教育王國

標題: 若４間私小都收, 點樣選擇好呢? [打印本頁]

作者: Childhood 時間: 07-10-16 22:21 標題: 若４間私小都收, 點樣選擇好呢?

幫個囡囡報咗 DGJS, GHS, APS, KTS, SFA 等私小, 一個假設性的問題: 若真係全部都收她(當然首選DGJS, 但我冇想過會咁好彩), 咁4間學校依次序應該點排名呢? 可否比意見

.其實4間都各有所長, 我自己4間都鍾意.
小女現讀 St.Catherine's. 較文靜、聽話, 但好有創意.

作者: JOELCC 時間: 07-10-16 23:39

GHS is better.

作者: rdc888 時間: 07-10-17 00:23

No need to think now, think of the interview lar.

作者: cherriemama 時間: 07-10-17 09:02

Ha Ha.... 點解你囡囡同我囡囡完全一樣? 連性格, 所讀學校, 報考學校都一樣!!

不過我仲未諗掂, 我打算收o左先揀, 話唔定到時只得一間收我囡囡我就唔駛咁頭痕!

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-16 22:21 硐表
幫個囡囡報咗 DGJS, GHS, APS, KTS, SFA 等私小, 一個假設性的問題: 若真係全部都收她(當然首選DGJS, 但我冇想過會咁好彩), 咁4間學校依次序應該點排名呢? 可否比意見 .其實4間都各有所長, 我自己4間都鍾意.
小女 ...

作者: Childhood 時間: 07-10-17 09:14

原文章由 cherriemama 於 07-10-17 09:02 硐表
Ha Ha.... 點解你囡囡同我囡囡完全一樣? 連性格, 所讀學校, 報考學校都一樣!! 不過我仲未諗掂, 我打算收o左先揀, 話唔定到時只得一間收我囡囡我就唔駛咁頭痕!

...

如果真係得一間收,或冇一間收, 咁就緊係唔駛頭痕啦, 但若全部都收(或有兩間收)你先去考慮, 決定, 如果唔夠時間, 你會好容易作出錯誤的選擇

.對嗎?

作者: cherriemama 時間: 07-10-17 10:11

唔會唔夠時間, 如果我囡囡咁好彩間間都收, 我會先俾留位費, 到時慢慢再諗!

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-17 09:14 硐表

如果真係得一間收,或冇一間收, 咁就緊係唔駛頭痕啦, 但若全部都收(或有兩間收)你先去考慮, 決定, 如果唔夠時間, 你會好容易作出錯誤的選擇 .對嗎? ...

作者: AndyRain 時間: 07-10-17 10:54

以我自己既經驗..........未到最後一刻都揀唔到的. 除非係至top同無咁top既收了你小朋友, 呢d咁明顯既對比就會好容易有結果.

或者都係用那老土方法,,,,,,,將每間學校的好處, 唔好處 list晒出黎, 你看張list會較為明顯.

再唔係..........俾晒留位費先啦.

我明白你的心情, 你是想盡你最大既努力去為孩子揀最好既學校.  慢慢黎啦, 還有時間.

作者: gwan 時間: 07-10-17 11:09

I understand sometime parents may feel '15' or '16' about different schools, but the best is to do the research now and don't hold too many offers as there are many other kids who are not so good at interviews and are on waiting lists. I know some parents would hold up to 6 to 7 places for their kids, that's really selfish unless they have good reasons. I can understand if someone hold 2 or 3 offers because they can't make up their mind, but over 3......is just kind of out of the line. Sorry if I offend some parents, but I have a friend whose son was very quiet and failed all interviews, he was on waiting list and only got an offer at end of August, his family suffered greatly during the waiting process.

作者: AndyRain 時間: 07-10-17 11:28

我所指最後一刻係指交留位費. 真係無辦法先係最難揀的2間交晒留位費, 我相信真係好難多過3間會咁難揀的. 因為你大概都有d心水的, 只是要時間叫自己去肯定這個選擇是最好的選擇而已.

作者: Childhood 時間: 07-10-17 11:47

多謝意見.
相信每位家長都係"想盡你最大既努力去為孩子揀最好既學校"

原文章由 AndyRain 於 07-10-17 10:54 硐表
以我自己既經驗..........未到最後一刻都揀唔到的. 除非係至top同無咁top既收了你小朋友, 呢d咁明顯既對比就會好容易有結果.

或者都係用那老土方法,,,,,,,將每間學校的好處, 唔好處 list晒出黎, 你看張list會較為 ...

作者: TomDog 時間: 07-10-17 18:44

因為報名前已篩選過, 我覺得是但一間收都值得開心嘅。但如果有超過一間收, 我會揀囡囡比較鐘意個間。我覺得set左的目標都幾清晰, 無打算同時留多過一間的位。

不過, 間間學校都成千人報名, 入哂waiting list都唔出奇。如果不幸 d 位讓很多拿不定主意的人hold住, 那就要看邊間學校先放個位俾我了, 但如果定左一間之後, 有更加心儀的學校同我話有位, 唯有give up之前個間, 咁我就無奈做左hold住d位的人嘍。又或者, 苦等到臨開學先知有邊間收。

愈多人hold位in the first place, 就愈多人陷入以上的scenario.

作者: Yau_Cheung 時間: 07-10-17 22:21

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-16 22:21 硐表
幫個囡囡報咗 DGJS, GHS, APS, KTS, SFA 等私小, 一個假設性的問題: 若真係全部都收她(當然首選DGJS, 但我冇想過會咁好彩), 咁4間學校依次序應該點排名呢? 可否比意見 .其實4間都各有所長, 我自己4間都鍾意.
小女 ...

What are GHS, APS, KTS, SFA? What are their full names. Many thanks.

作者: Childhood 時間: 07-10-17 22:40

GHS = 德望學校 Good Hope School

APS=九龍塘宣道小學 Alliance Primary School

KTA= 九龍塘學校 Kowloon Tong School

SFA=聖方濟各英文小學

St. Francis Of Assisi's English Primary School

原文章由 Yau_Cheung 於 07-10-17 22:21 硐表

What are GHS, APS, KTS, SFA? What are their full names. Many thanks.

作者: gwan 時間: 07-10-18 09:27

TomDog,

No, you don't have to do that. There is always a timing difference when schools giving out offers. If you have already accepted(deposits paid) your 3rd and 4th choice schools, now you receive offer from your 1st or 2nd choice schools, of course you would accept them too but you should write or call to the 3rd and 4th choice schools, telling them you are giving up your reserved places, so that they can offer to other waitlist candidates rightaway. That what I meant, we can help others without hurting our kid's interests.

Gwan

原文章由 TomDog 於 07-10-17 18:44 硐表
因為報名前已篩選過, 我覺得是但一間收都值得開心嘅。但如果有超過一間收, 我會揀囡囡比較鐘意個間。我覺得set左的目標都幾清晰, 無打算同時留多過一間的位。

不過, 間間學校都成千人報名, 入哂waiting list都唔出 ...

作者: Charlotte_mom 時間: 07-10-18 12:52

totally support!
我果時就係一個由十月叩門叩到七月尾既家長, 當中感受, 未試過真係唔明
我都知一個咁重要既抉擇, 有時真係好難make, 不過, 為其他無咁好彩既家長著想下啦!

原文章由 gwan 於 07-10-17 11:09 AM 硐表
I understand sometime parents may feel '15' or '16' about different schools, but the best is to do the research now and don't hold too many offers as there are many other kids who are not so good at i ...

作者: manisaac 時間: 07-10-18 13:04

其實有否問過我地D 寶貝佢地鐘意去邊間讀呢
始終係間學校讀6年係佢地, 唔係我地囉

作者: TomDog 時間: 07-10-18 13:04

原文章由 gwan 於 07-10-18 09:27 硐表
TomDog,

No, you don't have to do that. There is always a timing difference when schools giving out offers. If you have already accepted(deposits paid) your 3rd and 4th choice schools, now you receive ...

Gwan,
我想你有點誤解我的意思. 我試試舉個例子:
1. 我個人原則是at any given time, I'm going to hold 1 seat only.
2. 我報了5間學校, 假設全部都入waiting list(很可能, 是不是?).
3. 假設到12月, 只有school A打電話俾我話有位. 因為我只有一個選擇, 我會係school A 留位.
4. 假設留位之後都無其他offer. 直至明年大抽獎完畢, school B先至打電話黎話有位, 那麼我就變成有school A 和school B兩個選擇. Based on item1, 我要作出決定。
5. 假設我比較鐘意school B, 我就會係改係school B留位, 同時通知school A我放棄學位.
6. 這個決定令我變相hold住school A的學位達8個月之久. 可能有其他人一直在苦苦等侯這個school A位.
7. I meant to be good, 但為什麼會這樣呢?
8. 我覺得啊, 是與其他人幾時release佢地手上的位有關的.
9. 我的意思是說我覺得很無奈.

[ 本文章最後由 TomDog 於 07-10-18 13:09 編輯 ]

作者: TomDog 時間: 07-10-18 13:42

我有架, 囡囡都有問我: 小朋友可唔可以自己揀讀邊間小學, 我答可以, 但都要睇下間學校有無位。不過目前佢最鐘意個間, 並非我個人的首選. 但她在她最喜歡的學校, 面試表現也最好, 說不定她最後會入到. (她在不喜歡的學校則試過哭出來, 機會自然

原文章由 manisaac 於 07-10-18 13:04 硐表
其實有否問過我地D 寶貝佢地鐘意去邊間讀呢
始終係間學校讀6年係佢地, 唔係我地囉

[ 本文章最後由 TomDog 於 07-10-18 13:46 編輯 ]

作者: Radiomama 時間: 07-10-18 13:45

我路過的, 大家其實都好理性, 想為小朋友預備最好的, 但言歸正轉, 這四間私校的口碑如何呢?

小兒只是k1, 但我已開始為他做research!

想知道多d資料啊!

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-17 22:40 硐表
GHS = 德望學校 Good Hope School

APS=九龍塘宣道小學 Alliance Primary School

KTA= 九龍塘學校 Kowloon Tong School

SFA=聖方濟各英文小學St. Francis Of Assisi's English Primary School

...

作者: Radiomama 時間: 07-10-18 13:46

我路過的, 大家其實都好理性, 想為小朋友預備最好的, 但言歸正轉, 這四間私校的口碑如何呢?

小兒只是k1, 但我已開始為他做research!

想知道多d資料啊!

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-17 22:40 硐表
GHS = 德望學校 Good Hope School

APS=九龍塘宣道小學 Alliance Primary School

KTA= 九龍塘學校 Kowloon Tong School

SFA=聖方濟各英文小學St. Francis Of Assisi's English Primary School

...

作者: gwan 時間: 07-10-18 13:54

Dear TomDog,

I am sorry if I have misunderstood you. All along I am saying all this targeting to those parents who are already or planning to hold more than 3 places at any 1 time, I definitely will do the same as you in your example.
I have a relative, her son is very smart and got accepted by most schools, the parents held more than 6 places for their son, I asked why didn't she give up some places for others, guess what she said? She said, I have paid the deposits and I have the right to hold the places until last minutes, it's too bad other parents didn't train up their kids for better performance at interviews...........life is like that. I guess she also likes to brag about how many offers her son got........I avoided talking to her ever since!

Gwan

原文章由 TomDog 於 07-10-18 13:04 硐表

Gwan,
我想你有點誤解我的意思. 我試試舉個例子:
1. 我個人原則是at any given time, I'm going to hold 1 seat only.
2. 我報了5間學校, 假設全部都入waiting list(很可能, 是不是?).
3. 假設到12月, 只有scho ...

作者: leesasa 時間: 07-10-18 14:04

If I were u, I will choose between GHS andSFA. If your girl is admmitted by all, she must be very smart. Let her go to the higher level school .

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-17 22:40 硐表
GHS = 德望學校 Good Hope School

APS=九龍塘宣道小學 Alliance Primary School

KTA= 九龍塘學校 Kowloon Tong School

SFA=聖方濟各英文小學St. Francis Of Assisi's English Primary School

...

作者: Childhood 時間: 07-10-18 15:52

I 'll never say my girl is smart even she is admmitted by
all school that we applied.
The reason that I write this topic is getting more comment/ informations about those schools. So that I can choose a right school to my girl without holding some seats for a long time.

原文章由 leesasa 於 07-10-18 14:04 硐表
If I were u, I will choose between GHS andSFA. If your girl is admmitted by all, she must be very smart. Let her go to the higher level school .

作者: fyeung 時間: 07-10-20 19:04

Childhood,

我囡囡今年讀K2,我開始搜集小一資料,我想報的學校,跟你的差不多,除了SFA我沒有打算幫囡囡報.

GHS - 英文好,有中學,不過老師略欠愛心,而且之前BK有媽咪post過此學校壓力大,學生要睇心理醫生
APS - 沒有中學,注重音樂,升中派位不錯
KTS - 沒有中學,有資優班,很多人報
SFA - 沒有中學,有資優班,英文好,壓力大,有聽過插班入DGJS的例子

我的資料不多,希望可以幫到你!

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-16 22:21 硐表
幫個囡囡報咗 DGJS, GHS, APS, KTS, SFA 等私小, 一個假設性的問題: 若真係全部都收她(當然首選DGJS, 但我冇想過會咁好彩), 咁4間學校依次序應該點排名呢? 可否比意見 .其實4間都各有所長, 我自己4間都鍾意.
小女 ...

作者: Childhood 時間: 07-10-20 22:31

原文章由 fyeung 於 07-10-20 19:04 硐表
Childhood,

我囡囡今年讀K2,我開始搜集小一資料,我想報的學校,跟你的差不多,除了SFA我沒有打算幫囡囡報.

GHS - 英文好,有中學,不過,而且之前BK有媽咪post過此學校壓力大,學生要睇心理醫生
APS - 沒有 ...

Thank you fyeung.
可否講下為何沒有打算報SFA呀?
其實我都係屬意APS, KTS or SFA. 就後先到GHS.

先講GHS, 為一吸引是有中學, 重要係band 1名校中學, 但是如你所講, GHS老師略欠愛心, 校規極嚴. 早前去GHS Interview, 家長要填問卷, 其中一條問你如何教導/協助女兒守校規. Interview當日亦見有位老師當眾責駡一位"她認為"不守規的女仔, 那老師態度似懲教署職員.相信GHS的學生是在高壓政策下,規規矩矩.真係唔想小女在如始環境下長大.規矩當然要守, 但小孩是要教導, 唔係用高壓就可以

作者: fyeung 時間: 07-10-20 23:18

Childhood,

GHS interview架事,我都見有好多家長有發表意見.

我舊同事架小朋友係SFA入面讀,課程好催谷,多功課,我囡囡自問唔係可以坐定定集中精神不停做功課個種,我唔想到時難為左佢,更加難為左自己.

雖然有家長話GHS都多功課,有10幾樣

不過,佢地有中學,唔似SFA咁一定要谷好成績升中.

咁你大抽獎填邊間?

以上只是我得知的小小資料,希望有媽咪可以比多d意見!

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-20 22:31 硐表

Thank you fyeung.
可否講下為何沒有打算報SFA呀?
其實我都係屬意APS, KTS or SFA. 就後先到GHS.

先講GHS, 為一吸引是有中學, 重要係band 1名校中學, 但是如你所講, GHS老師略欠愛心, 校規極嚴. 早前去GHS Interv ...

作者: Childhood 時間: 07-10-20 23:25

原文章由 fyeung 於 07-10-20 23:18 硐表
Childhood,

GHS interview架事,我都見有好多家長有發表意見.

我舊同事架小朋友係SFA入面讀,課程好催谷,多功課,我囡囡自問唔係可以坐定定集中精神不停做功課個種,我唔想到時難為左佢,更加難為左自己.

雖然有家長話 ...

大抽獎報邊間真係末決定

, 等呢一兩個月私校結果再算.

作者: martie 時間: 07-10-21 18:08

It is always good to prepared for the best.　ｉＡＭ　ＡＬＩＴＴＬＥ　ＰＥＳＳＩＭＩＳＴＩＣ　　ＡＮＤ　　ＷＯＵＬＤ　ＡＬＳＯ　　ＡＤＶＩＳＥ　ＹＯＵ　ＴＯ　　ＰＲＥＰＡＲＥ　　ＦＯＲ　　ＴＨＥ　ＷＯＲＳＴ　ｉｅ　JUST WAITING FOR THE LUCKY DRAW.

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-16 22:21 硐表
幫個囡囡報咗 DGJS, GHS, APS, KTS, SFA 等私小, 一個假設性的問題: 若真係全部都收她(當然首選DGJS, 但我冇想過會咁好彩), 咁4間學校依次序應該點排名呢? 可否比意見 .其實4間都各有所長, 我自己4間都鍾意.
小女 ...

作者: fyeung 時間: 07-10-21 22:11

Childhood,

i.c.
咁真光及民生又點睇?
有中學架.到時唔使煩升中.

原文章由 Childhood 於 07-10-20 23:25 硐表

大抽獎報邊間真係末決定 , 等呢一兩個月私校結果再算.

作者: Childhood 時間: 07-10-21 23:13

原文章由 fyeung 於 07-10-21 22:11 硐表
Childhood,

i.c.
咁真光及民生又點睇?
有中學架.到時唔使煩升中.

民生口脾一般, 真光就唔係咁鍾意,我有個朋友她自己在真光畢業, 但她卻沒有送她的囡囡入讀真光. 她說真光在學術或課外活動等都係一般般.
有中學或一條龍對我來講並不是最重要, 找到間合適的才重要.

作者: GoodOldMum 時間: 07-10-21 23:58

I totally agree with you. Let's take my son as an example, my son has been admitted by ICQM and we paid the deposit fee of HK$1,000. One month later, my son was also admitted by the GT College. After receiving the GT offer, I immediately wrote a letter to the Principal of ICQM to withdraw from their offer hoping the reserved seat could be released to other talented child. I understand that waiting is really very annoying.

[quote]原文章由 gwan 於 07-10-18 13:54 硐表

I have a relative, her son is very smart and got accepted by most schools, the parents held more than 6 places for their son, I asked why didn't she give up some places for others, guess what she said? She said, I have paid the deposits and I have the right to hold the places until last minutes, it's too bad other parents didn't train up their kids for better performance at interviews...........life is like that. I guess she also likes to brag about how many offers her son got........I avoided talking to her ever since!

作者: gwan 時間: 07-10-22 08:26

GoodOldMum,

I am sure those parents who want their kids to get into ICQM would appreciate your act greatly. It just happens I have 2 friends who are waiting for seats from ICQM, let me say thank you to you on behalf of them!!

gwan

原文章由 GoodOldMum 於 07-10-21 23:58 硐表
I totally agree with you. Let's take my son as an example, my son has been admitted by ICQM and we paid the deposit fee of HK$1,000. One month later, my son was also admitted by the GT College. Af ...

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)