教育王國

標題: 對培正有啲失望 [打印本頁]

作者: kala 時間: 08-6-26 12:02 標題: 對培正有啲失望

我小朋友今年入k1, 考了培正但通知為後備生, 將於今年七月通知收唔收.

點知昨天午2:30培正打電話來話有一下午班學位, 問我要唔要, 我諗點都要同屋企人商量下, 同嗰個職員講可否俾一日時間我再答覆. 點知佢好無禮貌地講唔得, 仲要我2:45前好覆佢, 如果唔覆就當我放棄. 即係只得15分鐘俾人考慮.

個職員當時的語氣都好差, 我聽完個電話都有啲唔開心, 我知呢間學校大把人爭, 唔憂收唔到學生, 個學位我唔要大把人要, 但都唔洗咁不近人情.

好彩我個小朋友己搵到第二間學校, 本來諗住培正收的話要好好考慮選邊間, 而家連家庭會議都唔洗開了.

其實我最唔順氣就是培正的態度, 或者係我小氣啦, 大家聽完就算啦. 雖然係咁, 我仍然唔會否認培正係一間好好的學校的!!

作者: van_517 時間: 08-6-26 12:51

我個小朋友今年先會考K1,如果我Interview時我會特別留意老師&員工嘅表現!(我自己覺得interview我個小朋友嘅同時,亦係我interview間學校是否適合我小朋友)
我會睇下佢哋有無禮貌,有無愛心.....,因為我覺得幼稚園係小朋友學習嘅第一步,如果連老師都唔注重品德,又點會教得好小朋友,就算名校都係咁先!

作者: im_csb 時間: 08-6-26 12:53 標題: 回覆 #1 van_517 的文章

totally agree

作者: tpmak 時間: 08-6-26 13:02

I had recieved a call, I was not at office.
That guy left a fail message to my colleague,
so poor, that was my private matter.

原文章由 kala 於 08-6-26 12:02 發表
我小朋友今年入k1, 考了培正但通知為後備生, 將於今年七月通知收唔收.

點知昨天午2:30培正打電話來話有一下午班學位, 問我要唔要, 我諗點都要同屋企人商量下, 同嗰個職員講可否俾一日時間我再答覆. 點知佢好無禮貌 ...

作者: babyhowie 時間: 08-6-26 14:03

其實我個仔都考過培正兩次，
一次K1，一次K2插班，
感覺間學校真係高不可攀，
既然亞仔同間學校無緣，
我都唔會勉強，小一亦都唔考慮再考！

作者: wai406 時間: 08-6-26 14:52

可否告知現在你的小朋友選讀那一間學校

原文章由 kala 於 08-6-26 12:02 發表
我小朋友今年入k1, 考了培正但通知為後備生, 將於今年七月通知收唔收.

點知昨天午2:30培正打電話來話有一下午班學位, 問我要唔要, 我諗點都要同屋企人商量下, 同嗰個職員講可否俾一日時間我再答覆. 點知佢好無禮貌 ...

作者: atyl 時間: 08-6-26 15:01

原文章由 babyhowie 於 08-6-26 14:03 發表
其實我個仔都考過培正兩次，
一次K1，一次K2插班，
感覺間學校真係高不可攀，
既然亞仔同間學校無緣，
我都唔會勉強，小一亦都唔考慮再考！

我絕對同意,
我都打過去問後備生收生問題,
態度都非常之不好!
都知你是名校,
但都要注意一下態度問題,
想入讀貴校除了求學術外,
還想你把我的小朋友德育教好,
這樣的態度點教好我小朋友哩!
令小朋友讀書好不太難,
難在要品行都要好是很難,
現今社會太多事物令小朋友學壞.

作者: elizatyy 時間: 08-6-26 15:01

原文章由 babyhowie 於 08-6-26 14:03 發表
其實我個仔都考過培正兩次，
一次K1，一次K2插班，
感覺間學校真係高不可攀，
既然亞仔同間學校無緣，
我都唔會勉強，小一亦都唔考慮再考！

高不可攀...
I know a family who have 3 children studying there. They are all very naughty and do not look smart at all.

作者: QI 時間: 08-6-26 15:05

唔好意思,我想知培正幼稚園雖然係一條龍,但中學只是中文中學,其實為什麼是名校?????有什麼好?

作者: yu_baby 時間: 08-6-26 15:32

d人話佢地既學生好乖,同埋入左佢幼稚園,就唔洗煩,因為可以直升小學同中學,佢地收左我個囝讀am,但我冇比佢讀,因為我都勁唔鍾意佢地係中文中學!

作者: kiteli 時間: 08-6-26 16:17

原文章由 yu_baby 於 08-6-26 15:32 發表
d人話佢地既學生好乖,同埋入左佢幼稚園,就唔洗煩,因為可以直升小學同中學,佢地收左我個囝讀am,但我冇比佢讀,因為我都勁唔鍾意佢地係中文中學!

妳地講開呢間學校我都想分享下我以下的事

係2007年11月13 日交 application form 那天<< 我點會咁記得那天, 因為那天我要去醫院開刀生我細女

佢地封信到列明是帶出生證明文件正本

於是我帶了我大女的 id card 去, 都係出生證明文件, 是嗎 ??
(因為拎住張出花世紙不太方便)

收文件的人員說要帶出世紙喎

有以下對話

我 : 我地無帶出世紙, 祇帶了 id card , 不過我地都有帶出世紙 copy .

培 : 要帶出世紙正本啊

我 : id card 都係出生文件喎 ( 好友善 )

培 : 信件上寫到明係要帶出世紙 ( 串串地)

我:妳地信件上係寫上須帶出生證明交件，無講要帶出世紙　(進行交涉)

我老公：妳地要對　ｄ　咩野呀 ?? id card, 同出世紙都對到啦 ( 友善) 　

培 :我地要對父母名稱 ( 因 id card 是無的, 我地明白)

我老公: 因為我太太今日要去生 bb,  一係我地後補比妳啦

培 : 找個高級d 0既人來同我地講, 咁 ok啦　

其實，我同老公就呢件事好不滿意他們安排囉.
一來佢地又無明顯講話要出世紙, 我地都係以事論事姐 , 佢地不識採取適當0既應對囉

最後, 我女女就連 waiting list 都無 .
我地都唔 care, 因為佢地 d老師做法真係令我反感囉

早期, 聽到一個朋友講,其實佢地果刻可能巳經 bad list 了我們

係到, 我唔係想話培正不是, just share 我0既經驗
希望大家唔好誤會

作者: babyhowie 時間: 08-6-26 17:05

原文章由 QI 於 08-6-26 15:05 發表
唔好意思,我想知培正幼稚園雖然係一條龍,但中學只是中文中學,其實為什麼是名校?????有什麼好?

據聞佢地係唯一一間band1中文中學。
（如資料有誤，請見諒並更正。）

作者: candyckathybb 時間: 08-6-26 19:58

本來我都想同囡囡報培正,但聽完你們的經驗,我想我要重新考慮了,因為我絕對認同學校除了教小朋友智識外,培養小朋友的德育更為重要,如果學校喲教師及教職員會因為覺得自己係名校,而唔尊重我們家長,就算比我囡囡在此讀書,之後家校都唔會有好的溝通啦:;pppp:

作者: QQLAU 時間: 08-6-26 20:07

我舊年小朋友去面試k1,我已經對呢所學校好失望喇.

作者: Sumjac 時間: 08-6-26 20:25

為什麼呢？可否分享下？

原文章由 QQLAU 於 08-6-26 20:07 發表
我舊年小朋友去面試k1,我已經對呢所學校好失望喇.

作者: kala 時間: 08-6-26 21:17

Wai 406:

我個女好彩己經俾spk收咗, 都係一條龍, 而且之前連留位費, 書簿費同校服都買埋. 培正本來話七月先會通知收唔收, 咁遲先通知, 梗係做好第二個打算啦, 唔係都唔知點算.

我昨天本來到2:45都唔想覆電話俾培正, 但我老公叫我點都要覆返人, 仲要話俾佢聽而家係我哋唔要你個學位, 等佢哋唔好成日好似好巴閉咁. 我之後覆佢電話時有少少覺得自己咁講好衰, 但講完個心又好舒服添!!

作者: Mui_Chu 時間: 08-6-27 00:44

Good selection.
Of course choose SPK rather than PC, caused PC is
a chinese secondary school but SPC is an English one.

作者: ballchi 時間: 08-6-27 00:45

嘩!!!!!!!!!好巴弊啊..
一條龍既choose雖然吾係話好多,但係佢吾係唯一一間羅.

作者: atyl 時間: 08-6-27 10:55

原文章由 Mui_Chu 於 08-6-27 00:44 發表
Good selection.
Of course choose SPK rather than PC, caused PC is
a chinese secondary school but SPC is an English one.

唔好意思! 請問SPK的那間學校? THANKS.
我已打定輸數我的小朋友入不到培正(是後備生),
所以想來年再考多幾間做插班生.

作者: yuyumom 時間: 08-6-27 11:02

Hi! I also agreed that the attitude of pui ching teacher are very poor

作者: HelloPepsi 時間: 08-6-27 14:12

原文章由 yu_baby 於 08-6-26 15:32 發表
d人話佢地既學生好乖,同埋入左佢幼稚園,就唔洗煩,因為可以直升小學同中學,佢地收左我個囝讀am,但我冇比佢讀,因為我都勁唔鍾意佢地係中文中學!

據知佢地係一間英文好好既中文中學，如果唔係就唔會咁多人去考。

作者: elizatyy 時間: 08-6-27 14:15

I will rather choose an English primary school ...

作者: QQ_Monster 時間: 08-6-27 15:02

原文章由 yu_baby 於 08-6-26 15:32 發表
d人話佢地既學生好乖,同埋入左佢幼稚園,就唔洗煩,因為可以直升小學同中學,佢地收左我個囝讀am,但我冇比佢讀,因為我都勁唔鍾意佢地係中文中學!

既然你咁"勁唔鍾意佢地", 咁點解最初你會報名呢

作者: yu_baby 時間: 08-6-27 15:33

原文章由 QQ_Monster 於 08-6-27 15:02 發表

既然你咁"勁唔鍾意佢地", 咁點解最初你會報名呢

我知呢間學校勁巴閉,又話好難入,我緊係想去見識下啦!比$30可以比自己一個機會看多d,睇下入面咩野環境,亞囝又有多一次interview既機會!

作者: ysnmama 時間: 08-6-27 16:27

雖然家長同學校配合才可教出好孩子. 我也同樣認識一家族(他們來自不同家庭的表兄弟姊妹). 他們(約5-6個)全也在培正畢業. 巧合地5個也書又讀不好. 工又常常做不長.

原文章由 elizatyy 於 08-6-26 15:01 發表

高不可攀...
I know a family who have 3 children studying there. They are all very naughty and do not look smart at all.

作者: Mui_Chu 時間: 08-6-27 16:40

原文章由 atyl 於 08-6-27 10:55 發表

唔好意思! 請問SPK的那間學校? THANKS.
我已打定輸數我的小朋友入不到培正(是後備生),
所以想來年再考多幾間做插班生.

SPK: St. Paul Kindergarten (in Causeway Bay)

作者: atyl 時間: 08-6-27 16:42

原文章由 Mui_Chu 於 08-6-27 16:40 發表

SPK: St. Paul Kindergarten (in Causeway Bay)

多謝回覆!

作者: ICbaby 時間: 08-6-27 22:25

原文章由 kala 於 08-6-26 12:02 發表
我小朋友今年入k1, 考了培正但通知為後備生, 將於今年七月通知收唔收.

點知昨天午2:30培正打電話來話有一下午班學位, 問我要唔要, 我諗點都要同屋企人商量下, 同嗰個職員講可否俾一日時間我再答覆. 點知佢好無禮貌 ...

無法la, 大把人爭住讀, 係hill c d 架啦~
我[個人]黎講就一向不太中意呢間,徐了英文, 其他係用中文教.

作者: kala 時間: 08-6-27 22:47

但聽好多人話佢啲畢業生英文質素都好好, 我開頭才會幫個小朋友報. 而且貪佢係男女校, 因大多一條龍的學校唔係全男就係全女. 男女校好似發展平衡啲啲, 但點知師資原來係咁...差!

作者: elizatyy 時間: 08-6-28 06:02

原文章由 ysnmama 於 08-6-27 16:27 發表
雖然家長同學校配合才可教出好孩子. 我也同樣認識一家族(他們來自不同家庭的表兄弟姊妹). 他們(約5-6個)全也在培正畢業. 巧合地5個也書又讀不好. 工又常常做不長.

...

I was also surprised when I knew the kids were all from this school...

作者: joeyma 時間: 08-6-28 11:15

培正話係中文學校，但我唔覺得佢地中文好好喎！

話說上年阿囡去考時，爸爸帶佢上去，而我係校園逛，逛去一個作文展板度，有好多小學生優秀作文係度展覽，啲文應該俾老師看完改完，再俾學生謄上去，但係．．．．．．．好多篇都有錯別字，你話奇唔奇！！

作者: ICbaby 時間: 08-6-28 23:06

原文章由 joeyma 於 08-6-28 11:15 發表
培正話係中文學校，但我唔覺得佢地中文好好喎！

話說上年阿囡去考時，爸爸帶佢上去，而我係校園逛，逛去一個作文展板度，有好多小學生優秀作文係度展覽，啲文應該俾老師看完改完，再俾學生謄上去，但係．．．．．．．好多篇都有錯別字，你話奇唔奇！！:igi ...

呀, 咁咪名過於實.

作者: Anpanmama 時間: 08-6-29 04:18

原文章由 HelloPepsi 於 08-6-27 14:12 發表

據知佢地係一間英文好好既中文中學，如果唔係就唔會咁多人去考。

細妹 & 弟弟also study at 培正, and I was study at Band 1 English school, I do think their English were very good..
and now, two of my 外甥女 are studing at K2 and K1, the impression for me, four of them are very positive thinking, EQ very high level...but surely, it could be difference by individual character at all.

作者: mybabylove 時間: 08-6-29 16:10

我有個親戚個大女一考就入左

，但係個細仔就考左兩年都唔入

，考第三年先入，乜唔係有哥哥/家姐就easy d入架咩

？佢地重叫我個仔考入去，我都唔知比唔比佢考入去，讀完好似佢地D老師

咁就死勒。全港都唔係得佢一間名校、一條龍既學校姐。不過去見識下都好，而且可以睇下自己個小朋友既學習程度去到邊

。

作者: yaulinda 時間: 08-6-30 09:20

唔知態度唔好的職員是什麼職級?
如果只係文員, 而唔係教師,
我就覺得勉強可接受,
如果係教師,
就真係唔OK,
咁無禮貌同品德,
唔應該在幼稚園工作啊!

作者: ysnmama 時間: 08-6-30 09:52

雖然不知在電話裡是教師或文職員工. 但也是代表學校的. 理應態度也不應如此. 不過因為在培正的教職員. 可能分分鐘已做上十幾廿年. 所以態度可能........

作者: ChinChinMammy 時間: 08-6-30 10:30

Congratulations to you !

Your daughter was accepted by SPK. Woudl you please tell me how old is she? Are you gratulated from SPK (old girl)? and are you a Catholic.

My daughter was rejected by SPK for 2008 K1.
I plan to apply again this year.

Thank you very much.

原文章由 kala 於 08-6-27 22:47 發表
但聽好多人話佢啲畢業生英文質素都好好, 我開頭才會幫個小朋友報. 而且貪佢係男女校, 因大多一條龍的學校唔係全男就係全女. 男女校好似發展平衡啲啲, 但點知師資原來係咁...差! ...

作者: vinvillalee 時間: 08-6-30 21:54

SPK is which school?

作者: kala 時間: 08-6-30 22:07

SPK: St. Paul's kindergarden
銅鑼灣聖保祿幼稚園

作者: chingyu 時間: 08-6-30 22:35

kala,

In my opinion, SPK is much better than PC. Perhaps I care much about English standard of a school.

However, be careful that 2-3 students in a class will be kicked off from kindergarten to primary without any reason in SPK.

Therefore, you need to have some backup in K3.

原文章由 kala 於 08-6-30 22:07 發表
SPK: St. Paul's kindergarden
銅鑼灣聖保祿幼稚園

作者: chingyu 時間: 08-7-1 10:17

Sorry that I can't agree with you.

Though we understand the administrators/clerks may be very busy, everybody should keep appropiate manner in all circumstances.

I am also surprised to read this post.  To my impression, the advantage of PC should be the discipline and manner of students.  How can they nuture good attitudes of students in such environment?

From pre-nursery, kindergarten to primary, I visited lots of so-called famous schools.  You really can see the differences. Although some of them are very famous, you can see that they run everything smoothly and all teahcers/educational assistants/security guards/gardeners are very friendly and polite.  It depends on how their senior management monitors the school.

Quoted=============================
另外講一下:
全港八百多間幼稚園，約有150間私立幼稚園，80%私立幼稚園根據教育局調查都不合格。(註:數據是EDB網)
對於非牟利幼稚園，根據教育局調查，80%都合格，家長們自己考慮一下罷。
Unquoted===========================

Above figure doesn't make sense to me.
You can see that most of kids' parents working in EDB including those principals/teachers, most of them will put their kids in private schools or even international schools.
You may have this information when reading parental magazines.  Sometimes they will show the background of their kids.  Checking the kids of 孫明揚, 李國章, 羅太 and other principals, you will have clear picture.

Moreover, "grapes are sour without chances to enjoy"  cannot apply on 樓主.  Actually she got both good schools on her hands.

作者: boringggggggg 時間: 08-7-2 13:55

Being the father of a PC Kindergarden's student, luckily I don't have such 'bad' experience as some of you did. On the contrary, I found that the requirement expecially on the behaviour of the student are very high (actually it's a bit too high).

My son's head teachers in his K1 and K2 are quite nice. Besides, the quality of my son's classmate are also very good. Everytime I met their parents in the school day or other function, we shared our experience on how we grow up our kids, what kind of extra trainings on them are required and so on.

To me, I am very satisfied with the overall standard of the school so far.

Thanks for your reading.

作者: ivywong2301 時間: 08-7-2 17:36 標題: 回覆 #1 boringggggggg 的文章

I also no such bad experience in PC.
My daughter now is study K3.
teachers & admin clerks are good.
I think is "個別事件"

作者: kala 時間: 08-7-2 18:36

Sorry ChinChinMammy, 之前睇漏咗你的問題, 而家補答返:

我個女係05年4月出世, 我同先生不是舊生亦沒有任何宗敎信仰.
無論如何, 祝你女女今年成功插到班啦!

原文章由 ChinChinMammy 於 08-6-30 10:30 發表
Congratulations to you !

Your daughter was accepted by SPK. Woudl you please tell me how old is she? Are you gratulated from SPK (old girl)? and are you a Catholic.

My daughter was rejected by SP ...

作者: ChinChinMammy 時間: 08-7-3 10:12

Thank you Kala.

I think that your daughter is very smart.

Do you know whether SPK accept K2 application or not?

原文章由 kala 於 08-7-2 18:36 發表
Sorry ChinChinMammy, 之前睇漏咗你的問題, 而家補答返:

我個女係05年4月出世, 我同先生不是舊生亦沒有任何宗敎信仰.
無論如何, 祝你女女今年成功插到班啦!

...

作者: kala 時間: 08-7-3 11:07

I also want to know it. Coz one of my friend also want to apply K3 for her daughter.

原文章由 ChinChinMammy 於 08-7-3 10:12 發表
Thank you Kala.

I think that your daughter is very smart.

Do you know whether SPK accept K2 application or not?

作者: ko06879 時間: 08-7-15 22:51

原文章由 QI 於 08-6-26 15:05 發表
唔好意思,我想知培正幼稚園雖然係一條龍,但中學只是中文中學,其實為什麼是名校?????有什麼好?

可能因為佢係用英文課本中文教啦, 公開孝試又考英文卷, 所以公開孝試的成績很不錯, 幾年前仲出過 one and only one 中文中學 10A 會考狀元。
Just copy from apple daily:
培正中學的校長，一直進行專業抗命，於物理、化學、電腦和小量數學科採用英文

材，但用粵語授課。
http://appledaily.atnext.com/template/apple/art_main.cfm?iss_id=20080223&sec_id=4104&subsec_id=12731&art_id=10785139

仲有一間所謂中文中學不可睇少, 就是港島的金文泰中學。

作者: papaya 時間: 08-7-16 01:44

我路過見到尼個topic 都忍唔住講agree ,四五年前，我個女考小一，四出打探小學，剛巧致電培正問detail,我都未問，那女職員便迫我講我女兒出生日期，當然係細女唔駛考咁解，我知，但都可以等家長講講究竟想問甚麼，而並非必要咁無禮貌先算有名掛。結果我個女考到SFA,而家讀得好開心,我對培正些識員印象太差了。

作者: carol716 時間: 08-7-16 12:30

我上星期都打電話去培正問佢09/10讀k1的申請表，佢地的態度都唔係好好架，答幾個字：9月先再打黎啦．．．
有寶咩．．．

原文章由 papaya 於 08-7-16 01:44 發表
我路過見到尼個topic 都忍唔住講agree ,四五年前，我個女考小一，四出打探小學，剛巧致電培正問detail,我都未問，那女職員便迫我講我女兒出生日期，當然係細女唔駛考咁解，我知，但都可以等家長講講究竟想問甚麼，而並非必要咁無禮貌 ...

作者: ourbaby 時間: 08-7-16 13:58

原文章由 QI 於 08-6-26 15:05 發表
唔好意思,我想知培正幼稚園雖然係一條龍,但中學只是中文中學,其實為什麼是名校?????有什麼好?

a lot students who graduated from PC went to top 10
universities in U.S.

作者: ourbaby 時間: 08-7-16 13:59

原文章由 yu_baby 於 08-6-27 15:33 發表

我知呢間學校勁巴閉,又話好難入,我緊係想去見識下啦!比$30可以比自己一個機會看多d,睇下入面咩野環境,亞囝又有多一次interview既機會!

keep on interviewing and become an expert!!!

作者: atyl 時間: 08-7-16 14:50

原文章由 carol716 於 08-7-16 12:30 發表
我上星期都打電話去培正問佢09/10讀k1的申請表，佢地的態度都唔係好好架，答幾個字：9月先再打黎啦．．．
有寶咩．．．

好激氣! 因為覺得你係好學校才會那麼緊張,
點知學校的教職員態度噤差,
問吓有無CALL過我,
因為我好驚MISS咗佢個CALL,
CHECK吓都唔得,
又話未有位(佢學校都已CALL過幾個後備生嗱!),
好似驚我再問,
怱忙噤就收線,
好無禮貌!
唔等嗱!
我的小朋友讀回原校嗱!
對培正印象很差!!!

作者: kala 時間: 08-7-19 10:35

唔知點解前兩日培正又打電話來話有下午班學位問我要唔要, 我明明上次己專登覆電話講明唔要, 三個星期後又打來問, 間學校收生好似好無系統咁...

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)