既同學, 當時我係唔覺得有乜o野特別, 只不過去完佢地屋企之後同阿媽講一個同學個屋企個雪櫃門會出冰唔駛好似我地咁自己雪, 另外o個個同學住淺水灣, 屋入面有樓梯, 講完就俾阿媽鬧"貪慕虛名"... 我當時真係莫名其妙

仲有, 幼稚園o既時候樓o下o個家人會接我放學去佢地屋企託管幾個鐘, 有次佢地請我食apple, 係細細個o個種, 咁我真係未見過細apple(因為阿媽買親都係大個o個種), 我咪問點解d apple咁細o羅, 就咁就俾o個家人鬧o左一身~~~ 其實你話係咪d大人諗多o左呢~~

作者: Lovelybbs 時間: 08-12-9 12:55

同意.

根本呢兩間係唔同級數既學校, 我仔仔有考英華, 但就無考DBS, 無咁大個頭費是帶咁大頂帽啦.

既然考得DBS, 又取錄既話, 無理由唔讀.

原帖由 jennytms 於 08-12-9 12:15 發表
我都好同意你的講法. 因DBSPD太過有名氣, 太過有種貴族學校的感覺,所以D教職員可能都會看看家長的家境,另小朋友與小朋友之間都會互相比較. 但相反, 在YW可能會有不同的感覺, 林校長給家長或小朋友的印像都很好, 小朋 ...

作者: candace 時間: 08-12-9 13:39

For primary, I will choose YW. For secondary, I will choose DBS.

作者: mummy123 時間: 08-12-9 13:41

It is too silly to waste your time on comparing two schools. Each school has it own strength and weakness. Parents should find out the best school for their own kids, not the others'. Can your kids be benefited from these arguments between different groups of fans of DBS and YW?

I just want to share the information below with you. I didn't say which school could outweigh the other.

My friend ever asked an applicant in a job interview, "Why did you fail all subjects in HKCEE, except having a 'B' in English? A DBS student was not expected to have such result. The applicant replied, "There are several classes for each form. There are 3 good classes and 2 naught classes'. Actually, we are not naughty but the academic standard is not good. I have been assigned into the 'naught class' since S1. I liked music but I couldn't catch up with the progress of other subjects. Teachers didn't care about our class as long as you didn't interrupt the others.". My friend asked him why he didn't change the school. My parents liked the school name and I liked it too. The famous name might help me to get jobs. ".

Another friend said that his family was quite happy with DBSPD and DBSSD because his son's academic standard was quite high, especially the English standard. He further said that his son's IQ was found to be 140 at the age of 9 (primary 3).

DBSPD is an EMI school and YWPS is an CMI school.
I believe DBSPD can provide a more enriched language environment for kids to learn English.

YW's principal, Mrs. Lam, ever pointed out on the newspaper that YW was aimed to improve the standard of the whole form rather than for 1 or 2 classes or a small group of kids.

YWPS is quite new compared with DBSPD. Few years later, you may see the result, good or bad.

If I were you, I wouldn't tell my kid which school he should go unless he is granted the offer, or he may feel that he is going to substandard one and refuse to go as well. As parents, we have to find out the best place to suit our kids, not just the school name.

原帖由 stjoboldboy 於 08-12-9 11:35 發表
論學校, YW跟本未到DBS咁既級數!
論校長, YW林校長跟本未到DBS張焯祥校長咁既級數!

[ 本帖最後由 mummy123 於 08-12-9 13:48 編輯 ]

作者: stjoboldboy 時間: 08-12-9 13:55

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: kaifu 時間: 08-12-9 13:56

This comparison may not be very fair -

"論校長, YW林校長跟本未到DBS張焯祥校長咁既級數!"

YW林校長: we know that she is the primary school principal, but is she also the secondary school principal?

DPSPD - the person in charge should be Ms Lo (a former principal of TSL), not 張焯祥. Her job title is Headteacher which should be equivalent to a primary school principal.

Please correct if I am wrong.

原帖由 stjoboldboy 於 08-12-9 11:35 發表
論學校, YW跟本未到DBS咁既級數!
論校長, YW林校長跟本未到DBS張焯祥校長咁既級數!

[ 本帖最後由 kaifu 於 08-12-9 13:59 編輯 ]

作者: stjoboldboy 時間: 08-12-9 14:03

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: mummy123 時間: 08-12-9 14:16

Parents should compare on their own by gathering some information via different channels, including but not limited to the following:

perform a local visit to see how the students behave;
check the school's website and attend the briefing session (if any)
check out the school performance and the related secondary school's as well
check the booklist and try to compare the listed reference books
listen to the comments from parents whose kids are studying the desired schools.

The arguments made by the supporters (fans) of particular schools were already out of the discussion scope or comments. I put a full stop here.

原帖由 stjoboldboy 於 08-12-9 13:55 發表

咁唔compare下又點find out the best school for their own kids?

[ 本帖最後由 mummy123 於 08-12-9 14:18 編輯 ]

作者: stjoboldboy 時間: 08-12-9 14:31

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-9 14:55

yes, i think one should also sit-in the classes on all levels for one year or so in each school for a better comparison.

making such comments, i guess u are a ying wa parent?

原帖由 mummy123 於 08-12-9 14:16 發表
Parents should compare on their own by gathering some information via different channels, including but not limited to the following:

perform a local visit to see how the students behave;
check the s ...

作者: bobbbby 時間: 08-12-9 15:18

我絶對同意大家要求証網上流傳o既資料：英華小學成立於二零零三年，拔萃男書院附屬小學成立於二零零四年~~~

原帖由 mummy123 於 08-12-9 13:41 發表
YWPS is quite new compared with DBSPD. Few years later, you may see the result, good or bad.

作者: bobbbby 時間: 08-12-9 15:39

其實我唔係好明你講o既例子係乜野意思，宜家係比較緊小學，但係你提到去搵工o既畢業生，無乜可能係DBSPD畢業喎~~~

你只係講DBS畢業生，但唔係DBSPD畢業生喎~~~

原帖由 mummy123 於 08-12-9 13:41 發表
My friend ever asked an applicant in a job interview, "Why did you fail all subjects in HKCEE, except having a 'B' in English? A DBS student was not expected to have such result. The applicant replied, "There are several classes for each form. There are 3 good classes and 2 naught classes'. Actually, we are not naughty but the academic standard is not good. I have been assigned into the 'naught class' since S1. I liked music but I couldn't catch up with the progress of other subjects. Teachers didn't care about our class as long as you didn't interrupt the others.". My friend asked him why he didn't change the school. My parents liked the school name and I liked it too. The famous name might help me to get jobs. ".

作者: mow-mow 時間: 08-12-9 16:02

But 英華 only changed to be DSS this year.

原帖由 bobbbby 於 08-12-9 15:18 發表
我絶對同意大家要求証網上流傳o既資料：英華小學成立於二零零三年，拔萃男書院附屬小學成立於二零零四年~~~

作者: bobbbby 時間: 08-12-9 16:19

我只係糾正一啲錯誤資料，因為我見到有人留言話英華小學相對於拔萃男書院附屬小學係一間新學校，經查証後發現，英華小學成立時間係早過拔萃男書院附屬小學~~~

我無褒或貶兩間學校~~~

我唔係好明"英華今年轉直資"，同我講o既資料有乜野抵觸？你認為轉直資應該當"新學校"計？

原帖由 mow-mow 於 08-12-9 16:02 發表
But 英華 only changed to be DSS this year.

作者: gracechung 時間: 08-12-9 16:44

我諗，大家認為直資跟直資比較會好d，始終當yw還是津校時，自由度冇咁大。

原帖由 bobbbby 於 08-12-9 16:19 發表
我只係糾正一啲錯誤資料，因為我見到有人留言話英華小學相對於拔萃男書院附屬小學係一間新學校，經查証後發現，英華小學成立時間係早過拔萃男書院附屬小學~~~

我無褒或貶兩間學校~~~

我唔係好明"英華今年轉直資"，同我講o ...

作者: gracechung 時間: 08-12-9 16:46

我諗果位mami想指出學校教育理念既問題。學校出咩學生同學校本身的理念都有關系。

原帖由 bobbbby 於 08-12-9 15:39 發表
其實我唔係好明你講o既例子係乜野意思，宜家係比較緊小學，但係你提到去搵工o既畢業生，無乜可能係DBSPD畢業喎~~~

你只係講DBS畢業生，但唔係DBSPD畢業生喎~~~

...

作者: gracechung 時間: 08-12-9 16:51

其實比咩較遮？如果真係覺得咁一面倒既優勝劣敗，根本呢條問題就唔應該出現添啦，任何一個父母都會揀最好既比仔女啦。岩嗎？

作者: LouiseM 時間: 08-12-9 17:16

非常同意，任何一個父母都會揀最好既比仔女。但有時我也覺得父母都不清楚學校本身的理念同教法，便一面到的選校。
但現在這一刻，我們還是期待結果的來臨，好與否，真的看看小朋友的本事了。 :(

原帖由 gracechung 於 08-12-9 16:51 發表
其實比咩較遮？如果真係覺得咁一面倒既優勝劣敗，根本呢條問題就唔應該出現添啦，任何一個父母都會揀最好既比仔女啦。岩嗎？

作者: 榜上有名 時間: 08-12-9 17:29 標題: 邊間好不如問下專家

有個由張文光同狄志遠主辨既講座免費既又唔洗餞自己去報名啦！http://www.sedhk.org/news1.php

作者: kittifly 時間: 08-12-9 18:21

so do you mean u will choose ying wa over dbs if given the chance? or did you ever have this chance?

原帖由 mummy123 於 08-12-9 14:16 發表
Parents should compare on their own by gathering some information via different channels, including but not limited to the following:

perform a local visit to see how the students behave;
check the s ...

作者: Jean 時間: 08-12-9 18:30

原帖由 bobbbby 於 08-12-9 16:19 發表
我只係糾正一啲錯誤資料，因為我見到有人留言話英華小學相對於拔萃男書院附屬小學係一間新學校，經查証後發現，英華小學成立時間係早過拔萃男書院附屬小學~~~

我無褒或貶兩間學校~~~

我唔係好明"英華今年轉直資"，同我講o ...

你可以搜集英華小學既資料再談論兩校. 就知點解咁多家長話無得比.

英華fans覺得林校長加入和轉直資簡直令英華脫胎換骨.

不過好多長輩級BK會員和經驗家長都只當佢係深水埗區有名的學校. 要看多幾年佢地公開試成績再評論.

作者: bobbbby 時間: 08-12-9 19:31

你話搜集完英華小學o既資料後，就知點解咁多家長話無得比，係因為YWPS好過DBSPD好多？定係DBSPD好過YWPS好多呢？

原帖由 Jean 於 08-12-9 18:30 發表

你可以搜集英華小學既資料再談論兩校. 就知點解咁多家長話無得比.

英華fans覺得林校長加入和轉直資簡直令英華脫胎換骨.

不過好多長輩級BK會員和經驗家長都只當佢係深水埗區有名的學校. 要看多幾年佢地公開試成績 ...

作者: gracechung 時間: 08-12-9 20:37

咩公開試成績？小學有公開試嗎？

即使係地區有名學校，亦唔好輕易睇少，雖然我冇research過，common sense我知某些地區學校，eg林護(當然佢係中學)，公開試成績都唔錯架，實力不容否定架。

我想講，如果家長真係咁一面倒覺得db一定好過yw，或者yw一無是處，根本冇得揮，咁呢條問題根本唔可能出現啦(有人存心聊是鬥非就另計啦)。

如果認為兩方各有不同長處，咁就要因應自已環境揀適合自已，選一個可以比兒子更能發揮潛質、建立自信、有利成長既地方。

原帖由 Jean 於 08-12-9 18:30 發表

你可以搜集英華小學既資料再談論兩校. 就知點解咁多家長話無得比.

英華fans覺得林校長加入和轉直資簡直令英華脫胎換骨.

不過好多長輩級BK會員和經驗家長都只當佢係深水埗區有名的學校. 要看多幾年佢地公開試成績 ...

作者: Bilobi 時間: 08-12-10 09:51

其实, 兩間都係好好嘅学校, 都係 first tier 嘅,
當然, 論名氣, 舊校友社会地位等, DBS 確是佔優;
但 YW 又應該不只是"Sham Shui Po 較有名的學校",
不然, 報名人數就唔会有 1800+ la., 如果它(中学) 冇 re-locate & expand, 仍然坐落九龍塘牛津道, 会否令部分家長另眼相看呢?

本人並不是林校長 fans, 但我欣賞這校的熱誠及衝勁(包括副校長及其他老師), 学生的一張張可愛笑臉, 謙厚有禮, 相信家長会放心及開心地把最愛的孩子送進這校学習.

DBS 嘅優点, 三日三夜都講唔哂...社会是現實的, DBS offers 一出, 相信 YW 会流失一群準学生, 但亦不代表 YW 学生質素会差, 若兩校來個"統一入學試", 所收的學生還是頭500名 out of 1900 啊 (當中或包括心儀 LS, St. Paul's Co-Ed的)

打個比喻吧... Mercedes Benz 固然是名車, 很多人有錢的話都想買; 但 Lexus 性能都唔差喎, 實而不太華.

Conclusion: 最緊要適合自己小朋友及学習有成效

[ 本帖最後由 Bilobi 於 08-12-10 09:54 編輯 ]

作者: Jean 時間: 08-12-10 12:04

原帖由 gracechung 於 08-12-9 20:37 發表
咩公開試成績？小學有公開試嗎？

即使係地區有名學校，亦唔好輕易睇少，雖然我冇research過，common sense我知某些地區學校，eg林護(當然佢係中學)，公開試成績都唔錯架，實力不容否定架。

我想講，如果家長真係咁一面倒覺得db一定好 ...

當然是講中學的公開試, 正如有網友說要取好成績, 怎也不會輕鬆(但並唔代表學生會不快樂). 你或者將成績與學校生活掛上鉤. 總以為出好成績的學校, 學生之間會有很大的競爭, 平庸的學生就自信盡滅,不會開心.... 另外, 你似乎唔太認識DBSPD. 他的教學方式可以比很多學校更生動和互動, 功課壓力可能會比英華更少. 我見 DBSPD的學生都是活潑, 開朗, 喜愛上學. 縱使身邊有很多卓越的同學, 也無減他們的自信. 講到家長, 入拔萃是滿足家長虛榮心?? 你唔認為是太主觀? 我有3個朋友的兒子都是在DBSPD讀, 朋友都是一般的中產, 職業不是3師但有見識有修養. 從不與人比較自己孩子的才能, 也不會多提在那裡讀書. 你對拔萃呢類名校的偏見都幾深喎.

不談學術成就, 我相信全港每一區佔8成以上都是好學校. 每校有不同方面的優點. 英華小學背著英華書院呢個名來辦學, 不會讓學校人氣榜下落. 也不否認英華都努力梗作出改變, 希望日後見到她在某一方面有過人之處. 不過直資一條龍最實際, 想入男校入唔到男拔, 英華都係不異之選. 當然還有CKY, TSL, SMC..遠些有GT, HKUGA, LOGO, SSC,SPC, SPCC都是好的直資學校和私校(津校要派位所以唔講)各有特色喎. 間間學校都可讓學生發揮潛能, 建立自信. 問題係你揀左英華, 眼中便只有"她"吧.

回應很花時間, 不會再在有關xx vs yw呢類topic到磋跎了.

作者: kansang 時間: 08-12-10 12:40

原帖由 Jean 於 08-12-10 12:04 發表

當然是講中學的公開試, 正如有網友說要取好成績, 怎也不會輕鬆(但並唔代表學生會不快樂). 你或者將成績與學校生活掛上鉤. 總以為出好成績的學校, 學生之間會有很大的競爭, 平庸的學生就自信盡滅,不會開心.... 另外 ...

感同身受,絕對同意..........

作者: gracechung 時間: 08-12-10 12:49

sorry…我對任何一間學校都冇偏見。你留言內所講既說話係你講，並不代表我立場！我冇將成績與學校生活掛鉤。

唔係淨係你至識人讀dbs，我都識。我唔單止識人讀dbs，我亦識人教st cat，老師多年經驗，教出唔少cat仔讀db，亦同佢地媽咪有資訊流通，綜合以上資料，我諗我都有權有自已見解掛？！

anyway，我亦冇講過別人學校半句壞話。right?

最後我得重申一點：心水清的朋友，應該留意到我係較早前的留言已聲明"我講緊小學咋"。我認為大家容易的思維傾向把中小學混為一談，所以我先提問有"咩公開試"。

呢個毛病開始時我都有犯。當然，入讀一條龍，這種評價自然不過。不過小學階段跟中學階段，學生的需求的確唔同喎。

原帖由 Jean 於 08-12-10 12:04 發表

當然是講中學的公開試, 正如有網友說要取好成績, 怎也不會輕鬆(但並唔代表學生會不快樂). 你或者將成績與學校生活掛上鉤. 總以為出好成績的學校, 學生之間會有很大的競爭, 平庸的學生就自信盡滅,不會開心.... 另外 ...

作者: ma90a31 時間: 08-12-10 13:16

其實不需要比較學校

要找的是適合自己孩子的學校才是最重要的

我亦相信也許DBS 放榜
說不定~也會有少部份人從SPCC轉到DBS唷
(不過~相信應該不多但我確實有聽到真的有人喜歡DBS 勝過SPCC )

所以找一間適合自己孩子的學校
比在這邊比較哪一間比較好來的重要

更何況這都還要考慮到家裡遠近的問題經濟等....
很多方面都需要評估的

別動氣~
DBS有好學生　不過我也相信　有部份學生並非真的是最優秀的
同樣的～英華也許名氣沒有ＤＢＳ來的響
但我也相信　一定有些學生的素質是優過ＤＢＳ的

作者: fratelli 時間: 08-12-10 14:32

非常同意

選擇一間最適合自己小朋友的學校
比選擇一間最好的學校重要!
況且每間學校都有其優點和缺點，點比較都係冇結果

原帖由 ma90a31 於 08-12-10 13:16 發表
其實不需要比較學校

要找的是適合自己孩子的學校才是最重要的

我亦相信也許DBS 放榜
說不定~也會有少部份人從SPCC轉到DBS唷
(不過~相信應該不多但我確實有聽到真的有人喜歡DBS 勝過SPCC )

所以找一間適合自 ...

作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-10 14:34

Honestly, i really think that this discussion topic is a waste of time. I don't believe anyone will go to Ying Wah if DBS accept them. It's just those parents who want to convince their own selves or others that Ying Wah is also a good school since their kids can't be accepted by DBS. oh women, pls face the reality la!

作者: gracechung 時間: 08-12-10 14:51

我一早都咁講架啦。
硬係有d人中意話邊間同邊間唔同級數！
中意講咪講飽佢，夾硬話人對其校成見深！
別人唔同意見唔緊要，我最憎比人屈。

老實講啦，其間e+任何一間一條龍都未有自已一手湊大的應屆會考生啦。講咩公開試成績，對小學選校有咩邏輯關係？最大的好處咪可以直升囉。但係如果揀得唔岩自已小朋友的學習模式，小學基礎都"喎何"左，仲講乜鬼中學呀？！

原帖由 fratelli 於 08-12-10 14:32 發表
非常同意
選擇一間最適合自己小朋友的學校
比選擇一間最好的學校重要!
況且每間學校都有其優點和缺點，點比較都係冇結果

作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-10 15:07

the teaching approach of dbs is very free. many of my friends' sons are studying happily there now and love their school a lot. there are lots of extra-curricular activities and classes where you can learn a lot of stuff that can't be learnt from books. of course that also costs a lot of $$$.

pls don't always use the point which school suits your kid. how DBS isn't suitable for your son ah?? it's just a joke to others if you say you will choose ying wah over dbs, unless your are aware that your "family class or backgroung" does not suit that of dbs.

[ 本帖最後由 wlmom 於 08-12-10 15:19 編輯 ]

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-12-10 15:11

關於小學的成績，其實可以從TSA reports略知一二。另外，香港亦有些學校每年都會參加澳洲International Assessment of Schools，呢一個試好像有頗多學校參加，包括DBS、DGS、St Jo、聖心、Creative、VSA、St Mary、油天、保良局的學校，及一些國際學校如CIS。考試科目包括英文、英數及英科，雖然是自由參與，但亦可略知在云云的考生中，那些學校學生會是全港第一、第二等資料。

原帖由 gracechung 於 08-12-10 14:51 發表
我一早都咁講架啦。
硬係有d人中意話邊間同邊間唔同級數！
中意講咪講飽佢，夾硬話人對其校成見深！
別人唔同意見唔緊要，我最憎比人屈。

老實講啦，其間e+任何一間一條龍都未有自已一手湊大的應屆會考生啦。講咩公開試成績，對 ...

[ 本帖最後由 kyliema2006 於 08-12-10 15:22 編輯 ]

作者: gracechung 時間: 08-12-10 15:30

呢位家長講既係事實。咁現實上如果有家庭因為自已的條件、收入及能力所限而唔選擇入讀dbs，都唔係罪過，亦冇咩出奇！

原帖由 wlmom 於 08-12-10 15:07 發表
the teaching approach of dbs is very free. many of my friends' sons are studying happily there now and love their school a lot. there are lots of extra-curricular activities and classes where you ca ...

作者: LouiseM 時間: 08-12-10 15:45

Gracechung,

So, from your point of view, may I ask, how to choose?
and which school that you prefer?

作者: bobbbby 時間: 08-12-10 16:21 標題: 回覆 # 的文章

好多人都覺得DBS學生家庭背境個個都非富則貴，會唔會係美麗的誤會？我相信只有少數係大富人家，大部份都來自中產家庭~~~

作者: Markx 時間: 08-12-10 16:22

次次見到 DBS vs YW o的 post 都係吵吵鬧鬧收場! 但樓主早已唔見人,其實樓主是幸福人.又可揀DB 又可揀YW,何需大家費神呢!

作者: bobbbby 時間: 08-12-10 16:31

但係到今日DBSPD都未公佈收生結果喎~~~

原帖由 Markx 於 08-12-10 16:22 發表
次次見到 DBS vs YW o的 post 都係吵吵鬧鬧收場! 但樓主早已唔見人,其實樓主是幸福人.又可揀DB 又可揀YW,何需大家費神呢!

作者: johnny_tangcy 時間: 08-12-10 16:37

記得有"升中派位"那邊有人講過一句話:

名校家長好似一杯盛滿的茶....好似講得幾啱呀!!

建議將dbs, yw, qc, ls, spcc & kc列做bk禁語啦.

作者: BBR 時間: 08-12-10 16:40

其實DBS都未放榜駛咩咁早諗

,收左至慢慢諗都未遲. 好似DGS都未放榜我都費事諗,米一陣死諗完後唔收就浪費哂D腦力

,近排攪學校D野已經夠忙,各有所好,有咩好嘈

作者: Markx 時間: 08-12-10 16:51

更加不值得討論啦,樓主問意見?! 那方面的意見呀?奉勸两面家長勿傷和氣!

原帖由 bobbbby 於 08-12-10 16:31 發表
但係到今日DBSPD都未公佈收生結果喎~~~

作者: love_dreaming 時間: 08-12-11 16:55

咩人黎架？！講說話狗眼看人低！邊間學校收著呢聽家長既仔女，想唔沒落都幾難！話知係DBS定SPCC！

古語有云，國之將亡，必有妖孽！

原帖由 wlmom 於 08-12-10 15:07 發表
the teaching approach of dbs is very free. many of my friends' sons are studying happily there now and love their school a lot. there are lots of extra-curricular activities and classes where you ca ...

作者: 502 時間: 08-12-11 17:04

其實有沒有一間學校適合任何類型的孩子或家庭？

很奇怪，在BK家長老是請別人比較兩間學校，但最清楚一家學校的運作只有學生家長，最清楚一個孩子的應該只是他的父母.

與其問別人兩間學校哪間較好，倒不如問一下人家學校的教學方法! 孩子適合什麽類型的學校就只有家長本人才好回答。

對我來說，我只能因應對大兒子學校的認識和對小兒子性向的瞭解，評價弟弟該否也進哥哥的學校。別人問我意见時，我也只會談論學校的認識，是否適合只能由父母親自衡量!

選學校可不是問股評人買哪種股票！

作者: timtim852 時間: 08-12-11 17:28

502, I agreed.
Their comments (or better say, "argument) just reflect their "quality" mindset. Good luck to their kids...

原帖由 502 於 08-12-11 17:04 發表
其實有沒有一間學校適合任何類型的孩子或家庭？

很奇怪，在BK家長老是請別人比較兩間學校，但最清楚一家學校的運作只有學生家長，最清楚一個孩子的應該只是他的父母.

與其問別人兩間學校哪間較好，倒不如問一下人家學 ...

作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-11 18:14

love_dreaming,

i'm just an ordinary woman living in this realistic world.  all people know that students who can enter dbs or spcc are from families with background or connections with the school.  or maybe their kids are soooooo outstanding that could be spotted during the limited time available in the interviews.

and of course, social classes do exist in this world.  pls note that i am not humiliating anyone in this thread on their background.  i was just saying that $$ could be a problem to some families which is absolutely true.

pls watch your mouth.  you are saying others "dog eye" and 妖孽 so i couldn't see how you are much better in person.

原帖由 love_dreaming 於 08-12-11 16:55 發表
咩人黎架？！講說話狗眼看人低！邊間學校收著呢聽家長既仔女，想唔沒落都幾難！話知係DBS定SPCC！

古語有云，國之將亡，必有妖孽！

[ 本帖最後由 wlmom 於 08-12-11 18:34 編輯 ]

作者: HoHoMom 時間: 08-12-11 18:47

原帖由 love_dreaming 於 08-12-11 16:55 發表
咩人黎架？！講說話狗眼看人低！邊間學校收著呢聽家長既仔女，想唔沒落都幾難！話知係DBS定SPCC！

古語有云，國之將亡，必有妖孽！

作者: Bilobi 時間: 08-12-12 09:40

原帖由 love_dreaming 於 08-12-11 16:55 發表
咩人黎架？！講說話狗眼看人低！邊間學校收著呢聽家長既仔女，想唔沒落都幾難！話知係DBS定SPCC！

古語有云，國之將亡，必有妖孽！

作者: bobbbby 時間: 08-12-12 10:55

我相信果位家長唔係DBS或SPCC舊生／學生家長，請勿將他／她的言論跟兩間學校扯上任何關係~~~

我覺得佢係一位“名校專家”，我見到佢響好多有關名校o既題目都有發表“權威”言論，例如名校排名，同埋邊啲係一線名校，邊啲係二線名校之類~~~

原帖由 love_dreaming 於 08-12-11 16:55 發表
咩人黎架？！講說話狗眼看人低！邊間學校收著呢聽家長既仔女，想唔沒落都幾難！話知係DBS定SPCC！

古語有云，國之將亡，必有妖孽！

作者: fratelli 時間: 08-12-12 11:06

“名校專家”

發表“權威”言論

原帖由 bobbbby 於 08-12-12 10:55 發表
我相信果位家長唔係DBS或SPCC舊生／學生家長，請勿將他／她的言論跟兩間學校扯上任何關係~~~

我覺得佢係一位“名校專家”，我見到佢響好多有關名校o既題目都有發表“權威”言論，例如名校排名，同埋邊啲係一線名校，邊啲係二線名 ...

作者: love_dreaming 時間: 08-12-12 11:14

本人絕無侵犯此兩間學校之意，提及這兩校名字只不過打個比喻，對兩校有關人士做成不快，致萬分歉意。

言歸正傳，其實我一向好少留言，亦甚少睇呢板，因為我女女都升中囉。偶然無聊亂click，見到咁既留言，真係……有冇需要咁講說話呀？估唔到宜家爭入小學既競爭真係咁劇烈呀下！都係哥句啦，人必先自侮而後人侮之！

原帖由 bobbbby 於 08-12-12 10:55 發表
我相信果位家長唔係DBS或SPCC舊生／學生家長，請勿將他／她的言論跟兩間學校扯上任何關係~~~

我覺得佢係一位“名校專家”，我見到佢響好多有關名校o既題目都有發表“權威”言論，例如名校排名，同埋邊啲係一線名校，邊啲係二線名 ...

作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-12 11:47

partly right and partly wrong la :;pppp:

原帖由 bobbbby 於 08-12-12 10:55 發表
我相信果位家長唔係DBS或SPCC舊生／學生家長，請勿將他／她的言論跟兩間學校扯上任何關係~~~

我覺得佢係一位“名校專家”，我見到佢響好多有關名校o既題目都有發表“權威”言論，例如名校排名，同埋邊啲係一線名校，邊啲係二線名 ...

作者: davidmimi 時間: 08-12-12 11:56

wlmom,

唔係針對你呀,看過你最近的留言post.

DBS vs 英華, 你哋會點揀?
Wah Yan VS St.Paul
La Salle vs Ying Wa
MCS, St.Mary,協恩,你們會選邊間?
SPCS vs MSS 小一選校
St Paul Boy vs KTS

你對學校比拼的話題好有興趣喎,其實你部分言論係對的,不過客氣d會令人容易接受.

[ 本帖最後由 davidmimi 於 08-12-12 11:59 編輯 ]

作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-12 12:06

yeah, ok la. i was just "mo liu" to post these threads and didn't expect to raise so much "fire"

原帖由 davidmimi 於 08-12-12 11:56 發表
wlmom,

唔係針對你呀,看過你最近的留言post.

DBS vs 英華, 你哋會點揀?
Wah Yan VS St.Paul
La Salle vs Ying Wa
MCS, St.Mary,協恩,你們會選邊間?
SPCS vs MSS 小一選校
St Paul Boy vs KTS

你對學校比拼的 ...

[ 本帖最後由 wlmom 於 08-12-12 12:36 編輯 ]

作者: HKBEE 時間: 08-12-12 13:47

By my interview experience,
DBS is the worst school.
I don't know the past of DBS,
but keep this management, I cannot believe it.
By the way, it is not 100% direct to secondary school.

作者: inquisitive 時間: 08-12-12 14:45

I'll have to agree I didn't appreciate being treated like a second class citizen at the first interview, when parents were not even allowed into the school playground to pick up their boys and we had to wait behind a red tape. But I am impressed with the way DBS deals with children. My son came out of both interviews more confident than I have ever seen him.

作者: smartcar 時間: 08-12-12 21:25

This is never ending dicussion and boring to say each school has their own strengths and weaknesses.

I thought I am in Victoria Park on Sunday watching cross fire between Liberty and Communism parties.

作者: 3lamma 時間: 08-12-13 12:47

Agree with 502 and markx,

It's not the time to 'choose' between 2 schools yet because the result of DBSPD has not been released yet.

Lucky enough, my son is in this situation, waiting to be selected. However I am very clam and reluctant to discuss in this topic. The reason is I believe in both schools, ourselves as parents and my son. wherever he goes, I trust the teachers and ourselves will support him, wishing that he can develop his full potential and enjoys his life-long learning journey.

Let's come back to this topic or open a new topic if your son is accepted by YW and DBSPD, then we can discuss more and seek some advices from other parents.

Thanks.

3lamma

作者: HoHoMom 時間: 08-12-14 05:25

Well said !

原帖由 love_dreaming 於 08-12-12 11:14 發表

人必先自侮而後人侮之！

作者: LouiseM 時間: 08-12-15 10:07

You are so calm to wait the result right, not so stressful at all, hope you have a wonderful X'max 2008.

原帖由 3lamma 於 08-12-13 12:47 發表
Agree with 502 and markx,

It's not the time to 'choose' between 2 schools yet because the result of DBSPD has not been released yet.

Lucky enough, my son is in this situation, waiting to be select ...

作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-15 10:59

gd luck with ur st paul boys life la!

原帖由 HoHoMom 於 08-12-14 05:25 發表
Well said !

[ 本帖最後由 wlmom 於 08-12-15 11:02 編輯 ]

作者: HoHoMom 時間: 08-12-15 15:34

Thanks so much

Good luck with your and youir kids' lives in general

原帖由 wlmom 於 08-12-15 10:59 發表
gd luck with ur st paul boys life la!

作者: HoHoMom 時間: 08-12-15 15:46

Oh, just presuming you are a parent here, wherever your kids might go. If not .....

原帖由 wlmom 於 08-12-15 10:59 發表
gd luck with ur st paul boys life la!

作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-15 16:02

well, yes, i am a parent and my kid has already gone into a school which i think is good (according to my standard). Thanks!

原帖由 HoHoMom 於 08-12-15 15:46 發表
Oh, just presuming you are a parent here, wherever your kids might go. If not .....

作者: HoHoMom 時間: 08-12-15 16:04

Right.....

原帖由 wlmom 於 08-12-15 16:02 發表
well, yes, i am a parent and my kid has already gone into a school which i think is good (according to my standard). Thanks!

作者: littlecat 時間: 08-12-16 14:41

每間學校都有其優點和缺點, 我認為最重要是自己的小朋友讀得開心.

作者: jennytms 時間: 08-12-16 15:15

totally agreed with you.

原帖由 littlecat 於 08-12-16 14:41 發表
每間學校都有其優點和缺點, 我認為最重要是自己的小朋友讀得開心.

作者: gracechung 時間: 08-12-16 15:17

今時今日好多家長都係呢種諗法。
就我個人來講，可能我想法保守，
我認為讀得開心係唔夠，我始終期望完成六年小學之後，
最低限度要建立到"規矩"，
行為上的，學習上的都要自律。

並且，我認為今日的社會個人主義已經太氾濫，
我希望小朋友係學校裡要學識為人設想，
想團隊利益先於個人利益。

我對學校在教學上都有要求，
教學係學校最重要的責任，溫習家長一定要做，
但總不能期望家長同學生"自動波"識晒，
我最討厭書就冇乜點教，但試題就出到深一深，
或者教成個課題，只得一張工作紙做功課，
咁樣既教學基礎既攪得唔好，冇延展性，又缺乏支援。

以上只是我個人喜好，如果不認同者，本人亦不打算要與人爭辯。反正我幾廿歲人，唔會因人幾句就改變自已睇法，亦唔打算要改變別人想法。

原帖由 littlecat 於 08-12-16 14:41 發表
每間學校都有其優點和缺點, 我認為最重要是自己的小朋友讀得開心.

作者: NK媽 時間: 09-6-11 17:42

經常看到一些言論話「d人入唔到x先入y之嘛」

憑什麼有這樣結論？偏見？鄉愿？

發表個人意見時請對自己和別人保持尊重。

作者: shalaladream 時間: 09-6-11 20:16 標題: 回覆 86# NK媽的文章

Totally agree!!

作者: cecichan 時間: 09-6-11 20:39

每間學校都有其優點和缺點, 我認為最重要是自己的小朋友讀得開心. 英華現在不輸dbs
最緊要岩小朋友讀

作者: 小元 時間: 09-6-11 21:19

我們是平凡人,虛榮心一定有,放榜一聽到是DBS就會<哇>一聲,如果是YW就會<你就好啦>,如果有機會當然要試吓,不過壓力是有,讀唔掂退學大有人在,<人有白鴿眼>到處都有,真的要睇父母如何身教。

作者: littlecowbb 時間: 09-6-12 17:47

Hi Cecichan,

Really agree what u r talking, sometimes i think if too pushing kids to go to a reputation school...they will feel much pressure.......

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)