以普通話教授中文科會對學生帶來甚麼影響？

BK_EDITOR

（可選多項）
請投票並分享您的看法！

Abby媽

i think it is good for learning chinese.
but i not agree start it with primary 1, if start at about P3/P4. is acceptable.

IaMMoYY

IMHO, I think it ends up the kids are not good at even ONE language.

cup-noodle

嚴重缺乏師資，教出香港特色普通話。

Hipuppy

中文科o的字深過普通話科好多,我都擔心老師同學生都未準備好,我個小朋友就一定搞唔惦!!!!!!

yffanny

現 時  有 學 校 雖 已 推 行 普 通 話 教 學 多 年 ， 但 學 生 在 應 考 公 開 試 時 ， 又 會 選 擇 廣 東 話 作 應 考 語 言 ； 期 望 教 育 界 能 貫 徹 始 終 ， 教 、 學 及 評 估 有 一 致 性 ， 這 樣 學 生 才 不 會 無 所 適 從 。
http://www.rthk.org.hk/rthk/radio1/SmartParents/20081004.html

Chunyan

中文科老師普通話能力一定要好,否則,教錯學生.難為了老師及學生.

Charlotte_mom

一定要學校配合得好, 例如一定全部係native speaker, 課本亦要配合
如果搵本地老師教,  又用本身係for廣東話教既教材, 盞攪!
另外, 越細學越好, 我女小一已係pth教中文, 一星期對住普通話老師講5日, 家常便飯了, 而家小3, 發音係好鏗鏘準確的, 當然始終係廣東人, 有d用詞句子, 難免習慣用廣東法, 不過讀音就好ok了

yolandamama

認識有小學中文科已經用普通話教書
大部分小朋友都講得一口流利普通話

yolandamama

學每一種語言其實愈細個愈好
但用普通話教中文就唔知會產生化學反應

林嬌嬌

AGREE :   I think it ends up the kids are not good at even ONE language.

learning PinYing w/ one set of book,
and Chinese text book is another set.
reading comprehension. is another set.
they are never correlated , therefore, just increase the burden of  student but not benefit any !!!

ahdee

I think this is a trend. You can see there is less and less local HK Chinese Children literature, and the choice that you can get either translated from overseas, Taiwan or mainland China. Also in the last few years, there are less people in Shenzhen to speak Cantonese, while more and more people speak Putonghua. I can foresee within possibly ten years, schools in HK must use PTH to teach Chinese.

katrinaau2002

我女佢小學中文科已經用普通話教書.佢都講得一口流利普通話...寫作好通順..佢老師D發音好正宗..所以D小朋友讀書真係好好聽..有快慢.高低等

kambima

一定要由小學,甚至幼稚園就推行, 如果中學先黎用普遍話教,就無用啦!

YAN33383

睇既字同讀出黎一樣，應該作文寫少d廣東話既！

Chiu_mama

my sons start learning their chinese in pth since Primary Sch, I found it hinder them more than boosting their chinese.
mother tongue is mother tongue, it should come first.