教育王國

標題: St. Mary's, MCS, GH, Marymount, DGJS, HYS, St. Paul's Convent, SPCC [打印本頁]

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-27 23:30 標題: St. Mary's, MCS, GH, Marymount, DGJS, HYS, St. Paul's Convent, SPCC

How would u rank them?

作者: lugano 時間: 11-11-27 23:34

不喜勿插

AAAA: DGJS, SPCC
AAA: MCS, Marymount, St. Paul's Convent
AA: St. Mary's, HYS, GH

[ 本帖最後由 lugano 於 11-11-27 23:35 編輯 ]

作者: onsyan 時間: 11-11-28 00:02 標題: 回覆 1# lugano 的文章

same as you

作者: wootaitai 時間: 11-11-28 00:13

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: season_sincere 時間: 11-11-28 00:43

Personally (I've got two girls in DGJS so I'm a bit bias on that)

1. DGJS, SPCC, Marymount
2. St. Paul's Convent, Maryknoll
3. Gode Hope, Heep Yunn

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-28 01:10

原帖由 season_sincere 於 11-11-28 00:43 發表
Personally (I've got two girls in DGJS so I'm a bit bias on that)

1. DGJS, SPCC, Marymount
2. St. Paul's Convent, Maryknoll
3. Gode Hope, Heep Yunn

How about APSKT?

作者: share123 時間: 11-11-28 09:51

甘如果同一個level又如何? 例如SPCC vs DGJS?

作者: c1234 時間: 11-11-28 10:09 標題: 回復 2# myac 的帖子

Hi myac,
what is APSKT?

作者: share123 時間: 11-11-28 10:35

代答:九龍塘宣道囉

作者: truthmr99 時間: 11-11-28 10:47

How about Sacred Heart in the ranking list please?

作者: Sevendwarfs 時間: 11-11-28 10:53

Same as yours!

Within group AAA, I would rank St. Pauls' Convent a bit higher than MCS and Marymount.

原帖由 lugano 於 11-11-27 23:34 發表
不喜勿插

AAAA: DGJS, SPCC
AAA: MCS, Marymount, St. Paul's Convent
AA: St. Mary's, HYS, GH

作者: mmnn 時間: 11-11-28 11:00

It doesn't make sense to compare those schools by ranking.
Are you used to compare your children with others ?
Or do you like to compare you with others ?

作者: lugano 時間: 11-11-28 13:34

原帖由 Sevendwarfs 於 11-11-28 10:53 發表
Same as yours!

Within group AAA, I would rank St. Pauls' Convent a bit higher than MCS and Marymount.

Within each group, 我都沒有再細化再分 Rank

我的 Ranking 從不同角度去分析, 並不只參考"現今成績"

(1) 學校歷史
(2) 過往成績
(3) 現今成績
(4) 校風
(5) 校譽
(6) 舊生社會成就
(7) 舊生 Network
(8) 辦學團體理念
(9) 對現校學生觀感
(10) 個人認識的舊生

[ 本帖最後由 lugano 於 11-11-28 13:36 編輯 ]

作者: season_sincere 時間: 11-11-28 18:03 標題: 回復 6# myac 的帖子

Personally (I've got two girls in DGJS so I'm a bit bias on that)

1. DGJS, SPCC, Marymount
2. St. Paul's Convent, Maryknoll, Sacred Heart
3. Good Hope, Heep Yunn
4. APSKT

作者: Bingb 時間: 11-11-28 18:40

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: Ewongmum 時間: 11-11-29 08:50

2010 results , No scared Heart on list :

拔萃女書院

94.50

聖保祿學校

86.10

德望學校

85.00

4	瑪利諾修院學校（中學部）	1A	85.70*
5	庇理羅士女子中學	1A	82.30
7	嘉諾撒聖瑪利書院	1A	86.00
8	瑪利曼中學	1A	87.40
11	嘉諾撒聖心書院	1A	85.10*
12	英華女學校	1A	80.40
13	聖士提反女子中學	1A	79.90
16	協恩中學	1A	75.70
24	真光女書院	1A	72.70
27	聖傑靈女子中學	1A	--
31	寶血會上智英文書院	1A	77.50
34	聖保祿中學	1A	74.00
42	嘉諾撒聖方濟各書院	1A	70.00*
45	聖母玫瑰書院	1B	68.80
46	藍田聖保祿中學	1B	68.50*
60	香港真光中學	1B	68.00
63	聖羅撒書院	1B	66.00*
69	嘉諾撒書院	1B	64.70

作者: Ewongmum 時間: 11-11-29 08:51

DGS is always on the top.

作者: easyman 時間: 11-11-29 08:54 標題: 回復 2# season_sincere 的帖子

Can you share the feeling about DGJS? I got second interview but I am afraid my daughter cannot stand for the pressure as all the girls are great smart in the school!

作者: Ewongmum 時間: 11-11-29 09:00

I think the ones got in most of the 1st tiers 'DSS , private schools are smart and competitive students.

But as some of the top school, I think every students in DGJS either very good in acadamic or they have one or two outstanding talents. ( And confidence).

Parents paid lots of efforts in bringing them up.

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-29 10:28

原帖由 Ewongmum 於 11-11-29 08:50 發表
2010 results , No scared Heart on list :

1拔萃女書院

1A
94.50 4聖保祿學校

1A
86.10 5德望學校

1A
85.00

4瑪利諾修院學校（中學部）

1A
85.70*5庇理羅士女子中學

1A
82.30 7嘉諾撒聖瑪利書 ...

Thank you. However, we are talking about PRIMARY SCHOOL.

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-29 10:35

Thanks for your sharing. If we focus on only PRIMARY SCHOOL, how would you rank them? Say we rank them on basis of secondary school placement. Also as I know, DGS, a DSS school, has 50 F.1 spaces for non-DGJS and HYS, a govt aided school, has 100 F.1 spaces for non-HYPS. These factors affect the secondary school as well. For APSKT, every year they have among their 150 students at least 15 going to DBS and 10 going to DGS and 15 going to HYS but very few going to Maryknoll/Marymount. So APSKT is very strong.

This is how I rank them.....

DGJS>MARYKNOLL>APSKT>HYPS

作者: Ewongmum 時間: 11-11-29 10:43

only primary

DGJS >SPC = Mt. Mount = MaryKnoll > GH = Scared heart > Heep Yun > APK

作者: hophopbunny 時間: 11-11-29 10:51

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-29 10:54

原帖由 hophopbunny 於 11-11-29 10:51 發表
In recent years top 10% student of Marymount were admitted to DGS and SPCC. I believe the other "AA" schools are not bad in this aspect too

so if you can get into one of the AA and above schools if w ...

We got HYPS P.1 placement w/ 20 points. Waiting for APSKT interview. No luck with DGJS. Did not apply to GH/SC/SPCC as we live in Kowloon.

作者: Ewongmum 時間: 11-11-29 11:05

how lucky ! I would keep Heep Yun and use the school fees for other resources.

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-29 11:48 標題: 回復 25# Ewongmum 的帖子

But my dream is still DGJS and so will try again next year.

作者: kls12 時間: 11-11-29 12:02

原帖由 myac 於 11-11-29 11:48 發表
But my dream is still DGJS and so will try again next year.

If only consider the curriculum, APS is better than HY.

If your target is DGJS and you have confidence that your daughter is top in studying, APS is better.
However, you should consider the pressure in applying secondary if cannot change to DGJS in primary school.

[ 本帖最後由 kls12 於 11-11-29 12:18 編輯 ]

作者: Ewongmum 時間: 11-11-29 13:17

My friend's daugther is studying in alliance and she is from her own kinder. she is working hard in her daugther , try to push to the top 15 from the grade, push hard in her instruement , and try to apply P4 in Heep Yunn.

I think, If I have your choice, still heep yunn, and try to keep up the her ranking, and train her talents. and try again in DGJS. ( not saying alliance is no good. but since you are lucky enough to get Heep Yunn, ( still dream school for many girls.). work hard there if I were you. Keep the standard of your daugther's acadamic and any of her talents.

作者: Ewongmum 時間: 11-11-29 13:27

Remember , DGS wants sports / music/ acadamic...............

作者: qqzzma 時間: 11-11-29 18:08 標題: 回復 8# Ewongmum 的帖子

咁熱鬧ge, 加埋St. Stephen's Girls (SSGPS) 大家覺得又點排?

作者: qqzzma 時間: 11-11-29 18:10

咁熱鬧ge, 加埋St. Stephen's Girls (SSGPS) 大家覺得又點排?

原帖由 Ewongmum 於 11-11-29 10:43 發表
only primary

DGJS >SPC = Mt. Mount = MaryKnoll > GH = Scared heart > Heep Yun > APK

作者: bblovebb2 時間: 11-11-29 19:27

SPCC=DGS > St. Paul's Convent > Maymount = MCS > St. Mary's = HYS > GH

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-29 21:08

原帖由 Ewongmum 於 11-11-29 13:17 發表
My friend's daugther is studying in alliance and she is from her own kinder. she is working hard in her daugther , try to push to the top 15 from the grade, push hard in her instruement , and try to ...

I understand and appreciate your input. Since I graduated from APSKT ranking #2 in the grade and got admitted into DBS, I have this nostalgia for DBS/DGS...... I guess keeping HYPS make sense as I would have more resources to help my girl to be well-rounded in music, sports and academia. APSKT has 150 students where HYPS has 90 students. Only concern is I have 1 younger son coming and 1 daughter following. If my girl can get into APS and do well, the 2 younger ones can benefit. But I don't know whther she will deliver. So keeping her at HYPS, at least I still have HYS as a backup and can aim for DGJS or DGS.

作者: VincentL 時間: 11-11-29 21:18 標題: 回復 21# lugano 的帖子

Agreed, St Paul Convent should be slightly better

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-29 22:07

GOOD QUOTATION
協恩出名校風純樸成績中上,女抜出名成績優異.

選學校都要看個人本質,家長不應盲目追求名校,只要選了合適的學校,讀普通學校也可以有傑出的成就.

報讀女拔萃未取錄　會考卻一鳴驚人
記者：梁美寶　黃嘉寶　吳嘉文　佘慧紅
女神童掃走天水圍悲情

【本報訊】中學會考昨日放榜，香港史上最年輕的 9 優狀元何凱琳接過成績單後透露， 9 歲時曾投考傳統著名英中拔萃女書院，惟校方以她居於天水圍為由而將她拒諸門外，她遂欣然轉投中中東華三院盧幹庭紀念中學，終以 14 歲之齡奪佳績而一鳴驚人。這名智商高達 130 的「天水圍女神童」立志要做一名好醫生懸壺濟世，出身基層家庭的凱琳昨日吐氣揚眉，將天水圍的「悲情」一下子掃走。　
上月才剛滿 14 歲的何凱琳出身基層家庭，父母均於內地出生，只得初中程度；父親是任冷氣技工，母親為家庭主婦，兩人昨日表現極低調，不願多談背景。何媽媽說， 14 年前懷胎九月過關來港，一個月後誕下凱琳，三口之家原於元朗朗屏公屋居住，數年前遷往天水圍的居屋屋苑。
雖然家庭清貧，但何氏夫婦在女兒半歲至 1 歲時已發現她絕非池中物，天資聰穎，記憶力強，且過目不忘，他們遂盡心栽培女兒，包括發現她是資優兒童後，即讓她在小學跳級兩次，又經常買新書、材讓女兒學習。節儉的何媽媽、何爸爸，即使收入微薄，也要努力栽培女兒，新年不添新衣也不在乎。何太坦言：「為畀佢讀書，由佢 3 歲開始，我會每月儲 500 蚊，等佢將來讀大學時用。」
凱琳從沒介意家境欠佳，她說：「上次食魚翅、燕窩都唔記得係幾時，亦從來無試過一家人一齊去第二度旅行。」她還很感謝父母盡心的關懷、愛護，嚐到父親烹煮的菜餚已感到很滿足。
一隊老師跟進成長
凱琳報讀中一時，何媽媽專程帶她由天水圍往佐敦的拔萃女書院面試，惟終未獲取錄。凱琳憶述，面試時女拔萃的老師問當年只有 9 歲的她：「你咁細個，住天水圍搭車咪好遠？每日都要花好多時間搭車？」凱琳答：「是。」不久，何家獲女拔萃通知凱琳未獲取錄。本報昨日向拔萃女書院查詢當時為何不取錄凱琳，但未獲回應。
雖被名校拒諸門外，但幸而何媽媽也不希望女兒讀書壓力太大，故統一派位時獲第二志願的盧幹庭紀念中學取錄，仍欣然接受。凱琳說，她不介意就讀中中抑或英中，她也極愛目前的學校。事實上，該校知悉她是資優童後，成立了一隊老師小組跟進其個案及替她補習，同時有老師為她跟進成長、與同學相處的情況等。當她完成中一後，校方替她評核後讓她由中一跳級至中三。
打算在原校升中六
凱琳昨日在同學們、老師們的歡呼聲、掌聲下，取得 9 優成績單，她開心得難以言語，連聲向身邊友伴、老師道謝。她打算於母校讀畢中六後，再透過拔尖計劃升讀大學醫科。
「我之前睇過作家金鈴一本書，講一個醫生為錢而將一藥畀貧窮病人食，導致佢腦幹死亡，再將佢內臟出售，呢事令我好髮指。所以我立志要做一個用心去關心病人醫生，救助貧窮人。」凱琳的英文名為「 Phoenix 」，是鳳凰的意思，即如《哈利波特》小說中的鄧不利多的鳳凰，其眼淚可以治病，她也希望可以如小說的鳳凰一樣，為人治療傷痛。

作者: EllaHN 時間: 11-11-29 22:32

Hi All,

Thanks for yr useful comments! How abount St. Clare, would you pls give some commetns, if compare with HY? Many tks!

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-29 22:37

原帖由 EllaHN 於 11-11-29 22:32 發表
Hi All,

Thanks for yr useful comments! How abount St. Clare, would you pls give some commetns, if compare with HY? Many tks!

U want to compare St.Clare vs HYPS? I pick HYPS.

作者: cckidsmm 時間: 11-11-29 23:12

if HYPS = AA
St.Clare should be = A

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-29 23:14

原帖由 cckidsmm 於 11-11-29 23:12 發表
if HYPS = AA
St.Clare should be = A

I think St.Clare should be BBB only.

作者: iantsang 時間: 11-11-29 23:23

原帖由 Ewongmum 於 11-11-29 08:50 發表
2010 results , No scared Heart on list :

...

11
嘉諾撒聖心書院

1A

85.10*

...

The no.11 in the list is Sacred Heart (certainly there won't be a "scared heart"

)

作者: EllaHN 時間: 11-11-29 23:23

原帖由 myac 於 11-11-29 23:14 發表

I think St.Clare should be BBB only.

Would you pls give some example for BBB level school?

作者: Peter2880 時間: 11-11-29 23:24

原帖由 myac 於 11-11-29 22:07 發表
GOOD QUOTATION
協恩出名校風純樸成績中上,女抜出名成績優異.

選學校都要看個人本質,家長不應盲目追求名校,只要選了合適的學校,讀普通學校也可以有傑出的成就.

報讀女拔萃未取錄　會考卻一鳴驚人
...

人叻去邊度都叻, 但又有幾多e d 成功例子

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-29 23:28

原帖由 EllaHN 於 11-11-29 23:23 發表

Would you pls give some example for BBB level school?

e.g. St. Rosa

作者: iantsang 時間: 11-11-29 23:36

原帖由 myac 於 11-11-29 23:28 發表

e.g. St. Rosa

The name of the school should be St. Rose of Lima's.

作者: EllaHN 時間: 11-11-29 23:40

原帖由 myac 於 11-11-29 23:28 發表

e.g. St. Rosa

u are very demanding, tks for yr comment!

作者: VincentL 時間: 11-11-30 00:06 標題: 回復 4# Peter2880 的帖子

100%agree, in fact, she is much much smarter than 9a from DGS, because her conditions much worse.
"genius" is the only word I can use

作者: claudius 時間: 11-11-30 02:11 標題: 回復 16# Ewongmum 的帖子

請問這些評分在那裏找到？有冇小學的評分？

作者: Ewongmum 時間: 11-11-30 06:30

I don't think there is any primary ranking. Bascially, we look at primary sometimes , we see from their secondary allocations.

I search in goodle hk, and if you like you may pm your email to me. I can send you somemore.

作者: UncleGrand 時間: 11-11-30 08:44 標題: 回復 1# Ewongmum 的帖子

Hi Ewongmum,

I want to know too...
Would you please P M me a copy.

Million thanks

作者: Ewongmum 時間: 11-11-30 09:14

pls pm me your email address , I can then forward to you.

作者: iantsang 時間: 11-11-30 09:36

版主按 :

如欲提供/索取資料，請直接pm有關會員。如再有會員留下Please pm me/ Please check PM或Please email me等相關字句，本文將會被關閉，謝謝合作！

作者: myac 時間: 11-11-30 20:25

原帖由 iantsang 於 11-11-30 09:36 發表
版主按 :

如欲提供/索取資料，請直接pm有關會員。如再有會員留下Please pm me/ Please check PM或Please email me等相關字句，本文將會被關閉，謝謝合作！

Would all please observe the rules of EK and keep this topic ALIVE?

Thanks!

作者: hangyodon 時間: 11-12-1 14:16

原帖由 Peter2880 於 11-11-29 23:24 發表

人叻去邊度都叻, 但又有幾多e d 成功例子

個別例子真係冇乜意思
等如講有人唔努力做野；點知比佢中咗4升萬六合彩
之後佢就四維同人講做做人係唔使咁努力都可以成功
咁你覺得啱唔啱?

我諗你睇機會率啦
只能講入DGJS後，大咗之後係成功人仕機會一定大啲；但唔會有保證
入其他學校又唔代表唔會成為成功人仕(e.g. steve jobs)
但機會細好多啦

作者: myac 時間: 11-12-2 20:16

原帖由 hangyodon 於 11-12-1 14:16 發表

個別例子真係冇乜意思
等如講有人唔努力做野；點知比佢中咗4升萬六合彩
之後佢就四維同人講做做人係唔使咁努力都可以成功
咁你覺得啱唔啱?

我諗你睇機會率啦
只能講入DGJS後，大咗之後係成功人仕機會一定大啲；但唔會有 ...

At the end of the days, u can only plan for so much but so many unknowns in life exist... so as the Bible says, worries cannot change a thing.

What is 'success', after all?

歡迎光臨教育王國 (/)