教育王國

標題: SMC and CKY, how to choose? [打印本頁]

作者: estherking 時間: 08-10-30 17:55 標題: SMC and CKY, how to choose?

They are both using English as the medium of instructions, and CKY is quite expensive (may be because of IB), what do you think?

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-10-30 19:13

其實SMC都不錯，因為NET很多，好像有十多名，參與本地試。又有第三種語文挑選。

CKY就講明一半是NET，另外普通話人亦非常多，學校又有語文政策要求孩子說英語或普通話，語境算是不俗。講明考IGCSE及IBD。

各取所需啦！

作者: ryanyui 時間: 08-10-30 23:25

u think too early la!? u should consider the topic after u know the result ma?!?

作者: WD40 時間: 08-10-31 02:33

SMC 好似已經唔接收申請la，因為有好多小朋友都重未interview，同埋SMC除咗考本地試外都會考IGCSE。

[ 本帖最後由 WD40 於 08-10-31 03:52 編輯 ]

作者: estherking 時間: 08-10-31 09:00

Thanks WD40!

Maybe I think too much, I just want to chat around and collect info from the existing parents from both schools and other parents. Thanks for your advice!

原帖由 ryanyui 於 08-10-30 23:25 發表
u think too early la!? u should consider the topic after u know the result ma?!?

作者: lenmama 時間: 08-10-31 10:51

For me, I like SMC more, reasons are as follows:
1. school fee is cheaper apparently.
2. not clear the direction of IB to HK University upto now.

So...it really depends on what kind of school & what are your criteria requested.

作者: francisyyw 時間: 08-10-31 11:01

both schools are good. As for me, it deponds upon the location of the school.

原帖由 estherking 於 08-10-30 17:55 發表
They are both using English as the medium of instructions, and CKY is quite expensive (may be because of IB), what do you think?

作者: daisy17772 時間: 08-10-31 11:05

All mummies:

I often see SMC, can someone please tell me which school it stands for? My child is applying for P1 next year.

thanks
daisy17772

作者: ronnielee 時間: 08-10-31 11:39

St. Margaret's Co-educational English Secondary & Primary School

原帖由 daisy17772 於 08-10-31 11:05 發表
All mummies:

I often see SMC, can someone please tell me which school it stands for? My child is applying for P1 next year.

thanks
daisy17772

作者: daisy17772 時間: 08-10-31 11:42

thanks

daisy17772

原帖由 ronnielee 於 08-10-31 11:39 發表
St. Margaret's Co-educational English Secondary & Primary School

作者: kaifu 時間: 08-10-31 13:07

Yes, CKY is way too expensive for what they offer. Also, the places for IB students in the local universities are very limited, compared to regular students taking the public exams.

原帖由 estherking 於 08-10-30 17:55 發表
They are both using English as the medium of instructions, and CKY is quite expensive (may be because of IB), what do you think?

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-10-31 15:21

CKY的學費係幾貴架，因為一半老師都是NET，ABC, BBC乜都有, 然後有很多普通話老師。又有兩個足球場, 音樂廳, 室內泳池, 籃球場...。無咁上下學費，點可以有咁的設施及師資。比某些學校，算是平了。

原帖由 kaifu 於 08-10-31 13:07 發表
Yes, CKY is way too expensive for what they offer. Also, the places for IB students in the local universities are very limited, compared to regular students taking the public exams.

作者: Reximom 時間: 08-10-31 15:26

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: estherking 時間: 08-10-31 17:05

Can I say CKY is more or less like an international school but has higher Chinese standard? Their students can choose to take the local public exams or the international ones when they are in Grade 12 in order to enter the universities? Sometimes I just too focus on the primary section and miss the info about secondary section.

作者: papa_pop 時間: 08-10-31 18:50

Estherking, I dare not say CKY is like an IS coz it's not and it's never positioned itself as such. What I can say is that its resources (as regards teaching staff) are way better than most 'local' English primary schools.

It's true that it places much emphasis on languages; and that their language policy does gives a very good environment (esp for Y1-2 students) for kids to practise their English and PTH.

You may wish to compare it to those summer English immersion camps - the difference is that it's an immersion camp every day in school.

作者: bowie_p 時間: 08-10-31 23:18

What is CKY stand for??

作者: vow 時間: 08-11-1 16:12

原帖由 bowie_p 於 08-10-31 23:18 發表
What is CKY stand for??

PLK CHOI KAI YAU SCHOOL 保良局蔡繼有學校

作者: avislai 時間: 08-11-1 16:56

Can anyone tell me how much is the school fee?

原帖由 kyliema2006 於 08-10-31 15:21 發表
CKY的學費係幾貴架，因為一半老師都是NET，ABC, BBC乜都有, 然後有很多普通話老師。又有兩個足球場, 音樂廳, 室內泳池, 籃球場...。無咁上下學費，點可以有咁的設施及師資。比某些學校，算是平了。

...

作者: loy211 時間: 08-11-1 20:36

學費確是幾貴.

作者: elizatyy 時間: 08-11-2 16:45

If the school fee is not a concern, I will choose CKY.

作者: ronnielee 時間: 08-11-3 01:20

$5,xxx.

原帖由 avislai 於 08-11-1 16:56 發表
Can anyone tell me how much is the school fee?

作者: HeiHeiMa 時間: 08-11-3 07:59

應該係$4,600 ($50,600/11期)

原帖由 ronnielee 於 08-11-3 01:20 發表
$5,xxx.

作者: estherking 時間: 08-11-3 10:04

Why? Because of the facilities? What are its good points?

原帖由 elizatyy 於 08-11-2 16:45 發表
If the school fee is not a concern, I will choose CKY.

作者: WD40 時間: 08-11-4 13:25

CKY 學費高昂，因為此校屬於 "私校" 性質，沒有政府資助！而SMC屬於 "直資"，有政府資助。因此 HK$2 xxx就有好好資源。

聽講 CKY 前期有幾位好好老師俾其他學校 "括走"，現任老師英文發音不純正…云云。在在都因其無政府資助，資源及資金，正正就其根源問題所在。但若加之於家長身上，學費可能比現況更加據家長負擔！撥除資源問題，CKY都係一所好學校。

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-11-4 14:36

保良局每年都有撥款資助蔡繼有，聽校長說，家長支付的學費主要是支付薪金，其它關於學校的雜費，就是由保良局支付。若言没有了保良局的支持，相信學費會更貴。

學校的NET乜國籍都有，美音、英音甚至印度音都有，學生是要適應。興幸未曾遇過港式英語的英語老師，俾咁貴學費，俾港式英語的老師我，我都不能接受。

原帖由 WD40 於 08-11-4 13:25 發表
CKY 學費高昂，因為此校屬於 "私校" 性質，沒有政府資助！而SMC屬於 "直資"，有政府資助。因此 HK$2 xxx就有好好資源。

聽講 CKY 前期有幾位好好老師俾其他學校 "括走"，現任老師英文發音不純正…云云。在在都因其無政府資 ...

作者: estherking 時間: 08-11-5 09:46

IC, if there are so many net teachers at the school, then the school fee would be higher as they have higher salary than the local teachers, right?
In that case, since SMC---DSS and CKY---Private school ,then SMC is more preferable?

原帖由 WD40 於 08-11-4 13:25 發表
CKY 學費高昂，因為此校屬於 "私校" 性質，沒有政府資助！而SMC屬於 "直資"，有政府資助。因此 HK$2 xxx就有好好資源。

聽講 CKY 前期有幾位好好老師俾其他學校 "括走"，現任老師英文發音不純正…云云。在在都因其無政府資 ...

作者: bblaw 時間: 08-11-5 10:37

SMC is local cirrculum. CKY is IB. They are difference cirrciculum. IB is more expersive. Of course the private school fee variable is greater than DSS. DSS is under Gov't supervision .

At that moment, if u choose local cirriculum, U have 90 % chance enter HK University. If u choose IB or international school , U have 10% go to HK University. So that why someone tell u under IB cirriculum, U will study in other countries University. Bcos, u chance going to HK U is low. Of course, it may be something chance in the future. But, now, the ratio is like that. If u choose IB, u must spend some budget for UNiversity in other countries.

[ 本帖最後由 bblaw 於 08-11-5 10:45 編輯 ]

作者: catcatmom 時間: 08-11-5 10:49

我上次係書局睇荷花最新果本小學資料書, 我留意深水涉區, 我記得登出來資料係英華係2個net, 聖瑪加利十幾個, 而cky 係2x 幾個, 如果資料有錯, 請更正. 佢應該係最多net既主流小學, cky讀到p5之後, 轉交中學既學費, 所以學費係考慮因素, 但佢新學舍應該係好靚, 投資了很設備, 收甘多學費, 都係應該!

原帖由 kyliema2006 於 08-10-31 15:21 發表
CKY的學費係幾貴架，因為一半老師都是NET，ABC, BBC乜都有, 然後有很多普通話老師。又有兩個足球場, 音樂廳, 室內泳池, 籃球場...。無咁上下學費，點可以有咁的設施及師資。比某些學校，算是平了。

...

作者: bblaw 時間: 08-11-5 10:54

As i know, SMC is the more NET in DSS. Of course CKY is the more net in private school

作者: HeiHeiMa 時間: 08-11-5 11:29

我又覺得個chance未必係10%咁計!
揀得IS/CKY呢類行IB o既學校, 我諗好大部份都會出國讀書! 所以留低選擇local U可能人數相對冇咁多!
雖然local U大部份學位係預留比local schools學生, 但相對o黎講, local schools咁多畢業生, 競爭真係好激烈! 個chance真係唔容易!
況且由IB途徑入local U係冇特定限額, 咁多年後o既事冇人預計得到! 但連SPCC, DBS呢d名校都開辦IB, 我覺得local U有可能會擴大入學額!
以上純粹個人愚見!

原帖由 bblaw 於 08-11-5 10:37 發表
SMC is local cirrculum. CKY is IB. They are difference cirrciculum. IB is more expersive. Of course the private school fee variable is greater than DSS. DSS is under Gov't supervision .

At that mome ...

作者: estherking 時間: 08-11-5 14:01

Thanks for your info

原帖由 bblaw 於 08-11-5 10:37 發表
SMC is local cirrculum. CKY is IB. They are difference cirrciculum. IB is more expersive. Of course the private school fee variable is greater than DSS. DSS is under Gov't supervision .

At that mome ...

作者: kyliema2006 時間: 08-11-6 10:30

NET的數目佔一半人，因為每班都會有一名，現在有30－40班，那應該約有30－40名NET。

這是一分錢一分貨的道理，若單從學費考慮，SMC是較平，亦比其它傳統學校較多NET，所以一般人都可以負擔得來。

原帖由 estherking 於 08-11-5 09:46 發表
IC, if there are so many net teachers at the school, then the school fee would be higher as they have higher salary than the local teachers, right?
In that case, since SMC---DSS and CKY---Private scho ...

[ 本帖最後由 kyliema2006 於 08-11-6 12:36 編輯 ]

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)