教育王國

標題: 有無人收到王x輝的第三輪面試通知 [打印本頁]

作者: Joeyjoeycheng 時間: 08-9-30 17:27 標題: 有無人收到王x輝的第三輪面試通知

有無人收到王x輝的第三輪面試通知? just received call today my son need 3rd in on next monday

Anyone received the same??

作者: chrwan 時間: 08-9-30 17:39

U have 2nd Interview last Sat & have to interview the 3rd time? So many times?

作者: howto 時間: 08-9-30 17:39

下..........仲要第三輪, 我無收到wor.......
咁佢地有無講點解?

原帖由 Joeyjoeycheng 於 08-9-30 17:27 發表
有無人收到王x輝的第三輪面試通知? just received call today my son need 3rd in on next monday

Anyone received the same??

作者: Joeyjoeycheng 時間: 08-9-30 18:20

Yes, i just interview on last Sat but i don't know why need 3rd interview again

They told me that is group interview for child...

Really no idea

原帖由 howto 於 08-9-30 17:39 發表
下..........仲要第三輪, 我無收到wor.......
咁佢地有無講點解?

作者: birdbird 時間: 08-9-30 20:13

原帖由 Joeyjoeycheng 於 08-9-30 18:20 發表
Yes, i just interview on last Sat but i don't know why need 3rd interview again

They told me that is group interview for child...

Really no idea

嘩, 大人+ 小朋友要in 3 rounds....
可以話係一個 '折騰'.
其實學校有冇諗過, 佢揀學生之餘,
班未來家長都要去搵其他學校,
小朋友都要應付其他學校的 interview,
而家只係揀小一生 (得果5歲人仔) & 家長咋,
唔係揀太空人上神7升空,
唔好咁 'side' 人地時間啦!

作者: Santa_Maria 時間: 08-9-30 20:40

Fully agree birdbird.....

看到這裡,我開始懷疑她們的"教學理念".
往年攪什麼天才表演,我已經覺得過太,
如今取消了,卻弄出第三輪面試.向小朋友
同家長施壓,為乜呢

[ 本帖最後由 Santa_Maria 於 08-9-30 20:47 編輯 ]

作者: luckymother 時間: 08-9-30 21:47

原帖由 Santa_Maria 於 08-9-30 20:40 發表
Fully agree birdbird.....

看到這裡,我開始懷疑她們的"教學理念".
往年攪什麼天才表演,我已經覺得過太,
如今取消了,卻弄出第三輪面試.向小朋友
同家長施壓,為乜呢 ...

這麼高姿態,無非想給人一個印象,好像跟男拔等名校一樣.但實際是否一樣,就真的見仁見智.去年的天才表演,考中文生字和見家長,已經是難度分3.8了.但後來還不是周圍打電話給後補生等去註冊...

作者: monkeydad 時間: 08-9-30 22:35

We attended the interviews last year.

1st round was for the kids with drawing, talent show, questionaire on parents (which turned up carrying scores)...

2nd round was solely for parents. 6 pairs were invited in one lot for an open group discussion with no defined topic.

This year even have 3rd round...

What are the purposes of the interviews - just for sake of interviews???

作者: beetle 時間: 08-9-30 23:13

I didn't received call.....

[ 本帖最後由 beetle 於 08-9-30 23:31 編輯 ]

作者: Joeyjoeycheng 時間: 08-9-30 23:20

the main point is we don't have annual Leave anymore , so I will let my helper to take him go for 3rd interview as we don't have much time

3rd interview i feel Not good. maybe too much student and kick some out if performance are not good that what i am thinking

作者: beetle 時間: 08-9-30 23:28

Quote from the second interview letter:-

" ......to attend this second interview as a final step of the application process."

??????

[ 本帖最後由 beetle 於 08-9-30 23:32 編輯 ]

作者: Santa_Maria 時間: 08-9-30 23:37

No worries, let it be! many applicant still without the second round interview. But their concept for the admission, up to this moment, I have some adverse idea.

Second round is no problem, but how about the third round? Is that "enhance" the pressure to the kids...what's pity for the kids?

Sigh.....Compare with another year, the rate of birth for 2003 quite low.

All mami, don't focus to this school, many best choice for your kids.

作者: Santa_Maria 時間: 08-9-30 23:47

原帖由 beetle 於 08-9-30 23:28 發表
Quote from the second interview letter:-

" ......to attend this second interview as a final step of the application process."

??????

Sigh....final step...may be typing error.....hahah "final steps" :;pppp: Final step can be ...include many sub-steps.......noone knows...

But I'm bit worry that, if without 3 rd interview notification....what means? may be
1) Fail at second interview and no need for third round?
or
2) Give the last chance for the marginal pass student.....

..................what's the idea of this school.....

作者: Santa_Maria 時間: 08-10-1 00:07

原帖由 luckymother 於 08-9-30 21:47 發表

這麼高姿態,無非想給人一個印象,好像跟男拔等名校一樣.但實際是否一樣,就真的見仁見智.去年的天才表演,考中文生字和見家長,已經是難度分3.8了.但後來還不是周圍打電話給後補生等去註冊... ...

不是這麼嘛......今年攪到第三round interview 了,夠哂姿態

作者: IvIvSh 時間: 08-10-1 01:07

我都有去星期6的2nd interview. 以我理解, 應該是沒有3rd interview的.

其實有沒有其他家長都收到電話要3rd interview??

會唔會係聽錯左, 其實係其他學校??

作者: Santa_Maria 時間: 08-10-1 01:52

睇返呢個post祇係樓主收到3 round interview.通知.

都係果句:

一係第二round fail, 冇第三round通知.

二係第二掂左,入第三round,

三係比多次chance D marginal pass 既小朋友..整多round 補飛

[ 本帖最後由 Santa_Maria 於 08-10-1 01:58 編輯 ]

作者: Joeyjoeycheng 時間: 08-10-1 09:06

sigh....I may call tomorrow and check again

原帖由 Santa_Maria 於 08-10-1 01:52 發表
睇返呢個post祇係樓主收到3 round interview.通知.

都係果句:

一係第二round fail, 冇第三round通知.

二係第二掂左,入第三round,

三係比多次chance D marginal pass 既小朋友..整多round 補飛 ...

作者: masfamily 時間: 08-10-1 23:23

Very nervous..........I'm also attend the 2nd interview on Sat.
Waiting for your information, many many thanks!

作者: loy211 時間: 08-10-2 09:55

認同一些家長說法,三輪面試是一種折磨,一個小朋友嗜,幹嗎要折磨大人和小朋友?

作者: monkichi 時間: 08-10-2 11:19

唔好意思, 請問你地係咪講緊石門o個間學校??

作者: Joeyjoeycheng 時間: 08-10-2 12:51

Dear all

Already call today, Santa_Maria is correct:

(三係比多次chance D marginal pass 既小朋友..整多round 補飛)

I am thinking will let my son interview or not because of this, too much pressure for Him

原帖由 Santa_Maria 於 08-10-1 01:52 發表
睇返呢個post祇係樓主收到3 round interview.通知.

都係果句:

一係第二round fail, 冇第三round通知.

二係第二掂左,入第三round,

三係比多次chance D marginal pass 既小朋友..整多round 補飛 ...

作者: luckymother 時間: 08-10-2 13:39

原帖由 Joeyjoeycheng 於 08-10-2 12:51 發表
Dear all

Already call today, Santa_Maria is correct:

(三係比多次chance D marginal pass 既小朋友..整多round 補飛)

I am thinking will let my son interview or not because of this, too much pressur ...

真的懷疑是否需要第三輪面試,有的小朋友要見幾間學校,平時要上學,週末又要面試,真的是一種負擔,試想大人要見幾份工都覺得辛苦,何況是5,6歲的小朋友.如果是邊緣的,何不放在後補之列,等日後再作安排,因為一定有些家長放棄的.這間學校這麼便安排面試,又要分幾輪,到頭來又不是周圍call waiting list 的小朋友去讀.簡直是費時失事,浪費時間和資源.

作者: Joeyjoeycheng 時間: 08-10-2 19:55

Totally agreed 真的是一種負擔

原帖由 luckymother 於 08-10-2 13:39 發表

真的懷疑是否需要第三輪面試,有的小朋友要見幾間學校,平時要上學,週末又要面試,真的是一種負擔,試想大人要見幾份工都覺得辛苦,何況是5,6歲的小朋友.如果是邊緣的,何不放在後補之列,等日後再作安排,因為一定有些家 ...

作者: civic 時間: 08-10-2 20:42

That's really a pressure or it can depress children if they feel they still can't get the seat after 3rd interview. It will affect their interview in other school too. Think about that.

作者: IvIvSh 時間: 08-10-2 21:55

其實如果浸小是你的first choice, 而你又認同他的教育理念 (這點很重要, 因為final interview 就是想家長明白及認同), 就不要把interview當成負擔, 就算要見多一次, 你仍然比好多想見但一直無回音的家長好.

當然, 學校選你, 你亦可以選學校.

當比小朋友去玩多一次啦

作者: emmypun 時間: 08-10-2 22:56

原帖由 Joeyjoeycheng 於 08-10-2 19:55 發表
Totally agreed 真的是一種負擔

是否一種負擔在乎成人如何對待及解說...........

作者: IvIvSh 時間: 08-10-2 23:35

我小朋友到現時為止去了3間小學 interview, 每一次我都同佢講你去同d小朋友及老師玩耍...

他每一次見完都跟我說"好好玩, 希望快d再黎過"

小朋友都係得5歲左右, 唔應該會知道乜野係負擔, 作為成人及家長, 亦不應把自己的壓力轉移去小朋友身上...

就等小朋友像平時一樣表現自己就可以了...

負擔及壓力應該由家長一力承擔...

作者: Santa_Maria 時間: 08-10-2 23:58

原帖由 Joeyjoeycheng 於 08-10-2 12:51 發表
Dear all

Already call today, Santa_Maria is correct:

(三係比多次chance D marginal pass 既小朋友..整多round 補飛)

I am thinking will let my son interview or not because of this, too much pressur ...

Joeyjoeycheng

現在不用想太多,小朋友千萬不要給予他們壓力,
星期六日同佢玩下輕鬆下,千萬不要下下提
住聽日你去考乜考乜,你祇要同小朋友講
今日在Primary school 又有D 小朋友同先生同你傾下計,玩多次...that's it.制度下人人皆有壓力,我地為人父母,何忍給小朋友壓力呢?記著唔係D小朋友唔得,係制度令D小朋友同家長要面對呢D情況。既然你鐘情浸小,當然要面對其"遊戲規則",這點相信人人皆明白.

我絕對讚同學校揀人時,你亦可以揀學校.

真係當比小朋友去玩多一次吧,

祝成功!

[ 本帖最後由 Santa_Maria 於 08-10-3 00:03 編輯 ]

作者: 允允手記 時間: 08-10-3 00:17

今天我致電此校查詢。他們表示沒有第三輪面試。

作者: Santa_Maria 時間: 08-10-3 00:43

原帖由 luckymother 於 08-10-2 13:39 發表

真的懷疑是否需要第三輪面試,有的小朋友要見幾間學校,平時要上學,週末又要面試,真的是一種負擔,試想大人要見幾份工都覺得辛苦,何況是5,6歲的小朋友.如果是邊緣的,何不放在後補之列,等日後再作安排,因為一定有些家 ...

我一直在此留意此校之"收生理念",有幾點我也不明:
1.這輪第3 round面試,有必要在平日舉行嗎?這便好像剝削了小朋友乎平日在K3的課堂..
2.在此得各版友透露此校往年到最後都要四圍call 返D wait list既學生返黎讀,那證明些甚麼..證明很多人最終放棄學位??
3.如果根據以上各版友透露所知到最後都要四圍call 返D wait list既學生返黎,係咪意味住好多"正印"入選此校的學生到最終都放棄此校?有冇人知多唔多呢個情況呢???
4.據報紙報導過2003年既出生率比較低,整體適齡兒童都人數少了,學位也得充裕些,上述情況還會再出現嗎?
5.還有些版友在另一版還在問,還在等收到第 2 round interview信未??....既然如此,一早落選的,還不早早通知他們?

不過大把人還對此校趨之若鶩,大家點睇...
純屬愚見,請見諒

作者: Santa_Maria 時間: 08-10-3 00:49

原帖由 允允手記 於 08-10-3 00:17 發表
今天我致電此校查詢。他們表示沒有第三輪面試。

在此版祇知很多人都毋須3rd round,祇是有些個別例子而已,另一版仲有mami,還在等 2nd round interview通知信............

作者: charles2046 時間: 08-10-3 04:21

相信只是個別例子吧, 上週六2nd interview 已經好似冇咩好做, 只係校方同家長聯誼吓咁, 一陣就走得.... 如果重有得in 既話, 唔知會唔會你眼望我眼幾分鐘就叫你返屋企?!

作者: Joeyjoeycheng 時間: 08-10-3 10:36

Thank you so much Santa_Maria ...

All parents, 3rd interview is only for special case as my son is marginal pass, so they need to re-take the exam, so if you call school, they will not tell you that they have 3rd interview ....

原帖由 Santa_Maria 於 08-10-2 23:58 發表

Joeyjoeycheng

現在不用想太多,小朋友千萬不要給予他們壓力,
星期六日同佢玩下輕鬆下,千萬不要下下提
住聽日你去考乜考乜,你祇要同小朋友講
今日在Primary school 又有D 小朋友同先生同你傾下計,玩多次...that ...

作者: misschoy 時間: 08-10-6 10:13

Dear all parents, we haven't change to take 2nd interview of Wong Kam Fai, just wonder if all you had 2nd chance been living in Shatin or out of Shatin?

作者: misschoy 時間: 08-10-6 10:17

Dear all parents, we haven't chance to take the 2nd interview of Wong Kam Fai, wonder if you had 2nd chance been living in Shatin district or not.

We & my known family had no chance, we all use the address are out of Shatin.

作者: monkeydad 時間: 08-10-6 12:26

What I feel is the school is quite messy. Many of the parents who had attended the 2nd interview (we did last year) commented the interview did not appear to serve any purpose from the school selection perspective. Quite interesting that a 3rd interview is required - is it indicating the school might not be confident on the effectiveness of the 1st two interviews or it has learnt that 1st two interviews they organized were not effective enough.

Anyway, it does provide a chance for those marginal case candidate.

作者: AntheaLin 時間: 08-10-6 12:46

I think some of the parents did not attend even the 2nd interview as they were accepted by other schools, so WKF called the marginal applicants for re-test, it's administrative convenience. Simple guess only.

作者: Joeyjoeycheng 時間: 08-10-6 21:21

Dear all Parents

My son just attend 3rd interview today but he can't answer what teacher asked as he told me so nervous

, so i am thinking my son marginal case are no chance anymore

Anyway i won't give him any pressure just take it easy as he only 5 year old and how i expect what he face to stranger !!!

Good luck others!!

原帖由 AntheaLin 於 08-10-6 12:46 發表
I think some of the parents did not attend even the 2nd interview as they were accepted by other schools, so WKF called the marginal applicants for re-test, it's administrative convenience. Simple gue ...

作者: luckymother 時間: 08-10-6 21:52

原帖由 Joeyjoeycheng 於 08-10-6 21:21 發表
Dear all Parents

My son just attend 3rd interview today but he can't answer what teacher asked as he told me so nervous , so i am thinking my son marginal case are no chance anymore

Anyway ...

在這裡跟大家分享一個真實個案,去年我朋友的小朋友到一間學校面試,小朋友面對校長,父母則坐在旁邊,校長給小朋友7個蘋果,叫小朋友分給校長及自己,但要平均分,不能多,不能少,也不能剩.小朋友分了幾次,校長都堅持要平均分配.結果小朋友一臉無奈,不知怎做.跟著校長叫小朋友數圖畫中的物件,小朋友數完答15隻,但校長用凌厲眼神問他,真的是15隻嗎?我說應該是16隻,於是小朋友再數一次,當然答案都是15隻,但校長都說小朋友數得不對.小朋友差點連手指都扭斷了.如果要小朋友一次又一次的經歷同等的遭遇.他就算被收了,還會讀得開心嗎?

作者: iwff 時間: 08-10-6 22:50

以下的topic是否講緊這間學校, quote比考慮緊的家長參考一下。重申我不是面試者,小朋友已讀小一。

http://forum.edu-kingdom.com/vie ... tra=page%3D1&page=1

[ 本帖最後由 iwff 於 08-10-6 23:12 編輯 ]

作者: monkeydad 時間: 08-10-6 23:34

iwff,

Your quote is very useful.  It again confirms that our decision not to study in this school is definitely right.

Thank also to the 2nd interview chaired by the young lady which we reckoned totally meaningless and lack of substance.  Hence, we decided not to accept the offer.

We found the school is quite messy.  Teachers are relatively green and inexperienced.  Teaching style is inconsistent.

作者: aniwong 時間: 08-10-7 19:54

原帖由 IvIvSh 於 08-10-2 21:55 發表
其實如果浸小是你的first choice, 而你又認同他的教育理念 (這點很重要, 因為final interview 就是想家長明白及認同), 就不要把interview當成負擔, 就算要見多一次, 你仍然比好多想見但一直無回音的家長好.

當然, ...

We need to follow the rules of this silly P.1 interview game, why, because we are living in Hong Kong!
So! Your comments are most reasonable & positive!
就不要把interview當成負擔! Perfect!
我會當成一個meeting? 成功與否？再接再厲？　

作者: aniwong 時間: 08-10-7 20:01

原帖由 IvIvSh 於 08-10-2 23:35 發表
我小朋友到現時為止去了3間小學 interview, 每一次我都同佢講你去同d小朋友及老師玩耍...

他每一次見完都跟我說"好好玩, 希望快d再黎過"

小朋友都係得5歲左右, 唔應該會知道乜野係負擔, 作為成人及家長, 亦不應把 ...

極度同意！!！
小朋友會隨時發揮她們的小宇宙. 其實她們好大壓力, 大人的壓力可以自己舒緩, 對五歲的她, 是一項挑戰! 如果當成參與遊戲, 她們會更投入, 最重要讓她們開心和有興趣地參與遊戲. 不要加壓!
Everybody relax & enjoy this Halloween trick!!
( 以上純個人意見．）Thank you!!!

作者: iberia 時間: 08-10-7 22:06 標題: What is your dream school

原帖由 monkeydad 於 08-10-6 23:34 發表
iwff,

Your quote is very useful. It again confirms that our decision not to study in this school is definitely right.

Thank also to the 2nd interview chaired by the young lady which we reckoned tot ...

What is your final selection. What is your dream school to fulfill all your requirement.

A lot of parent thinking once found a well-known school can't do nothing. I think this kind of concept is totally wrong.

作者: IvIvSh 時間: 08-10-7 22:51

我相信無一間學校係可以滿足到不同類型的家長.

家長可以做的, 是盡量在不同學校中找一間合適自己兒童學習的學校.

就因為這個過程, 當中就一定會發生家長期望與學校教育理念不同的結果.

就正如我們正在工作的公司, 大家都可能覺得公司唔好. 但都會有其他員工唔覺得公司有問題一樣.

最後都係公司選員工, 員工選公司, 學校選學生, 學生選學校

這是一個十分簡單的道理, 作為家長應該要明白的. 希望大家都找到心中理想學校.

作者: catcatmom 時間: 08-10-8 12:02

我覺一間有心辦學既團體, in 第一次小朋友, in 第二次家長, 已經足夠時間去觀察個小朋友同家長, 究竟適唔適合讀佢地學校, 無理由仲要in第三次, 樓主講出來係伸吓! 希望 d家長講吓學校 base on 咩野理由要in3次, 希望有合理既理由聽吓! 唔係話咪當去冒險樂園玩吓囉! 家長要請假去架! 你估真係開心去旅行咩! in 第三次家長可能好少, 未必係得一個, 其他果d 家長可能無上bk姐!

以下係舊年家長既comments!
http://forum.baby-kingdom.com/viewthread.php?tid=783607&extra=page%3D1&page=1

[ 本帖最後由 catcatmom 於 08-10-8 12:07 編輯 ]

作者: Joeyjoeycheng 時間: 08-10-8 12:52

Dear Catcatmom

You are right, my son is not the only one, my husband told me it had been arranged10 marginal appliant for 3rd interview on Monday (he saw the list)

My son told me he was very nervous when interview again in same school and ask me why he need to go there for so many times...

For me, nothing to say...

原帖由 catcatmom 於 08-10-8 12:02 發表
我覺一間有心辦學既團體, in 第一次小朋友, in 第二次家長, 已經足夠時間去觀察個小朋友同家長, 究竟適唔適合讀佢地學校, 無理由仲要in第三次, 樓主講出來係伸吓! 希望 d家長講吓學校 base on 咩野理由要in3次, 希望 ...

作者: mimia810 時間: 08-10-8 14:20

We weren't selected for the second interview. Does it mean my daughter fail this school? I called this school before, the girl said still not confirm she's failed until the end of Oct when we receive the confirmation letter. Isn't it true?
Mimia

作者: beetle 時間: 08-10-8 14:53

wow, catcatmom, how u find this topic??? This topic is already 2 years ago!!!

Anyway, thanks for your info!

原帖由 catcatmom 於 08-10-8 12:02 發表
我覺一間有心辦學既團體, in 第一次小朋友, in 第二次家長, 已經足夠時間去觀察個小朋友同家長, 究竟適唔適合讀佢地學校, 無理由仲要in第三次, 樓主講出來係伸吓! 希望 d家長講吓學校 base on 咩野理由要in3次, 希望 ...

作者: SuggieC 時間: 08-10-8 14:54

mimia810,

我都call左學校, 因為我個仔都冇收到2nd int 或唔收嘅通知。佢地嘅回應同你一樣, 話最遲到10月底通知。

我住馬鞍山, 入於沙田區, 好似最多收30%, 學位唔多。我估佢地會分開選生。anyway, 咪等下囉!

有感小朋友噤細已經要開始進入充滿競爭嘅世界!

無奈!

Suggie

原帖由 mimia810 於 08-10-8 14:20 發表
We weren't selected for the second interview. Does it mean my daughter fail this school? I called this school before, the girl said still not confirm she's failed until the end of Oct when we receiv ...

作者: catcatmom 時間: 08-10-8 16:35

There have been a lot of discussions on this A school among the BK parent both pros and cons.
As soon as you type the key words (e.g. A luck to escape from ...) in google, you can find a lot ....

原帖由 beetle 於 08-10-8 14:53 發表
wow, catcatmom, how u find this topic??? This topic is already 2 years ago!!! Anyway, thanks for your info!

作者: fumiko 時間: 08-10-8 16:58

Just wonder what "A" school means?
Even in the school briefing, no explanation but keep referring to A school.

作者: monkeydad 時間: 08-10-8 17:29

A refers to the word "Affiliate". It is the affiliate school of the University.

原帖由 fumiko 於 08-10-8 16:58 發表
Just wonder what "A" school means?
Even in the school briefing, no explanation but keep referring to A school.

作者: fumiko 時間: 08-10-8 17:51 標題: 回覆 # 的文章

Thanks a lot!

作者: 941媽咪 時間: 08-10-9 00:07

我唔係好明白！如果這間學校不好，為何還要選擇它？乾脆放棄它!還有很多私校和直資可以申請，不需為這間學校的混亂行政而煩惱! 選擇權始終在你手中。

作者: 941媽咪 時間: 08-10-9 00:12

大家都係BK媽咪或爹哋，在BK Forum也畧知此校的過往及負面消息！如果不喜歡此校就忘記它，好的選擇還多！

作者: iberia 時間: 08-10-9 14:00 標題: HKBUAS

原帖由 941媽咪 於 08-10-9 00:12 發表
大家都係BK媽咪或爹哋，在BK Forum也畧知此校的過往及負面消息！如果不喜歡此校就忘記它，好的選擇還多！

We love this school very much. My elder son is studying in Pui Ching. My younger son is studying in HKBUAS. We have a lot of parents has elder sister in St Mary or elder son in DBS. But the younger son are studying in HKBUAS.

I can tell you this is a good school. We have 2 years experience there. We love the school and all teachers.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)