教育王國
標題: La Salle vs Ying Wa [打印本頁]
作者: yikyubb 時間: 08-11-24 15:45 標題: La Salle vs Ying Wa
小兒獲兩校取錄,很難選擇, 如不用考慮學費問題,
從(師資 / 功課 /學校成績 /學生品德)作比較,請給意見.
作者: belle 時間: 08-11-24 15:47
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: Mamahui 時間: 08-11-24 15:47
原帖由 yikyubb 於 08-11-24 15:45 發表 
小兒獲兩校取錄,很難選擇, 如不用考慮學費問題,
從(師資 / 功課 /學校成績 /學生品德)作比較,請給意見.
吾駛諗啦＝＝＝梗係喇沙啦。
作者: charwes 時間: 08-11-24 15:48
La Salle is the obvious choice.
原帖由 yikyubb 於 08-11-24 15:45 發表
小兒獲兩校取錄,很難選擇, 如不用考慮學費問題,
從(師資 / 功課 /學校成績 /學生品德)作比較,請給意見.
作者: ernie 時間: 08-11-24 15:49
WHY?WHY?WHY?
作者: CandyBB 時間: 08-11-24 15:55
me too!! La Salle.
原帖由 charwes 於 08-11-24 15:48 發表
La Salle is the obvious choice.
作者: shirleyyip04 時間: 08-11-24 15:55
La Salle
作者: safarimama 時間: 08-11-24 15:57 標題: 回覆 # 的文章
of course LS ............!!! No need to think!!!!!
作者: parentslove 時間: 08-11-24 15:58
Of course, La Salle! I was grad there. But I got two daughters, no advantage!
Congratulations!
作者: BBR 時間: 08-11-24 15:58
多事一問,LS好似一面倒,咁如果LS同DBS呢?
作者: Yonniewong 時間: 08-11-24 15:59
La Salle....Without hesitation!
作者: charwes 時間: 08-11-24 16:01
My friend's son got accepted by both LS & DBSPD last year and he finally went for LS. I think I will do the same for my son next year if I'm lucky enough to face the same dilemma.
原帖由 BBR 於 08-11-24 15:58 發表
多事一問,LS好似一面倒,咁如果LS同DBS呢?
作者: Mamahui 時間: 08-11-24 16:03
原帖由 BBR 於 08-11-24 15:58 發表
多事一問,LS好似一面倒,咁如果LS同DBS呢?
都係LS，何不將果ｄ學費比佢學下其他野，反正兩間既名氣都咁高咁大。
作者: phoebelau 時間: 08-11-24 16:03
SURE La Salle
作者: mamimummy 時間: 08-11-24 16:05
of course LS ............!!!!!!!!
if LS同DBS
, ....
if I have $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$, I'd pick DBS.
學術相同
,身份有別
.
[ 本帖最後由 mamimummy 於 08-11-24 16:12 編輯 ]
作者: Era 時間: 08-11-24 16:08
我諗樓主問呢個問題,係想到除左名氣,仲有其他野可以考慮囉.
作者: cheerbye 時間: 08-11-24 16:08
LS, YW, DBSPD.....
一定選LS......
原帖由 yikyubb 於 08-11-24 15:45 發表
小兒獲兩校取錄,很難選擇, 如不用考慮學費問題,
從(師資 / 功課 /學校成績 /學生品德)作比較,請給意見.
作者: storyteller 時間: 08-11-24 16:09
Of course LS!!
But I'm thinking St.joseph(Wan Chai) vs Ying Wa?
原帖由 mamimummy 於 08-11-24 16:05 發表
of course LS ............!!!!!!!!
作者: smallmama 時間: 08-11-24 16:13
當然係喇沙啦.
作者: Yonniewong 時間: 08-11-24 16:15
still LS...
作者: 小謙伯伯 時間: 08-11-24 16:15
除非你唔係想囝囝入「名校」喇，否則無可能棄喇沙而揀英華喎。
作者: mamimummy 時間: 08-11-24 16:15
if St.joseph(Wan Chai) vs Ying Wa
OF Course St.joseph(Wan Chai) -- English Primary School. (even compare with LS).
原帖由 storyteller 於 08-11-24 16:09 發表
Of course LS!!
But I'm thinking St.joseph(Wan Chai) vs Ying Wa?
作者: conniengor 時間: 08-11-24 16:16
梗係LS, 但我已無望!
作者: CHTmami 時間: 08-11-24 16:17
原帖由 BBR 於 08-11-24 15:58 發表
多事一問,LS好似一面倒,咁如果LS同DBS呢?
Still LS!!!
作者: LS+MCS 時間: 08-11-24 16:19
I vote for La Salle.
作者: IncyWincySpider 時間: 08-11-24 16:20
我有朋友既另一半係DBSPD教書, 較知道校內的事, 她將自己個仔送了去喇沙小學, 現在成績很好.
她的另一位同事亦一樣, 將兒子送了去喇沙.
她不願說原因, 只說”喇沙很好”.
若我住九龍塘區, 我都會試抽呢間架!
我曾經問過英華
vs 喇沙, 她說: ”當然喇沙啦!”
原帖由 CHTmami 於 08-11-24 16:17 發表
Still LS!!!
作者: charwes 時間: 08-11-24 16:25
St. Jo and LS are both from the Lasallian Family and both of them are good. I think the geographical factor would be the decisive factor for opting which one to go for.
原帖由 mamimummy 於 08-11-24 16:15 發表
if St.joseph(Wan Chai) vs Ying Wa
OF Course St.joseph(Wan Chai) -- English Primary School. (even compare with LS).
作者: belle 時間: 08-11-24 16:31
提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: charwes 時間: 08-11-24 16:38
I think it's no difference between DBS and LS on whether ALL the students could be promoted to the secondary session. Although DBS is a DSS, the students will still need to maintain an acceptable standard, otherwise you will face ALL kinds of pressure from the school and you might be gone well before you can be promoted to the secondary session if you are considered mediocre by the school.
原帖由 belle 於 08-11-24 16:31 發表
But if I am rich, I would choose DBS. Since it is DSS and the boy can get into the Secondary session easily (all past the subjects???)
But for La Salle, you need to be the top 100 , otherwise no cha ...
作者: Junko 時間: 08-11-24 16:38
I prefer Ying Wa to La Salle.
Students of Ying Wa have gone through the interview and the competition is keen. On the contrary, students of La Salle were admitted via lucky draw.
You will think that the standard will be varied amongst kids at La Salle. As for Ying Wa, most of the students are come from similar background ... more easier for school to achieve its target.
Choosing a right school for kids cannot just depend on its "NAME" only.
Religion is also a consideration .... one is a Catholic and one is a Christian school.
作者: Era 時間: 08-11-24 16:47
非常有同感,不過係一直驚講出來會俾人話啫.
我覺得個小朋友知道自己係有盡力去爭取返來既,好過係一間佢地係靠運氣而入既囉.
同埋ls既功課量,聽講都好驚人,目的就係要將頂唔順既學生趕走.所以入得去亦都要有心理準備,將會面對既係乜野既生活.
原帖由 Junko 於 08-11-24 16:38 發表
I prefer Ying Wa to La Salle.
Students of Ying Wa have gone through the interview and the competition is keen. On the contrary, students of La Salle were admitted via lucky draw.
You will think that ...
作者: hoosier 時間: 08-11-24 21:54
當然現時兩間比較，LS是最好的選擇。
但我唔會忽略英華在未來的成就；我對林校長的領導材能有信心，她是一位很有感染力的校長。
小兒亦剛收到林校長的錄取通知信，但遺撼的是因我家住東區，所以都會選港大同學會(因他們亦收我小兒)。
作者: kaifu 時間: 08-11-24 21:58
Are you really a hoosier? I am a boiler.
原帖由 hoosier 於 08-11-24 21:54 發表
當然現時兩間比較，LS是最好的選擇。
但我唔會忽略英華在未來的成就；我對林校長的領導材能有信心，她是一位很有感染力的校長。
小兒亦剛收到林校長的錄取通知信，但遺撼的是因我家住東區，所以都會選港大同學會(因他們亦收 ...
[ 本帖最後由 kaifu 於 08-11-24 23:02 編輯 ]
作者: hoosier 時間: 08-11-24 22:24
原帖由 kaifu 於 08-11-24 21:58 發表
Are you a really hoosier? I am a boiler.
Yes, I am a hoosier, year of 1987. Nice to meet you boilermaker 
: , hey, you guys beat us real bad in the Old Bucket game by 52 points.
作者: kaifu 時間: 08-11-24 23:01
You guys beat us in the "Ying Wa" game! We lost at the first round. What a small world. We went to grad school at Purdue in the 90s. Go Boilers!
Been to Bloomington a couple of times to see the fall colors. U ever been to W Lafayette?
原帖由 hoosier 於 08-11-24 22:24 發表
Yes, I am a hoosier, year of 1987. Nice to meet you boilermaker ::" />:" /> , hey, you guys beat us real bad in the Old Bucket game by 52 points.
作者: Jean 時間: 08-11-24 23:07
Ying Wa小學太新, 老師資歷不見突出. 而林校長, 前鋒又係佢, 後防又係佢. 比佢做得更好的校長亦有不少, 只是無咁high profile啫.
LS雖然係派位, 我認識既LS boy家庭背景都非常非常好. 就算資質普通既學生, 只要有LS spirit, 都有其耀眼的一面.
個人意見, 不喜勿插.
作者: baseball 時間: 08-11-24 23:13
Totally agree with u as my relative is
P.3 now which he is really get a big pressure
in this school, even he is a quite smart boy
and aldy had several private tutors for helping
him on his school homework and revision
as his parents are both working. Moreover,
he seems don't have much confidence as before.
原帖由 Era 於 08-11-24 16:47 發表
非常有同感,不過係一直驚講出來會俾人話啫.
我覺得個小朋友知道自己係有盡力去爭取返來既,好過係一間佢地係靠運氣而入既囉.
同埋ls既功課量,聽講都好驚人,目的就係要將頂唔順既學生趕走.所以入得去亦都要 ...
作者: Yonniewong 時間: 08-11-24 23:18
Totally agreed!
Moreover, Principal Lam is going to retire. It is the point I choose LS if I am you.
原帖由 Jean 於 08-11-24 23:07 發表
Ying Wa小學太新, 老師資歷不見突出. 而林校長, 前鋒又係佢, 後防又係佢. 比佢做得更好的校長亦有不少, 只是無咁high profile啫.
LS雖然係派位, 我認識既LS boy家庭背景都非常非常好. 就算資質普通既學生, 只要有 ...
作者: hoosier 時間: 08-11-24 23:18
原帖由 kaifu 於 08-11-24 23:01 發表
You guys beat us in the "Ying Wa" game! We lost at the first round. What a small world. We went to grad school at Purdue in the 90s. Go Boilers!
Been to Bloomington a couple of times to see the f ...
I went to WL every couple years for the IU away football game.
My family lives in Bloomington, IL. I didn't go to UI and went to IU - Bloomington because I am a basketball fan and a big fan of Coach Knight........ my major was sports management. Well, I like Ying Wah because they also have good tradition in sports.
Well, college basketball season just started and hopefully we will get it back from football, cheers .....
作者: 2046 時間: 08-11-24 23:20
La Salle vs Ying Wah
I'll choose La Salle even though Ying Wah is also very good. In terms of school spirit, history and faciities. But you need to get ready for the upcoming challenge. I can't get LS in the first round allocation. But I have no guts to gamble again by giving up Ying Wah. You got the luck and why don't you go and get it!
作者: mamimummy 時間: 08-11-25 00:22
High Profile?! 對. 林校長都只是借協恩個名, 如果她不是前協恩校長情形會跟現在一樣嗎
? 協恩不是她一手帶起的, 更不會因為沒有她而失去精神, 動力 和 吸引力.
原帖由 Jean 於 08-11-24 23:07 發表
Ying Wa小學太新, 老師資歷不見突出. 而林校長, 前鋒又係佢, 後防又係佢. 比佢做得更好的校長亦有不少, 只是無咁high profile啫.
LS雖然係派位, 我認識既LS boy家庭背景都非常非常好. 就算資質普通既學生, 只要有 ...
[ 本帖最後由 mamimummy 於 08-11-25 00:24 編輯 ]
作者: abmum 時間: 08-11-25 01:37
I am of the view that before making a choice, you'd better best estimate and understand the boy's ability and his personality.
To survive in such kind of Super Band 1 school (LS and DBS), the boy must be a very tough, outgoing, active or excellent academic background.
Confidence is very important in the child development. Take a shool that your boy will belong to the range "above average" of that school. Don't place the child to a school that he only marginally meet the standard, he will loss the confidence which is not worth.
So, only you know your boy and you are required to be honest to put him to the place that best fit.
原帖由 Yonniewong 於 08-11-24 16:15 發表
still LS...
作者: loy211 時間: 08-11-25 08:48
我都選喇沙,津校,慳番d錢俾佢學野.
作者: smartcar 時間: 08-11-25 11:32
I think most parent here would opt for LS over all else. And I did also.. I did the attempt in two occasions for LS lottery but fail, even my son was born Catholic with 20pts.
It is normal to fancy famous school.
However, I am more than happier to be in Ying Wa. My son loves the school very much altought the school keeps him very busy from Mon to Sat.
YW is the most traditional school in HK since 18XX. The school just celebrated her 191st Anniversary. All celebrities of old YW alumini attended the function. However, YW is low profile in the past and lost lust comparing to earl noble school as DBS and LS.
YW is on the move and has chosen the right direction now. YW has underlying strength to compete and publicity helps it to achieve.
YW's boys are confident and cheerful kids.(why, becoz I see him everyday
作者: jennytms 時間: 08-11-25 12:05
其實我們不應在這裡比較學校的好與不好, 最重要是你覺得那所學校適合你的小朋友. 之前曾在網上見到一些有關"林校長"的訪問, 她講得很有道理, "名校"是否實至名歸, 最重要就是要有好的老師, 有愛心的老師, 能夠因材施教, 能將每一個小朋友的才能都能充份發揮, 咁就真係能做到名副其實的好學校. 我囝囝很幸運地入到這所學校, 雖然他自行分配都入到一間心儀的官校,但我們都會讓囝囝入讀英華, 因我們想小朋友可以開心快樂地成長,相信英華這所學校就是可以做到這點. 我們亦好欣賞林校長對教育那顆熱誠的心.
以上純粹個人意見. 如有說得不好, 望多見諒.
作者: 小謙伯伯 時間: 08-11-25 13:29
From La Salle's school song:
"There are famous schools in plenty,
With their heroes by the score,
And they flourish high and mighty,
But La Salle is something more."
So, you know how to choose. (laughter : )
作者: LLPP 時間: 08-11-25 14:56
Bruce Lee Fans - LS of course!
作者: smartcar 時間: 08-11-25 15:10
SAM Hui and Leung Kam Chung fans,
of coz Yin Wa
作者: vivian3328 時間: 08-11-25 19:40
首先申報，小兒現在在英華讀小一。
講真，如果抽到LS，根本無可能會放棄LS而選英華。因為人始終有啲虛榮心，LS個名係响啲！
但就好睇個小朋友得唔得，因為壓力係好大既。5年前，我同事佢個仔(好好彩)抽到入LS，當然全家都好開心啦。但佢仔仔確係跟唔上，結果，不停補習，老師不停要見家長，全家壓力都超大，同事亦因此同仔仔關係惡化！最後，佢將仔仔送咗去英國。於是全家都開心哂！因為LS係抽既，小朋友都有啲差別，跟唔到就好辛苦。
你當我係賣花讚花香啦，只可以講小兒返學好開心，我所識既小一家長都表示兒子都好鐘意返學，咁佢又學到嘢，
又一條龍，仲想點喎！
作者: mayc 時間: 08-11-26 11:19
Dear all:
昨天明報教得樂拔小,喇沙,英華三位女校長分享教子心得,不妨了解多些她們的教子理念!
http://hk.wrs.yahoo.com/_ylt=A3xsaNa6wCxJwaEA9Lqzygt.;_ylu=X3oDMTE4OHJlb2c0BHNlYwNzcgRwb3MDMQRjb2xvA2hrX2ludGwEdnRpZANoa2MwMDNfNzE-/SIG=12g74f1v2/EXP=1227756090/**http%3A//happypama.mingpao.com/cfm/Ebook1.cfm%3FCategory=happy
不過這是上一期的內容,也是有關英華的,不妨了解多些才決定!
[ 本帖最後由 mayc 於 08-11-26 11:27 編輯 ]
作者: MTRC 時間: 08-11-26 13:04
作出選擇前,我會多考慮小朋友的特質和先放名校的負累,我記得約在五、六年前,某報頭條刊登了一則新聞關於舊小男拔生放棄一條龍直升男拔而决心離開選擇其他中學,我記得家長說除了第一天收到舊小男拔取錄後十分興奮後,家長和小朋友都未開心過,名校學習壓力和競爭實在很大,你和你的孩子是否適合,請三思。其實ㄚW是一個不錯選擇,一條龍直升中學,愉快開心學習,不需要煩呈分,爭入直屬中學
作者: nigelman 時間: 08-11-27 06:39
想指出,近年英華(中學)收"即食"運動員,已到畸形情況,e.g. 20歲兵球學界 A grade代表仲讀緊F.4, 全隊 A grade籃球隊正選都係插班生,和男拔"交換"泳手.
Is this the school you want your sons to study?
作者: hogwarts 時間: 08-11-27 07:25
LS should be a better choice for me if both schools accepted my boy.
I guarated from a school used to have some connection with the LS brother. The LS brothers, same as Wah Yan's fathers, do have a very unique experience and system to run school. Yes, many will say LS being too tough, but learning is a tough process.
I have no experience with YW but both are good schools. One may like to go to LS because of the school's tradition or simply it is "free of charge" and one may like to go to YW because of Mrs. Lam. At the end, it is the boy's and his parents' own inputs will count more.
作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-11-27 10:05
有些學校是不可以接受成績下滑的事實，最快捷的方法就是外求，為求成績，不擇手段，英華如是，喇沙亦不惶多讓。所以我覺得SPCC在頂級名校當中是最有校品的一間。
原帖由 nigelman 於 08-11-27 06:39 發表
想指出,近年英華(中學)收"即食"運動員,已到畸形情況,e.g. 20歲兵球學界 A grade代表仲讀緊F.4, 全隊 A grade籃球隊正選都係插班生,和男拔"交換"泳手.
Is this the school you want your sons to study? ...
[ 本帖最後由 kyliema2006 於 08-11-27 10:06 編輯 ]
作者: cutiemo 時間: 08-11-27 12:51
Hi Yikyubb,
can you share are you score 20 and live in net 41?
as your son has been accepted by LS..
also, any one accepted by LS by score 20 not living in net 41?...
原帖由 yikyubb 於 08-11-24 15:45 發表
小兒獲兩校取錄,很難選擇, 如不用考慮學費問題,
從(師資 / 功課 /學校成績 /學生品德)作比較,請給意見.
作者: nigelman 時間: 08-11-27 12:54
SPCC has tried to offer full scholarship to tempt the most famous young table tennis player of LSC before he started F.1. BTW, SPCC is too expensive in the current economic situation.
作者: vivian3328 時間: 08-11-27 23:28
嘜呢個係問題咩？原來你而家先知有啲咁既情況！你唔係話LS無咁做嘛！我相信好多所謂名校都有咁既現象，只不過係多定少。其實有嘜奇怪，你個仔讀書讀得叻，你都有可能插班去你認為更好既學校啦，你唔轉校我好欣賞，但你個仔轉校，我亦覺得無問題。好既運動員轉去佢哋覺得更好既學校無可厚非。
原帖由 nigelman 於 08-11-27 06:39 發表
想指出,近年英華(中學)收"即食"運動員,已到畸形情況,e.g. 20歲兵球學界 A grade代表仲讀緊F.4, 全隊 A grade籃球隊正選都係插班生,和男拔"交換"泳手.
Is this the school you want your sons to study? ...
作者: nigelman 時間: 08-11-28 07:53
轉校不是問題,但收個程度唔夠,20歲仲讀緊F.4,作為一間有191年歷史之名校,係咪咁害個學生?而對其他原可代表學校出賽之同學都不公平,這正是"買人"之壞處.而且在籃球隊更加過份,很多校友已表示不滿.Sam Hui都係中六入英華,但佢A-level成績優異,正正係win-win situation,對雙方都有好處, 這正是家長們可望見到的情況.
作者: hingmami 時間: 08-11-29 18:59
依種情況第時會唔同，而家英華小學收生咁勁，肯定唔駛收外援。原帖由 nigelman 於 08-11-28 07:53 發表
轉校不是問題,但收個程度唔夠,20歲仲讀緊F.4,作為一間有191年歷史之名校,係咪咁害個學生?而對其他原可代表學校出賽之同學都不公平,這正是"買人"之壞處.而且在籃球隊更加過份,很多校友已表示不滿.Sam Hui都係中六入英 ...
作者: gracechung 時間: 08-11-29 21:57
我唔係話偏幫邊間學校，事實上，聞說好些名校就係咁，唔同學生有唔同function，有些負責讀好書爭成績，有些負責運動爭獎，根對唔係過別學校做法對與不對，根本成個香港的觀念同風氣就唔健康！
原帖由 nigelman 於 08-11-28 07:53 發表
轉校不是問題,但收個程度唔夠,20歲仲讀緊F.4,作為一間有191年歷史之名校,係咪咁害個學生?而對其他原可代表學校出賽之同學都不公平,這正是"買人"之壞處.而且在籃球隊更加過份,很多校友已表示不滿.Sam Hui都係中六入英 ...
作者: laichuilai 時間: 08-11-29 23:25
聽過咁多家長意見，我相信大部份小朋友讀YW較LS開心。另外，YW是直資，所有學生要經過3次面試，由林校長從一千八百多位挑選150位，而LS是沒有自主權選學生，所以學生質素相信YW較LS高。除了LS不用學費，我想不到它有什麽較YW優勝。
作者: mamimummy 時間: 08-11-30 00:08
勁?! 我腍就算你問林校長, 收生時佢都唔知邊個運動勁, 邊個數學叻. 英華小學得個幾年! 轉直資計埋in近都係得2年! buy 林校長係因為協恩, 但協恩一向都不是輕松學習, 要谷架啦.
原帖由 hingmami 於 08-11-29 18:59 發表
依種情況第時會唔同，而家英華小學收生咁勁，肯定唔駛收外援。
作者: hingmami 時間: 08-11-30 01:38
1800人都搵唔到勁 人？
原帖由 mamimummy 於 08-11-30 00:08 發表
勁?! 我腍就算你問林校長, 收生時佢都唔知邊個運動勁, 邊個數學叻. 英華小學得個幾年! 轉直資計埋in近都係得2年! buy 林校長係因為協恩, 但協恩一向都不是輕松學習, 要谷架啦.
...
作者: mamimummy 時間: 08-11-30 03:34
唔係無, 不個無你講得咁誇張, 而家d直資,好多都千幾二千幾人考, 各有各賣點, 各有各叻人. 有d叻ke要享受免費教育唔讀直資, 有d好活潑的唔敢讀以'傳統'出名的學校. 你話自己的學生叻, 都會想'囉埋'會贏自己學生的人嘛.
原帖由 hingmami 於 08-11-30 01:38 發表
1800人都搵唔到勁 人？
作者: hogwarts 時間: 08-11-30 07:02
哈哈！入什么学校，可以是神的安排(兩间都是GOD's schools)，又可以是符碌。
楼主是个可以又要LS、又可挑YW的幸福人，大家不必太上心了。为自己的孩子多花心思好了。
作者: smartcar 時間: 08-11-30 16:46
原帖由 vivian3328 於 08-11-27 23:28 發表
嘜呢個係問題咩？原來你而家先知有啲咁既情況！你唔係話LS無咁做嘛！我相信好多所謂名校都有咁既現象，只不過係多定少。其實有嘜奇怪，你個仔讀書讀得叻，你都有可能插班去你認為更好既學校啦，你唔轉校我好欣賞，但你個仔轉校，我亦覺 ...
I attended my boy(P.1)'s Sport Day last week and few schools were invited to compete in relay.
When I saw representatives from LS's(P.6), they are really outstanding. They are in no difference with F.2 or F.3 boys, I meant their height, muscle build, and speed.... Comparing to other schools, they are really professional at primary stage.
作者: authenticseelai 時間: 08-12-1 23:35
樓主,
咁多人俾咗咁多意見, 都註冊完, 開估你點揀?
是不是La Salle?
作者: hogwarts 時間: 08-12-1 23:49
楼主就是在享受大家吵來吵去嘛！
作者: yikyubb 時間: 08-12-2 00:04
感謝各位的意見.
我們選了YW, 因YW比較適合囝囝, 功課壓力不大, 可愉快學習, 我們都相信林校長對教育那份熱誠的心.
祝各位小朋友都能入讀合適的小學.
[ 本帖最後由 yikyubb 於 08-12-2 00:08 編輯 ]
作者: gracechung 時間: 08-12-2 00:23
如果你小朋友入讀YW，我相信佢以後都唔捨得走！
我個朋友都有小朋友，同我傾湊仔經，佢話風聞LS遲d小三時會加人收插班，佢話一齊試下啦。
我個仔玩緊聽到大人講野，不知幾緊張，喊添呀，話唔轉校，話自已讀得好開心又學到野。
其實，我根本都唔係想佢轉校，見佢咁鬼緊張，好得意。
亞仔鬼咁緊張，話校長比左張紙佢，佢當寶架。原來係評估後校長派比每一個小朋友的鼓勵說話。我諗小朋友係YW真係好開心好有自信。
我都好滿意。其實，YW做到咁多有利成長既事，亞仔得到實際得益，我根本唔會介意佢係咪所謂的"名校"，我亦唔會追求"名氣"而犧牲亞仔的利益，就算其他學校更好，不過，YW適合佢嘛！
原帖由 yikyubb 於 08-12-2 00:04 發表
多謝各位的意見.
我們選了YW, 因YW比較適合囝囝, 功課壓力不大, 可愉快學習, 我們都相信林校長對教育那份熱誠的心.
祝各位小朋友都能入讀合適的小學. ...
作者: mamimummy 時間: 08-12-2 00:41
如果個個家長會咁腍, 香港下一代有希望la.
.
原帖由 gracechung 於 08-12-2 00:23 發表
"亞仔得到實際得益，我根本唔會介意佢係咪所謂的"名校"，我亦唔會追求"名氣"而犧牲亞仔的利益，就算其他學校更好，不過，YW適合佢嘛！"
[ 本帖最後由 mamimummy 於 08-12-2 00:43 編輯 ]
作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-2 12:45
I'll choose La Salle of course! It has got so good reputation in academinc results and on the sports side as well. I know a lot of old La Salle boys and they are all from good family background and have decent jobs now.
Actually i just know that there is a "Ying Wah" girls' school on the HK Island side which is considered as good.
作者: catcatmom 時間: 08-12-2 14:29
如果講名氣, 更係前者, 又唔冼$, 學舍又靚有泳池.不過其中一個間既學生出名好"曳", 暑假去過一間補習社, 佢地係間學校對面, 所以收好多佢地學生, 有一次我個仔去影印室搵位坐,因末上堂,裡面有一個位, 有個著校服既男仔, 將個書包擲個位, 跟著好無禮貌甘講: 無位啦!! 跟著我同亞仔講: 無謂坐係 le d 人隔離啦! 我見到其他既學生.....另外一間就5知.
[ 本帖最後由 catcatmom 於 08-12-2 14:33 編輯 ]
作者: Fatdog 時間: 08-12-2 22:47
There are famous schools in plenty,
With their heroes by the score,
And they flourish high and mighty,
But La Salle is something more.
作者: Jean 時間: 08-12-2 23:16
總結係:
普遍家長都傾向揀LS
英華, 似乎都是本身已是英華既家長或是抽唔到LS但考到YW(除了樓主).
林校長最叻既就係把英華轉直資. 我從沒想過YW可以與LS相提並論.
作者: BBHin 時間: 08-12-3 03:38
原帖由 hogwarts 於 08-12-1 23:49 發表
楼主就是在享受大家吵來吵去嘛！
Haha! Well said! Never ending argue for this kind of topic. Just choose the school you like as it's your choice.:loveliness:
作者: Threetoone 時間: 08-12-3 08:47
Usually in the middle of such dilemma, you can set some criteria in helping you out to make the decision.
Just pick the one that you think it's most suitable for your son. And it would be perfect if that's the one you like most. However, if there's any discrepancy, then go for your son's suitability because that's for his own good, not yours. Then never look back and no regret, and make sure you "like" the school as well if you did not previously.
Unless you have chance to go for both at the same time, you will never know which road is the best in the end, rite?
And in your situation, both are very good boys' schools, so no matter which one you pick, you won't be too wrong! Good luck!
作者: 猴子爸 時間: 08-12-3 14:57
选英华的，主要是被林校长和直资自选学生吸引，但论中学，喇沙就高几班。以目前环境而论，最好是小学读英华，中学读喇沙。
但想问一问，如果喇沙?小学也变了直资，你们会选英华还是喇沙
作者: safarimama 時間: 08-12-3 16:23
哈哈, 其實樓主都應該在26/27號揀定咗啦! "兩間只能活一間"!! 原帖由 BBHin 於 08-12-3 03:38 發表
Haha! Well said! Never ending argue for this kind of topic. Just choose the school you like as it's your choice.:loveliness:
作者: youma 時間: 08-12-4 23:53
LS (中學及小學) 增值較高, 各方面較追求卓越(即係唔哀得), 大部份學生也都愉快學習 (有機會請看看他們放學和課外活動!), 但家長普遍較緊張.
作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-5 16:29 標題: 回覆 # 的文章
Totally agreed! YW and La Salle are just two different classes. I told my ex-La Salle friend and he feels angry. ha ha!
作者: 傑西 時間: 08-12-6 10:58
一定選英華！！！
作者: 囝囝爸 時間: 08-12-6 13:30
講地區, 校舍, 校網, 喇沙當較優勝.
兩間中學都是老牌名校, 但喇沙成績歷來前列. 英華小學尚
算是新校, 和有傳統成績支持的喇沙, 不能比較, 也不公平.
講讀書壓力, 想喇沙會高, 但有成績回報. 英華如要好成績, 將來都唔會輕鬆. 成績唔代表一切, 但唔夠成績條路會較難行.
講報名人數, 直資冇限制, 不能和有限制官津相比. 直資間間都有千幾二千人報讀, 但報讀直資目標家長個個報三五七間, 就算二千人報讀, 除番五, 實則得400人. 收到學生都未必揀你果間.
一間學校好唔好, 有理念都要推行後才可印證, 學校培育方法好重要, 但亦要天時地利人和配合.
作者: youma 時間: 08-12-6 21:22
選YW棄LS？
打死都唔信．
作者: 嫦娥一号 時間: 08-12-7 00:27
喇沙績方面應該勝英華。
喇沙梁校長希望LS成為全港最優秀的小學，
每年也吸引很多優質學生插班填補轉校生的
學位，根本不用轉值資也不愁收不到各區
優質的學生。
加上有心報LS的家長，大部份都是有傋而
戰，盲目靠天份想在LS生存，又或有些人心存
到此一遊也好呀的心態，同樣害了孩子。
要順利爭上中學是一場實力大比拼，只有勤
力、努力、加無比精力，才有希望成就大業
直升去中學。
我很欣賞以孩子品性來選校的家長。
YW有林校長=有好老師
有愛心
有創意
家長會永無冷場，笑聲連場！
她以孩子為中心
快樂、精彩校園生活保證。
她用真心誠意把教學理念實現出來，肯做、敢做、求進步，林校長是不可多得的人材！
林校長閱人無數，能被取錄的學生都是有根據的。
[ 本帖最後由 嫦娥一号 於 08-12-7 00:34 編輯 ]
作者: Jean 時間: 08-12-7 01:42
原帖由 嫦娥一号 於 08-12-7 00:27 發表
YW有林校長=有好老師
有愛心
有創意
家長會永無冷場，笑聲連場！
她以孩子為中心
快樂、精彩校園生活保證。
她用真心誠意把教學理念實現出來，肯做、敢做、求進步，林校長是不可多得的人材！
以上咁多點也同時是不少直資校, 很多私小和津校校長所具備. 甚至很多屋村小學校長也不見得比林校長能力低, 但林校長可能手段較高明. 再講現在有邊間學校敢唔搞創意, 而越新既老師通常愛心越無限, 這道理你想一想會明. 故何必要交12年學費就是為一個校長.
恕我直言, 千幾人面試, 可能有一半以上都係BK友. 羊群心態多人講間學校唱好唱衰. 即時會反應在報名收生上. 被取錄既上來開多幾個帖咪又起宣傳效用. 但津校靠運氣, 被名津校取錄既, 最多俾人恭喜兩句. 無得發揮話自己兒仔係千幾人裡面被揀中.
作者: nicolemummy 時間: 08-12-7 15:36
自由講場的這個topic 好好笑....
http://forum.baby-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=1903113&extra=page%3D9
原帖由 Jean 於 08-12-7 01:42 發表
以上咁多點也同時是不少直資校, 很多私小和津校校長所具備. 甚至很多屋村小學校長也不見得比林校長能力低, 但林校長可能手段較高明. 再講現在有邊間學校敢唔搞創意, 而越新既老師通常愛心越無限, 這道理你想一想會 ...
作者: gusi 時間: 08-12-10 21:32
I heard that the top 5 school in HK is
King College, St.Paul College, LS, DBS(included girls and boys school) and ...... (the last one had forgotten......) long time ago.
作者: laichuilai 時間: 08-12-10 21:49
Is it the last one - 聖保羅男女小學 ?
原帖由 gusi 於 08-12-10 21:32 發表
I heard that the top 5 school in HK is
King College, St.Paul College, LS, DBS(included girls and boys school) and ...... (the last one had forgotten......) long time ago.
作者: janfion 時間: 08-12-10 21:59
Hi nicolemummy,
我check漏了BK的mail box，所以遲了五至十日覆您e-mail, please check PM.
Fion
作者: Martina 時間: 08-12-10 23:10
The last one may be Queen's
原帖由 gusi 於 08-12-10 21:32 發表
I heard that the top 5 school in HK is
King College, St.Paul College, LS, DBS(included girls and boys school) and ...... (the last one had forgotten......) long time ago.
作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-11 10:26
honestly, st pauls college and kings should be out of the list.
作者: HoHoMom 時間: 08-12-11 11:27
So which ones do you think should be on the list leh ? Pls share with us the tiering of schools which you seem to be very very familiar with.
原帖由 wlmom 於 08-12-11 10:26 發表
honestly, st pauls college and kings should be out of the list.
作者: wlmom 時間: 08-12-11 11:56
i don't think there is any official list. in my opinion: st paul's co-ed, dbs, dgs, queen's, la salle.
btw, i am only talking about secondary schools.
i just commented in terms of the academic results known generally. don't ask me the statistics. anyone can disagree and anyone can use other reasons like studying in other schools can be happier wor, less pressure wor, don't want to change even have a place in la salle wor, etc etc.
原帖由 HoHoMom 於 08-12-11 11:27 發表
So which ones do you think should be on the list leh ? Pls share with us the tiering of schools which you seem to be very very familiar with.
[ 本帖最後由 wlmom 於 08-12-11 11:57 編輯 ]
作者: Smalljokerbb 時間: 08-12-12 16:49
其實大家有否考慮現在轉了中學334 & 要加入通識課程後, 對那些已往自命高學術成績的超級名校有什麼影響? 選小學時又有冇考慮這點呢?原帖由 gusi 於 08-12-10 21:32 發表
I heard that the top 5 school in HK is
King College, St.Paul College, LS, DBS(included girls and boys school) and ...... (the last one had forgotten......) long time ago.
作者: Era 時間: 08-12-12 16:59
有考慮,所以揀一啲淨靠c谷既學校,第日就會有問題啦.
原帖由 Smalljokerbb 於 08-12-12 16:49 發表
其實大家有否考慮現在轉了中學334 & 要加入通識課程後, 對那些已往自命高學術成績的超級名校有什麼影響? 選小學時又有冇考慮這點呢?
作者: smartcar 時間: 08-12-12 21:11
The argument is aimless and would last forever and appears periodically in BK in future.
Afterall, we would never have a chance to know as we could not compare at the present stage.
Your kids do not know either as they would not have an opportunity to study both schools and compare.
We comments upon our collections of memories in the old days on which schools are band 1. Time has changed.
Parents play important part over all else and school is just a platform to round up the study materials and follow the syllabus. I don't think smart kids could survive in top schools without efforts of their parents.
作者: davidmimi 時間: 08-12-12 21:50
原帖由 Smalljokerbb 於 08-12-12 16:49 發表
其實大家有否考慮現在轉了中學334 & 要加入通識課程後, 對那些已往自命高學術成績的超級名校有什麼影響? 選小學時又有冇考慮這點呢?
中學334後,所有學生f1讀到f6,中學無得換血,對名校當然有影響,但係對普通band 1中學影響更大,因為有d band 1中學,可以係f6收5成以上外來生,相反名校一般不足1成.
作者: Smalljokerbb 時間: 08-12-13 02:10
That's the point!! 其實嗰個所謂"新學制" + "通識教育"是某程度是學IB. 而香港現在亦有搞中六&七ib的學校. 有發現一些來自傳統谷成績學校的學生未能掌握活學活用的課程, 溝通能力及視野亦不足! 原帖由 Era 於 08-12-12 16:59 發表
有考慮,所以揀一啲淨靠c谷既學校,第日就會有問題啦.
作者: bobbbby 時間: 08-12-13 12:02
"已往自命高學術成績的超級名校"－我諗名校係唔需要"自命高學術成績"，全部係傳媒報導，只有補習社先要"自命高學術成績"去賣廣告招倈學生報名~~~
原帖由 Smalljokerbb 於 08-12-12 16:49 發表
其實大家有否考慮現在轉了中學334 & 要加入通識課程後, 對那些已往自命高學術成績的超級名校有什麼影響? 選小學時又有冇考慮這點呢?
| 歡迎光臨 教育王國 (/) |
Powered by Discuz! X1.5 |