教育王國
標題: 請教同各位SC同KV已收的家長會揀邊間同點解? [打印本頁]
作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-3 17:54 標題: 請教同各位SC同KV已收的家長會揀邊間同點解?
SC同KV都收,取向KV因為小孩比較無禮貌,失控但受教,唔怕俾人鬧完失去自信.愛讀書.但中文完全唔識,怕再讀埋SC上小學會追唔上.因為英文比較容易响出面幫到.所以KV應該係我嘅選擇.唔知各位兩間都有收嘅家長為你哋嘅小孩作出的決擇有甚麼意見?
[ 本帖最後由 fishny 於 08-12-3 18:21 編輯 ]
作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-3 17:57
same as me, kv & sc is am class... any comment??
作者: chu__chu 時間: 08-12-3 18:02
I think each parent will make his/her decision according to own circumstances. If you say your b is "比較失控但受教,唔怕俾人鬧完失去自信.愛讀書.但中文完全唔識", then obviously kv is your choice.
For me, it's SC of course. The decision comes from my comparason between my friend's kids who graduated from (or is studying at) both schools
作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-3 18:14
原帖由 chu__chu 於 08-12-3 18:02 發表 
I think each parent will make his/her decision according to own circumstances. If you say your b is "比較失控但受教,唔怕俾人鬧完失去自信.愛讀書.但中文完全唔識", then obviously kv is your choice.
For ...
謝謝意見,我知道响我嘅情況,KV會係比較識合我小孩,但我想知道我會唔會對SC比較注重英文的優點外,仲有一些優點我係唔知道呢.而依D優點對我小孩是否有幫助呢?因我想小心作出選擇.所有希望知道大家作出選擇的原因.
作者: dingdingbb 時間: 08-12-4 09:51
我有朋友係kv讀過,佢既小朋友真係好有禮貌及有規矩,而且佢媽咪話kv所學到既野係佢感意外既,如k1已學到五大洲,七大洋~
但sc既英文又比較好,真係較難取捨
作者: chu__chu 時間: 08-12-4 09:59
原帖由 fishny 於 08-12-3 18:14 發表
謝謝意見,我知道响我嘅情況,KV會係比較識合我小孩,但我想知道我會唔會對SC比較注重英文的優點外,仲有一些優點我係唔知道呢.而依D優點對我小孩是否有幫助呢?因我想小心作出選擇.所有希望知道大家作出選擇的原因. ...
SC is famous for its English. Apart from that, I have friends whose son studying at SC who is "inquisitive", "fast-learning" as well as "presentable".
I prefer SC's campus more than KV's. Can't imagine those primitive 滑梯 built on top of a store room at Dorset campus (the waiting area to interview) ...
My daughter got offers from both schools and I decided to register SC for her.
作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-5 02:15
原帖由 chu__chu 於 08-12-4 09:59 發表
SC is famous for its English. Apart from that, I have friends whose son studying at SC who is "inquisitive", "fast-learning" as well as "presentable".
I prefer SC's campus more than KV's. Can't imag ...
多謝你的分享,希望你小孩不單可以開心响SC度過3年,仲可以喺知識上建立好的foundation.
作者: Pkceddie 時間: 08-12-5 02:20
原帖由 fishny 於 08-12-3 18:14 發表
謝謝意見,我知道响我嘅情況,KV會係比較識合我小孩,但我想知道我會唔會對SC比較注重英文的優點外,仲有一些優點我係唔知道呢.而依D優點對我小孩是否有幫助呢?因我想小心作出選擇.所有希望知道大家作出選擇的原因. ...
我會kv 難入d 學術好小朋友易教， st.c除咗英文好學費又貴
作者: qoo_pooh 時間: 08-12-5 09:14
我都識讀2間幼稚園的小朋友,
so far 我覺得KV的學術水平真係唔錯,
同埋紀律 train得好好
不過, KV的小朋友大多很文靜,
可能學校要小朋友好乖咁坐定定 ~~
而SC的小朋友就活躍D,
英文好D ~~
其實兩間學校係好唔同種類,
各有各好,
真係好睇小朋友適合讀邊間同埋家長的要求
作者: qoo_pooh 時間: 08-12-5 09:17
其實讀KV要係出面上英文同普通話 course,
學費計落其實同SC差不多
同埋係出面上英文同普通話 course多是1星期1堂/2堂,
所以若計英文同普通話SC會抵D
原帖由 Pkceddie 於 08-12-5 02:20 發表
我會kv 難入d 學術好小朋友易教， st.c除咗英文好學費又貴
作者: chu__chu 時間: 08-12-5 09:43
原帖由 fishny 於 08-12-5 02:15 發表
多謝你的分享,希望你小孩不單可以開心响SC度過3年,仲可以喺知識上建立好的foundation.
You too! Hope you can make a choice that you would never regret and your kid can enjoy the pre-school life (either at sc or kv) as well!
作者: wilsonchanwh 時間: 08-12-5 10:10
原帖由 qoo_pooh 於 08-12-5 09:17 發表
其實讀KV要係出面上英文同普通話 course,
學費計落其實同SC差不多
同埋係出面上英文同普通話 course多是1星期1堂/2堂,
所以若計英文同普通話SC會抵D
But KV 係數學方面比 SC 強很多。
作者: 靚媽唔易做 時間: 08-12-5 10:33
同意. 好既英文補習係外面好易揾, 但中文同數學相對無咁多, 再加上我都聽過d媽咪就算讀st cat, 佢都照幫個仔補英文&普通話.
我揀kv係一心想幫個女打好個底, 加埋佢既性格夠定, 獨立同吸收快, 所以我覺得kv岩佢多d.
各位媽咪, 揀幼稚園真係除咗名氣外, 要考慮埋你小朋友既性格同天資, 如佢跟本唔適合但你夾硬比佢讀, 最終咪又要轉校或佢讀得辛苦.
原帖由 wilsonchanwh 於 08-12-5 10:10 發表
But KV 係數學方面比 SC 強很多。
作者: gym 時間: 08-12-5 11:40
As far as the campus is concerned, I prefer KV's. I recall that SC's campus has some very narrow side stairs going up to some classrooms which are situated at some place like an attic, whereas KV's campus is rather clear and open and all staircases are built properly indoors.
原帖由 chu__chu 於 08-12-4 09:59 發表
I prefer SC's campus more than KV's. Can't imagine those primitive 滑梯 built on top of a store room at Dorset campus (the waiting area to interview) ...
作者: chu__chu 時間: 08-12-5 11:57
原帖由 gym 於 08-12-5 11:40 發表
As far as the campus is concerned, I prefer KV's. I recall that SC's campus has some very narrow side stairs going up to some classrooms which are situated at some place like an attic, whereas KV's c ...
Anyway, 咸魚青菜,各有喜愛, just make a choice you would never regret and good luck!
作者: 雙子媽媽 時間: 08-12-5 12:10
agreed. 其實KV同St. Cat有咩優點, 有咩缺點, 各家長都心中有數. 各取所需吧. 舊年我都有呢2間offer, 我end up選左kv.
仲有, KV並唔係坊間所傳咁可怕ge, 咩什麼k1開始寫字, 咩無童真, 我唔覺得係羅. 我個囝係坐唔停個type人, 但so far我見佢都讀得幾開心.
原帖由 chu__chu 於 08-12-5 11:57 發表
Anyway, 咸魚青菜,各有喜愛, just make a choice you would never regret and good luck!
作者: fatsin 時間: 08-12-5 12:51
其實每個媽咪都想為個小朋友好,又怕揀錯左,所以好混亂,我都一樣,想kv教到佢乖乖,聽話聽教,學好中文同數學,但又怕佢因嚴而讀得唔開心。又想sc教好佢英文,個人活d,但又怕佢中文同普通話唔得。真係各有各好,最後應該點下定論呢?好苦腦!!!!!
請問下sc既中文、數學同普通話程度如何呢? 是否如有媽咪所講,仍需要在外上堂學呢?
至於 kv 方面,我姪女佢讀到 k3,最近才同佢媽咪講話其實凟得唔係咁開心,但其實唔開心,對小朋友有無影響呢,因為上到傳統小學都差不多,應該都唔會話太開心,功課壓力始終大。
作者: mrnosey 時間: 08-12-5 13:46
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: 靚媽唔易做 時間: 08-12-5 15:05
em........聽聞好多famous primary school除咗收st cat既學生外, kv都唔少喎, 我係九龍塘interview o個陣, 好多嬸嬸派既傳單基本上唔會少咗"根德園"呢3個字的, 如果照你d教師朋友咁講, 每年就唔會有咁多人爭, 佢亦唔可以叫名校啦, 佢生存到咁耐梗係佢本事既.
講真, 香港除咗每月差不多成皮既真正國際學校既教學模式係唔同外, 其它名小, 私小既教學模式咪又係一樣, 上堂, 寫字, 默書同考試.
你朋友個女有咁既問題, 可能佢父母當初一心想推個女入呢間學校, 無細心觀察究竟適唔適合佢, 欠缺溝通, 依家發生咗呢d問題就歸咎於間學校, 會唔會父母都要負返d責任呢?
原帖由 mrnosey 於 08-12-5 13:46 發表
其實除了學術上要 consider , 性格發展都好重要, KV 的教學方式, 比較是罐頭式的單向教法, 要短時間內吸收大量學術知識, 但是咁的教學方式就比較不合時宜 (個人意見) 我們在學校不但是想佢學好學術吧, 我身邊認識 ...
作者: sallyfung001 時間: 08-12-5 15:12
聽各位講完之後，仲攪到我心大心細！点算？
作者: fatsin 時間: 08-12-5 15:16
完全有同感,都係唔知點好,15、16,死啦。
原帖由 sallyfung001 於 08-12-5 15:12 發表
聽各位講完之後，仲攪到我心大心細！点算？
作者: JESSTIFF 時間: 08-12-5 16:16
你覺得吾好睇,但吾代表吾好玩,吾代表危險,現今小孩什麼都用好的,新的,靚的,club house內設施靚過學校,但原來咁簡單的設施小朋友一樣開心,看不起它的只是大人自己. 學校是簡樸,從不做什麼特意取悅你們家長,只埋頭苦幹著重教育下一代,連功課用的paper,半張A4,前後都寫,不浪費,足夠、夠用便是了. 你可說學校cheap, 但我覺得這樣學生學懂珍惜.
kv學費明年又不加(已好多年冇加),比超市有良心,又冇其他雜費,家長開心. 可以加,但吾加; 或是可以吾加,但都加. 那類型幼稚園,家長自己選擇.
每日上課只是3個多小時, 玩滑梯可能得10分鐘, 用真金打造一條滑梯,都是給人看而已,羊毛出在羊身上,家長要裝潢,就比多d雜費了.
原帖由 chu__chu 於 08-12-4 09:59 發表
Can't imagine those primitive 滑梯 built on top of a store room at Dorset campus (the waiting area to interview) ...
作者: chingchingb.ma 時間: 08-12-5 16:16
我見坊間學英文/普通話嘅地方都唔少SC嘅學生wor。
如果唔使喺出面上course,SC計落係會抵d,但如果唔係的話,就......
原帖由 qoo_pooh 於 08-12-5 09:17 發表
其實讀KV要係出面上英文同普通話 course,
學費計落其實同SC差不多
同埋係出面上英文同普通話 course多是1星期1堂/2堂,
所以若計英文同普通話SC會抵D
作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-5 16:58
只是愚見,自己本身也是香港罐頭救育制度出產的.深明其害處,但是身在香港,假使唔玩這個遊戲,只好向國際學校條路行,不要講所要付的額外費用,可能我見識少,但我看不出度出的學生普遍香港社會會比香港本土教育出來的特別好.除非你話子女一定唔香港生活就另話.
作為父母,當然想子女開心,包括學習.但是現實歸現實.讀書有壓力,有兢爭,我出做都係,不要講話香港,全世界大城市都係咁.理想都要同現實妥協.可憐的現實就係子女由兩歲開始就要面對兢爭了.對我來說,我寧願讓佢提早面對,但這又是否代表佢一定唔快樂呢?可能佢係一個天生兢爭者呢?當然這兩年多的相處,各父母應該對自己子女的性格和能力已心裡有數,知道佢係適合甚麼.
一班裡面,一定有人考第一,有人考第尾,孝第尾個會同人講這學校唔夠嚴,唔逼我小孩.孝第一個又話依間學校非常好,給我小孩快樂學習,自由發揮.咁我聽得邊個?但是我想講就係幾快樂的學校都已經有兢爭了,你家長唔在意嗎?講真,我一定在意.唔在意的我就唔洗去爭入依D所謂的名校了.
我只能說,玩得這個遊戲,就有贏有輸,我只希望我同我小孩能力範圍內成功到達目的地.開心很重要,但我覺得現實更加重要...哈哈!果然係一個不折不扣的港人.
作者: chiumh 時間: 08-12-5 17:32
我唸我會揀SC,因為我個女係唔鬧得
及我無時間陪佢溫習功課。
作者: 雙子媽媽 時間: 08-12-5 18:27
唔鬧得
, 點樣唔鬧得法? 有邊個人心甘命抵比人鬧? 咁細個小朋友, 唔鬧得就唔鬧咩? 況且妳點知SC一定唔鬧人呢? 同埋, 有d小朋友係蝦屋企人ge, 比人鬧返而好地地. 好似我個囝咁, 佢係屋企都好霸道, 我問佢係學校(kv)有無比老師鬧, 佢話有. 我問鬧咩, 佢話老師話佢坐得唔好羅. 我再問"咁你咪好唔開心羅", 佢竟然答"唔係ge, 係我自己唔啱先". 老實講我真係打個突. 佢係屋企發起脾氣黎真係好似顛佬咁. 但估唔到佢係學校比人鬧都咁considerate.
原帖由 chiumh 於 08-12-5 17:32 發表
我唸我會揀SC,因為我個女係唔鬧得 及我無時間陪佢溫習功課。
作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-5 18:52
"咁細個小朋友, 唔鬧得就唔鬧咩?"
我鍾意呢句!!!鬧都唔得?打就話姐??不過我相信唔鬧嘅都係好普遍囉!!
作者: BJLover 時間: 08-12-5 18:54
My son got accepted at both schools AM class as well. However, the reason why I applied for KV was because I wanted my son to have more interview experiences. My preference is SC because I think both academic and happy childhood is both important for a kid. Honestly, I think disciple should be taught by parents instead of school. You can imagine that there are almost 30 kids in one class with only 2-3 teachers. Therefore, don’t expect they can focus too much on your kids. I think SC is better because I think they provide a more balance of school life and since it’s a bigger school, I think they should have more big events and activities that our kids can attend.
作者: mrnosey 時間: 08-12-5 21:09
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: mrnosey 時間: 08-12-5 21:16
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: mrnosey 時間: 08-12-5 21:33
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: cleverbb 時間: 08-12-5 21:43
My friend told me that after his elder son studied in SC, she found that only in K1 got the NET in class. From K2, 1 NET is shared among various classes (only ~ 20-30 mins a day). Does anyone know this arrangement?
For her younger son, she picked another kinder even though got the offer from SC.
作者: ManKeimama 時間: 08-12-5 23:01
原帖由 qoo_pooh 於 08-12-5 09:17 發表
其實讀KV要係出面上英文同普通話 course,
學費計落其實同SC差不多
同埋係出面上英文同普通話 course多是1星期1堂/2堂,
所以若計英文同普通話SC會抵D
作者: chingchingb.ma 時間: 08-12-5 23:37
完全明白。但我亦相信一個小朋友能夠英文or普通話可以好impressive,屋企嘅語言環境一定係功不可沒。
咁如果想入Maryknoll, St. Mary又唔需要話一定讀SC or KV嘅,只要夠分or住啱校網都有機會入,邊間幼稚園都冇所謂嘅。
都係嗰句,父母應該最清楚自己小朋友適合乜嘢學校,無論揾邊間學校,屋企(其實係最重要)亦都要有好嘅配合先至可以事半功倍。
原帖由 mrnosey 於 08-12-5 21:16 發表
我覺得要出去補不一定是sc 不enough , maybe 佢地是向super famous 學校進發la... eg cckg, 女拔, maryknoll, st mary , 咁一定是英文要好標青 la...
作者: andykwan 時間: 08-12-5 23:54
KV's curriculum is really good... if your kids can master it... good learning foundation can be built.. it is really useful in life time...
原帖由 dingdingbb 於 08-12-4 09:51 發表
我有朋友係kv讀過,佢既小朋友真係好有禮貌及有規矩,而且佢媽咪話kv所學到既野係佢感意外既,如k1已學到五大洲,七大洋~
但sc既英文又比較好,真係較難取捨 ...
作者: ysnmama 時間: 08-12-5 23:56
真的是家長想小朋友獲得什麼而去選擇是最好. 沒有一間學校是完美的.
這兩間學校的學生所獲得及不足的. 可以衡量是否容易往外尋求協助. 如果容易的. 問題根本不大.
作者: fishny 時間: 08-12-6 00:14
原帖由 mrnosey 於 08-12-5 21:33 發表
真是恕我直言, 想子女好就更加是不能只看重學術 , 小朋友未懂得表達真正的 feeling, ( 好似有個家長話, 小朋友長大後先話其實在 kv 讀得唔開心, 又or 有小朋友比家長要學piano, 小朋友完成 grade 8 原來只因為parent ...
我不敢苟同你的看法,但我會尊重唔同人有唔同意見的,沒有對與錯,你不能話我錯,我也不會話你錯的,希望你能為你小孩作出正確的選擇.這已經很足夠了.
作者: joeyxlma 時間: 08-12-6 00:20
我想最重要是了解了2間幼稚園的特點之後再取所需.
我地就好旗幟鮮明, 因為我地認為bb小時候是學外語的黃金時期, 所以選sc. 英普.
作者: rainbowbb 時間: 08-12-6 01:56
原帖由 cleverbb 於 08-12-5 21:43 發表
My friend told me that after his elder son studied in SC, she found that only in K1 got the NET in class. From K2, 1 NET is shared among various classes (only ~ 20-30 mins a day). Does anyone know thi ...
Although NET is shared among various classes, i don't think it's a big deal as you don't expect the NET can help in Chinese class. So during those classes with Chinese learning, the NET will go to other class.
My kid is in K2 E/P and I do not spend much on her homework except on writing as teachers recommend the parents to work with them to keep an eye on 筆順 so that they write it correctly. Starting on K2, they need to hand in the homeworks on arrival to the classroom and packs their own schoolbag to train their independence. As I know some parents send their kids to Eng class etc to prepare for P1 interview as their targets are on DGS, GH etc. and for K1 students, some parents may want to get their girls to admit CCKG so they will take extra course outside school.
One thing is that St. Cat emphasis on 親子 activities ie. doing homeworks, go outings, reading etc. They encourage kids on reading.
Most of the students are quite active and the school trains them to be more confident in public speaking as kids are need to stand in front of the class to do 'show and tell', parents prepare the news and explain to the kid and the kid will tell it to the class and sometimes they need to tell story in front of the class. My girl is a shy one and I saw great improvement on her that she is not afraid of talking with strangers.
For chinese - K2 now starts to write 男女, they have a vocabulary book had some chinese words on one side and the other one , we need to picture about their words to stick on it. This week talks about winter and talks about 火鍋、運動 last week 消防員、警察 and the kids had to recognize it so I don't think the chinese level in St. Cat is low.
But the most important thing is the school is suitable for your own kid and what type of school does you want your child to have (traditional teaching or activity based). For both SC and KV, students go to traditional or DSS primary school and they do well there. So just choose the kindergarten that you think your kids will be happy in the school life.
作者: BJLover 時間: 08-12-8 23:27
can we write letter to request the E/P at SC? My son got accepted in E/C class but I would love him to go E/P class.
作者: wttclh 時間: 08-12-15 09:44
終於做了決定, 無交到kv留位費.
[ 本帖最後由 wttclh 於 08-12-18 10:33 編輯 ]
作者: sallyfung001 時間: 08-12-15 16:27
Same to you!
原帖由 wttclh 於 08-12-15 09:44 發表
終於做了決定, 無交到kv留位費.
作者: anthony010103 時間: 08-12-15 16:47
原帖由 rainbowbb 於 08-12-6 01:56 發表
Although NET is shared among various classes, i don't think it's a big deal as you don't expect the NET can help in Chinese class. So during those classes with Chinese learning, the NET will go to ...
Do you know where the students of E/C classes study more PTH outside usually?
作者: jennychin 時間: 08-12-15 17:44
原帖由 sallyfung001 於 08-12-15 16:27 發表
Same to you!
why & which one u choose??
作者: chu__chu 時間: 08-12-15 18:42
原帖由 wttclh 於 08-12-15 09:44 發表
終於做了決定, 無交到kv留位費.
Same to u, I register SC for my daughter and give up KV.
作者: Cardiff 時間: 08-12-16 23:41
me too. I gave up KV.
作者: sallyfung001 時間: 08-12-17 17:57
SC.
I like the English learning environment!
:)原帖由 jennychin 於 08-12-15 17:44 發表
why & which one u choose??
作者: SCKnight 時間: 08-12-18 00:50
Me 2, pick SC and give up KV
作者: wttclh 時間: 08-12-18 10:35
我老公最後改變主意, 交咗kv留位費.
佢話佢有兩個客的囝囡都係讀kv, 基礎打得好好, 上咗小學一路成績keep得好好.
原帖由 wttclh 於 08-12-15 09:44 發表
終於做了決定, 無交到kv留位費.
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |