教育王國

標題: 小一自行收生-呢的人真係唔應該俾佢抽到 [打印本頁]

作者: ruru 時間: 07-11-27 17:49 標題: 小一自行收生-呢的人真係唔應該俾佢抽到

http://www.mingpaonews.com/20071127/gfc1.htm

個對陳氏夫婦...俾得起HKD8,000個仔課外活動,就去讀私校啦,阻住的位

作者: tungtungma814 時間: 07-11-27 17:50

咪係, 咁有錢點解唔去讀直資/私校:tongue:

原文章由 ruru 於 07-11-27 17:49 硐表
http://www.mingpaonews.com/20071127/gfc1.htm

個對陳氏夫婦...俾得起HKD8,000個仔課外活動,就去讀私校啦,阻住的位

作者: bbq71 時間: 07-11-27 17:54

點解唔留番d 位比真係負擔唔到私校or直資學費嘅家庭,奇實係咪有d唔fair 呢?

原文章由 ruru 於 07-11-27 17:49 硐表
http://www.mingpaonews.com/20071127/gfc1.htm

個對陳氏夫婦...俾得起HKD8,000個仔課外活動,就去讀私校啦,阻住的位

作者: PansyMummy 時間: 07-11-27 18:19

原文章由 ruru 於 07-11-27 17:49 硐表
http://www.mingpaonews.com/20071127/gfc1.htm

個對陳氏夫婦...俾得起HKD8,000個仔課外活動,就去讀私校啦,阻住的位

我都覺得佢地應該讀私校或直資, 因為聖保羅, 聖方濟各英小 + 英華3間名校都收咗佢個仔啦, 点解佢地要搬屋都唔去呢3間是但一間啫:tongue: :tongue: :tongue:
其實呢3間小學絕對唔差得過喇沙喎, 我自已重覺得可能好過添, 而且佢地似乎絕對有經濟能力可以負擔到呢幾間直資/私小......

不過, 我又平心而論咁講, 其實所有香港人嘅子女都有權讀官立/津小嘅, 因為呢D係所有納稅人享有嘅福利嚟, 由其是中產階層果批添, 因為呢批人平時已經無乜社會福利可以享用, 所以如果連津小/官小都唔俾佢地揀, 咁又講唔通嘅。
而且我相信重有好多其他嘅家長等緊/希望佢地嘅小朋友可以入到呢3間名校, 陳氏夫婦唔要, 大把人要啦。

作者: 東南媽媽 時間: 07-11-27 18:54

我都好同意pansymummy的講法!
另外, 有時很花金錢去培育子女, 並不代表富有, 只是很明白現今single-child家庭有誰不會月花數仟在子女身上...唉...祝佢好運吧!

作者: Cartier 時間: 07-11-27 19:00

咁又唔好咁話人, 事實上喇沙好過英華, 而聖方濟各英小又冇中學, 聖保羅男女和喇沙同級數, 但要$48000一年, 正常人都應該會揀喇沙, 否則會比人話佢蠢

作者: Ben2003 時間: 07-11-27 19:03

>咁又唔好咁話人

Agree.

>另外, 有時很花金錢去培育子女, 並不代表富有, 只是很明白現今single-child家庭有誰不會月花數仟在子女身上

Agree.

作者: 我的小豬 時間: 07-11-27 19:23

>咁又唔好咁話人

>另外, 有時很花金錢去培育子女, 並不代表富有, 只是很明白現今single-child家庭有誰不會月花數仟在子女身上

>其實所有香港人嘅子女都有權讀官立/津小嘅, 因為呢D係所有納稅人享有嘅福利嚟, 由其是中產階層果批添, 因為呢批人平時已經無乜社會福利可以享用, 所以如果連津小/官小都唔俾佢地揀, 咁又講唔通嘅。

Agree.

原文章由 Ben2003 於 07-11-27 19:03 硐表
>咁又唔好咁話人

Agree.

>另外, 有時很花金錢去培育子女, 並不代表富有, 只是很明白現今single-child家庭有誰不會月花數仟在子女身上

Agree.

作者: Ben2003 時間: 07-11-27 19:50

>其實所有香港人嘅子女都有權讀官立/津小嘅, 因為呢D係所有納稅人享有嘅福利嚟, 由其是中產階層果批添, 因為呢批人平時已經無乜社會福利可以享用, 所以如果連津小/官小都唔俾佢地揀, 咁又講唔通嘅。

Agree.

作者: 瑩瑩老豆 時間: 07-11-27 21:37

只可以話佢地好運, 津小/直資名校都收佢.

但又唔可以話佢唔應該去津小, 佢係香港人相信也是納稅人, 佢嘅子女都有權讀官立/津小嘅,

原文章由 ruru 於 07-11-27 17:49 硐表
http://www.mingpaonews.com/20071127/gfc1.htm

個對陳氏夫婦...俾得起HKD8,000個仔課外活動,就去讀私校啦,阻住的位

作者: SandyWu 時間: 07-11-27 21:43

原文章由 瑩瑩老豆 於 07-11-27 21:37 硐表
只可以話佢地好運, 津小/直資名校都收佢.

但又唔可以話佢唔應該去津小, 佢係香港人相信也是納稅人, 佢嘅子女都有權讀官立/津小嘅,

我係認同,所以我有心儀既私小收左,我都會照TAKE LUCKY
DRAW,因為係我地D所謂"中產"既福利,抽唔到好既官津咪當係參予下LAW

作者: rdc888 時間: 07-11-27 22:32

原文章由 瑩瑩老豆 於 07-11-27 21:37 硐表
只可以話佢地好運, 津小/直資名校都收佢.

但又唔可以話佢唔應該去津小, 佢係香港人相信也是納稅人, 佢嘅子女都有權讀官立/津小嘅,

完全同意你的講法，不論他們是否有錢，是他們的運氣。

作者: ruru 時間: 07-11-27 22:46

其實我個女在昨天已經派到心儀的小學,只不過看到這段新聞,有感而發,又看到這裡昨天抽唔中的媽媽為自己的子女擔心到出年唔知點算,但這對陳氏夫婦竟然在報紙上跨耀自己有幾好彩,有幾多間名校等佢個仔去讀,我個人覺得做人唔可以咁,比記者訪問到你你話好開心咪得lor,大家都會替你高興,唔使咁樣跨耀自己,如我個女昨天派不到學校而看到這段新聞個心情會係點.....

作者: vesley 時間: 07-11-27 23:18 標題: 回覆 #13 ruru 的文章

from ruru:其實我個女在昨天已經派到心儀的小學,只不過看到這段新聞,有感而發,又看到這裡昨天抽唔中的媽媽為自己的子女擔心到出年唔知點算,但這對陳氏夫婦竟然在報紙上跨耀自己有幾好彩,有幾多間名校等佢個仔去讀,我個人覺得做人唔可以咁,比記者訪問到你你話好開心咪得lor,大家都會替你高興,唔使咁樣跨耀自己,如我個女昨天派不到學校而看到這段新聞個心情會係點.....

你真的寫得很好!
也是我的同感。

[ 本文章最後由 vesley 於 07-11-27 23:41 編輯 ]

作者: BillieBug 時間: 07-11-27 23:36

Every year, there have always been some "funny" parents talking such kind of wonderful things in front of La Salle ---
1. bought properties in millions near La Salle and told the whole world that he had spent a lot of $$$,

2. daddy bursted into tears, complained his son had failed to get a seat, :tongue:
3. daddy insisted the elder son to repeat P.6 so that the younger son could be admitted,

And this year......

原文章由 vesley 於 07-11-27 23:18 硐表
這段新聞,有感而發,又看到這裡昨天抽唔中的媽媽為自己的子女擔心到出年唔知點算,但這對陳氏夫婦竟然在報紙上跨耀自己有幾好彩,有幾多間名校等佢個仔去讀,我個人覺得做人唔可以咁,比記者訪問到你你話好開心咪得lor,大 ...

[ 本文章最後由 BillieBug 於 07-11-28 00:01 編輯 ]

作者: vesley 時間: 07-11-27 23:43

billybug,
st. paul co ed . congradulation to u!
from ruru:其實我個女在昨天已經派到心儀的小學,只不過看到這段新聞,有感而發,又看到這裡昨天抽唔中的媽媽為自己的子女擔心到出年唔知點算,但這對陳氏夫婦竟然在報紙上跨耀自己有幾好彩,有幾多間名校等佢個仔去讀,我個人覺得做人唔可以咁,比記者訪問到你你話好開心咪得lor,大家都會替你高興,唔使咁樣跨耀自己,如我個女昨天派不到學校而看到這段新聞個心情會係點.....
me only share the same view.
but the view is good.

[ 本文章最後由 vesley 於 07-11-27 23:45 編輯 ]

作者: BillieBug 時間: 07-11-28 00:15

陳氏夫婦 is a very very lucky case but a very very poor demonstration! It really gives me an impression ---putting salt over one's wound. Lucky parents should learn to be more considerate and humble!!:tongue: :tongue:

原文章由 vesley 於 07-11-27 23:43 硐表
billybug,
st. paul co ed . congradulation to u!
from ruru:其實我個女在昨天已經派到心儀的小學,只不過看到這段新聞,有感而發,又看到這裡昨天抽唔中的媽媽為自己的子女擔心到出年唔知點算,但這對陳氏夫婦竟然在報 ...

作者: 東南媽媽 時間: 07-11-28 00:21

這是一面很好的借鏡, 如果日後我們中榜的話, 要懂得怎樣表達!

作者: lui 時間: 07-11-28 00:39

I have another views. The couple gave ppl the first impression of being "proud" and act like "putting salt over other wound". However, I think that it might be the reporter ask them questions by questions rather than they said their own story out all by themselves. Just think, if you were the reporter, you might want to create "news"!!!

作者: 小LEGO老豆 時間: 07-11-28 01:43

原文章由 lui 於 07-11-28 00:39 硐表
I have another views. The couple gave ppl the first impression of being "proud" and act like "putting salt over other wound". However, I think that it might be the reporter ask them questions by quest ...

Yup. Contrast effect.

Some got all they want VS some got nothing they want.

Although I feel jealous too, but their son must be quite smart.

作者: chanwk 時間: 07-11-28 02:03 標題: 回覆 #17 BillieBug 的文章

I am totally agree with you and feel great to see such a high quality parent like you in bk.Humble and considerate for those parent have got an good offer and dont give up and move on to those parent still waiting. god bless you all.

作者: 巴菲特 時間: 07-11-28 02:15

原文章由 chanwk 於 07-11-28 02:03 硐表
I am totally agree with you and feel great to see such a high quality parent like you in bk.Humble and considerate for those parent have got an good offer and dont give up and move on to those parent ...

今年可在網上查閱自行派位結果，親身前往學校等候結果的家長人數較以往少。住九龍塘的陳先生及陳太，其獨生子昨日獲派喇沙小學，不過，兩人仍未決定是否讓愛子入讀，因為同時報讀的幾間名校包括聖保羅男女、聖芳濟各及英華均取錄其子，「多數揀聖保羅，到時或者搬去附近（半山區）」。

希望陳生陳太好好考慮清楚，作為正準備入讀spcc的家長，真係好擔心...

作者: 991129 時間: 07-11-28 09:32

原文章由 瑩瑩老豆 於 07-11-27 21:37 發表
只可以話佢地好運, 津小/直資名校都收佢.

但又唔可以話佢唔應該去津小, 佢係香港人相信也是納稅人, 佢嘅子女都有權讀官立/津小嘅,

Totally agree...

作者: 991129 時間: 07-11-28 09:34

原文章由 BillieBug 於 07-11-28 00:15 發表
陳氏夫婦 is a very very lucky case but a very very poor demonstration! It really gives me an impression ---putting salt over one's wound. Lucky parents should learn to be more considerate and humble! ...

Yes, they are really lucky but no need to show-off lor

作者: 長毛 時間: 07-11-28 10:02

D 喇沙家長仲擔心......

原文章由 巴菲特 於 07-11-28 02:15 發表

今年可在網上查閱自行派位結果，親身前往學校等候結果的家長人數較以往少。住九龍塘的陳先生及陳太，其獨生子昨日獲派喇沙小學，不過，兩人仍未決定 ...

[ 本文章最後由長毛於 07-11-28 10:05 編輯 ]

作者: d2343130 時間: 07-11-28 10:10

我都好明白同同意大家的睇法, 而我在星島都見過有關報導, 他們認為孩子應較合適到男女校, 所以他們應唔會要la salle了.

但其實好多家長, 都會盡報所有好的直資同私立學校, 當中不乏天資好而又加上家長小孩一出生便不惜工本的培育, 所以去到邊間學校面試都差不多實收, 所以呢個時間係佢地的初步收成期. 又唔可以怪佢地有呢d咁樣的回應, 係bk都有唔少家長又係好多間都收,反過來問人地揀邊間好啦.....其實佢地報學校之前,從來無好好收集學校資料同已排好心儀次序嗎??? 問人地反過來不是自己更清楚!! 那麼陳氏比較踏實同有清晰的取向, 起碼回應記者時心中已有數,不是向記者說"呢間,呢間同果間都收, 間都係出名的,都唔知揀邊間好"!!!

呢個小一入學制就係咁, 要講彩數又唔話得哂, 要講實力又唔完全係....只可以為人父母盡力而為吧!! 有時, 你好有心去做結果出來唔理想, 其實過程中你同小朋友都有得著(我指你有報直/私校),唔好太執著! 因為總有factors係你控制以外的!! 可能大家都可以有陳氏每月比到$8k出來培育小孩,大家都有可能與他們一樣的結果!

所以唔好理人地了, 自己盡力而為吧! 尤其我呢d 未有學校收的!!

原文章由 991129 於 07-11-28 09:34 發表

Yes, they are really lucky but no need to show-off lor

作者: bbq71 時間: 07-11-28 11:33

你真係完全明白我哋1st round 落空家長嘅心情,任何一個派到心儀小學嘅家長,我哋都會為佢哋高興,奈何見到呢則新聞,就好似雪上加霜咁,家長就係小朋友嘅鏡子,其實做人謙虛d好.

原文章由 ruru 於 07-11-27 22:46 發表
其實我個女在昨天已經派到心儀的小學,只不過看到這段新聞,有感而發,又看到這裡昨天抽唔中的媽媽為自己的子女擔心到出年唔知點算,但這對陳氏夫婦竟然在報紙上跨耀自己有幾好彩,有幾多間名校等佢個仔去讀,我個人覺得做 ...

作者: BillieBug 時間: 07-11-28 21:35

Considerate parents should also give up other school offers as soon as possible. The offers not in need may be desperately needed by other parents and kids. To hold more than one offer in hand will also waste unnecessary $$ and make you struggle from time to time.
So would all of you pls make up your mind and release unnecessary offers to others as soon as you can!!

原文章由 chanwk 於 07-11-28 02:03 發表
I am totally agree with you and feel great to see such a high quality parent like you in bk.Humble and considerate for those parent have got an good offer and dont give up and move on to those parent ...

作者: SandyWu 時間: 07-11-29 00:32

原文章由 BillieBug 於 07-11-28 21:35 發表
Considerate parents should also give up other school offers as soon as possible. The offers not in need may be desperately needed by other parents and kids. To hold more than one offer in hand will al ...

I have already done so. Actually, our child can only take
one seat

: I hope all the children can have a happy
school life

作者: Uncle-DOS 時間: 07-11-29 09:59

可能那個家長有報很多間直資, 但全部failure. 所以抽喇沙.

因為註冊了直資, 便無可能抽獎了.
現在亦有些私校都會呈報上教署, 學生亦有機會無得抽獎.

作者: NeoMom 時間: 07-11-29 10:10

點解傳媒唔報導下果d幾年前曾高調入那巴書院既人幾年後既情況

作者: sally.cc 時間: 07-11-29 10:16

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Johnny_hk 時間: 07-11-29 10:19

I think most of the parents will "Hope for the best, prepare for the worst" -- that's why even the child has 20 or more marks will still apply for DSS or private school for backup.

Just like the P1 application form, you have 1st, 2nd and more choice.

For those already accepted by a "good" school (commonly ranked), congratulation! For others, keep your love to your child like other parents -- we just do our best for them, or what we think the best

原文章由 d2343130 於 07-11-28 10:10 發表
我都好明白同同意大家的睇法, 而我在星島都見過有關報導, 他們認為孩子應較合適到男女校, 所以他們應唔會要la salle了.

但其實好多家長, 都會盡報所有好的直資同私立學校, 當中不乏天資好而又加上家長小孩一出生便 ...

作者: d2343130 時間: 07-11-29 10:25

如果同直資學校signed咗undertaking的信係係入自行表之後, 教局未有咁快suspended佢個application,所以結果出咗都會有學位比咗呢d人, 但係呢個係假像因學校應已知佢地放棄咗,唔會比佢地註冊的!!

原文章由 Uncle-DOS 於 07-11-29 09:59 發表
可能那個家長有報很多間直資, 但全部failure. 所以抽喇沙.

因為註冊了直資, 便無可能抽獎了.
現在亦有些私校都會呈報上教署, 學生亦有機會無得抽獎. ...

作者: miffy 時間: 07-11-29 10:45

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: NeoMom 時間: 07-11-29 10:54

原文章由 sally.cc 於 07-11-29 10:16 發表

咁就証明咗有ｄ直資唔係名校囉！

http://i235.photobucket.com/albums/ee236/minisizeshirt/4673200651720639.gif

根據你既logic應該係3間都唔係名校, 所以我唔認同呢個logic

作者: YanYan0116 時間: 07-11-29 11:14

其實我都識好多人家境富庶都讀津小/官小.

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)