教育王國

標題: SFA VS GH 你哋會揀邊間呀? [打印本頁]

作者: hellorachel 時間: 08-11-15 23:52 標題: SFA VS GH 你哋會揀邊間呀?

DEAR ALL:
想請教一下大家,你哋會揀邊間呀? 我囡囡而家接受緊傳统式教學,應該適合邊間多D呢!請大家多多指教!

作者: BBR 時間: 08-11-15 23:54

兩間都收左你個女女?定係佢已經讀緊小學?

原帖由 hellorachel 於 08-11-15 23:52 發表
DEAR ALL:
想請教一下大家,你哋會揀邊間呀? 我囡囡而家接受緊傳统式教學,應該適合邊間多D呢!請大家多多指教!

作者: hellorachel 時間: 08-11-15 23:56

兩間都收咗!唔知點好!

作者: JustinJustin 時間: 08-11-16 00:14

I prefer SFA, because their graduate's prospect are excellent.

原帖由 hellorachel 於 08-11-15 23:52 發表
DEAR ALL:
想請教一下大家,你哋會揀邊間呀? 我囡囡而家接受緊傳统式教學,應該適合邊間多D呢!請大家多多指教!

作者: 羊咩囝 時間: 08-11-16 00:24

我會揀德望
有中學駁腳唔駛再煩!
加上學校環境稍優

作者: wynma 時間: 08-11-16 00:28

Hi JustinJustin,

我都係會揀SFA架, 但係their graduate's prospect 有幾好呀? 可否share 吓? Thanks!

原帖由 JustinJustin 於 08-11-16 00:14 發表
I prefer SFA, because their graduate's prospect are excellent.

作者: BBR 時間: 08-11-16 00:38

其實最緊要係你小朋友鐘唔鐘意讀書,你有冇時間陪佢讀書,你個小朋友可唔可以乘受壓力,其實我知兩間課程都難,但SFA一定比GH更深,睇返兩間學校D post就知,我已經揀左GH,學校環境好D,如果你覺得個女可以應付到又想學深D野米揀SFA

原帖由 hellorachel 於 08-11-15 23:56 發表
兩間都收咗!唔知點好!

作者: JustinJustin 時間: 08-11-16 01:39

Professional. They entered different secondary school, but finally being Doctors, lawyers, engineer, teachers..........

原帖由 wynma 於 08-11-16 00:28 發表
Hi JustinJustin,

我都係會揀SFA架, 但係their graduate's prospect 有幾好呀? 可否share 吓? Thanks!

作者: Mamahui 時間: 08-11-16 02:04 標題: 回覆 # 的文章

我會揀 GH，有埋中學，吾駛再煩多次。

作者: hellorachel 時間: 08-11-16 02:06

我囡囡都鍾意讀書,但我聽朋友話GH好多功課,請問有無人知佢哋有乜分別呀?請指教下!

作者: junior_pam 時間: 08-11-16 08:53

Both schools have the same stuff of homeworks.
If you can take accept this kind of educational game(interview, interview and interview many times), OK just take because you have repeat one more time in secondary level. It is also one more time pressure on your kid again.
Is it deserved to do it again?
please consider seriously because to a certain extent both schools are similar and they have respective strength and weakness.
thanks

原帖由 hellorachel 於 08-11-16 02:06 發表
我囡囡都鍾意讀書,但我聽朋友話GH好多功課,請問有無人知佢哋有乜分別呀?請指教下!

作者: BBR 時間: 08-11-16 09:10

係,起碼GH有中學,唔駛6年後又要驚一次,雖然我都可能會比個女考其他中學,但起碼有間打低無咁驚. 至於話SFA有好多都做左Doctors, lawyers, engineer, teachers我個人諗為只要小朋友肯讀書,學習環境好就邊間的小朋友都可以做Doctors, lawyers, engineer, teachers. 我有幾個friends响雜嘜中小學讀書,一個宜家係醫生,一個係律師,一個係accountant,我老公都係雜嘜中小學讀佢都係engineer. 所以我覺得最緊要搵間適合的學校比小朋友,令小朋友喜歡讀書,如果家長同小朋友都可以乘受壓力米揀間課程深D,我响小學一覽個到睇左這兩間學校的post,其實兩間都難,但SFA的家長就乳佢地真係讀到

D小朋友都係剛好合格,而且好多野做,如果要返工的媽咪真係未必應付到,我就預左一至五D時間比哂個女,希望六日有時間同佢出街玩.
hellorachel你可以去小學一覽到睇下這兩間學校P.1家長的內容就最好,因為佢地D小朋友真係讀緊P1,情形最真實

原帖由 Mamahui 於 08-11-16 02:04 發表
我會揀 GH，有埋中學，吾駛再煩多次。

作者: hellorachel 時間: 08-11-16 21:21

多謝你哋寶貴嘅意見!

作者: charwes 時間: 08-11-16 21:47

I went through the same dilemma last year and opted for GHS because it has a pretty good secondary school and we could avoid another torture after she completed her primary education, although we eventually went for the allocated school because it's our first choice.

原帖由 hellorachel 於 08-11-15 23:52 發表
DEAR ALL:
想請教一下大家,你哋會揀邊間呀? 我囡囡而家接受緊傳统式教學,應該適合邊間多D呢!請大家多多指教!

作者: QQMa42 時間: 08-11-16 23:46

本人舊年也為此問題考慮了一段時間,最終為囡囡選了SFA.放棄GH只是不希望將來囡囡會讀12年的女校.開學到現在已近三個了,SFA的確對學生有要求,但不是外間所說的那麽恐怖.每天的功課有部份也可在學內完成.另外,我們希望為囡囡打好基礎,將來上中學會讀得輕鬆一D,所以選了SFA.

作者: BBR 時間: 08-11-17 00:57

我都唔想個女讀12年女校,所以就算我揀GH將來中學都會同佢考其他中學,不過宜家有間中學可以比佢直升咁將來無咁大壓力

原帖由 QQMa42 於 08-11-16 23:46 發表
本人舊年也為此問題考慮了一段時間,最終為囡囡選了SFA.放棄GH只是不希望將來囡囡會讀12年的女校.開學到現在已近三個了,SFA的確對學生有要求,但不是外間所說的那麽恐怖.每天的功課有部份也可在學內完成.另外,我們希望 ...

作者: hellorachel 時間: 08-11-17 01:30

HELLO QQMa42:
咁請問你囡囡番學嗰陣,係咪正如佢封信話上堂只准用英文及普通話溝通呢?

作者: hellorachel 時間: 08-11-17 01:33

但係GH中學雖唔雖要追平均分升原校?

作者: BBR 時間: 08-11-17 01:42

咁我相信如果你成績好差的話當然未必可以升上佢的中學，你成績差的話想搵返有名的中學入都唔得啦

原帖由 hellorachel 於 08-11-17 01:33 發表
但係GH中學雖唔雖要追平均分升原校?

作者: wendyyy 時間: 08-11-17 06:18

Hi QQMa42,

妳囡囡讀邊班呀 ? 看看是否跟我囡同一班, 佢 o地讀 1a & 1b.

原帖由 QQMa42 於 08-11-16 23:46 發表
本人舊年也為此問題考慮了一段時間,最終為囡囡選了SFA.放棄GH只是不希望將來囡囡會讀12年的女校.開學到現在已近三個了,SFA的確對學生有要求,但不是外間所說的那麽恐怖.每天的功課有部份也可在學內完成.另外,我們希望 ...

作者: minghei_mama 時間: 08-11-17 09:50

can SFA result be checked via school website ??

作者: AgnesHimMa 時間: 08-11-17 13:27

wendyyy and QQMa42

我個囝有sfa, 禮賢同九龍灣 st jo 收咗,
其實我想比佢讀sfa, 但又驚好辛苦, 仲有驚學費+雜費會唔平,
仲煩緊應唔應該比佢讀得開心啲而選擇禮賢或st jo.
請兩位家長share 多啲資料, thanks>

minghei_mama 如果你仲未收到信, 可以打電話去學校問吓!佢哋唔可以係web 度check 口家!

萬分感激.

作者: minghei_mama 時間: 08-11-17 18:42

thx,我個女都唔識雙位加數.... 我估sfa 都系陪跑... 我已有禮賢及聖母... 好大機會讀禮賢...講真...若sfa真的收我個女... 真系要諗下佢同我頂唔頂得住...我唔想佢系有童年陰影... 另 GH waiting, 都應該無機......

原帖由 AgnesHimMa 於 08-11-17 13:27 發表
wendyyy and QQMa42

我個囝有sfa, 禮賢同九龍灣 st jo 收咗,
其實我想比佢讀sfa, 但又驚好辛苦, 仲有驚學費+雜費會唔平,
仲煩緊應唔應該比佢讀得開心啲而選擇禮賢或st jo.
請兩位家長share 多啲資料, thanks>

m ...

作者: junior_pam 時間: 08-11-17 20:25

You have to trust your kids because they are alike a sponge which absorbs every pieces of daily life and school life.

原帖由 AgnesHimMa 於 08-11-17 13:27 發表
wendyyy and QQMa42

我個囝有sfa, 禮賢同九龍灣 st jo 收咗,
其實我想比佢讀sfa, 但又驚好辛苦, 仲有驚學費+雜費會唔平,
仲煩緊應唔應該比佢讀得開心啲而選擇禮賢或st jo.
請兩位家長share 多啲資料, thanks>

m ...

作者: AgnesHimMa 時間: 08-11-18 10:47

Hello, junior_pam

你係咪都有小朋友讀緊sfa, 如果係請share 吓啲資料呀 please.

原帖由 junior_pam 於 08-11-17 20:25 發表
You have to trust your kids because they are alike a sponge which absorbs every pieces of daily life and school life.

作者: junior_pam 時間: 08-11-18 20:37

Kids are very interesting creatures. They store everything the parents and environment offered.
Of course, parents should give full support.
SFA is really a tough primary school. You have to grasp the ability, personality and capability of your kid.

原帖由 AgnesHimMa 於 08-11-18 10:47 發表
Hello, junior_pam

你係咪都有小朋友讀緊sfa, 如果係請share 吓啲資料呀 please.

作者: ymama 時間: 08-11-18 21:49

AgnesHimMa;

SFA沒有雜費的, 只是正常的學費+校車費+LUNCH BOX.
其他星期六的ECA參加才收費, 我沒有參加. 只入了學校的合唱團, 一年才$500(包團服+FILE, 去年因比賽成績理想, 還有一餐自助餐吃)

YMAMA

原帖由 AgnesHimMa 於 08-11-17 13:27 發表
wendyyy and QQMa42

我個囝有sfa, 禮賢同九龍灣 st jo 收咗,
其實我想比佢讀sfa, 但又驚好辛苦, 仲有驚學費+雜費會唔平,
仲煩緊應唔應該比佢讀得開心啲而選擇禮賢或st jo.
請兩位家長share 多啲資料, thanks>

m ...

作者: AgnesHimMa 時間: 08-11-19 10:39

Thanks, ymama

我yesterday, 打電話去學校問過, 個staff 話放學後啲活動係無校車arrange, 唉! 即刻唔開心.
你哋係咪都係因為咁, 所以無報activities?

作者: Miuccia224 時間: 08-11-20 12:13

Hi all,

May I know what is the FULL name of SFA in both English & Chinese.

I would like to take a look from their web site.

Thanks.

作者: BBR 時間: 08-11-20 12:16

聖方濟各英文小學
St. Francis Of Assisi's English Primary School

http://www.sfaeps.edu.hk/

原帖由 Miuccia224 於 08-11-20 12:13 發表
Hi all,

May I know what is the FULL name of SFA in both English & Chinese.

I would like to take a look from their web site.

Thanks.

[ 本帖最後由 BBR 於 08-11-20 12:17 編輯 ]

作者: kittyswng 時間: 08-11-20 14:56

Hi all,
I have the same ?? now, as both admitted my daughter too, and wondering which one shall I opt for my daughter, really don't know. Both schools are good and have their own merits. We live in Sai Kung and so GH is more near to our home. But as some of the BK moms saids here, don't want to let our daughter to study in girls' school for 12 years. If possible, SFA grad can be allocated to good govt or sub secondary school, then could save the school fee for the secondary school.

作者: BBR 時間: 08-11-20 15:06

我揀左GH,起碼有間中學打低6年後唔駛咁驚,我都會同個女再搵中學,但到時搵唔到都唔駛咁驚先,SFA睇完佢地D post我驚個女品德唔好或比人蝦,所以小學揀住女校先

作者: Mememe0319 時間: 08-11-20 15:12

do you think you have over generalized the scenario a bit?

原帖由 JustinJustin 於 08-11-16 01:39 發表
Professional. They entered different secondary school, but finally being Doctors, lawyers, engineer, teachers..........

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)