港同 vs 大坑真光

munloveyes

覺得兩間都是好學校，如果先不論小朋友適合那一種教學模式，但考慮埋六年後的升中前景，會點揀呢？

helloqueen01

I prefer hkgaps

yame

I know a friend whose elder son was in a traditional catholic school while her younger daughter is in HKUGAPS.  She said she likes the traditional school more as she found the HKUGAPS course structure and assessment difficult to follow.  

She said it is easier for her son to study / prepare for exams than the little sister working on worksheets that are loosely organised.

Estama

聽朋友講港同今年都勁多人in!

Charlotte_mom

對習慣傳統的家長, 港同果套係好似好唔organized架, 例如, 傳統教常識係一本書, 一課跟一課教, 備課又得, 溫書又易, 搵料又straight forward
但港同教常識, 係單元形式, 一張張工作紙(所以無得備課), 有時又無正統答案, 總之岩邏輯就得, 要學生做完d討論/活動之後自己搵答案 (老師會有帶住), 有時d題目係老師建議d link, 小朋友自己上網搵資料, 係要家長幫手架, 小朋友未必睇得明同夠能力消化, 砌埋砌埋年尾就一個folder, p1-p4都唔駛考, 上堂評估都做埋, 家長都無咩點掂過份野

所以你朋友感覺我明白, 有時我地自己家長都講笑, 讀傳統仲快攪掂, 讀活動要花多左時間

睇家長點睇兩種學習方式


升中方面, 真光中學係津中, 所以要爭, 大概75-80%會直升
而港同係一條龍直資, 基本上係100%直升

公開試成績
真光: http://www.tlmshk.edu.hk/academic3.php
港同: http://www2.hkugac.edu.hk/img/fi ... lege_HKDSE_2014.htm

jupas入學率:
真光jupas入8大66.7%:http://www.tlmshk.edu.hk/academic3.php
港同jupas入8大52.3%: http://www2.hkugac.edu.hk/img/fi ... te_201408181447.pdf

其實港同公開試成績都算唔差, 不過真光真係勁

munloveyes

好多謝各位用心解答