教育王國

標題: 高主教 vs SMC (St Margaret's Co-edu) [打印本頁]

作者: zenzenmama 時間: 08-11-12 15:05 標題: 高主教 vs SMC (St Margaret's Co-edu)

Dear all parents,

Can you advise as captioned?
As I want to release one of the place for others, thank you very much for your advice.

作者: DaddyShum 時間: 08-11-12 16:01

our situation is same to yours -- both SMC and Raimondi offered a seat for my son.

Personally I like SMC more because she provides a very good language learning environment, not only English and Mandarin, but also some exposure to other languages (Japanese, French and Spanish) since P1. But on the other hand, we are skeptical about her over-emphasis on language but lagging other subjects, so on this perspective we tend to prefer traditional schools like RC.

作者: zenzenmama 時間: 08-11-12 16:06

Dear DaddyShum,

Thank you very much for your response. For your reference, I just gave up SMC as I have the concern over the secondary school. I like SMC as well, however, I still prefer to the one with track record.

Glad to share with you as we have same situation.

作者: mamay 時間: 08-11-12 16:57

How is the English level of RC? Will they use English as teaching media to other subjects (other than teaching English)?

作者: zenzenmama 時間: 08-11-12 17:00

They use English to teach English and General studies, PTH to teach Chinese and PTH subjects.

作者: zenzenmama 時間: 08-11-12 17:01

Also English +Cantonese for Maths

原帖由 zenzenmama 於 08-11-12 17:00 發表
They use English to teach English and General studies, PTH to teach Chinese and PTH subjects.

作者: belle 時間: 08-11-12 17:09

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: zenzenmama 時間: 08-11-12 17:12

Thank you Belle,

Agreed. That's the main reason of choosing RC between RC and SMC. SMC Primary is definitely a good school with "heart" but i still want to have a better back up full-train secondary school at the time of selecting primary for kids.

作者: belle 時間: 08-11-12 17:14

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: mgwong 時間: 08-11-12 19:34

My situation is same.
Accepted by Ramondi & SMC.
To be honest, I like SMC very much.
Only concerning about the location because I live in HK side.

作者: G-Ma 時間: 08-11-12 19:37

smc現時的中學生都不是從小學升上去, 是外來收生, 因為小學今年才有六年班的學生, 明年開始會有自己學生升上中學, 我相信到時成績會有好大改善.

當然smc中學仍然未有實際數據去參考, 所以大家都會覺得冒險一點. 不過如果小朋友成績係好, 到中學時真係覺得學校唔夠好, 要轉去其他中學我相信都唔困難, 因為smc小學係英文既訓練好好, 特別係學生大多係好敢發言, 所以係英文interview中會較有利.

但我地smc家長大部份都會選擇留係smc中學, 因為語言環境好好, 英文, 普通話都有一定水平, native teacher 比較多, 還可以多學一種外語, 而且大家都相處左6年, 對學校都好有歸屬感, 所以留低機會好大.

作者: 曦曦媽媽 時間: 08-11-14 11:17

請問smc 在哪裡?
因為我住在港島.

作者: zenzenmama 時間: 08-11-14 11:22

SMC is somewhere near Nam Cheong, next to Ying Wah. Just fyi, no school bus from HK side to SMC. Maybe need to find other sources of transportation.

http://www.smcesps.edu.hk/

作者: mgwong 時間: 08-11-14 13:16

Hi,
I live in hong kong side also, maybe we can join.
where do u live, please PM me, thanks.

原帖由 曦曦媽媽 於 08-11-14 11:17 發表
請問smc 在哪裡?
因為我住在港島.

作者: CHIULHJ 時間: 08-11-14 14:08

My kid is lucky enough to get an offer from SMC and is waiting for the 2nd interview result of St Paul's Boys Primary School. Even if he is admitted by St Paul's Boys, I will choose SMC for him.

I live in HK side. I am going to bring him school by myself (then go to office) and pick him up by my housemaid.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)