教育王國

標題: 得20分，博唔博MCS/St. Mary好？ [打印本頁]

作者: Piaget 時間: 08-11-6 03:03 標題: 得20分，博唔博MCS/St. Mary好？

小女有20分，其實第一round抽到MCS or St. Mary的機會係咪好微呢？有無邊間校風淳樸嘅天主教學校係20分有把握入啲嘅呢？請俾意見！Thank you!

作者: mow-mow 時間: 08-11-6 10:41

天神嘉諾撒學校 - their students can go directly to St Mary Secondary School. Mind you, since they have annouced this arrangement, competition has increased so 20 points still isn't safe.
The other one worth considering is St Paul Catholic Primary School in Happy Valley. 20 points should have a very decent chance in the 1st round.

原帖由 Piaget 於 08-11-6 03:03 發表
小女有20分，其實第一round抽到MCS or St. Mary的機會係咪好微呢？有無邊間校風淳樸嘅天主教學校係20分有把握入啲嘅呢？請俾意見！Thank you!

作者: easybring 時間: 08-11-6 11:18 標題: 回覆 # 的文章

抽獎既野...有20分一定要試.

作者: 陳師奶 時間: 08-11-6 11:48

搏下啦, 舊年我樓上個女仔, 第一輪20分都中左MCS, good luck, 亞仔就好唔好彩, 抽唔到LS.

原帖由 easybring 於 08-11-6 11:18 發表
抽獎既野...有20分一定要試.

作者: angelsmama 時間: 08-11-6 12:39

請問mcs係邊間?

作者: 陳師奶 時間: 08-11-6 13:58

瑪利諾

原帖由 angelsmama 於 08-11-6 12:39 發表
請問mcs係邊間?

作者: kls12 時間: 08-11-6 14:11

原帖由 easybring 於 08-11-6 11:18 發表
抽獎既野...有20分一定要試.

搏 , 一定搏.

If failed, try to study GHS, SFA or APS and knock the Door in P2.
It is less chance in P1 for knocking the door if no relationship or no excellent performance

[ 本帖最後由 kls12 於 08-11-6 14:19 編輯 ]

作者: Coletteli 時間: 08-11-6 14:17

Already expired for the 1st round of this year, do you mean next year (2010-2011)
?

原帖由 Piaget 於 08-11-6 03:03 發表
小女有20分，其實第一round抽到MCS or St. Mary的機會係咪好微呢？有無邊間校風淳樸嘅天主教學校係20分有把握入啲嘅呢？請俾意見！Thank you!

作者: bird-bird 時間: 08-11-6 15:49

原帖由 kls12 於 08-11-6 14:11 發表

搏 , 一定搏.

If failed, try to study GHS, SFA or APS and knock the Door in P2.
It is less chance in P1 for knocking the door if no relationship or no excellent performance

小妹都係20分, 一樣入表St. Mary, 而家只等天主安排啦.....

kls12 照你意思, 係咪讀 GHS, SFA or APS, 係P2敲門入St. Mary 會比較有把握呢? 咁請問APS 是指邊間呢?

其實Good Hope 同 SFA, 兩間您會點選呀?

Sorry, too many questions at a time....hope you don't mind.

作者: Piaget 時間: 08-11-6 19:15

mow-mow,

Is St. Paul Catholic Primary School more easy to enter with 20 points? It's also a very good school. Even though my girl has 20 points, I still feel very insecured to choose MCS and St. Mary.

原帖由 mow-mow 於 08-11-6 10:41 發表
天神嘉諾撒學校 - their students can go directly to St Mary Secondary School. Mind you, since they have annouced this arrangement, competition has increased so 20 points still isn't safe.
The other one ...

作者: Piaget 時間: 08-11-6 19:19

Coletteli,

Yes, it's my girl's turn next year - She is in K2 now. I just wanna gather more information and comments from parents who have had or are having such experience.

原帖由 Coletteli 於 08-11-6 14:17 發表
Already expired for the 1st round of this year, do you mean next year (2010-2011)
?

作者: YAPPLE 時間: 08-11-6 20:08

搏 , 一定搏.
20分唔係實得,但唔係絕對冇機會,
上年08/09都有朋友20分,分別中MCS / St.Mary.
值得一試,最多咪讀返私校...

作者: momosimo 時間: 08-11-6 20:28

Hi, I hope someone can help me.

Under this first round pointing system, does the school only consider the number of points and the application form? Will there be an in person interview as well?

Thanks,

作者: YAPPLE 時間: 08-11-6 20:34

momosimo,

Only consider the number of points .

原帖由 momosimo 於 08-11-6 20:28 發表
Hi, I hope someone can help me.

Under this first round pointing system, does the school only consider the number of points and the application form? Will there be an in person interview as well?

Th ...

作者: momosimo 時間: 08-11-6 20:40

原帖由 YAPPLE 於 08-11-6 20:34 發表
momosimo,

Only consider the number of points .

Yapple,
Thanks for your reply.

I am a Catholic from Canada. Will I get the 5 points for religion? My friend told me that you have to attend the church affliated with the school to get the 5 religion points. Does anyone know which church in HK is afflicated with Maryknoll or St Mary?

Thanks,

作者: nicolemummy 時間: 08-11-6 22:07

20分是有機會.

即使15分無機會, 我和同學都沒有放棄, 都爭取機會, 相繼搬了到41區. 然後第一輪當然唔中, 只有同區大抽獎的這一次,僅此一次的機會而已.

結果, 全班5個41區15分的女仔裡有3個第二輪抽中了. 我們感謝天主. (因為我們是天主教幼稚園的)

原帖由 momosimo 於 08-11-6 20:40 發表

Yapple,
Thanks for your reply.

I am a Catholic from Canada. Will I get the 5 points for religion? My friend told me that you have to attend the church affliated with the school to get the 5 rel ...

作者: Cathleen 時間: 08-11-7 00:31

why so late to open this topic? is not all of 1st round had been done?

作者: kls12 時間: 08-11-7 08:55

原帖由 bird-bird 於 08-11-6 15:49 發表

小妹都係20分, 一樣入表St. Mary, 而家只等天主安排啦.....

kls12 照你意思, 係咪讀 GHS, SFA or APS, 係P2敲門入St. Mary 會比較有把握呢? 咁請問APS 是指邊間呢?

其實Good Hope 同 SFA, 兩間您會點選呀?

Sorr ...

APS 是九龍塘宣道小學

去年 MCS 可說是九龍區女名校中最多P2挿班位的,考40個收10個. GHS , SFA & APS 已佔了十多人考了,其他學校的學生要拿入場卷要花些心思吧, 但在小班下不知今年如何.

St. Mary P2沒有正式的考試,有位會收,多是這些私校.

以小女讀的幼稚園一班為例,10個在大抽獎選MCS為第一志願,大部份現在讀GHS了

作者: mow-mow 時間: 08-11-7 09:15

Piaget,
If you rather play safe, St Paul Catholic Primary is a good choice.
I can't guarantee a sure win, but the chance will be much higher than MCS & St Mary's (most parents in Hong Kong side will go for Marymount).
Rumor has it that occasionally even 15 points managed to get in at the 1st round - not sure if it is true though.

原帖由 Piaget 於 08-11-6 19:15 發表
mow-mow,

Is St. Paul Catholic Primary School more easy to enter with 20 points? It's also a very good school. Even though my girl has 20 points, I still feel very insecured to choose MCS and St. Mary ...

作者: baba_mama 時間: 08-11-8 22:48

but which one is better?
MCS or St Mary?

原帖由 mow-mow 於 08-11-7 09:15 發表
Piaget,
If you rather play safe, St Paul Catholic Primary is a good choice.
I can't guarantee a sure win, but the chance will be much higher than MCS & St Mary's (most parents in Hong Kong side will g ...

作者: Coletteli 時間: 08-11-9 10:58

MCS is the most hightest level school in Hong Kong. My friend had give up St. Mary offer after MCS accept her daughter.

原帖由 baba_mama 於 08-11-8 22:48 發表
but which one is better?
MCS or St Mary?

作者: mmak 時間: 08-11-9 23:09

MCS 嘅位比 st maty 多D... 按比率, 應該 MCS 機會大D...

作者: vic6 時間: 08-11-10 08:29

the school will only accept the profolio, they do not hv the interview at all....it's only based on your marks in 1st round...but don't give up, once you hv submitted the profolio, you will hv chance for knock in after 2nd round result.

原帖由 momosimo 於 08-11-6 20:28 發表
Hi, I hope someone can help me.

Under this first round pointing system, does the school only consider the number of points and the application form? Will there be an in person interview as well?

Th ...

作者: baba_mama 時間: 08-11-10 13:33

Both MCS and St Mary are government schools, how can your friend got both offer at the same time?

原帖由 Coletteli 於 08-11-9 10:58 發表
MCS is the most hightest level school in Hong Kong. My friend had give up St. Mary offer after MCS accept her daughter.

作者: Coletteli 時間: 08-11-10 14:58

She "knock door" at MCS.

原帖由 baba_mama 於 08-11-10 13:33 發表
Both MCS and St Mary are government schools, how can your friend got both offer at the same time?

作者: kls12 時間: 08-11-10 15:04

原帖由 Coletteli 於 08-11-10 14:58 發表
She "knock door" at MCS.

It was a very strange case. If your friend likes MCS, why did she apply MCS directly instead of St. Mary?

作者: Coletteli 時間: 08-11-10 15:12

She's not in 41 net, so she can't choose MCS in 2 round. So she try to knock the door(MCS) .

原帖由 kls12 於 08-11-10 15:04 發表

It was a very strange case. If your friend likes MCS, why did she apply MCS directly instead of St. Mary?

作者: kimimi 時間: 08-11-11 13:01

your friend really very lucky and smart !! Both MCS and St. Mary accepted her !!

原帖由 Coletteli 於 08-11-10 15:12 發表
She's not in 41 net, so she can't choose MCS in 2 round. So she try to knock the door(MCS) .

作者: kimimi 時間: 08-11-11 13:04

In the first round, if we are same point, then will have lucky draw, may I know who arrange it, school or EDB ?

原帖由 YAPPLE 於 08-11-6 20:34 發表
momosimo,

Only consider the number of points .

作者: pearjadema 時間: 08-11-11 13:54

原帖由 kimimi 於 08-11-11 13:04 發表
In the first round, if we are same point, then will have lucky draw, may I know who arrange it, school or EDB ?

if same point, the lucky draw will arrange from EDB

作者: baba_mama 時間: 08-11-12 00:34

when did she knock MCS then?
I mean in which month?

and when st mary gave her a seat in the first round, how can she still knock MCS as MCS is also a government school..

Can we occupy two seats at the same time?

原帖由 Coletteli 於 08-11-10 14:58 發表
She "knock door" at MCS.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)